Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To go easier or tougher on 17 year old daughter?

118 replies

allmaskedout · 19/10/2021 14:15

We are not in UK. Final State exams mid 2023. She has dyslexia. Zero interest, average intelligence and trying
To get out of going to school And supervised study as much as possible.
I am at the end of my tether with her .
The only thing that makes her happy is he weekend job in a bar . She loves it, is good at it and loves earning her own money.
Our relationship is suffering because I am
Distraught to watch her throw her dreams
Away.
She wanted to be a nurse but hasn't a hope of getting on that course now as she won't do well
Academically based on her current level of work . Her friends are high achievers but she doesn't give a toss.
She won't be hanging around home after she finishes second level education as I
Am a single parent and will have to focus on my
Other children's education .
My daughter would quite happily stay in bed all day long and do nothing
To help me whatsoever. She is lazy and selfish aswell as being warm and kind too
I've put so much time money and effort into her education and feel so disappointed. It feels
Frustrating watching her throw her ability away. She has plenty of ability but uses her dyslexia to do the least amount of work possible .
Advise me please. I've all but given
Up on her, educationally.thanks

OP posts:
titchy · 19/10/2021 15:28

She's 17. No one has wasted their life or not met their potential based on what they do or don't do aged 17. So she fails or gets Ds next year. So what? That's on her. She will presumably be able to carry on doing her fun job with increased hours - and why not. If you can't have a fun crappy job in your teens when can you.

At some point in the next few years she will grow up, realise that 25 hours a week in a bar, living in a shitty houseshare with mould in the bathroom, just isn't what she wants for the rest of her life. Then she can figure it out with the benefits of hindsight and maturity. At that point she'll totally regret not pulling her finger out now, but at least she'll have some motivation to do something about it. Right now she won't have any motivation at all.

Remember you can lead a horse to water and all that. And horses generally drink when they absolutely have to.

allmaskedout · 19/10/2021 15:25

I'm Of the same opinion regarding job or study @SnipSnipMrBurgess.
No laying about. This is my concern too.

OP posts:
SammyScrounge · 19/10/2021 15:24

What do you mean by getting tough with her? You cannot force study; you cannot prevent her working where she likes. I suppose you could throw her out if her choices disappoint you deeply.
Dyslexic children often feel they don't fit in anywhere. Your daughter has found a place where she is at ease. There are courses in business management, hotel managent etc when she is a little older. Support her.

SnipSnipMrBurgess · 19/10/2021 15:24

I have a very clever son who I want to do well when he does his leaving cert (ireland)

But he hates school, he spends more time trying to get out of going than he does going. Possible ADHD, school is a big trigger, awaiting cahms.

But my policy is, you leave school once exams are finished and its up to you what you do, you go into further education or a job. No laying about the house. As long as your daughter is happy healthy and is working then I would back off, life is too short to be fighting all the time.

allmaskedout · 19/10/2021 15:23

@Derbee she never had any motivation to begin with so you're wrong there. As for me thinking she is useless ... I don't. I think she is wasting her potential and using her dyslexia as an excuse to do sfa.she doesn't even try. These are the facts .

OP posts:
allmaskedout · 19/10/2021 15:21

She has had every resource publically and privately To support her dyslexia .
You are all right. She will
Make her own way. It is just incredibly
Frustrating.

OP posts:
Derbee · 19/10/2021 15:19

I’d say there’s a good chance that her confidence is taking a beating, both with bad results and a mother who clearly thinks she’s useless. The motivation to try has been knocked out of her because it feels overwhelming.

diddl · 19/10/2021 15:17

Has she ever had any help with her dyslexia?

You say she uses it as an excuse, but if reading is difficult, that surely impacts everything?

elbea · 19/10/2021 15:10

My mother pushed me really hard at school, I did really well all the way until my A Levels when the more she pushed, the less I tried.

I did an apprenticeship, used that to get into uni and work in a well paid, professional job. It took me a few more years but I got there on my own steam.

Tailendofsummer · 19/10/2021 15:09

Does she so any signs of ADHD OP? I have a half-arsed dyslexic dc who is now being tested for this. Won't take on any suggestions to do with his dyslexia.
It's great if she does well in her weekend job and would suggest that something in that line would be better for her than nursing

LettertoHermoine · 19/10/2021 15:07

Let her keep her job and make her own way, sounds like she is not academically minded at the moment and no amount or pushing, encouraging, cajoling, nagging etc works. I know because I have tried. It is normal for you to feel the way you do, I did and it can be hard BUT I did learn that there was a lot more to life than exams, a lot more options than I would have thought and that sometimes, even when you think you know better, you don't always. Kids can prove you wrong. Sometimes they are so lazy they wouldn't scratch themselves at home but excel and make great strides in their own chosen job.
You mention she is kind, warm and sociable. She is halfway there already.

frazzledasarock · 19/10/2021 15:05

My DH did similar in his late teens, he dropped out of uni to work in bars, he loved earning his own money and found studies boring and restrictive.

Let her map out her own life, sit down and discuss what she wants to do what her plans are, and let her know what you can help with and your limits.

If it helps, DH has worked his way up to a pretty senior position and is very well liked and respected.

He worked in bars, managed bars and did double glazing sales at one point amongst a long and interesting career. He's none of these anymore.

Your DD can go into nursing at a later time, my close friend qualified as a midwife in her mid thirties.

SpiderinaWingMirror · 19/10/2021 15:03

I would (and did) take the most enormous step back. I know how hard that is. Really tough because you don't want her to make a mistake. I really think that she has to make her own mistakes. She will learn. She will find that working in a bar isn't necessarily going to get her what she wants. But let her do that.

Branleuse · 19/10/2021 14:58

Some kids just want to earn money and get a job.
You can take a horse to water but you cant make it drink. Youve facilitated her getting her education,. Youve supported and encouraged her. Im not sure what else you can do. Id go easier. Can she tell you how she sees her career progression going from the bar work, and what are her plans?

Skyla2005 · 19/10/2021 14:52

Let her get on with it. She can do nursing in the future. You can't force her to study now. She has a job which she loves. Let her be and she will work it out for herself. The more you push the more she will pull. Just because she's not willing to put the effort In now doesn't mean she won't knuckle down in a few years time.

allmaskedout · 19/10/2021 14:48

Thanks for giving me an alternative angle.
Lots of great ideas

OP posts:
allmaskedout · 19/10/2021 14:47

She has never been interested in school and uses her dyslexia as an excuse to do the minimum since she went to second
Level. She likes to stay on bed, watch tv, go on her phone and generally schlep about. Zero interest or
Motivation to
Do Anything but doesn't
Suffer from Confidence issues or low
Mood. Just bone lazy and sometimes it's important to say things as they are.
I know her well enough to say that. My other child with dyslexia will
Take on any recommendation given by her teachers and tutors to work around it but
Wouldnt have the same
Ability as her older sister .
It's a personality thing.

OP posts:
ikeepseeingit · 19/10/2021 14:45

Just a note that in the UK we have apprenticeships for things like IT which is well paid once you get past the first couple years. As well as childcare/ business administration/ adult care. Perhaps something like adult social care would work perfectly for her? It's pretty similar to nursing and might provide a way in. Particularly if she is friendly, sociable and kind I can imagine she would make an amazing carer.

mm40 · 19/10/2021 14:44

You can’t force her. She will realise the ‘mistake’ at some point in her life. Be grateful she has a work ethic and has realised she likes earning money.
She can always go back to education if she wants to.

mm40 · 19/10/2021 14:44

You can’t force her. She will realise the ‘mistake’ at some point in her life. Be grateful she has a work ethic and has realised she likes earning money.
She can always go back to education if she wants to.

HollowTalk · 19/10/2021 14:42

I wonder whether nursing is suitable for her if she's dyslexic - how bad is her dyslexia? It would be awful to make a mistake with medications.

She seems to be sociable and hardworking when she's doing something she enjoys. When she's being forced to do something she struggles with, then she's unhappy and takes it out on you.

What attracted her to nursing? Was it the fact she could be sociable, friendly, working with the public? The fact she can be sociable is really great - so many young people don't have that ability.

Does she want to leave school at the moment or can she see the advantages of those exam results?

What about talking to her about starting work in an area where she could employ those useful skills? What about an apprenticeship? Do those exist where you are? If she's doing something she enjoys you might find that she is able to work her way up the career ladder and end up with a good job.

ikeepseeingit · 19/10/2021 14:39

@allmaskedout

She has always been. 'C' student . She is currently a 'D' student. She has pleNty of Ability but can't be arsed. Every school Report since the age of 8 has said the same. My thoughts are that if she is a c student , a c is perfectly acceptable fl For her but not a flurry of d grades.she's opted out sadly .
Can't be arsed or is finding is more difficult as the work gets harder? Her work will be being marked more stringently and any spelling and grammar errors will not be overlooked anymore. She will be finding it hard to read as quickly as her peers as well, I imagine it takes her twice as long to read stuff in class, so she will be getting gaps in her knowledge that she has to make up for.
allmaskedout · 19/10/2021 14:38

Great ideas.
I've suggested apprenticeships and hospitality but she believes that they are ' badly' paid.
I thought that perhaps hairdressing/ nail
Tech/ MUA would suit her as she loves these areas but said she couldn't live on what she would earn from
Those jobs.

OP posts:
Dixiechickonhols · 19/10/2021 14:35

Does she need to be in school she’s already 17 and her exams aren’t until 2023 so 19? Can she leave and work. She may be better suited to a practical course or apprenticeship. It’s hard to advise if you are abroad. I’d get her to see a career advisor and go from there. If she’s enjoying bar work there’s lots of careers that may suit that won’t need formal qualifications.

334bu · 19/10/2021 14:35

If she enjoys her work in a bar, why does she not consider a career in hospitality. She can train on the job and progress that way.