Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this class should be closed?

668 replies

Jenster03 · 18/10/2021 23:11

I'm a part time primary teacher and in the space of two weeks, 14 children have tested positive out of 30 in my class.
We've had 2 or 3 return in that time, but more and more are testing positive. Now my teaching assistant has it.
AIBU to think we should be sending the class home and remote learning? How would you feel if you were a parent of a child in my class?
Oh, and I'm pretty anxious about my level of exposure too!

OP posts:
Iggly · 19/10/2021 10:38

Humans are terrible at assessing risk. Always have been

That’s why we are one of the most successful species on the planet 🤨

Humans rely on instinct, and it shouldn’t be ignored. Relying on “numbers and probability” is itself a foolish thing to do. We are human and our emotions play a key part in who we are.

TheKeatingFive · 19/10/2021 10:36

Bad analogy. We ve spent at least 100 years crafting policy to promote road safety. And we are still looking to REDUCE these deaths. I would bring my kid to a motor way and open the door.

It's not at a bad analogy at all. Despite safety precautions, children and indeed probably any healthy adult, double vaxxed under 65 is almost certainly at more risk from death or serious outcomes from a RTA than covid.

Humans are terrible at assessing risk. Always have been.

Rosebel · 19/10/2021 10:33

@StripyHorse

I am so angry at the way children have been screwed over.

2 years of face to face education disrupted to protect us.

Now, adults have had the chance to be vaccinated so many couldn't give a crap about children. You only need to look around and see who can't be arsed to wear a mask or is spouting 'vulnerable people are protected we need to get on with life'.

For the sake of children, school workers and their families..

  • masks, isolation of contacts (especially household contacts) and switching to home learning for classes if cases rise to high should remain in place. At least until after that age group is vaccinated.
  • additional measures such as investment in ventilation should have happened before now. I know of a school with a top spec system (new build) they don't have this problem of in class transmission.
  • Schools shouldn't be prevented from reintroducing bubbles / home learning etc. to keep their population safe.

The policy seems to be to 'take it all in one hit' and get children infected as quickly as possible before winter and fuck anyone who is hospitalised, suffers long covid or looses relatives because of it.

Your post doesn't make sense. You are angry because children have had their education disrupted for 2 years but you would be happy for school to close again and classes to be online. I don't wear a mask anymore because I can't breathe properly with them on. I'm actually except but struggled on last time. It's not all about being selfish. I want my children to get a decent education not be stuck at home struggling to study, especially as I also have a toddler. It's harsh but we've got to try and live normally now
Hyly68 · 19/10/2021 10:30

@StripyHorse

I am so angry at the way children have been screwed over.

2 years of face to face education disrupted to protect us.

Now, adults have had the chance to be vaccinated so many couldn't give a crap about children. You only need to look around and see who can't be arsed to wear a mask or is spouting 'vulnerable people are protected we need to get on with life'.

For the sake of children, school workers and their families..

  • masks, isolation of contacts (especially household contacts) and switching to home learning for classes if cases rise to high should remain in place. At least until after that age group is vaccinated.
  • additional measures such as investment in ventilation should have happened before now. I know of a school with a top spec system (new build) they don't have this problem of in class transmission.
  • Schools shouldn't be prevented from reintroducing bubbles / home learning etc. to keep their population safe.

The policy seems to be to 'take it all in one hit' and get children infected as quickly as possible before winter and fuck anyone who is hospitalised, suffers long covid or looses relatives because of it.

switching to home learning for classes if cases rise to high should remain in place. At least until after that age group is vaccinated.

Are you happy to pay everyone’s mortgage and bills whilst the parents take time off work to educate their children, until their age group get vaccinated and what about the parents who don’t agree to their young children receiving an experimental vaccine?

BeardyButton · 19/10/2021 10:29

@gingercatsparky

Ps- you play Russian roulette every time you leave the house, every time you get in a car or cross a road. You are more likely to get hit by a car than you are to get long COVID. Yet everyone still takes their children to school as that what it is so tiny. I will take my changes yes with long COVID as I won't put my life on hold for a very tiny, tiny chance.
Bad analogy. We ve spent at least 100 years crafting policy to promote road safety. And we are still looking to REDUCE these deaths. I would bring my kid to a motor way and open the door. I wouldn’t actively increase my risk of having an accident if I knew conditions were icy. If I lived on a hill, and was snowed in, I d keep my kid off school.

The numbers aren’t tiny tiny for long Covid. The numbers of DEATHS aren’t negligible but are extremely low for children. Inform yourself. At the very least. Know the risk you are taking. And know the risk you are contributing to for others.

berlinbabylon · 19/10/2021 10:27

Now, adults have had the chance to be vaccinated so many couldn't give a crap about children. You only need to look around and see who can't be arsed to wear a mask or is spouting 'vulnerable people are protected we need to get on with life

Yes I am quite judgey about elderly people not wearing masks in shops. We locked down to protect them and now they won't even wear masks (and no, they're not all exempt by a very long way - the word "selfish" is massively overused in relation to covid, but they are being selfish).

I went to London yesterday and was very surprised by the low numbers of people not wearing masks on the trains. I have now ordered some FFP2 masks.

However, I think the risk of no education is higher than the risk of covid for most children and schools should be kept open (and it is about EDUCATION, not childcare!!!!). Staff have now been vaccinated (if they want to be). However, simple precautions should be reinstated like opening windows and letting the kids wear coats to keep warm.

Even if it were about childcare, people need to work to eat and keep a roof over their heads.

Covidsucks · 19/10/2021 10:26

@toooldforthis321 yes you are 100% right I changed my mind when it happened to me and I'm happy to take the criticism thrown my way for it.

I am sorry to hear of your recovery, honestly I didn't realise just how much this virus has devastated people in so many ways.

BeardyButton · 19/10/2021 10:18

@StripyHorse

I am so angry at the way children have been screwed over.

2 years of face to face education disrupted to protect us.

Now, adults have had the chance to be vaccinated so many couldn't give a crap about children. You only need to look around and see who can't be arsed to wear a mask or is spouting 'vulnerable people are protected we need to get on with life'.

For the sake of children, school workers and their families..

  • masks, isolation of contacts (especially household contacts) and switching to home learning for classes if cases rise to high should remain in place. At least until after that age group is vaccinated.
  • additional measures such as investment in ventilation should have happened before now. I know of a school with a top spec system (new build) they don't have this problem of in class transmission.
  • Schools shouldn't be prevented from reintroducing bubbles / home learning etc. to keep their population safe.

The policy seems to be to 'take it all in one hit' and get children infected as quickly as possible before winter and fuck anyone who is hospitalised, suffers long covid or looses relatives because of it.

It’s awful. But boris is jst playing to the masses, as evidenced by this thread. Those of us who actually read to inform (as opposed to collect random facts to use out of context and incorrectly to justify selfishness) are hysterical and should jst sacrifice the health of kids so people can have childcare.
BeardyButton · 19/10/2021 10:15

And I can promise you... my marriage and mental health has suffered. My kid is currently off school. I don’t think it’s Covid. But he had a test this morning. He won’t return until he is healthy and neg result. I believe that is the right approach. I would never knowingly subject others to contracting a terrible disease by sending my child in potentially Covid pos. I would never knowingly subject him to contracting it by sending him to a place I know is rampant with it. I think that is morally wrong, whatever the Tories say about it. And I believe that in any healthy society, the majority should behave in a way that does not mortally endanger the minority. However hard that is.

Lightswitch123 · 19/10/2021 10:13

@ImUninsultable

My business shut down because of lock down. I lost earnings for a year and a half. I didnt qualify for any if the supprort grants, like thousands of others. But I guess that doesnt matter to all the hysterics who want to keep everything closed and sit in their houses just wishing the virus will go away.

It wont. This is life. We take sensible precautions. We get vaccinated. We get boosters. We take LF tests twice a week. We wash our hands regularly. We stop touching our faces all the time. We maintain social distancing and masks.

But we dont start closing things up again because it changes nothing. We end up right back here again, over and over. This is life now. Get used to it.

Exactly. Covid 19 can join the ranks of the other seasonal viruses which most people don't notice they have / have a mild illness. Some people sadly become more unwell. But we have a vaccine. 2e don't lock down for flu. We shouldn't lock down for covid again. If you really cared about population health obesity, cars, smoking and alcohol would be far greater priorities to tackle than respiratory viruses.

Some people just seem to love obsessing about covid. The wood for the trees.... Move on!

StripyHorse · 19/10/2021 10:11

I am so angry at the way children have been screwed over.

2 years of face to face education disrupted to protect us.

Now, adults have had the chance to be vaccinated so many couldn't give a crap about children. You only need to look around and see who can't be arsed to wear a mask or is spouting 'vulnerable people are protected we need to get on with life'.

For the sake of children, school workers and their families..

  • masks, isolation of contacts (especially household contacts) and switching to home learning for classes if cases rise to high should remain in place. At least until after that age group is vaccinated.
  • additional measures such as investment in ventilation should have happened before now. I know of a school with a top spec system (new build) they don't have this problem of in class transmission.
  • Schools shouldn't be prevented from reintroducing bubbles / home learning etc. to keep their population safe.

The policy seems to be to 'take it all in one hit' and get children infected as quickly as possible before winter and fuck anyone who is hospitalised, suffers long covid or looses relatives because of it.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 19/10/2021 10:11

The press seem agitated today about the complacency of Boris. Including overseas press. And the Express is going mad😁

I think some restrictions will return soon

BedisBliss · 19/10/2021 10:10

I'm a secondary school teacher. The autumn term has been awful - so much disruption due to PCR testing and Covid cases amongst pupils. It's been really difficult but we can't close schools again. The younger pupils have been severely damaged by lockdown - educationally they are behind where they should be, mental health issues are greater than ever and many are lacking basic social skills. Children need to be at school and as a 50+ teacher, with vulnerable parents I need to just get on with my job, like so many others.

BeardyButton · 19/10/2021 10:09

I bought hepa filters for my kids school. Went into debt to do it.

BeardyButton · 19/10/2021 10:08

@gingercatsparky

We are going to have to agree to disagree. I don't think it's the right thing to do anymore. That's not a fact I need to not face and my morals are very much in check thanks. We don't lock down for other illnesses such a flu which causes many deaths each year. The real fact is the welfare of the majority now needs to come before the welfare of the minority. Those minority now need to put into place their own protections how they see fit.
I am not trying to convince you of anything. Just to point out that the facts you use don’t justify your position. As I said, you are lucky that the Tories are aligned with your take on survival of the fittest. So you are well within your legal and political rights to crack on. Doesn’t make it the right thing to do.

Risk profile wise, Covid is more like polio and measles than flu. I’d go hungry before I willingly let my kid contract measles or polio.

toomuchlaundry · 19/10/2021 10:07

@motherrunner I don’t know of any schools that have received their monitors either.

For the poster saying the percentage of children getting Long Covid is small, it might be but if we are working on the basis that all children will get COVID that is quite a high number of children with long term health implications

gingercatsparky · 19/10/2021 09:59

[quote Hyly68]@BeardyButton

When you lost your job, how did you pay your bills?

It may result in the loss of a job. Again, that doesn’t mean it isn’t the right thing to do.

Then how do you provide food and a home for your children, if you lose your job?
What about single parents who only rely on one income?[/quote]
Yes- I think my Dcs home life will be much more greatly affected by loosing our house, my MH or ds MH (he now sees a therapist we were so worried about him) deteriorating, divorce and the fact I now have to work evenings/weekends and put them in after school clubs to make up the hours I have missed studying than staying in school where there are is a high number of covid cases because they may get long COVID. The risks are not comparable.

FindingMeno · 19/10/2021 09:55

To my mind this is clearly a deliberate ploy to gain at least short lived immunity in children prior to flu taking hold this year.
Rightly or wrongly.
Nothing the individual says or does will change this trajectory as its policy, innit?
We just need to crack on and get through this best we can, and make our thoughts known next General Election.
I'm tired of feeling angry all the time.

motherrunner · 19/10/2021 09:52

*put

motherrunner · 19/10/2021 09:51

@gingercatsparky

We are going to have to agree to disagree. I don't think it's the right thing to do anymore. That's not a fact I need to not face and my morals are very much in check thanks. We don't lock down for other illnesses such a flu which causes many deaths each year. The real fact is the welfare of the majority now needs to come before the welfare of the minority. Those minority now need to put into place their own protections how they see fit.
But what about if the ‘minority’ can’t out in place their protections @gingercatsparky? See my above comment re CO2 monitors. The Government said they would help to protect school communities by providing these when all other mitigations were dropped. I know of not one school who has received them.
Hyly68 · 19/10/2021 09:51

@BeardyButton

When you lost your job, how did you pay your bills?

It may result in the loss of a job. Again, that doesn’t mean it isn’t the right thing to do.

Then how do you provide food and a home for your children, if you lose your job?
What about single parents who only rely on one income?

TheGonnagle · 19/10/2021 09:51

I don’t think there’s any right answer here. I was shielded throughout the period when it was recommended, I’ve had my three primary doses because I’m a very high risk case. But I work in schools with kids playing musical instruments blowing Covid particles merrily around me and have an as yet unvaccinated child.
I know that the risk is high for me, but I also know that my child and my students NEED to be back at school. And I also know that from a realistic point of view the needs of the many (students and child) outweigh the needs of the few (me). And we’re really not in a position where I can give up work!
So life goes on. Fingers crossed…

gingercatsparky · 19/10/2021 09:47

We are going to have to agree to disagree. I don't think it's the right thing to do anymore. That's not a fact I need to not face and my morals are very much in check thanks. We don't lock down for other illnesses such a flu which causes many deaths each year. The real fact is the welfare of the majority now needs to come before the welfare of the minority. Those minority now need to put into place their own protections how they see fit.

Frazzled2207 · 19/10/2021 09:46

It's far from an ideal scenario but if you close the class now are you going to close it again next time someone is ill? And again after that?
It's a worrying state of affairs but given the government's total inaction the best we can hope for is that we all the children get it and get it out of the way asap. At least adults have some protection through vaccination.

Toooldforthis321 · 19/10/2021 09:46

@Covidsucks so basically, you changed your mind once it happened to you.
Your username is right, it does suck. 18 months in and I still have a leg that doesn't function properly, and even worse lungs than I had before.
Teachers were made to feel bad during lockdown, so I'll suspend my sympathy for people moaning about actually looking after their own kids.
I hope you have a speedier recovery than I am having.