Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this new heat pump policy will just push people towards replacing still working gas boilers

113 replies

nosyupnorth · 19/10/2021 08:40

It's pushing me anyway. The subsidy amount offered per household is only a fraction of the cost of a heat pump and the totally only covers a fraction of the population -- which means they're probably also going to wrap it up in a criteria to limit who gets it to pensioners etc so that normal working people get nothing.

If it weren't for this, I would get maximum use out of my boiler before it gives out and then replace it which is the most enviromentally efficient choice but instead I now feel forced to plan to replace my boiler with a new one while I can still get one, which is surely the opposite of a good enviromental choice.

OP posts:
Igmum · 19/10/2021 12:00

I'm actually tempted by it, particularly since my gas boiler will need replacing soon, but I live in a Victorian end of terrace. I have some insulation but suspect not enough to be suitable

AnkleDeep · 19/10/2021 11:54

We've just bought a new gas boiler. Not spending more than we have to - that's daft.

CausingChaos2 · 19/10/2021 11:52

BigWoollyJumpers I have a heat pump and am the same as you, windows open, at least a little, year round. Still find the heating performs well.

MamsellMarie · 19/10/2021 11:49

If you use oil or gas you can adjust the temperature of the water in your radiators, you might put it up in cold weather. If you use heat pumps the temperature is much lower - the upshot is to warm a house it will have to run for much longer to throw out the same heat. Running it for longer requires electricity for the pump that pumps the hot water round your rads. .......... so in cold weather the whole country could be running heating 24/7 with the odd electric heater for top up. Hopefully they won't be needing electricity for cars too!

Coogee · 19/10/2021 11:46

The thing I can't get round with heat pump technology is that your house has to be completely sealed up to be effective

That is only because they put out a lot less heat than a typical gas boiler can.

You could just size up the heat pump to cope with the heat losses but that would cost more for the pump and the electricity to run it.

BigWoollyJumpers · 19/10/2021 11:43

We've just replaced our 25 year old gas boiler.... with a new gas boiler. It will be much more efficient, and we won't need to supplement with the immersion any more, also upgraded our hot water tank. £3.5K all in. The boiler will take some tolerance of hydrogen input when available.

We live in a very well insulated house, double glazing, cavity wall insulation etc, but even then we would have needed extra work to effectively install a heat pump, and at huge expense.

The thing I can't get round with heat pump technology is that your house has to be completely sealed up to be effective. We always leave windows open on latch, I can't sleep in a sealed room. I just can't see how that would work for us on the fresh air front either. Maybe I am misunderstanding the technology. And don't old houses need to "breathe"?

Coogee · 19/10/2021 11:41

I hate gas anyway. know in the scheme of things it is very safe, but you still get explosions from time

I suspect that far more people are fatally electrocuted every year than are killed in gas explosions.

Tal45 · 19/10/2021 11:35

@berlinbabylon

Not sure people will replace them for the sake of it. Even with the subsidy it is going to cost substantially more than gas boiler would.

I am not sure they will work very effectively when they are retrofitted to (in my case, a 1960s) older houses. Our boiler is nearly 30 year old and on borrowed time so I am wondering whether to look into replacing everything with Fischer electric heaters and look at a more sophisticated immersion heater for the hot water. I hate gas anyway. know in the scheme of things it is very safe, but you still get explosions from time to time.

Research reviews on the Fischer heaters, I had a look at them as we're electric and there were a lot of terrible reviews. They come on whenever the temperature drops so could be any time day or night. Day electric energy is much more than night so they end up really expensive (we currently have storage heaters which are crap too so also have an aga). We have an immersion heater and I absolutely hate it, we'll move in the next few years and would never move to another house that was electric. I know the government want to get rid of gas and the price has gone up but I'd still prefer it.
Watchingyou2sleezes · 19/10/2021 11:30

@MrsSlocombesPussy

Are we going to have enough electricity generating capacity to power all these heat pumps? We'll also need to charge up our electric cars at the same time.
The national grid is already creaking at the seems. Needs several hundred billion pounds spending on it already.

As an illustration imagine every single on of the idiots queuing for fuel recently over that week, imaging them all doing it every single night for their car. I own both Tesla & Porsche electric vehicles and both recommend that they're kept as close to fully charged as possible, so every night 30 odd million plugging their cars in, plus millions of electric boilers etc etc it's all a complete folly being madly pursued by these loons.

Coogee · 19/10/2021 11:29

Probably via water electrolysis, the technology for which is currently also being improved at pace.

For domestic heating, I’m struggling to see the point of using electricity to make hydrogen, then turning the hydrogen back into electricity with a fuel cell.

Wexone · 19/10/2021 11:22

You should use your boiler to the end of its lifespan. Then replace it with the most up to date method and cost effective you can afford also avail of al the grants available to you. I have just recently moved into an old house after selling my A rated house. My house was about 7 years old but was insulated well and the heating was an energy efficient one. Yes my electricity went up a bit however i didnt have to buy oil or coal as much. Have now moved into a old house to rent while we build our new house. It has just killed me to get 500l of oil costing at 500e nearly knowing it will only last till just after xmas. I hate radiators hey take up so much space, the house looses so much heat when heating goes off, never had that problem in my old house, it was always warm. Its only October i dread to think what Dec and Jan going to be like in this house. Be open minded for what options you have out there, invest in what you can afford and what is best for your house, its so worth it in the end

MasterGland · 19/10/2021 11:16

@coogee. Probably via water electrolysis, the technology for which is currently also being improved at pace.

MrsSkylerWhite · 19/10/2021 11:04

We had a new gas boiler last year. No requirement to have it replaced until it dies a natural death. Heat pumps are massively expensive, even with the subsidy so it will be gas for us for a good while.

Coogee · 19/10/2021 11:01

I wouldn't worry about it. By 2035, I am quite confident that our existing gas infrastructure will have been adapted for hydrogen.

Hydrogen fuel cells will be the answer.

Where is all the hydrogen going to come from?

MasterGland · 19/10/2021 10:47

I wouldn't worry about it. By 2035, I am quite confident that our existing gas infrastructure will have been adapted for hydrogen. Over the next few decade or so, the supply of gas will be mixed with a proportion of hydrogen, until we have full hydrogen supply. Heat pumps will be limited to the early adopters only, or those going "off grid“. Same with cars. I think electric cars will be the eight tracks of their day, as electricity becomes ever more expensive to generate. Hydrogen fuel cells will be the answer.

CrumpleHornedSnowcack · 19/10/2021 10:44

I agree OP. It will also increase the supply of knock off replacement parts to go inside boilers to prolong their life, it's an accident waiting to happen imo

Coogee · 19/10/2021 10:40

Are we going to have enough electricity generating capacity to power all these heat pumps? We'll also need to charge up our electric cars at the same time.

That’s not a problem. We can recommission our coal fired power stations.

The UK fired up an old coal power plant on Monday to meet its electricity needs.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-58469238

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 19/10/2021 10:37

YANBU op like the stupid car scrappage schemes that junked thousands of perfectly serviceable cars.

MrsSlocombesPussy · 19/10/2021 10:35

Are we going to have enough electricity generating capacity to power all these heat pumps? We'll also need to charge up our electric cars at the same time.

Nanny0gg · 19/10/2021 10:31

They are enormous great ugly buggers that not everyone will have the space for. Total eyesore in your garden.

And if you don't have the right infrastructure/insulation then a total waste of money.

Put them in new builds by all means but I bet they won't work for the vast majority of British homes

godmum56 · 19/10/2021 10:26

I investigated it last year as I have just had my boiler replaced. I have got a well insulated house. My previous boiler lasted 20 years. Key for me was how long it would take to get back the difference in cost between an air source heat pump and a traditional boiler. I can't remember the figure now but it was longer than I expect to live in the house. There was also the issue that I know a couple of people who have them and they all say that additional heat is needed.

Jux · 19/10/2021 10:23

Our house is 250 years old and is as insulated as it can be. It's impossible to heat, we're always cold in winter as it is and have to have supplementary heaters all over the place. We've found the most effective are electric oil filled radiators which we can wheel around as needed. I already have one in regular use this year, and that's if I don't use the sitting room at all, but do everything in the kitchen - online stuff (banking, MN, shopping, research etc), hobby, tv, radio - all in the kitchen now.

My friend just bought a recent barn conversion with excellent insulation and a heat pump and lots of modern wondrousness (the controls take up a whole room). I have to admit to envy!

Indecisivelurcher · 19/10/2021 10:21

My dad lives in New Zealand, most houses there don't have gas central heating. He has a reverse fridge type air source heat pump. Others have the electric boiler type ones that heat rads. They have things like heat lamps in the bathroom and electric heated towel rails. Obviously it gets very cold there.

SpiderinaWingMirror · 19/10/2021 10:19

I think that given moat people struggle with the cost of a gas boiler, this can only go ahead if prices reduce substantially.

MojoMoon · 19/10/2021 10:18

Probably worth flagging also the £5k subsidy scheme announced today is for England and Wales.
Scotland is expected to have its own one out shortly, probably just before the COP26 summit in Glasgow