Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this class should be closed?

668 replies

Jenster03 · 18/10/2021 23:11

I'm a part time primary teacher and in the space of two weeks, 14 children have tested positive out of 30 in my class.
We've had 2 or 3 return in that time, but more and more are testing positive. Now my teaching assistant has it.
AIBU to think we should be sending the class home and remote learning? How would you feel if you were a parent of a child in my class?
Oh, and I'm pretty anxious about my level of exposure too!

OP posts:
Hyly68 · 19/10/2021 14:08

@BeardyButton What is your answer to the current high levels of Covid at schools?
Do you want to see schools closed again?

Do you think it’s fair doctors are treating sick patients (being exposed to Covid) and going home to their families?

gingercatsparky · 19/10/2021 14:05

The virus was running rampant in my dcs school. That's why I commented. I didn't say the mitigations would solve the problem I stated that saying their are not mitigations is simply not true. This is an outline of the mitigations my dcs school put in place during this time.

Yes- I find it frustrating that still parents are not allowed to watch key school events. I understand why but this is more mitigations put in place.

gingercatsparky · 19/10/2021 14:05

The virus was running rampant in my dcs school. That's why I commented. I didn't say the mitigations would solve the problem I stated that saying their are not mitigations is simply not true. This is an outline of the mitigations my dcs school put in place during this time.

Yes- I find it frustrating that still parents are not allowed to watch key school events. I understand why but this is more mitigations put in place.

BeardyButton · 19/10/2021 13:57

@gingercatsparky

There are mitigations in my dcs school. When the cases rose they went back to some regulations from before in terms of picking up and dropping off. Sporting events against other schools were postponed as were activities which involved mixing lots of year groups. Now children are being tested and have to contact the school with results, track and trace contact people, hand washing and windows open. Events where parents might come and watch annoyingly have also been stopped.

It is not true there are no mitigations.

Washing hands won’t do much for an airborne virus. This thread is about a school where the virus is running rampant. Highly unlikely that school has adequate mitigations. Almost by definition really.

Also, if your school has hepa filters then you ll be among the vast minority of schools in UK. Other countries in Europe did provide these. Part of the explanation why UKs numbers are so hideous.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 19/10/2021 13:51

No idea. Maybe little reception kids, but not teens.

BeardyButton · 19/10/2021 13:51

Yes! So odd.... to argue agn sending children into schools with rampant Covid and no mitigations. Strange indeed!

We had our chance to make schools safe. We could have

Controlled community transmission (not had freedom Friday or whatever Boris called it)

Reviewed ventilation in schools

Provided hepa filters

Provided CO2 monitors

Provided for antigen testing

Ramped up test and trace

Contacted close contacts

Isolated close contacts

None of that was done. Statistically Covid is likely to be mild in chn relative to adults. Most cases won’t result in hospitalisation. Some will. Vast man of chn won’t die. Some will. 7 percent roughly will suffer w long Covid. We are still grappling with what that will mean. Risk profile looks more like polio or measles than flu.

What odd thinking, to send a child into a Petri dish with NO adequate mitigations in place. How ODD to actively participate in the spread of Covid amongst children.

SheikhMaraca · 19/10/2021 13:40

@BeardyButton

www.google.ie/amp/s/www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/virginia-child-covid-death-schools-b1932393.html%3famp

Just putting this here. The story of a mother’s rage at selfish parents after her child died of COVID. But it’s ok, right, as statistically it’s rare? So, although some children will die, it’s highly unlikely to be YOUR child. That makes it ok. For You! That is the definition of selfish.

This is the risk we all take every day though.

The idea that it is possible to live life without risk is frankly bizarre.

There is a chance that any one of us will die from a random event, we need to become more comfortable with this idea, not bring the whole of society to its knees in an attempt to prevent it.

What odd thinking some people have.

ThirdElephant · 19/10/2021 13:14

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow

They can close for Norovirus.
Isn't norovirus more dangerous to children than COVID is?
ThirdElephant · 19/10/2021 13:14

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow

They can close for Norovirus.
Isn't norovirus more dangerous to children than COVID is?
gingercatsparky · 19/10/2021 13:11

There are mitigations in my dcs school. When the cases rose they went back to some regulations from before in terms of picking up and dropping off. Sporting events against other schools were postponed as were activities which involved mixing lots of year groups. Now children are being tested and have to contact the school with results, track and trace contact people, hand washing and windows open. Events where parents might come and watch annoyingly have also been stopped.

It is not true there are no mitigations.

gingercatsparky · 19/10/2021 13:11

There are mitigations in my dcs school. When the cases rose they went back to some regulations from before in terms of picking up and dropping off. Sporting events against other schools were postponed as were activities which involved mixing lots of year groups. Now children are being tested and have to contact the school with results, track and trace contact people, hand washing and windows open. Events where parents might come and watch annoyingly have also been stopped.

It is not true there are no mitigations.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 19/10/2021 12:14

They can close for Norovirus.

Lightswitch123 · 19/10/2021 12:09

@Wondergirl100

It's not 'never ending' - it's a virus ciruclating as bugs do every winter. There is no zero covid - it's a fantasy. We don't close schools every winter when flu knocks out whole classes - which I remember very well happening pre covid - I remember a virus knocking out the teacher and half the kids one winter in my sons school.

nobody talked about closing down the rest of the class.

In Australia and NZ they are now accepting they will have covid ciruclating just as we do here once they open up. The vaccine does not stop people passing it on - it stops people ending up in hospital. There is no eradication we have to live with it.

Exactly. Do we close schools for cases of D&V? Flu? RSV?

I wish people would just stop worshipping at the covid altar.

It's so boring.

Get a new hobby

TheKeatingFive · 19/10/2021 11:56

There are NO mitigations in UK schools. Therefore the analogies don’t work!!!

That doesn't mean the analogies don't work.

The risk to children from Covid is very small. Everyday greater risks are run with no thought given to them. I see an RTA as much more likely to result in poor outcomes for my children than covid (and that stands even with minor mitigations in place on the roads and none for Covid).

When it comes to covid mitigations in schools it's like everything else, about weighing up costs and benefits. The costs of disruption to education and its knock on for everything else are very significant for a disease likely to impact children only very minimally.

BeardyButton · 19/10/2021 11:48

@TheKeatingFive

Ya! I wouldn’t bring my kid to a school I know has meningitis either.

Well no, because the outcomes are significantly more serious than covid. That's my point.

The difference is in the reflection on safety. There are NO mitigations in UK schools. Therefore the analogies don’t work!!!

You are right that humans are bad at risk. Esp when there is a risk to others and a benefit to selves. That’s what government is for - to balance the incentives. I can see you understand this and jst obfuscating for own ends. I wouldn’t send my kid to a polio party either.

toomuchlaundry · 19/10/2021 11:45

@gingercatsparky a lot of people complain about mitigation in schools eg masks.

I have known schools close for a few days when norovirus has taken hold and they want to do a deep clean and also hopefully break the cycle.

TheKeatingFive · 19/10/2021 11:31

Ya! I wouldn’t bring my kid to a school I know has meningitis either.

Well no, because the outcomes are significantly more serious than covid. That's my point.

gingercatsparky · 19/10/2021 11:31

www.google.co.uk/amp/s/www.imperial.ac.uk/news/224853/over-million-adults-england-have-long/amp/

This article says 6% had what is classed as long COVID symptoms. So that is a tiny minority in my book, maybe not yours. So what 80-90% of the population who would be affected by classes being sent home because of 6%?

Plus- the road safety analogy is valid. We have spent millions trying to reduce the risk of covid and there aren't no measures. My dcs school have put measures in place from advice from the Health authorities once cases began to rise, we have tests, Windows are left often, hands are washed, track and trace are still contacting people and giving advice to schools. These may not be the preventions you believe in or want but it is incorrect that there are no preventions.

Yes- I would much rather have clubs, pubs, concerts closed before they close schools. How can anyone justify these being open and classes being sent home?

GinPin2 · 19/10/2021 11:31

My grandson attends a rural school - 60 pupils - 3 classes- 4-11 age range.
He took Covid home to parents and 2 sisters. He is 8 and has asthma, got covid badly. Sisters 10 and 6 ( in different schools ) both quite poorly. Mum and Dad - just like a bad cold.
About 2/3rd of the school had it at any one time,
County would not let the Head close the school and then relented by which time most children had had it and then the school was closed for 3 days to deep clean and all children to test.
This did mean that that those children who had been off still had to have further days off.
I feel for the staff in that kind of situation where masks are not worn by the age group spreading Covid.

BeardyButton · 19/10/2021 11:30

@TheKeatingFive

And we are still compiling evidence of long Covid outcomes. Doesn’t look great either.

The data on long covid is a shit show. Until that's sorted out, it's impossible to say.

They compare to measles and polio..... not great I’d say!

How about compared to meningitis, childhood cancers, RSV, pneumonia, RTAs, accidents, etc, etc?

Ya! I wouldn’t bring my kid to a school I know has meningitis either. But thx for making my point for me!!!!!
dogrilla · 19/10/2021 11:28

It's rife around us now and most kids I know have had it over the past month. None have been ill for more than 2 or 3 days. Double vaccinated adults similarly OK. I have it at the moment (day 3) and if it wasn't for Covid isolation protocols I would go for a run as just feel like I have a mild cold. I know it's not the same for everyone but it's more the pain-in-the-arse factor than life-threatening illness now. Have cancelled a half term holiday and son has missed a milestone event but am almost relieved we've finally got it and can get it out of the way.

TheKeatingFive · 19/10/2021 11:27

And we are still compiling evidence of long Covid outcomes. Doesn’t look great either.

The data on long covid is a shit show. Until that's sorted out, it's impossible to say.

They compare to measles and polio..... not great I’d say!

How about compared to meningitis, childhood cancers, RSV, pneumonia, RTAs, accidents, etc, etc?

BeardyButton · 19/10/2021 11:24

And we are still compiling evidence of long Covid outcomes. Doesn’t look great either.

BeardyButton · 19/10/2021 11:24

@TheKeatingFive

Just because we accept a certain level of risk in one area (where we have worked very hard to lower that risk) doesn’t mean we should accept risk of very poor outcomes in another area where we have done nothing to lower that risk.

But outcomes for Covid aren't 'very poor' for children compared to the other diseases or causes of injury/death that are out there.

They aren’t very poor compared to adult outcomes Covid. They compare to measles and polio..... not great I’d say!
Herewegoagain84 · 19/10/2021 11:19

No - in our school they’ll only close the class when there are 5 cases as that is deemed a mini outbreak and must be reported to DofH.