Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this new heat pump policy will just push people towards replacing still working gas boilers

113 replies

nosyupnorth · 19/10/2021 08:40

It's pushing me anyway. The subsidy amount offered per household is only a fraction of the cost of a heat pump and the totally only covers a fraction of the population -- which means they're probably also going to wrap it up in a criteria to limit who gets it to pensioners etc so that normal working people get nothing.

If it weren't for this, I would get maximum use out of my boiler before it gives out and then replace it which is the most enviromentally efficient choice but instead I now feel forced to plan to replace my boiler with a new one while I can still get one, which is surely the opposite of a good enviromental choice.

OP posts:
Watchingyou2sleezes · 19/10/2021 16:35

@Coogee

The manufacturers play this down, but I know aircon units can be noisy and heat pumps look similar.

Aircon units are heat pumps.

Not really. Very few heat pumps are air to air. A small air con unit for a room is actually a pretty decent heat source though when run in heat mode
StoneofDestiny · 19/10/2021 16:24

My guess is your home in summer is too warm because of solar warming through glass windows and doors. Fit some solar shades or awning and keep the sun off the glass - makes a massive difference and is again why Mediterranean homes often have awnings or external shutters

Agreed. My home is well insulated it's never cold in winter. Very low energy use as even winter sun heats the house through our glass walls. However, summertime is too hot. Placing big garden parasols in front of the windows stops the sun hitting them - problem solved. Awnings would do it more efficiently I guess.

TooBigForMyBoots · 19/10/2021 16:08

Do you drive an electric or hybrid car @nosyupnorth?

Coogee · 19/10/2021 16:01

Quietest

Coogee · 19/10/2021 16:00

I can imagine a row or terraced houses or block of flats, all with heat pumps running, generating noise pollution.

Having spent some time abroad with our aircon unit outside directly below the bedroom window, I have the same concerns.

Our gas boiler is getting on for 50 years old now and my husband has been outside this morning trying to work out the quietist place to put heat pump units if we switch. Nowhere is ideal but apparently it’s possible to build a sound proofing enclosure over them. Drilling down into the ground is another option we are looking at. Quieter and more efficient but around £20K cost.

montysma1 · 19/10/2021 15:07

Fisher are a scam, don't do it. Internet is full of stuff about them.

eightlivesdown · 19/10/2021 14:50

@Coogee

The manufacturers play this down, but I know aircon units can be noisy and heat pumps look similar.

Aircon units are heat pumps.

Exactly. And they are noisy, some more than others of course. I can imagine a row or terraced houses or block of flats, all with heat pumps running, generating noise pollution. And being intrusive if a window is open or someone is relaxing in the garden / on a balcony.
Fernhilde · 19/10/2021 14:26

Why did the government pay to install oil central heating in my house at the beginning of 2021 if everything is already supposed to change to a different fuel?

politics4me · 19/10/2021 14:26

I am not using any brain energy on this 'Policy' because:
It is not finalised, it's a wish list
The devices are not wonderfully efficient
The house needs to be insulated to a standard that it is extremely difficult to achieve.
Firstly they need to force builders to install on all new properties.

Have any Govt Departments or Devolved administrations specified the change for what they commission? Scotland?

Changing cars and heating for house in same year is impossible for most families.

We can't afford it Carrie-

Coogee · 19/10/2021 14:04

The manufacturers play this down, but I know aircon units can be noisy and heat pumps look similar.

Aircon units are heat pumps.

Coogee · 19/10/2021 14:02

We just replaced a perfectly good boiler for a new one with a 12 year guarantee.

Why?

eightlivesdown · 19/10/2021 14:02

The Govt. is relying on the cost of heat pumps reducing and efficiency in relation to older houses increasing as demand rises to make heat pumps more affordable and practical. Or that hydrogen boilers are developed as an alternative. It's difficult to see a mass take-up of heat pumps without the cost / efficiency improvements. The £5k incentive won't do it as there's only funds for 90,000 homes whereas the Govt. talks of 600,000 installations per year; the additional costs of larger radiators and additional insulation can also be high.

Personally, I'm also wary of the noise they make. The manufacturers play this down, but I know aircon units can be noisy and heat pumps look similar.

There's a need to increase the supply of electricity as people switch from gas boilers to electric heat pumps (and petrol / diesel cars to electric cars). This supply needs to be from green sources, otherwise it's pointless.

There's an element of virtue signalling going on, as Boris wants to parade in front of world leaders at the upcoming Cop26 climate conference as the greenest man in the room. The target is announced, but the road map on how to get there is somewhat vague.

Rabblesthecat · 19/10/2021 13:35

We just replaced a perfectly good boiler for a new one with a 12 year guarantee.

berlinbabylon · 19/10/2021 13:27

I recently moved in to a house with electric storage heaters, intending to upgrade the heating system very quickly

The right storage heaters are actually very good - my mum has them and her house is always warm, unlike our house which is only warm when the heating is on. Her bills are about the same as our combined gas and electricity for a smaller house, so yes, more expensive, but always warm.

My father actually worked for Dimplex many moons ago, I'll have a look at what they offer these days.

Hydrogen - hmmm. Even more explosive than natural gas, although I assume the fuel cells aren't.

DoubleTweenQueen · 19/10/2021 13:21

DH has looked at the specs for air-source heat pumps, and we honestly don't see the point in them, apart from perhaps for eco new homes.
We live in the country and are on oil. We will replace two boilers for the best we can get, in the next two years, and have a wood-burning stove which supplements (our own wood). Plus have insulated the house and upgraded to double and triple glazing.
Our neighbours removed oil from their home a number of years ago and have an air-source heat pump and PV. They also have had to retain an enormous electric arga which is a vast lump of heat throughout the winter, and uses low-tarrif electricity, plus two wood-burning stoves. The air-source heat pump doesn't seem to do much! Apart from sound like an industrial refrigeration unit clicking on and off regularly through day and night.

They only seem to be good for new fitting companies.
You still need electricity to heat water.

Why not just go back to night-storage heaters?

For us, a ground-source pump would be more effective, but less straightforward to fit so they won't opt for these but push the easier air-source.

Yes, I'm pretty cynical about the whole thing!

Flogert · 19/10/2021 13:14

We considered air source, but were quoted 16k for installation of pump, resiting the boiler as it wouldn’t fit in our immersion heater cupboard, new radiators, new loft insulation. Funnily enough, not the kind of cash we have lying around for a one off investment like this, regardless of pay backs which are quarterly over seven years. It’s just too out of reach for our financial situation

nosyupnorth · 19/10/2021 13:13

lots of interesting comments in this thread but mostly confirming my theory that I'm going to aim to replace my boiler somewhere around 2031/32 regardless of how well it is doing so that I won't have to worry about the current one dying 2036 and being forced to shell out ££££s for a heat pump

the fact of the matter is, if heat pumps were suitable for most people then all the goverment would need to do is put out the info and people would choose to upgrade, not need to be forced into it by the government banning all alternatives.

Unless there is some consideration for the many people in homes where heat pumps aren't viable due to lack of space or age/design of structure and unless we see much better subsidies than a small fraction of the price being offered to a small number of households then the only result I foresee from this boiler ban is a wave of artificial fuel poverty as people either have no way to heat their homes or are forced onto electric which we've always previously been told is far less effiicient than gas

OP posts:
Simonjt · 19/10/2021 13:12

We looked at one for our holiday home, the quote was just shy of £15k, however on top of that we would need to insulate the roof and all internal walls, as the internal walls are exposed brick this would also ruin the property and then need plastering over, painting etc.

The building is grade 2 listed so the outside needs to be preserved, so any external fitting must either be approved, or under ground.

A new oil based boiler was £3k fitted.

Coogee · 19/10/2021 13:08

It makes sense, I believe, to try to adapt existing gas infrastructure to run on hydrogen. For domestic heating, cost and reliability for the consumer will be a big factor.

Why not just the electricity to heat homes directly? Even better, use the electricity to power a heat pump.

MasterGland · 19/10/2021 12:59

@mojomoon didn't BNEFs own hydrogen analyst also state that he thinks hydrogen fuel will still have it's day, because of the plummeting costs of solar to power the electrolysis? (can't remember where I read this) .
It makes sense, I believe, to try to adapt existing gas infrastructure to run on hydrogen. For domestic heating, cost and reliability for the consumer will be a big factor.
With fuel cells, I think range will be the big determinant in the further development of the technology.
Of course, there are unknowns, and you clearly don't agree. So we will have to see what happens, I guess. Perhaps we can reconvene on here in a few years? Smile

MojoMoon · 19/10/2021 12:28

@BigWoollyJumpers. Your house doesn't need to be totally sealed. It's just that you use less energy if you don't let heat out the window.

Heat pumps can heat any building, just like a gas boiler can.. It's just that you would need a bigger heat pump for the more heat you need to produce. Same as a gas boiler - if you want to heat a leaky seven bed room house, you need a bigger boiler than for an energy efficient two bedroom property.

Homes do need ventilation but there are more energy efficient ways of doing it than leaving windows open. Heat recovery ventilation systems move stale air out and fresh air in but recover the heat as they do so, cutting your energy costs as you aren't losing heat out of a vent.

But if you like windows open, you can do that. It's just that you need to use a bit more energy to stay warm. Same as with your gas boiler and the windows being open

MojoMoon · 19/10/2021 12:23

@MasterGland. How do you think hydrogen is made?

Green hydrogen is made from renewable electricity (and water) through electrolysis.

If electricity is going to be "so expensive" that it won't make sense for heating or vehicles, why would green hydrogen be any better? Its main input cost is.....the cost of electricity.

The round trip efficiency of electricity to hydrogen and back to electricity is low. If you can use electricity directly, that is a more effective approach.

I'd recommend reading the three part blog from BNEF
about.bnef.com/blog/liebreich-separating-hype-from-hydrogen-part-one-the-supply-side/

IneedSocks · 19/10/2021 12:23

I actually said to my DP let's invest in a new boiler quick, no way I'm having a heat pump but thankfully the previous owner updated it only three years ago!

LemonMuffins · 19/10/2021 12:20

We rent a 10ish year old house which has an air source heat pump with ground floor underfloor heating. I hate it. Hate it so much. It takes an age to change temperature, has a needlessly complicated operating panel, costs a fortune to run and the upstairs radiators seem to cool down when the kitchen is too warm. It also sends a vibration through the house which drives me mad. I hope they've improved because I will do everything in my power to not have one when I move out of here.

EmmaGrundyForPM · 19/10/2021 12:07

Our ASHP heats our 1960s house just fine, and we sleep with the windows open.