Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are they being unreasonable? Work and mat leave

85 replies

MatLeaveHassle · 19/10/2021 11:12

My work keep hassling me to know what I plan to do when/if I come back from maternity leave because other staff have asked to change their hours and they don't want to agree until they know what I'm going to do.

If I was right at the end I'd understand but I still have well over 6 months left (they knew I was taking the full year) and I don't want to keep being pestered for a decision right this minute.

AIBU to think they shouldn't keep asking me? In truth I don't yet know what I want to do when I go back, whether I'll request less hours etc.. nearer the time. I do plan to give them notice of my plans when I've made them but not over 6 months worth! It's putting so much stress on me feeling like I've got to make a decision right now and that what I decide now will affect colleagues requests.

OP posts:
KarmaStar · 19/10/2021 12:37

Sorry I think Yabu and need to get yourself organised,decide your hours and arrange childcare.
You say you appreciate you might not get what you want,but what if you are given hours that are not compatible with the available child care.
I know having a new baby is beyond exhausting and life changing but please plan ahead for your own sake.🌈

Lazypuppy · 19/10/2021 12:35

I would be biting their hand off to make sure i got the hours i wanted, if thry are going to be chabging other peoples hours then you have far less chance of getting what you want.

But i knew i was taking 9 months mat leave and going back full time so i made that clear so my job and role didn't change or get given to someone else befote i went back. I didn't want them to worry i wasn't actually going to go back

Aprilx · 19/10/2021 12:31

@MatLeaveHassle

I genuinely didn't realise that everyone goes on years mat leave having already arranged with work exactly what hours and days they'd like to work when they come back in a years time. They never suggested I'd need to do this.

I have said the likelihood is id like reduced hours but I appreciate this may not be accommodated at the time.

As a manager I would assume that the employee is returning to work the same hours as previously unless they had requested and we had agreed something different.

If you are not ready to request something different, then surely your answer should be that you intend to return to your job as it was. You cannot seriously think it is ok to be vague about that and then object to be asked for clarification. To be honest, I wouldn’t be pestering you though,, I would be proceeding on the assumption I mentioned above.

Westerman · 19/10/2021 12:31

It seems to me that they are being very respectful of your maternity based rights and are doing a good thing in including your wishes in their human resource planning. I think you need to tell them now to go ahead and base their planning on you returning to work full time, as it's not fair that you hold up other people's requests to change working patterns. When you do go back, or nearer to that time, then you can take a chance on submitting your own request for reduced hours. But please don't then go waving around the maternity rights banner, claiming you've been badly treated. I've seen this happen so many times and it's very unfair.

hotmeatymilk · 19/10/2021 12:30

Just for another take: I didn’t start looking at nurseries till about 3 months before I needed them (we didn’t know which city we’d be in) and it was totally fine, got a place at our first-choice Ofsted Oustanding nursery no probs, no waiting list – and this is in nappy valley.

Haven’t got a five-year plan either, and think it’s OK to want to spend time with your child before deciding your working hours. Some people thrive on maternity and decide they want to work less, some people think “quick, get me out of here!”; certainly I wanted work to leave me alone and didn’t want to do KIT days. But MN will have you signing up for childcare before you even TTC.

JuneOsborne · 19/10/2021 12:29

Haven't got time to read the whole thread, sorry. But everywhere I have worked you out in an application for flexible or changed working hours before you go off. Largely because if it is denied, you can't apply again for another year!

MajorCarolDanvers · 19/10/2021 12:28

OP you absolutely do not have to tell them your plans just now.

However a bit of give and take is a good thing. You could give them an indication of what you are thinking but they also need to understand that you might change your mind.

6 months is a very long time when you are on maternity leave. All sorts of things can change.

But ultimately if you don't know or are not comfortable discussing it yet then they really need to back off.

ThorsLeftNut · 19/10/2021 12:28

They sound better than my workplace, they wouldn’t discuss it with me at all and said they would give me my final desicion 10 days before I was due to return.
If you have a workplace being proactive at considering your needs and request now - then I would take them up on it and arrange it.

Tee20x · 19/10/2021 12:27

OP... I go back to work in January and I still haven't sorted out what hours I'm doing going back. I too have kept it vague as I keep changing my mind & my manager and I have agreed to have a chat end of November to confirm what I will be doing.

I think it depends on where you work and the size of the organisation. I work in a pretty big one so colleagues hours etc haven't had to be changed on the basis of me coming/going.

Just be honest with them and give them a general idea of what you will be doing. Keep them in the loop, there's no more you can do than that.

I've roughly that I'm planning on returning FT but will be looking at making use of the flexible working policy to shift my hours around.

Fetarabbit · 19/10/2021 12:27

It sounds like they want to factor you into their decisions, I am sure if they didn't ask, granted everyone else part time hours and would then have to deny you any request for flexible working as they couldn't accommodate you you'd be miffed as well. If you aren't arsed then just tell them that.

JetRocket · 19/10/2021 12:26

I’m on mat leave with approx 6 months left, this is my second time around in less than 3 years.

The legal answer is, you do not have to tell them and are well within your rights to tell them to f* off and stop bothering you (not that exact wording obviously).

The practical answer is, it’s not usual for employers to be asking. A mass amount goes into staff planning and keeping all your options open for you until pretty short notice isn’t practical, even if they legally have to.
I think most women do know their plan by 6 months even if it’s just a theory. I found being up front and keeping my employers in the loop was massively helpful in limiting the impact on my colleagues. You have no legal protection from your colleagues thinking you’re a bit of an A H when you do eventually return x

starfishmummy · 19/10/2021 12:26

It seems like they are doing this to make sure you get your choice of hours and fit others round you, rather than you having to fit round the other people. That sounds to me like they are trying to be helpful.

TheEponymousGrub · 19/10/2021 12:23

Yes, they shouldn't keep asking you; they should just go ahead and facilitate the other staff, as they wish to. It sounds like you are clear in your own mind that your choice is: decide nothing now, and just accept whatever arrangements are available when you do return. If so, maybe you haven't been clear enough with them?

DogManStar · 19/10/2021 12:22

Hmm.

My former employer did this when I was on mat leave, and it pissed me off immensely. I was on maternity leave; I wasn't giving work any thought at all, never mind what my work pattern might be in 6-8 months' time. I got so fed up with them asking that I said I would sooner jump in a vat of hot oil than think about going back to work at all while I was on maternity leave, thank you very much, but would let them know when I had made a decision.

(In fact, I resigned, and two of them were sacked for bullying - not over this specific event, but many, many others of a similar nature, always directed at female colleagues with children).

rookiemere · 19/10/2021 12:21

Feel free not to give them an indication, but then don't complain if they can't accommodate the pattern you want when yo have decided.

dreamingbohemian · 19/10/2021 12:19

Can you at least tell them a date by which you will decide? e.g. I will be able to give you a definite answer 5 months before I return.

I don't think it's strange to know 6 months in advance what you want to do. You must have an idea of whether you can afford to cut hours, what childcare costs will be, whether you have family help, etc.

Tbh I would start getting used to long-term planning, it's only going to get worse (e.g. applying to schools a year in advance).

cabbageking · 19/10/2021 12:19

They should not be pressurizing you.

You don't need to tell them if and when you are coming back until nearer the time

MrsArchchancellorRidcully · 19/10/2021 12:18

I booked my Dd into private nursery when I was 8m pregnant as the nursery was so sought after. Tho admittedly I knew I'd be going back ft.

AvocadoOrange · 19/10/2021 12:17

Op I'm with you - I didn't want to make a decision so early either. I would just tell them you don't know?

EmmaGrundyForPM · 19/10/2021 12:17

You really need to get your childcare sorted out! Surely you must have an idea of how many hours/days you want to work? And then you need to find a nursery or childminder who can accommodate you. Then confirm what days etc. If you find a perfect nursery but they can only offer space on Mondays and Tuesdays, you need to put in a request to your manager to work those days.

Starsong82 · 19/10/2021 12:16

I don't think your work are being unreasonable, I'm 27 weeks pregnant and have just in the last couple of weeks submitted my matb1 form and HR forms for maternity leave. Part of those forms was notifying them of my intended dates to start and end maternity leave, any annual leave I planned on taking immediately after maternity leave and my requested working pattern on my return. I'm happy to get all this sorted before I go on leave as it means I won't have to worry about it at all while I'm actually off! If you're looking at nursery for childcare you may find they need a lot more notice then you thought. I'm not surprised you're feeling stressed but think this is something you should be looking at sooner rather than later, lots of people have these plans in place before their leave even starts. If you genuinely don't mind/ can manage going back full time at the end of your leave then tell them that, if you think there's any chance you will want to reduce your hours then give them a figure now - I'd think they're more likely to be able to accommodate raising your hours on your return than reducing them.

Bluntness100 · 19/10/2021 12:15

Agree, and you are late on nurseries op you need to be clear on whay you’re asking them in terms of hours.

SHAR0N · 19/10/2021 12:13

@FollowYourOwnNorthStar

At my work the plan needs to be in place before the person leaves on parental leave. The person on leave can apply at any time to change it, but that request is looked in less and less favourably the closer it gets to a return to work time, because we have to assess it against business needs.

You are only thinking of yourself (fine), but a manager has to make fair decisions for an entire team. Someone could be given a part or full time contract based on your decision and want to apply for a mortgage on that salary. Whilst that isn’t your problem and you can and should think of your own needs, late notice makes it very difficult for your manager, who has to balance your wants/needs with other staff and with the business.

This came up recently at my work, and the person who requested changes at short notice was refused. They are now behaving terribly, when everyone else is aware it was because management had been asking if she was sticking with the same return to work plan for the last 6 months, and she refused to answer, so they took it at her word, made employment and business decisions and when she did change her mind there was no room to accommodate her.

This is excellent advice.
Bluntness100 · 19/10/2021 12:11

I honestly don't expect them to hold off making decisions for anyone else. I understand that this means I may not be able to work what I want when the time comes and I accept that.

Have you actually told them that? Because your messages on here are all over the place. You’ve now got posters doing the same as them. Habe you actually said to them “I will likely request reduced hours but appreciate that you need to make a decision now, I cannot do so at this stage and if this means you cannot fulfil my request this is fine, I will confirm on x date my request”

They are trying to help you op.

Fallagain · 19/10/2021 12:09

You need to start considering and booking childcare. In some areas people have to do this when they are pregnant and in other 6 months before is OK but it’s definitely time you start looking.

If you are genuinely happy to continue working the same hours then tell them that but it’s very likely that they won’t be able to accommodate changes later. If reduced hours are important to you then you need to tell them now.

Swipe left for the next trending thread