Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this new heat pump policy will just push people towards replacing still working gas boilers

113 replies

nosyupnorth · 19/10/2021 08:40

It's pushing me anyway. The subsidy amount offered per household is only a fraction of the cost of a heat pump and the totally only covers a fraction of the population -- which means they're probably also going to wrap it up in a criteria to limit who gets it to pensioners etc so that normal working people get nothing.

If it weren't for this, I would get maximum use out of my boiler before it gives out and then replace it which is the most enviromentally efficient choice but instead I now feel forced to plan to replace my boiler with a new one while I can still get one, which is surely the opposite of a good enviromental choice.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Coogee · 25/10/2021 11:11

You do need room indoors for the inside unit

There are some available now that combine the inside unit with the outside, so just the water tank is needed inside.

NeverForgetYourDreams · 24/10/2021 07:24

We replacing our current working Worcester boiler a year before the ban comes in. They last typically 15-25 years so should see me through a bit ..!

knitnerd90 · 24/10/2021 06:50

Heat pumps are very common here in the USA. There is a big push to expand their use here, because the electric source can be made renewable. At the moment, gas heating is somewhat cheaper to use, but not enormously so. They come with auxiliary electric heat for when it's very cold. The latest models are suitable for Northeastern winters. Ordinary electric heat is much more expensive; you can't compare the two.

They do also do air-con but in order to do that, you need the ducting, which is how they are normally set up here. The heating will still work if you crack open a window but think about it; you're letting cold air in while you're trying to heat the house, so it will make the pump work harder.

As for terraced houses, you will see townhouse developments here where all the houses have a heat pump unit in the back, often hidden by a bit of shrubbery. It's not that big. You do need room indoors for the inside unit and for your water tank.

Buddywoo · 23/10/2021 09:52

The local landowner has replaced the oil fired central heating in the 30 houses he owns in the village with a ground source heat pump. The disruption and mess in the village, and to the individual houses, was huge.
All the houses are built of stone and none is properly insulated i.e. all single glazed, no cavity wall insulation and probably very little loft insulation.
His tenants were not happy about it but had no choice. We could have joined the scheme but chose not to and have just installed a new oil boiler.
I shall be watching with interest this winter to see how the scheme works.

Luckytattie · 21/10/2021 08:10

@LivingDeadGirlUK I guess that makes sense. I sold the house that had the pool so don't have it anymore. Will be a distant memory when I get the next one I suppose!

LivingDeadGirlUK · 21/10/2021 07:27

@Luckytattie you at least need to be cleaning/changing the filters or its not going to work efficently.

EmmaGrundyForPM · 21/10/2021 06:43

@antsinyourpanta

Our boiler is 16 years old. I'm imagining we'll need a new one fairly soon. On a report I saw yesterday there was (I think) a plumber saying if you had a new heat pump boiler you would need all new, bigger radiators as well and that its a much bigger and more time consuming job than simply fitting a new gas boiler.
That is true for older homes. We ended up having to put new radiators in our main living/dining/kitchen and in our bedroom. But nowhere else So 3 new radiators in total. The biggest additional expense was that we had to have a much bigger hot water cylinder. put in because our old one was tiny.

When we had the companies out to quote it was made clear to us that we would need the radiators and the cylinder so there were no surprise costs.

Coogee · 20/10/2021 21:59

so if the temp outside is like minus 3 how will the heat pump heat the house

It sucks in the minus 3 air and makes it even colder. The heat that it takes out to make it colder goes into the house.

antsinyourpanta · 20/10/2021 21:44

Our boiler is 16 years old. I'm imagining we'll need a new one fairly soon.
On a report I saw yesterday there was (I think) a plumber saying if you had a new heat pump boiler you would need all new, bigger radiators as well and that its a much bigger and more time consuming job than simply fitting a new gas boiler.

generalh · 20/10/2021 21:32

No.

Wherearemymarbles · 20/10/2021 21:31

What with everything going electric our domestic supply will need massivd upgrading.

Currently its capped at 100A which equates to about 23Kw at 230v.

So anyone with a larger house with say 15kw pump who also charges their car with a fast charger which could be 22kw will quickly find the lights go out…

MasterGland · 20/10/2021 21:30

It will have to be nuclear. Which probably won't sit well with a lot of the old school greens.

simonisnotme · 20/10/2021 20:52

wheres the electric coming from to run all these heat pumps
our power plants cant cope with what we use now

Luckytattie · 20/10/2021 20:46

@BigWoollyJumpers

No-one ever mentions annual maintenance in their calculations of efficiency. A heat pump system apparently needs, like a standard boiler, an annual service. Servicing will take a day, rather than an hour, cost several hundred pounds, and at the moment, hardly anyone is qualified to do it. Just like electric cars, at present a huge issue is the maintenance of all those new technologies.
I had an air source heat pump and it didn't need annual service or maintenance 🤷
simonisnotme · 20/10/2021 20:38

so if the temp outside is like minus 3 how will the heat pump heat the house
disclaimer (no intention of having one ever)

MrsSkylerWhite · 20/10/2021 20:15

I heard someone say on the radio this morning that you would need a water tank. We have a combi-boiler and hot water as we need it is fantastic.
Does this mean that we’ll have to go back to rationing baths, because the hot water in the tank will run out as it used to with the old electric immersion tanks?

EmmaGrundyForPM · 20/10/2021 18:54

He checks the unit, whilst it's running, which takes a few minutes. Then he goes into the airing cupboard and checks the valves and the HWC. Obviously there's no boiler so it doesn't take as long. He came last month, I think he was here for about 45 minutes but wasn't actually timing him.

Coogee · 20/10/2021 13:33

Ours costs £75 each year and the guy is here for less than an hour.

What does he do?

EmmaGrundyForPM · 20/10/2021 13:24

@BigWoollyJumpers

No-one ever mentions annual maintenance in their calculations of efficiency. A heat pump system apparently needs, like a standard boiler, an annual service. Servicing will take a day, rather than an hour, cost several hundred pounds, and at the moment, hardly anyone is qualified to do it. Just like electric cars, at present a huge issue is the maintenance of all those new technologies.
I don't know where you got this from. It's just not true.

There's very little to go wrong with an ASHP. Ours costs £75 each year and the guy is here for less than an hour.

BigWoollyJumpers · 20/10/2021 13:20

No-one ever mentions annual maintenance in their calculations of efficiency. A heat pump system apparently needs, like a standard boiler, an annual service. Servicing will take a day, rather than an hour, cost several hundred pounds, and at the moment, hardly anyone is qualified to do it. Just like electric cars, at present a huge issue is the maintenance of all those new technologies.

Coogee · 19/10/2021 19:02

So you need a hugely well insulated, hermetically sealed house. You also need much bigger radiators as the incumbents would have been designated around a flow of 70 -80 deg.

You could compensate by running the heating for longer periods.

Wherearemymarbles · 19/10/2021 18:56

Also forgot to add - the colder it is outside the less efficient an air source heat pump becomes.
So you’re bills will really crank up on a freezing winters night!

Wherearemymarbles · 19/10/2021 18:43

For most the downfall of a retrofit is sheer cost.
Heat pumps can only heat to about 48 deg. So you need a hugely well insulated, hermetically sealed house. You also need much bigger radiators as the incumbents would have been designated around a flow of 70 -80 deg.

Also with air source the efficiency is often no where near the upper limits stated and varies a lot with ambient temperature. So its not even that cheap to run

Anyway to insulate my Victorian place properly would cost the same as heating it with gas for about 35 years. Heat pumps for the vast majority of housing stock is not really viable

nosyupnorth · 19/10/2021 18:37

@TooBigForMyBoots

Do you drive an electric or hybrid car *@nosyupnorth*?
Currently I'm car free (and electric cars are another topic I have a lot of options on regarding the government setting targets without considering older homes or lower income households!) but I'm curious as to why you'd ask?
OP posts:
Coogee · 19/10/2021 18:01

Not really. Very few heat pumps are air to air. A small air con unit for a room is actually a pretty decent heat source though when run in heat mode

Whether they are air to air or not is immaterial. Unless I am very much mistaken, the mechanism by which they transfer heat from one place to another is called a heat pump.