Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this new heat pump policy will just push people towards replacing still working gas boilers

113 replies

nosyupnorth · 19/10/2021 08:40

It's pushing me anyway. The subsidy amount offered per household is only a fraction of the cost of a heat pump and the totally only covers a fraction of the population -- which means they're probably also going to wrap it up in a criteria to limit who gets it to pensioners etc so that normal working people get nothing.

If it weren't for this, I would get maximum use out of my boiler before it gives out and then replace it which is the most enviromentally efficient choice but instead I now feel forced to plan to replace my boiler with a new one while I can still get one, which is surely the opposite of a good enviromental choice.

OP posts:
MojoMoon · 19/10/2021 10:15

@Gothichouse40. Air source heat pumps are common in Scandinavia and it's quite cold there in winter.....

The Viessman ASHP I am looking at has an overnight noise level of 35db.
That's about half the noise level of a washing machine or dish washer. To qualify for subsidy the max decibel allowed is 42db.

I am on a compact terrace with small back yard too.

If you want to do some research, I'd recommend the Energy Saving Trust.

Coogee · 19/10/2021 10:15

The garden is built on stone and also I would worry that drilling down might cause subsidence.

Then use an air source heat pump, although if your house is also sitting on stone the chances of subsidence are virtually nil.

Gothichouse40 · 19/10/2021 10:08

Im already stressed out with how much this is going to cost. Im also worried about angering my neighbours. Im in a mid terraced older property. The noise from a heat pump will drive them ( and me) mad. I foresee an increase in noise complaints, as if it's not bad enough that no one now has carpets on floors. This scheme has not been thought through. From the research I have done heat pumps are useless at heating your house and noisy. Have the people who invented this system lived through a severe Scottish winter? They are having a laugh. Meanwhile China and other countries merrily go on their way polluting the world. Ordinary people here will be bankrupted with these schemes as I know I wont qualify for any funding. Many people are suffering fuel poverty right now, how are they expected to fund this?

Indecisivelurcher · 19/10/2021 09:52

@MojoMoon thanks, am looking at ones that achieve the BTU at delta 50. Does that cover it? Honestly it's been quite the mine field.

RandomLondoner · 19/10/2021 09:52

I suspect that air source heat pumps will be impractical, and that the best solution will be to just have such massive amounts of carbon-free electricity that prices will fall and we can just use straight-forward electric heating.

I see there is now a commercial project under way to make one pipe-dream of mine come true: getting solar power from the Sahara. The company is going build a massive solar plant in the south/middle of Morocco, and ship electricity to the UK via high-voltage DC lines under the sea. (This is actually perfectly practical, although they are having to build their own factory in Scotland to make the cable because the amount they need is five years annual output from all factories in the world. And they want it sooner than the factories could make it, anyway.)

Interestingly, the solar plant will also have a considerable number of wind turbines, because that part of the world has a late-afternoon to evening wind, and the wind turbines mean they can continue producing electricity during the UK evening, when household demand peaks.

Apparently the cables will land in the UK on the Devon coast, and supply 8% of UK electricity requirements. Once the project has proven itself, hopefully a lot more similar capacity will be added.

ProudMaiasaura · 19/10/2021 09:51

Just to add to my post...biomass and ground source have been viable boiler options for years as boilers. In terms of options moving forward the air heat pump and hydrogen are the ones companies are seriously considering to be the best options for Net Zero ambitions.

MojoMoon · 19/10/2021 09:49

For those of you worrying about space - check on Sunamp heat batteries. A much more compact way of storing heat (which is what a hot water cylinder is for)

@Indecisivelurcher. Definitely not an expert but part way through the process of getting an ASHP, complicated by being in a conservation area.
If you've not bought radiators yet, getting low flow temp ones seems an excellent idea. You'll need to bear it in mind with your boiler settings - often gas boilers are set to 65c and you'll probably be best turning that down a bit as the radiators will be so efficient. The good news is that will also save you money - heating water to a lower temperature uses much less gas so lower bills

EmmaGrundyForPM · 19/10/2021 09:49

@berlinbabylon

Not sure people will replace them for the sake of it. Even with the subsidy it is going to cost substantially more than gas boiler would.

I am not sure they will work very effectively when they are retrofitted to (in my case, a 1960s) older houses. Our boiler is nearly 30 year old and on borrowed time so I am wondering whether to look into replacing everything with Fischer electric heaters and look at a more sophisticated immersion heater for the hot water. I hate gas anyway. know in the scheme of things it is very safe, but you still get explosions from time to time.

We installed an ASHP to our 1960s house 3 years ago. It's brilliant, works really well and the house is warm. Our house is double glazed and has CWI. I wouldnt install one in a single glazed property.
Mellowfruitfulnessy · 19/10/2021 09:47

I don’t think there’s anything that live in small terrace houses can do here.

I recently got a quote just to upgrade the large double glazed windows (60s build) - that was nearly 20k! So unless significant subsidies happen, I feel like I don’t have much option but to keep burning gas.

LemonSwan · 19/10/2021 09:46

Its a shame. We are currently just starting a refurb of an old property with no central heating.

Would be ideal timing to put one in - but with everything else we need to pay for (double glazing, roof insulation etc) I cant justify spending that much extra on whats essentially a boiler.

ProudMaiasaura · 19/10/2021 09:43

@Veiaola

Air heat source still requires electricity to run it, you will still need a very well insulated house. The costings are very vague. However I think we are all going to be forced to go down this route eventually.
We are all definitely going to be forced down this route. If you're younger than 60 you'll see the end of mains gas heating homes in your lifetime.

The current options are electric boilers aka heat pump or hydrogen boilers. Heat pump will hopefully get more efficient as more manufactures up their game. Hydrogen will offer similar capability to gas...however your actual network needs to be converted for you to take advantage of that so it's a logistical nightmare that utility companies are trying to think their way around at the moment. I know there are mixed use boilers coming to market that can handle gas or hydrogen with little interference so that may be a more popular option for homeowners.

The irritating thing about the heat pump boilers is that you need modern style insulation for them to be effective...except new builds from the last 20 years that have this sort of insulation are not built with sufficient space to house all the extra equipment needed (water tanks etc) so older properties will suit the installation of heat pump boilers better than new ones - but they won't be as effective.

For the first time in my life, I'm glad we're not likely to ever own a home. This is not my problem to solve!

Watchingyou2sleezes · 19/10/2021 09:42

The prices being banded around today are incorrect. As an element of a general refurb @£11k is about right but as a retro fit you'd be lucky to get anywhere near that low.
Ground source are fantastic bits of kit (my main house is heated this way) air source not so much. I'm heavily involved in the heat pump game and some of that grant money will end up in my pocket but I'm not overly enthused by air source as a solution.
I own 2 apartment blocks with 4 air source pumps each and photovoltaics on the roof to power them as much as possible to run a metered whole block heat system.
Unfortunately due to never ending reliability problems we're almost certainly sticking in two large 3 phase electric boilers in each block as back up. Massively regret not putting gas in during construction and individual boilers in the apartments.

number87inthequeue · 19/10/2021 09:41

I'm not sure this sort of subsidy will do much to encourage people to move away from gas. I recently moved in to a house with electric storage heaters, intending to upgrade the heating system very quickly. So you'd imagine I would be in an ideal position to switch to a heat pump. But from what I've read, fitting a heat pump and all the piping/radiators etc would be more expensive that getting a gas boiler gas heating system. If I move to a gas system I could get rid of the current emersion hot water tank, freeing up space inside my house. If I move to a heat pump I would need a tank at least as big as that inside and would also lose some of my outside space for the pump. The pumps also seem to be particularly industrial looking, so not really something that will be appealing in a small garden. On top of all that, there are no guarantees that a heat pump will be any cheaper to run than the current inefficient storage heaters. I have a fear that if we fit a heat pump now it will be obsolete in a few years so we will need to replace the whole system again and/or it will reduce the house value.

What would make a real difference would be investment in finding ways to make greener systems smaller and simpler to work

RandomLondoner · 19/10/2021 09:40

Our boiler is nearly 30 year old and on borrowed time so I am wondering whether to look into replacing everything with Fischer electric heaters

I think electricity costs 3 to 5 times as much as gas, so this would cause a huge increase in your heating bills. The sort of heating you're proposing would be 100% efficient, but the very best air source heat pumps can be 300% or more efficient, because they're not creating heat, they're moving it from somewhere else into your house. So, at their very best, they might be able to compete with gas for running costs.

RandomLondoner · 19/10/2021 09:35

Sorry, I also failed to read the OP properly, she wasn't asking what I though she was.

billysboy · 19/10/2021 09:33

the majority of gas boilers are under £2k to buy plus fitting so I think it will be a hard sell , but all we need is gas prices to go through the roof and we all will have a bit more incentive !

Luckytattie · 19/10/2021 09:30

I mean, it seems like it's very common in scandi countries and it's not been a thing about "oh it won't work in all houses or you'll lose wall thickness or you need to strip everything back" etc etc

I think people need to go away and research it properly. Including myself.

Maybe @SprayedWithDettol you're friends got a ground source pump and it would have been different if they chose an air sourced one

DaisyNGO · 19/10/2021 09:28

@FinallyFluid

We agreed last night to replace our boiler in 2031.
Yes, I think this is going to be the thing

By 2034 no one will be selling or installing

My concern is that there will be no one to service or repair.

Luckytattie · 19/10/2021 09:27

Basically you can opt for a ground source heat pump which does involve a 150m deep hole
OR you get an air sourced heat pump which I have had and wasn't bug at all and was I stalled on a few hours. That was to the pool not the house so I guess maybe it would be longer to I stall to a house but doesn't seem like a big deal.
I don't think you need to site a new water tank or anything.

www.worcester-bosch.co.uk/heat-pumps

SprayedWithDettol · 19/10/2021 09:27

Friends have a very very large house and during its total refurb had heat source pumps installed. They work very well and keep the house and water hot. The house needed stripping back and huge amounts of insulation added to ensure it was able to be sufficiently warm. This isn’t going to be possible for most people - the walls for example are now much thicker in each room.
We are looking to do the same, we have oil fired central heating as no gas where we live. I think our option will be to clad the outside of the house with insulating cladding. Again, not a solution for many.
I’m just not sure how this is going to work in a country with a high % of such poor quality housing.

FangsForTheMemory · 19/10/2021 09:25

You seem to have a bit of a chip on your shoulder, OP. I’m now ‘pensioners etc’ but I used to be ‘normal working people’. We all get old.

Luckytattie · 19/10/2021 09:20

You don't replace a perfectly fine working boiler. You'd do it when it is failing and you need a new one.

We had an air sourced heat pump for our large swimming pool and it wasn't big at all.
Why would you need a water tank outside @pussycatlickinglollyices? I don't really know too much about it

FinallyFluid · 19/10/2021 09:20

We agreed last night to replace our boiler in 2031.

Indecisivelurcher · 19/10/2021 09:19

@SuperLoudPoppingAction this is Air source heat, not ground source, so no drilling down required. You'd need to replace your boiler with one and possibly replace some radiators.

@pussycatlickinglollyices are you thinking about air source heat pumps that work like a reverse fridge and heat one room, rather than the ones that replace the boiler? Genuine question because I don't know.

@MojoMoon you seem to know about this subject, my new extension is almost finished but can I make any changes at 11th hour? Radiators are not purchased yet.

RandomLondoner · 19/10/2021 09:14

My boiler is so old it's not even a condensing one. I have had an estimate of £5000 to replace it. That includes the extra cost of the new pipework that will be needed for a condensing boiler. If I could just replace the boiler with the same kind, I'd guess it might cost £3,000.

The figures I've read is that an air source heat pump install will cost maybe £10,000. With the grant that comes down to £5000. Still more than the maybe £3000 that it would cost to replace a boiler if replacing with one of the same kind, so I don't think people will be doing unnecessary replacements.

I'm tempted to do it anyway, if air source heat pump means I have air conditioning in the summer. My home office has a 8 foot wide by 8 foot high south-facing window, and gets very hot.

My problem is that I'm in a flat, can't legally make alterations to the outside of the building for the exterior part of the heat pump. And I wouldn't want to make the building ugly, anyway. Nor would I want my neighbours to be allowed to. Does anyone know how heat pump installs are going to work for flats?