Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this class should be closed?

668 replies

Jenster03 · 18/10/2021 23:11

I'm a part time primary teacher and in the space of two weeks, 14 children have tested positive out of 30 in my class.
We've had 2 or 3 return in that time, but more and more are testing positive. Now my teaching assistant has it.
AIBU to think we should be sending the class home and remote learning? How would you feel if you were a parent of a child in my class?
Oh, and I'm pretty anxious about my level of exposure too!

OP posts:
Angie1403 · 20/10/2021 21:41

@julieca

I have to isolate now for 10 days. I am losing money for work as a result. I cant see my elderly parents, they will just have to manage as covid would kill them. Not that any people on this thread would care.
We are in the same boat. Luckily haven’t had it but self employed so the folk banging on about restarting the economy are basically forcing me to put money before my health and be unable to visit my elderly family member who lives in care due to dementia. They really need physical visits, a zoom call can’t cut it. It’s a toll on our mental health being separated from them, not just a toll on theirs. We sacrificed 14 months of visits to keep everyone safe and now what…no one gives a shit and why? Cos now they’re bored with covid
MrsArchchancellorRidcully · 20/10/2021 21:41

@KayKayWat

Whilst we do need to get on with it, most people in offices wouldn't be happy to have to work in close proximity to dozens of people with covid.
It wouldn't bother me in he slightest. Stats say my chances of dying from covid are pretty low. Given I have a grown up attitude to risk taking abs am able to cross the road by myself, I'll take that chance.
jumpbounce · 20/10/2021 21:38

If there was 18 cases of norovirus in one class the class would be closed and has been closed for less than that in our school before. I would want the class closed

clarcats · 20/10/2021 21:37

if your Co2 monitor is always red then surely that tells you to open some windows/the door to change the air in the room?

How do you know that 'viral load is high' - are you personally measuring the viral load of everyone who gets Covid or are you picking this information from the (scaremongering) media?

Do you get this concerned every winter when there's flu/norovirus around?

Angie1403 · 20/10/2021 21:36

@ImUninsultable

There us no point.

Covid is not going away. This is life now. We just need to accept that we are now living in a world with a virus that is mostly fine with a vaccine but sometimes people will get very ill or die. It's not nice, but its how we lived for a couple thousand years before modern medicine. And it's just how we need to live now.

It isnt going away. People die every year from the flu and we dont shut down. With a vaccine now, it isnt like it was back at the start.

If you dont want to live with the risk then maybe consider a career change.

Your a dick
Angie1403 · 20/10/2021 21:34

@lughnasadh

There's no point in sending them home. When you consider siblings, childminders, after school clubs etc. they'll all be mixing with the rest of tbe school /community outside of teaching hours anyway.

They're better off getting it over with.

Pretty much everyone who can be/wants to be vaccinated has been.

Are you out of your mind?! People are dying from that bloody virus, even kids and what about if the teacher/OP has underlying health issues you selfish idiot?!!!!!! I can’t deal with people like you only a couple of weeks ago a quarter million kids were newly infected; if even one of them dies it’s one too many.
PorthbeanCove · 20/10/2021 21:31

The people saying we just have to "live" with the virus are the first to kick off when their bins don't get emptied because the refuse collectors are in isolation, or the supermarket shelves aren't fully stocked, or the police can't attend a report because they're working from home with Covid. It's not just about who DIES and plenty still are, but it's also a massive disruption to services.

Awalkintime · 20/10/2021 21:25

hamptonedge
Our head made the decision today and went over what PHE had said - we didn't have the staff to stay open so we couldn't keep the kids safe.

MrsArchchancellorRidcully · 20/10/2021 21:20

@CherryBlossomWinter

Of course you should send the class home. Your instincts are totally right. They all need to self isolate for up to two weeks and do remote learning in that time.

Public Health are absolutely crazy not to advise you to do this. Read about the Irish school that have gone onto remote learning for two weeks, as they also have not had adequate advice.

I’m a medical professional. Vaccinations are a big part of the control of the pandemic, but they won’t work on their own. Children do get ill, do transmit to others (leading to breakthrough serious cases), do get long covid, do sometimes get seriously ill.

It is not a good strategy by any means to just ‘herd immunity’ children in schools. Reducing cases is extremely important still

  • by mitigations within school (mostly ventilation, HEPA filters, masks) greatly reduce transmission.
  • by sending close contacts of a positive case home (= the whole class) for testing for at least a week.

The best strategy is as soon as a child tests positive, for the whole class to switch to online learning for 5 days, and then daily antigen tests for another week. That is the very least to be done, and is quite an effective way of reducing transmission.

And what do you suggest I do with my 9 yr old DS who can't learn at home and his school who won't provide live lessons. He refuses to learn off worksheets. Thrives in school.

Every time he's a close contact he should come sit on his Nintendo for 5 days??

As someone has said, this is the reality now. We have to live like this. I'm really sorry I can't wave a magic wand and make all risk disappear. Sadly the vulnerable have always been vulnerable and will continue this way with it without covid. We can't start sending whole classes home again. Like is risky and hard for many.

hamptonedge · 20/10/2021 21:19

Schools have to take advice from public health England and local authority, who will advise when to close. Its not the schools decision.

ThirdElephant · 20/10/2021 20:42

@Sisad

Hi all first can you tell me what the vote means aibu etc . Now the covid thing , class shoul be shut immedately & fumigated, shock to you but well known that the Yanks developed covid with the Chinese as a limited spread W.M.D for use I suppose against Russia in case of war, well it escaped either from China or via American tourist or whatever , so the costs of the devastation should be borne by both . PUTIN knows what happened now he's "hounding " America , killer nation .
Here's the first thing you asked for: www.mumsnet.com/i/acronyms

No idea what the rest of your post was on about.

BlueMoodComing · 20/10/2021 20:37

You're not being unreasonable to think they should close - I feel the same - but it is out of the schools hands. We had a similar situation and advised families we were moving to remote learning (it was over a weekend) and when we finally got in touch with the local council on the Monday, they told us we were wrong and to bring them all back. Ridiculous to me.

Sisad · 20/10/2021 20:26

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Awalkintime · 20/10/2021 20:17

@YerMaWantsYa

In some circumstances they'll identify only the close contacts rather than the whole class to take the PCR.
The whole class are usually close contacts though given they all sit on the carpet together, then sit at tables with different people, then sit at lunch with different people. It is the whole class in most cases.
cantkeepawayforever · 20/10/2021 20:16

I don't know why U.K. schools are so resistant to doing this.

Let's be clear - I know no SCHOOLS that are resistant.

Unfortunately our GOVERNMENT is resistant, and due to the way that they react to schools trying to act in a way that takes greater account of the H&S of their students (e.g. threatening to take schools who wished to move early to online learning before Christmas to court), it is not easy for individual heads to put additional mitigations in place. This is particularly the case for masks and ventilation - there is no money for improving ventilation or additional heating to counteract the cold of classrooms with windows open (many schools in England already have to run at or close to deficit due to inadequate funding), and the the government's public messaging means that people are refusing to wear masks.

1onway1under12and1over18 · 20/10/2021 20:16

Good god mumsnet is brutal & toxic. Jumping on OP for being a teacher with concern, suggesting she should think of another occupation. Suggesting that teachers want lockdowns again. It’s a post asking for validation of a concern about rising infection rates. Of course that concern is valid! It doesn’t mean she should get a different job or is pro lockdown. The last thing teachers would want is to be back to March 2020 teaching pupils online as well as those in class as keyworker children! No one wants that. Small adjustments can be made now we know so much more 18 months on. Whole school assemblies have been halted once again. My sons school reintroduced masks indoors, moved from twice weekly to daily testing. The head asked for contacts of positive cases to remain home. Today plan B for winter is being discussed - not full lockdown but a return to masks and perhaps WFH again. A natural firebreak of half term is upon us. THAT is living with it. Completely ignoring it because we’re bored of it won’t work. Small, collective measures can reduce higher numbers which are starting to impact on (smaller than previous yet still seeing increase) hospitalisation & death figures. Booster vaccines need to be pushed as immunity has waned from those that had doses from Dec / jan time. We also need to encourage those that haven’t yet had any jabs to consider doing so. Whatever your opinion there’s no need to be so brutal and jump on OP for raising a concern. We all have our own fishbowl view on covid.

LaDamaDeElche · 20/10/2021 20:01

I'm a teacher in Spain. We wear masks inside, ventilate the classrooms and practice good standards of hygiene. I can't remember the last time I had a student with Covid. DD has never been in a class where they had to isolate, in fact no classes on either her primary school or her high school have had to. I don't know why U.K. schools are so resistant to doing this. People wanted their freedom day, to not have to wear masks in enclosed spaces etc, and the numbers have predictably gone up, while they are dropping considerably in other European countries.

jobling · 20/10/2021 19:57

We've had the same issue. we had email saying there were a couple of confirmed cases (cpr tests, the lateral flows weren't even counted) and then my child went in 2 days later and only 18 out of 30 in, when we found out it was rife we pulled child out Wednesday, hoping to avoid 10 isolation and catching it ourselves (s/e in client homes), told it was unauthorised and child probably had already! 🤨 retuned Monday 13 children in. Child / we Seem to have avoided 🤞I wanted remote learning for a week.

YerMaWantsYa · 20/10/2021 19:38

In some circumstances they'll identify only the close contacts rather than the whole class to take the PCR.

Silverswirl · 20/10/2021 19:28

@YerMaWantsYa

So what's the policy in England / Wales? Does nothing happen at all if a classmate tests positive? That, along with the lack of masks, seems utter madness.

Here in NI, the whole class automatically goes off and has to get a PCR. Once you get a negative result, your're allowed back to school. It's 1 or 2 days off not 10 so the inconvenience is minimised but takes steps to ensure safety of others...

So then what if the child has the negative pcr. Goes in and then the next day another child tests positive. Does the whole class need to do the pcr again? 15 out of 30 had covid this month in my sons class. Every day there were more positives. Would the kids just be off every day doing pcr’s? In that case May as well close the class for 10 days and not have to subject young children to repeated throat swabs which for many parents of little kids is a nightmare.
Plumbuddle · 20/10/2021 19:22

@orangetriangle

why are they also encouraging people to go back into the office as well when there is no reason to the job in many cases can be done just the same at home
True. HMCTs are fully back and judges and representatives all being pressured to attend in person.
LisaD76 · 20/10/2021 19:16

Kiduknot…. No other profession is being exposed in that way…. Really…. What about retail workers, there is no longer anyone wearing a mask and some of us have jobs that involve close contact with customers goods that are not at all clean and customers who think nothing of coming in unwell or even on their way to a covid test… as they might have to isolate, so they better get everything done that they need

Vynalbob · 20/10/2021 19:15

I'd say it's responsible to send them home.... but then I'd have done everything at least a month sooner than gov have done it.... in the 6 weeks holiday they could have had secondary pupils vaccinated... but no mask less in school and out.... It's still here due to PM cxxking it up and antivaxxers and antimaskers.
I've taken to reading news from other countries.... latest news due to lack of restrictions a sub-variant of the delta one (no catchy name yet but I vote for the name dipstick variant) is growing and almost exclusively found in Britain (handful of cases in Denmark).
Deseases can be controlled.... but not if we/the Gov are so slug like and halfaxsed.

Yes I'm sick of it but putting my fingers in my ears whilst singing just get over it isn't a solution (isn't an option for the 954 deaths for the week between 14th-20th of this month....and that's using the 28 day rule that catches 88% of deaths)

😳🍀🍀🍀🍀

beigebrownblue · 20/10/2021 19:03

@YerMaWantsYa

So what's the policy in England / Wales? Does nothing happen at all if a classmate tests positive? That, along with the lack of masks, seems utter madness.

Here in NI, the whole class automatically goes off and has to get a PCR. Once you get a negative result, your're allowed back to school. It's 1 or 2 days off not 10 so the inconvenience is minimised but takes steps to ensure safety of others...

I'm South West England.

No, there is nothing in place right now like this.
Plus the sxxt show of inaccurate PCR tests in the South West.

My DD's teacher has Covid a couple of days ago and we've not been told to get a PCR test, or for DD to stay off.

Feelingsupersonic1 · 20/10/2021 19:01

My son caught it from another pupil (21 kids from a class of 26 ended up off) and school advised we could still send his siblings in as they were negative - week later daughter is positive and a few days later our third child was positive as were me and hubby. Now other kids in their classes all have it too. School advised wouldn’t have work to send if we kept them home as teacher focussing on classes in school. Head teacher wanted to close school but was told by council and public health were to remain open.