Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To go easier or tougher on 17 year old daughter?

118 replies

allmaskedout · 19/10/2021 14:15

We are not in UK. Final State exams mid 2023. She has dyslexia. Zero interest, average intelligence and trying
To get out of going to school And supervised study as much as possible.
I am at the end of my tether with her .
The only thing that makes her happy is he weekend job in a bar . She loves it, is good at it and loves earning her own money.
Our relationship is suffering because I am
Distraught to watch her throw her dreams
Away.
She wanted to be a nurse but hasn't a hope of getting on that course now as she won't do well
Academically based on her current level of work . Her friends are high achievers but she doesn't give a toss.
She won't be hanging around home after she finishes second level education as I
Am a single parent and will have to focus on my
Other children's education .
My daughter would quite happily stay in bed all day long and do nothing
To help me whatsoever. She is lazy and selfish aswell as being warm and kind too
I've put so much time money and effort into her education and feel so disappointed. It feels
Frustrating watching her throw her ability away. She has plenty of ability but uses her dyslexia to do the least amount of work possible .
Advise me please. I've all but given
Up on her, educationally.thanks

OP posts:
shedofdread · 19/10/2021 16:30

I don't have kids, but I'm going to tell you about the relationship I have with my parents now I'm 44.

I have spent my entire life feeling like a failure because I never managed to live the life that my dad wanted for me. Your daughter is trying to tell you school isn't for her by her actions (or not for now at least - no doors are closing if she doesn't train for something straight away!).

What you might be telling her is that she's in the wrong for not living the life you have in store for her. This isn't fair.

TBH, I question the value of further education anyway in the job market. Someone who works in a bar is not going to be replaced by a computer in the future. Do you think most accountants could say the same?

beigebrownblue · 19/10/2021 16:28

I would forget about the marks and grades.

Nowadays degree apprenticehships are fantastic potentially and if she enjoys working it may well be this is where you might find her 'home'.

She can earn money and do quals

what's not to like?

There will be some in the hospitality industry and sounds like she will have references from her current employer?
that is potentially an amazing start in life.

Studying on it's own is not for everyone.

qualitygirl · 19/10/2021 16:27

Where are you based @allmaskedout?

SollaSollew · 19/10/2021 16:24

My dd has quite severe dyslexia and poor short term memory she is 18 and has decided that school is not for her so has now started working full time. She hated every minute of school and it was both a constant source of stress for her and for me. She had a private education which meant she received a lot of support and as a result scraped through with a not bad of GCSEs but revision was torture for her because of her dyslexia and the more I pushed the more we argued and the more she felt that I didn't care about how she felt and stopped telling me anything at all.

At various points she told me that she wanted to be a hairdresser, in the navy, be a personal trainer and be a vet. I actually think she never had any intention of being any of these things, it's just what she said to stop me asking! It's very possible your dd had absolutely no intention of being a nurse at all so I would try not to get too fixated on that.

I think you need to take a massive step back and just support her. Some people are academic and some are practical, it's not always the academic ones who end up with the more successful lives.

starrynight21 · 19/10/2021 16:23

@allmaskedout

Would you allow her to Continue her weekend work?
Of course ! She loves it - why would you not allow her to do it ? Personally I'd be suggesting that she should do a certificate in hospitality and she could work in that field in the future. Nothing wrong with hospitality work.
Blackberrybunnet · 19/10/2021 16:21

It sounds as though she is throwing YOUR dream away, not hers! As others have said, there are many routes to success, both academic and practical, and it's not a one-time thing. Go a bit easier on her. Help her to find her own way forward.

Wildheartsease · 19/10/2021 16:18

Parenting a 17 year old is different from parenting a 3 year old... but having to manage that furious desire for independence does have similarities!

She knows what you think is important and is deciding that she thinks/feels differently. The more you push your view of things - the more entrenched she is likely to be. It is so worrying and so exhausting.

Sadly - you might well know best!
On the other hand, her mistakes are things that she will learn from. Education can be picked up later.

Suggestions:
Be kind to yourself. Play the long game. Try not to feel too responsible for her mistakes.
Avoid being the big-stick-fun-sponge ( :) ) who must be ignored(independence!)

Listen to her. Let her to talk as freely as possible - don't contradict or correct or advise. (Easier written than done!)

Ask interested questions - wait to be asked for advice. (It can be a verrrrrry long wait!)

TatianaBis · 19/10/2021 16:11

OP has suggested hospitality but DD says it's 'badly paid'.

She's right it is but she can work her way up.

Zilla1 · 19/10/2021 16:10

Although the world sees more credentialised with more studying for bachelors for previously secondary school-entry employment and masters degrees for jobs that previously required a first degree, as a PP says, school is not so much a one time entry into higher education if that part of her long-term destination. Also, it takes some people much longer to find their rhythm and grow up, emotionally, adademically and so on.

Although some children need tough love, be careful you don't jeopardise your long-term relationship with your daughter for your aspirations and ambitions for your DD.

Good luck.

HaveringWavering · 19/10/2021 16:10

@334bu

If she enjoys her work in a bar, why does she not consider a career in hospitality. She can train on the job and progress that way.
Exactly. Sounds perfect!
TatianaBis · 19/10/2021 16:08

There are some kids who work out the value of qualifications by leaving school without many and having to make their way in the working world.

Tough jobs for shit money may be the thing that puts a bomb under her. I notice you said:

I've suggested apprenticeships and hospitality but she believes that they are ' badly' paid.

I thought that perhaps hairdressing/ nail Tech/ MUA would suit her as she loves these areas but said she couldn't live on what she would earn from Those jobs.

She's right, they're badly paid and it will be difficult to live on what she earns from these jobs, but right now these are the only jobs she is likely to get.

You tell her this until you are blue in the face, but until she's in one and realises there's no way out bar a. more qualifications or b. hard graft up the greasy pole she's not going to engage with reality.

At 17, there's not much you can do if she won't listen and she hasn't figured this stuff out for herself.

It's important that you don't bankroll her once she leaves school, that will simply delay her facing reality.

AdmiralCain · 19/10/2021 16:07

Time will tell, With the greatest of respect it sounds like you're projecting your educational wishes on your daughter. If she doesn't have those desires she doesn't have them.
I left school at 15, only in my late thirties did I get a calling for what I wanted to do in life and I went to Uni then. She may get inspired in 10 or 20 years. This isn't the end for her, just the beginning.

Roselilly36 · 19/10/2021 16:05

I can only speak of my experience, DS is now 18 and a half, severely dyslexic also.

Please don’t put pressure on your DD, as it won’t make any difference.

We spent money on private tutors etc, made no difference in the slightest, as DS could not retain the information/formulas etc.

DS was convinced he wouldn’t pass any exams, in actual fact he did pass his Eng. Lit GCSE. He has the most amazing work ethic, dyslexic students, are not lazy.

DS now works in a highly specialised area of tech that really interests him, he is doing brilliantly, so based on my experience I really wouldn’t worry.

Your DD will find her way.

Wondergirl100 · 19/10/2021 16:03

Op what if you let go of the academic thoughts and encouraged her to work hard at bar work? No reason she couldn't be a good bar manager etc - you could tell here there is no sitting around doing nothing but remove the pressure to be a 'high achiever'

LillianGish · 19/10/2021 15:45

In your position I would be having a chat with her and pointing out that whatever grades she gets are the ones she will have to go forward with for the next phase of her life. The important thing is that she does her best - if her best is a C then that's great. What's not great is getting a C and forever thinking "If only I'd worked harder I could have got a B" (or whatever). I'd tell her she's got a short window now (in terms of the rest of her life) to throw everything at it - after that school is finished. Lots of people look back and wish they'd worked harder at school. At that age you literally have nothing else to worry about. You can go back and do it later, but it's usually harder, not easier. That's what I told both my kids. I think working a bar (or indeed having any kind of part time job is great). But I'd stress that what feels like good money when you are 17 does not go far when you need to support yourself on it. You can't live on the wages of part time bar work. You can say all of this kindly - don't get frustrated she's 17! You need to be on her side and she needs to feel this, but in the end you can't do it for her. It's up to her.

FawnFrenchieMum · 19/10/2021 15:38

Are you sure there is no other special needs going on. Dyslexia often goes hand in hand with ASD / ADHD. Lots of our comments ring true to my DS who has recently been diagnosed with both. He really struggles to keep up at school, he wants to do well but is physically unable to keep on track.

Cameleongirl · 19/10/2021 15:35

@Auroreforet Exactly, that's why I'm suggesting her DD speaks to a career counsellor. We parents aren't experts on what our children can/should do career-wise.

user1471462428 · 19/10/2021 15:33

Another voice recommending the nurse associate course. I’ve got a student nurse associate at the moment, she is fantastic! Not an academic person but she will be a fantastic nurse associate.

suspiria777 · 19/10/2021 15:33

Why are you writing like that?

Anonymice1 · 19/10/2021 15:32

I’m thinking it won’t be as fun working in a bar once you need to pay for your own house and food. But then again, maybe she will.

Auroreforet · 19/10/2021 15:30

When I was 16 I wanted to leave school after gcse’s and go to college to be a nursery nurse.
My parents said no and I ended up leaving at 17 to work in a bank.
I hated it.
By the time I left the bank I was married and couldn’t afford to go to college so I went to do nursing which was paid at the time.
It was a huge mistake and I also slipped my discs.
I’m retired now, had back problems all my life and never did the job I wanted.
If I could go back in time I would still be a nursery nurse.

Children often have a better idea of their abilities than their parents do.
Trust her to choose.
Be supportive.
I really wish my parents had listened to me.

Anonymice1 · 19/10/2021 15:28

An honest question, based on your writing, are you dyslexic too op? If so you might have an understanding what it is like. She is probably tired of school, has now found that it’s nice to make her own money. She can go back to school later, though it will probably be even more difficult for her but not impossible.

Cameleongirl · 19/10/2021 15:28

Does her school offer much in the way of college/career counselling? My DD is in the same school year and she's meeting with a counsellor in a couple of weeks (DD is setting up the meeting but I quietly reached out to the counsellor first and asked if she'd be available soon as DD's been getting in a state about her future plans).

I think it's much easier when they can discuss their options with an outsider who works in the field and really knows what's available to them - and what they need to do to get on a particular career path.
We parents can only provide limited guidance.

My DD is the opposite, getting stressed about achieving the right grades, but they all need to know more about what's available to them and then they can move forward, IYSWIM.

ExConstance · 19/10/2021 15:28

Is there a care type job she could go into and then progress to a nursing course.? Here in the UK you can join NHS as care assistant and become nursing associate and then nurse if you are motivated. In most care services they will offer level 3 qualifications and you can use these plus maybe an access course to get Maths and English up to scratch to go on to a nursing degree. If she took that route she would have the satisfaction of working and earning and still be able to train longer term.

CatsArePeople · 19/10/2021 15:28

How long of school has she left? She should work full time job then.