Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this class should be closed?

668 replies

Jenster03 · 18/10/2021 23:11

I'm a part time primary teacher and in the space of two weeks, 14 children have tested positive out of 30 in my class.
We've had 2 or 3 return in that time, but more and more are testing positive. Now my teaching assistant has it.
AIBU to think we should be sending the class home and remote learning? How would you feel if you were a parent of a child in my class?
Oh, and I'm pretty anxious about my level of exposure too!

OP posts:
BeardyButton · 19/10/2021 09:41

@gingercatsparky

Yep for me it is about education mostly. My dcs have had to home school 4 times since this began. I was worried about dcs mental health during the second lockdown and my own. Dd is now behind in her school work and need to catch up. I am worried about the level of work they have missed.

It's also my MH too. I was trying to juggle multiple things during lockdown and survive on little sleep doing it. I am now behind in my studies which means evenings and weekends working and possibly not getting into a job at the time expected. My marriage was in trouble as a result of the stress I was under during that time. DH has his own business and was stressed about work and bringing new business in to pay our bills and the bills of 30 other people.

You need to have a think about other peoples situations before you claim it's so easy for classes to be sent home and how it's only about education. Not everyone is a SAHM or has a flexible job where they can fit it around home schooling. Not everyone has paid furlong or continued to be paid during lockdown. I have my own business too and if I don't work I don't get paid. I instantly lost my income. So no- sorry, I don't agree with classes being sent home on the tiny possibility of long COVID or the tiny minority who have a vulnerable person in their family.

At least you are being honest. I get it’s hard. I lost my job because of similar issues. But it isn’t a tiny chance of long Covid. Looks to be about 7 percent of chn that get Covid get long Covid. And it isn’t only the “vulnerable person in the family”. Allowing Covid to rip through schools like this facilitates increased community spread. Let it rip affects way more people than the immediate family. And it isn’t just people who have decided to not vacc. Here 33 percent of people in hospital are double vacc’ed.

You have the choice to do as you are doing. The UK gov is facilitating that choice. But that doesn’t mean it is the morally right thing to do. Keeping a child home in this context may be hard. It may result in the loss of a job. Again, that doesn’t mean it isn’t the right thing to do.

Pushing incorrect facts (tiny chance long Covid) etc. Or even using facts in a distorted way (New Zealand) is disingenuous. If you are happy doing the morally wrong thing and affecting others (including your own children) because of potential learning loss or impact on your career or mental health, then unfortunately you have the right to do so.

motherrunner · 19/10/2021 09:40

I would still like to know when I will be getting the much heralded CO2 monitors we were promised before term began?

gingercatsparky · 19/10/2021 09:39

@ElizaDarcysDeeds

If your class had lots of Covid cases then their education was disrupted. It was disrupted for the DCs who were at home. It was disrupted when they came back into class and had to catch up. There was no continuity. The only difference keeping them in school made was that the Government can pretend everything is fine and parents could both go to work. Well, until the parents also caught Covid. It shouldn't be an afterthought that some families can't stay away from vulnerable members. Also your comment about vulnerable people who are unlikely to have lasting effects once double jabbed is factually inaccurate. There are vulnerable people who can't get jabbed. And there are people who are double jabbed who have been left with lasting effects. I know these facts are inconvenient. That doesn't change them. And the impact on DCs of seeing their friends ill; of hearing about their friends' parents also falling ill; of worrying that they're going to pass it on to vulnerable family members, etc - is devastating. This current approach is having a much bigger impact on DCs' MH than lockdowns had.
No- they missed a weeks schooling when they caught it. Under the old guidelines they would have been sent home countless times as so many children got it over a monthly period. So 10 days after each child got it. That could have been 6 weeks missed. No thanks.

I understand about vulnerable people, I have two close family members who are in this position who I didn't see for months because of this. One died without me seeing them- not due to covid. BUT we can't shut down on the off chance for a few people anymore. I agree- if people are worried they can home schooling their own dcs and take the precautions they see fit. But others should not be forced to do so anymore.

Sweettea1 · 19/10/2021 09:36

My dc has been really struggling in school because of all the changes they need structure and routine. Closing down every time their is a few cases is not the answer.
Positive side most of the children in your class have now had it and are unlikely to get it again atleast for a few months so less disruption.

Dancerinthedark01 · 19/10/2021 09:35

Well - I'm pretty relaxed about Covid. I also work in a school.

This sounds mad though OP. Just for a minute imagine if it was some other illness - I suppose you'd carry on until it worked it's way out of the class' system ...

In the long run it will give the kids in the class (possibly life long) immunity.

But obviously the teachers and other staff are are great risk with heavy amounts of virus around them. That's the bit that needs to be considered.

gingercatsparky · 19/10/2021 09:34

Ps- you play Russian roulette every time you leave the house, every time you get in a car or cross a road. You are more likely to get hit by a car than you are to get long COVID. Yet everyone still takes their children to school as that what it is so tiny. I will take my changes yes with long COVID as I won't put my life on hold for a very tiny, tiny chance.

ElizaDarcysDeeds · 19/10/2021 09:33

that was to @gingercatsparky

ElizaDarcysDeeds · 19/10/2021 09:32

If your class had lots of Covid cases then their education was disrupted. It was disrupted for the DCs who were at home. It was disrupted when they came back into class and had to catch up. There was no continuity. The only difference keeping them in school made was that the Government can pretend everything is fine and parents could both go to work. Well, until the parents also caught Covid.
It shouldn't be an afterthought that some families can't stay away from vulnerable members.
Also your comment about vulnerable people who are unlikely to have lasting effects once double jabbed is factually inaccurate. There are vulnerable people who can't get jabbed. And there are people who are double jabbed who have been left with lasting effects. I know these facts are inconvenient. That doesn't change them.
And the impact on DCs of seeing their friends ill; of hearing about their friends' parents also falling ill; of worrying that they're going to pass it on to vulnerable family members, etc - is devastating. This current approach is having a much bigger impact on DCs' MH than lockdowns had.

LaikO · 19/10/2021 09:31

I think YANBU, OP. Although the droves of maskless coughers not covering their mouths when they do it wandering about shops and most other places makes me think we're all going to get it anyway. Unfortunately we got it a long time ago, but I do what I can to avoid getting it again.

gingercatsparky · 19/10/2021 09:30

Yep for me it is about education mostly. My dcs have had to home school 4 times since this began. I was worried about dcs mental health during the second lockdown and my own. Dd is now behind in her school work and need to catch up. I am worried about the level of work they have missed.

It's also my MH too. I was trying to juggle multiple things during lockdown and survive on little sleep doing it. I am now behind in my studies which means evenings and weekends working and possibly not getting into a job at the time expected. My marriage was in trouble as a result of the stress I was under during that time. DH has his own business and was stressed about work and bringing new business in to pay our bills and the bills of 30 other people.

You need to have a think about other peoples situations before you claim it's so easy for classes to be sent home and how it's only about education. Not everyone is a SAHM or has a flexible job where they can fit it around home schooling. Not everyone has paid furlong or continued to be paid during lockdown. I have my own business too and if I don't work I don't get paid. I instantly lost my income. So no- sorry, I don't agree with classes being sent home on the tiny possibility of long COVID or the tiny minority who have a vulnerable person in their family.

jackstini · 19/10/2021 09:28

You can't continue to close classes or school's for healthy children

Unfortunately this is it now, Covid is not going away

Speaking as someone who is recovering from Covid along with DH -we caught from dd who got it at school

I do think all school staff should be entitled to the booster jab though

Hyly68 · 19/10/2021 09:27

It’s tricky getting the right balance, lessening exposure to teachers but also preventing further disruption to children’s education. There is 50 students off in my sons year (secondary school). Two students who travelled on the bus yesterday have tested positive too and he said many of the students have coughs who are at school. I really don’t know what the right answer is but there’s also factoring in parents being able to take more time off work to home school for the remainder of the school term, although not many days I know. My sons school year are already behind on GCSE prep and the teachers are having to play catch up from the previous year. My son is wearing a mask to school again now, even though it’s not required and he has hand sanitiser to use throughout the day.

gingercatsparky · 19/10/2021 09:22

@ElizaDarcysDeeds

I'd be fully supportive of you closing the class. We had similar levels in DD's year and spoke to the HT about it. The HT wanted to close the class but felt her hands were tied by government advice and parents who Hmm think they can get herd immunity if their DCs get infected despite there being no research to support that position and who don't give a stuff about families with vulnerable members who can't be vaccinated. The fallacy that 50% of a class being off with Covid doesn't disrupt education is so nonsensical, I don't know where to start. In our school, everyone's education has been impacted much more by DCs getting Covid and others having to get PCRs than it was by the lockdowns. It's also wreaking havoc on the DCs' MH so the people who pretend this is about protecting DCs' MH obviously haven't spoken to any DCs or HTs or anyone involved with DCs' MH. However since there are rumblings about another lockdown expect to be inundated with UsForThem-ers pretending they represent parents when their numbers prove they very much don't.
I care about families with vulnerable people in them, I am one. But we can't continue to shut down for those minority every time there is a break out. We have done this, we now need to look after the majority.

When my dcs had it we simple stayed away from the vulnerable person for 10 days. Not too complicated really. Although I appreciate some people can't. But 30 dcs education and 30 families can't continuously be disrupted for a what if for a few vulnerable people who are extremely unlikely to have lasting effects once double jabbed.

BeardyButton · 19/10/2021 09:21

@gingercatsparky

We had 3/4 of my ds class off with COVID at one point and they didn't send the class home. I was perfectly happy sending my son in but knew it was a matter of when not if he was going to catch COVID. However, some of the kids didn't catch it. I didn't want him to take any more time off school than he needed- we did end up home schooling for a week. When would you let them come back anyway? If that many of them are getting it if you did 10 days after the last one got it they could be off for weeks. They have missed enough school as it is.
Ya.... it’s about education. Suuuuuure. You are sending your kid into a Petri dish. Playing Russian roulette with long Covid. Because you want to make sure he doesn’t miss out on two weeks of abc s or algebra. Suuuuure!
BeardyButton · 19/10/2021 09:19

I look at threads like this.... threads where facts are wheeled out to justify positions, with little or no reflection or understanding. Like the New Zealand example used to show that “they got it wrong too”, when as mentioned above they have minimal deaths and impact of Covid compared to UK. And I think.... are the posters really this hard of thinking or do they know exactly what they are doing and just going for obfuscation as an argumentative ploy?! Genuinely don’t know the answer.

There is stupidity and there is pretending stupidity in order to get what you want. Either way - the virus doesn’t listen and doesn’t care. At the rate the UK is going, you are looking at social chaos in a few months (I’d say January).

2Two · 19/10/2021 09:18

Exactly. That'why we cant close schools. Yet that poster blames the school for covid and seems to think it should have closed. So find. If she is happy to have her kids at home and do the teaching herself, then she could. No one is stopping parents who want their kids at home from doing just that and homeschooling them.

No, that isn't the case. There is a massive and very obvious difference between homeschooling for a week or so because your child's class has closed and saying that parents must homeschool permanently if they need to minimise the risk of covid. What is stopping parents from keeping their children at home long term is, self-evidently, economic imperatives. Losing your pay for a week is just not comparable.

gingercatsparky · 19/10/2021 09:16

We had 3/4 of my ds class off with COVID at one point and they didn't send the class home. I was perfectly happy sending my son in but knew it was a matter of when not if he was going to catch COVID. However, some of the kids didn't catch it. I didn't want him to take any more time off school than he needed- we did end up home schooling for a week. When would you let them come back anyway? If that many of them are getting it if you did 10 days after the last one got it they could be off for weeks. They have missed enough school as it is.

ElizaDarcysDeeds · 19/10/2021 09:14

I'd be fully supportive of you closing the class. We had similar levels in DD's year and spoke to the HT about it.
The HT wanted to close the class but felt her hands were tied by government advice and parents who Hmm think they can get herd immunity if their DCs get infected despite there being no research to support that position and who don't give a stuff about families with vulnerable members who can't be vaccinated.
The fallacy that 50% of a class being off with Covid doesn't disrupt education is so nonsensical, I don't know where to start. In our school, everyone's education has been impacted much more by DCs getting Covid and others having to get PCRs than it was by the lockdowns.
It's also wreaking havoc on the DCs' MH so the people who pretend this is about protecting DCs' MH obviously haven't spoken to any DCs or HTs or anyone involved with DCs' MH.
However since there are rumblings about another lockdown expect to be inundated with UsForThem-ers pretending they represent parents when their numbers prove they very much don't.

christinarossetti19 · 19/10/2021 09:10

Something similar has happened at a school near me Jenster03 and the local authority won't let them close.

5 out of 6 of the Early Years staff were off at one point and they still weren't allowed to close.

I completely agree with you that a few days of remote learning would be the most sensible thing, but the government has pushed it's laughable 'schools are safe' mantra throughout and they're not going to change now.

I hope that you don't get sick, and that the next few days go by smoothly and quickly.

theemperorhasnoclothes · 19/10/2021 09:10

Oh and hospitals ARE close to breaking point. With some people waiting insane amounts of time both for and in ambulances. Do the people saying 'back to normal' not read the news? Better hope you don't need an ambulance any time soon.

www.independent.co.uk/news/health/nhs-emergency-waiting-preston-ipswich-b1940158.html

rrhuth · 19/10/2021 09:09

@theemperorhasnoclothes

Also, what we're doing is actively increasing our disabled population at a fast rate. The number of people who are double jabbed who still haven't recovered after a few months is high.

As well as being morally bankrupt, it doesn't even make economic sense. Unless you're a disaster capitalist.

Please don't bring facts and economic reality into it....
theemperorhasnoclothes · 19/10/2021 09:06

Also, what we're doing is actively increasing our disabled population at a fast rate. The number of people who are double jabbed who still haven't recovered after a few months is high.

As well as being morally bankrupt, it doesn't even make economic sense. Unless you're a disaster capitalist.

TimeForLunch · 19/10/2021 09:06

The same thing happened in my DC's primary class. Half of the class came down with it within the first two or three weeks back. All back now and it seems to have stopped. No point closing down the class, the ones that didn't get it and were susceptible to getting it would only catch it when they went back! These half measures that PPs mention are simply delaying the inevitable. There would only be a point to that if the local hospitals could not cope. And anyway, in our case, none of the children had much more than a runny nose and parents/staff did not catch it.

middleager · 19/10/2021 09:05

I'm double jabbed and caught it off my child from school.

2Two · 19/10/2021 09:05

Australia and New Zealand come to mind. They had all kinds of draconian rules, and they still couldn't make it work

Those really don't illustrate your point, @PurpleOkapi. Australia has had 5691 cases per million population, New Zealand 1030. Compare that with our 125K per million, and you can't claim that their practices don't work.

But currently the better comparator is Europe, where sensible precautions are keeping their figures under control whereas ours keep rising.