Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Bullying or friendship issues

54 replies

ShepherdMoons · 18/10/2021 22:51

I've posted in the past about my dd (8) who is I'm a very small class of 10. There were four girls and five boys until another girl joined the class last term. Since then it seems to have come to a head more.

Dd has been recently been bullied by a boy in the year below (this is now resolved). It really affected her though and she really wants to play with her bestie and the new girl. Dds bestie now is close friends with the new girl, they so a lot of extra curricular activities together (I only found out about this last week).

Today dds bestie told dd she had to play on the other side of the playground away from her friends today. They shout at dd to get away if she comes close.

Is this just friendship problems or bullying? The class teacher is off sick long term at the moment but I feel that this problem is getting worse. Dd is anxious at night and didn't get much sleep last night.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TwinsandTrifle · 20/10/2021 21:19

Yes, I did, and fwiw I think is the best route for you and DD.

I was addressing the poster who was being rather sanctimonious, with the my DD would ensure everyone was included, and would be frightfully horrified if her DD didn't behave this way.

Congratulations on your excellent 8yr old who definitely behaves like that, on every occasion. And thank you for letting us know how great your child is, who neither attends OPs school, or helps OP in any shape or form as it's not what's happening here in the real world, and we're looking for an actual solution...

I'm glad you've found one. Good luck with the move OP Flowers

ShepherdMoons · 20/10/2021 18:15

@TwinsandTrifle have you read my previous post?! We are moving dd to a bigger school. The issue is the pool of friends - way too small!! Thank you!

OP posts:
TwinsandTrifle · 20/10/2021 17:45

@Coronawireless

Personally, by “good social skills” I mean that she makes friends easily AND will invite a child on their own to join in a game, even if she has nothing in common with them. The first is something she was luckily born with. The second is something everyone could do if they bothered.
I completely agree. But this is a little short sighted.

Inviting someone who isn't a friend/you would not choose to play with, to join your game, a couple of times is fine. That's not an answer. It means DD is included a couple of times, because a child is doing the "right thing" as opposed to being allowed to play how they prefer. That's a couple of times. Not a solution.

After the 5th lunch time of "you have to include this child" if you think any 8yr old isn't going to be getting fed up at their free time being dictated by someone they wouldn't choose to play with, then you are somewhat naive.

Is it then better for Peter to hear "Pleeeease, can it be someone else's turn to play with Peter"..."I've had to play with Peter all week"

What will it do to Peter's self esteem to hear that? I maintain that these girls are not excluding DD because she only wants to play with 2 girls out of so many other children. She doesn't like how the boys play? Well ok. She's cut out 5 of her options there. But if she's allowed to choose not to play with them, others have the right to choose that too. By personally ruling out others, it doesn't mean that the only 2 left are excluding. It means you only want to play with two people. And life is not always getting what we want.

Coronawireless · 20/10/2021 17:25

Personally, by “good social skills” I mean that she makes friends easily AND will invite a child on their own to join in a game, even if she has nothing in common with them. The first is something she was luckily born with. The second is something everyone could do if they bothered.

TwinsandTrifle · 20/10/2021 17:12

@maddening

And parents that say "it doesn't matter if Peter is on his own, it is OK to leave him out" are doing everyone a disservice.
It's not ok to leave Peter out for unkind reason.

We're practicing something we learned last night. Isn't unkind.

5zeds · 20/10/2021 16:51

I’m not sure what you think good social skills are if the difficulties are all social?Confused

Coronawireless · 20/10/2021 16:34

It worked well for us OP. My DD has good social skills too. Good luck!

ShepherdMoons · 20/10/2021 16:03

thank you for your advice. I'd just like to correct any misgivings about dd's social skills. She has good friends outside of school, the girl she regarded as her 'bestie' was a very good friend (a reciprocal friendship not dd following her round as has been proposed on here) and I think the upset here is genuinely because dd was previously always included and now is not. I would definitely not describe dd as 'socially awkward' at all!!! It's a small pool of friends as many have pointed out.

There is a good community school not far from us that has places so we are going to meet the headteacher with a view to move dd after half term. There are other benefits to a larger school, hopefully this will have more clubs, activities, facilities than the one she is currently in.

OP posts:
XelaM · 20/10/2021 15:26

It's horrible to exclude one child for whatever reason. And when my daughter was telling me how no one (including my daughter) wanted to play with one particular girl at her old primary, I always told her this was not ok and encouraged her to be kind to the girl (because how would she feel if it was done to her!)

It's terrible parenting to teach your kids not to care about other kids' feelings!

maddening · 20/10/2021 14:11

And parents that say "it doesn't matter if Peter is on his own, it is OK to leave him out" are doing everyone a disservice.

maddening · 20/10/2021 14:01

@TwinsandTrifle

If the boys are leaving Peter out the teachers should be helping the dc to learn how to negotiate play rather than leaving out 1 dc. Eg how to take turns so that all dc get a bit of a game they want inc the boys and Peter.

Being aware of people being left out and compromising to include others is a good social skill to have.

Given a bit of time and the chance to join in i am sure Peter would become a fun friend to play with too. He can't learn being left out and lonely on the side lines. So all dc learn good social skills and possibly benefit from a friendship initially discarded due to social awkwardness.

ShepherdMoons · 20/10/2021 13:40

@TwinsandTrifle I really think you have completely misunderstood this situation

Thank you to the other posters who have given such kind advice. I called the local authority this morning and I have some schools to ring up thus afternoon.

OP posts:
TwinsandTrifle · 20/10/2021 13:03

not all paired off leaving one child constantly alone so that their school year is lonely and miserable.

There's 2 pairs. It's only all paired off because OP has put her DD in such a tiny school that two pairs means the whole group bar one girl. They were "all paired off" with the four of them previously.

It is absolutely NOT ok to exclude one particular child and parents who encourage that kind of behaviour are unbelievable

Lol at this projection.

The DD is "excluded" because one pair of people prefer to play in their pair. The DD hasn't ever played with the other two girls, so OP decides this "pairing" is fine. But the one girl DD has always relied on simply being there, has now found a good friend that she likes to see in and out of school. But this isn't ok with OP. It's exclusion bullying. Interesting that she's not complaining about the other pair of girls. Because her DD chooses not to play with them. But because another child has started, she posting about this girl stealing her daughter's bestie Hmm This is because OP has put her DD in a tiny school, and doesn't like that two children prefer each other to her DD, yet the other two girls in a pair are allowed to continue playing as they choose because they aren't DDs preference. The one that DD wants is a bully if she doesn't want to play with DD.

Parents who instill "if others won't play with you then they're bullies" are doing their children a far greater disservice than those who say "it's ok not to be everyone's cup of tea, play with someone else". It's none of the children's fault that the school is so tiny, there is no "someone else" in the selection that DD prefers to play with.

This is entirely different to a class of 30 all actively excluding 1 child. It's three children, and two get on better.

XelaM · 20/10/2021 12:37

OP - please ignore the horrible poster and try to move your daughter to a different school. My daughter had similar problems at her small (although slightly bigger) primary. It is absolutely NOT ok to exclude one particular child and parents who encourage that kind of behaviour are unbelievable

Coronawireless · 20/10/2021 12:14

But go ahead and wilfully misunderstand.

Coronawireless · 20/10/2021 12:13

No one’s expecting the girls to be best friends with the child. Just to have a class where everyone is kindly included during playtime hours, not all paired off leaving one child constantly alone so that their school year is lonely and miserable. Outside of school everyone can meet whom they like.
It’s not hard to understand, and many classes and groups do work this way. Unfortunately other groups have people like the pps in them.

TwinsandTrifle · 20/10/2021 12:02
Grin

Yes. You should obviously break up the natural friendship groups because of one child, who only has no one because she prefers to play within her tiny year group, and the other "lone girl" has now made another friend.

The world does not revolve around DD. OP is teaching her it does by insinuating that two girls forming natural pairs, and her DD not being one of those, is bullying. You can see her dislike of this "new girl" and how she "found out" that they were doing after school activities together from her OP. Literally it reads like she thinks this little girl is cheating on her daughter.

The two girls played together before, because they were the only two left over. It doesn't look like the other girl was naturally drawn to DD, given that another girl has only just started and they are immediately doing out of school stuff with her (presumably she never chose to with DD or OP would have let us know this).

I'm sorry if its hard reading OP, but it's a fact of life that people will prefer others over your DD. It doesn't make them bad, or wrong, there will be people who prefer your DD, she's just in such a tiny year group that because Alice likes Jane, and Susan likes Claire, that's everyone paired off.

And no, I won't teach my children that they must continually play with people they don't want too, because the other child wanting too has a greater right. They don't.

As long as my children are kind, they can choose their friends. "Why do we have to play with Peter? He always wants to play robots, it's loud and we don't like it, and no one else wants too"

"Oh but you must, or Peter won't have anyone to play with"

Actually. Peter needs to understand that, if no one else wants to be that loud, he can either a) be loud on his own, no one's stopping him, or b) he doesn't get to dictate how anyone else plays, so he can join the other children, playing tag (or whatever) because that's their choice.

Peter's rights do not trump anyone elses.

Imagine DD being told "you must play football at lunch"..... "But, I don't like football? I don't want to play football. I am not friends with the people that play football."....."yes but Peter wants too, so you must"

You wouldn't expect that of DD. Why do you expect it from other children?

Coronawireless · 20/10/2021 10:55

OP, it’s useful to have an insight into the mindset of these kinds of parents. They haven’t even read your posts.
There are two sets of best friends and a group of boys who play more physical games that this little girl is not interested in. She is unluckily left on her own and it sounds as if none of the other 4 girls (happily paired up) notice or care. I would be angry with my DD of this was happening in her small class and she was happy to leave a child to spend the days on her own day after day. Really not ok. But as I say - just read some of the above posts to see the type of homes these girls come from. If things don’t improve, I think you’d be right to move on and leave them to it. What an unkind group of people.

TwinsandTrifle · 20/10/2021 10:44

I really think you have got your facts wrong here. Dd was certainly not 'following' this boy around at all.

No, you've misread that. She's most likely following the two girls until they get so annoyed they shout. As you say this girl doing so is sweet and gives hugs etc. So it is very unlikely her reflex response is to shout at your DD. More likely she has asked nicely several times and your DD ignores this.

ShepherdMoons · 20/10/2021 10:41

FYI the incident with the boy was not just something that involved my dd. The boy attempted to strangle dd's friend and it resulted in the Head having to speak to him about it!!!

I really think you have got your facts wrong here. Dd was certainly not 'following' this boy around at all.

OP posts:
ShepherdMoons · 20/10/2021 10:33

Dd has never dismissed any other child at all! She would welcome another child to play with even in another year group. I said she would prefer to play with someone from her year group.

Yes I am ringing schools today to see if she can be moved.

OP posts:
TwinsandTrifle · 20/10/2021 10:24

Then maybe you need to move schools? If she's being slapped by one child, and refuses to play with all the children bar 2, who just want to play by themselves?

It doesn't sound like a fun time. And I think you need to be encouraging your daughter to accept she needs to play with other people, rather than being angry at an 8yr you've defined as her bestie, preferring to play with another girl. Apparently your DD can dismiss others as people she doesn't want to play with, but these two girls can't.

ShepherdMoons · 20/10/2021 10:18

Just a second! No that is not the case at all, dd was being physically slapped, hit and pushed by the other boy!!! I think what you are saying here is very unfair.

OP posts:
TwinsandTrifle · 20/10/2021 10:16

Well the above comment shows clearly the “I’m all right Jack” attitude of a certain type of parent that allows this playground unkindness.

You mean like OP, until this other 8yr old turned up and "ruined everything" for her DD.

No one has done anything wrong. DD doesn't want to play with anyone else, which OP thinks is fine. But these two girls don't want to play with DD and OP thinks the school need to address these "bullies". OP notes that she's already had to deal with another bully last month. Maybe so. Maybe a pattern is starting for anyone who doesn't do what DD wants and objects to her.

The school have already told the DD to play with other children. They haven't told the two girls to stop bullying.

Coronawireless · 20/10/2021 10:03

Well the above comment shows clearly the “I’m all right Jack” attitude of a certain type of parent that allows this playground unkindness.