Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Falsely accused of crime on FB

86 replies

falselyaccused · 18/10/2021 21:11

I've put this in legal too but posting here for traffic:

I was in a shopping centre on the weekend and had finished my shopping in a popular clothes shop. As I was exiting the store, the alarm sounded and I was asked by a security guard to stand aside and allow him to check my bags which I was happy to comply with. As expected, no stolen items were found in my bag and the security guard actually said the alarm might’ve gone off by mistake, or someone could’ve timed their exit with mine to increase their chances of getting away with theft. I though it was all okay until I got home and decided to check FB later in the day. Imagine my shock to find very clear photos of me having my bags searched by the security guard at the store which someone had taken. They accused me of theft and warned other people to stay away from me if they saw me in the street! The post had a gazillion replies of shock and people lamenting about how the area was going to the dogs, etc. I reported the post and it got taken down but I’ve had people who recognised me in the photos contacting me and asking wtf was going on?!

I’m livid and want to know if I can take legal action against this person for defamation of character/slander? I tried following their profile link but it doesn’t seem to exist anymore or I’ve been blocked from it.

Can anyone help?

OP posts:
2Two · 18/10/2021 23:17

You could sue, but it needs to be false (it is false) and there must be serious harm to your reputation (this is arguable as to the level of harm to your reputation)

When someone is falsely accused of a crime, it is automatically actionable, i.e. there is a presumption that it has caused serious damage without the claimant having to prove actual financial loss.

HalzTangz · 18/10/2021 23:14

I personally would make a pot explaining what happend so those that read it and see you know the other post was trash.

I think social media need to put a stop to all this naming and shaming, uploading photos of people in groups etc

slashlover · 18/10/2021 23:08

@2Two

What would the screenshot do? I have a screenshot of the original post.

You need it as evidence of the libel. Ideally you also need a screen shot showing the reaction to the post.

Who is OP going to sue? The account has disappeared and could easily have been a fake account.
imnotacelebritygetmeoutofhere · 18/10/2021 23:03

@Nanny0gg

Slander/defamation is a civil complaint. The police absolutely won't be interested.
I was interviewed by the police as a witness to this, they absolutely were interested. Worth a try OP.
Tommika · 18/10/2021 23:02

You could sue, but it needs to be false (it is false) and there must be serious harm to your reputation (this is arguable as to the level of harm to your reputation)

Defences include that the statement is true or it is their honest opinion.
It is true that you were stopped by security after the alarm being triggered, it can be the onlookers honest opinion that you had been shoplifting

Sueing for defamation is expensive, and though you were innocent of the allegations it’s not guaranteed that your case would succeed

www.carter-ruck.com/expertise/reputation-media-privacy/defamation-faqs/

2Two · 18/10/2021 22:46

What would the screenshot do? I have a screenshot of the original post.

You need it as evidence of the libel. Ideally you also need a screen shot showing the reaction to the post.

NamechangeApril21 · 18/10/2021 22:46

@MsLizard

I'd post on the local group stating that you're aware that a libellous and completely untrue post was made about you and has since been deleted.

Calmly state that the guard checked and confirmed that you were fine, and you suggest that people in future don't post incorrect and damaging information when they have no idea what they're talking about.

This
Nanny0gg · 18/10/2021 22:44

Slander/defamation is a civil complaint. The police absolutely won't be interested.

imnotacelebritygetmeoutofhere · 18/10/2021 22:39

I would have reported that person to the police for slander/defamation of character and harassment! I would also contact the page is was posted on, although it's been removed, to ask WTF they think they are doing allowing these types of posts on their page.
You say the person's profile has also disappeared? I wonder if that's because facebook will close your profile if you are reported too many times.
I'm outraged on your behalf!

lanthanum · 18/10/2021 22:37

I'd ask the group admins to post a message along the lines of "A photo was posted here yesterday of somebody having their bags checked by security; the person concerned had done nothing wrong, and the post and comments have been removed. Please think before posting accusations which may be unfounded."

That way hopefully anyone who saw the original post will know that it was unfounded, but without your name being attached to the whole debacle.

EKGEMS · 18/10/2021 22:35

I've set off security alarms before and definitely never stolen anything-I had a store employee tell me once the purse brand I was carrying was notorious to cause false alarms at their store. Back in the late 80s I purchased a skirt for a special occasion and got home to discover the cashier hadn't removed the security tag on it and had to return to store with the receipt and still got given the 3rd degree over it-the anger should've been directed at their security system and not an innocent teenager. I'm so sorry @falselyaccused that you've had to deal with this nonsense!

beachbabyy · 18/10/2021 22:32

At the very least I'd be posting in the group explaining what had actually happened.
Really annoys me when people post pictures to social media, news papers etc without actually knowing what was actually happened.

falselyaccused · 18/10/2021 22:30

@2Two

You might be able to find a lawyer willing to take this on on a no-win n-fee basis, but it may depend on whether the prospective defendant has the means to pay hefty damages - they would have to be hefty to make the lawyer's percentage worth having. But you'll need a screenshot.

What would the screenshot do? I have a screenshot of the original post.

OP posts:
McOrange · 18/10/2021 22:29

@Winniemarysarah

My uncle was recently posted all over fb for being a ‘dogknapper’. Apparently he was seen driving around our local area in a white van following dog walkers and taking photos of potential victims. He’s actually a roofie and was sat in the work van when the someone walked past with the fattest dog he’d ever seen in his life. He took a photo of it because he thought it was funny, and someone saw him and posted it on fb where it got a few hundred shares and thousands of comments calling him all sorts. As soon as he realised he did what someone said on here and wrote his own post, also added pic of fat dog to prove his point 🙄
Our local page has something similar - warning of a dodgy guy in a white van outside a house in an affluent area who “became uncomfortable when I started photographing him”

Poor guy came on fo the group to say it was him and he was just outside his house, that’s why he was uncomfortable!

purpleme12 · 18/10/2021 22:29

If you've got legal cover in your house insurance it can offer cover social media defamation. No idea if it would take in this particular situation but it's just a thought

Winniemarysarah · 18/10/2021 22:27

My uncle was recently posted all over fb for being a ‘dogknapper’. Apparently he was seen driving around our local area in a white van following dog walkers and taking photos of potential victims. He’s actually a roofie and was sat in the work van when the someone walked past with the fattest dog he’d ever seen in his life. He took a photo of it because he thought it was funny, and someone saw him and posted it on fb where it got a few hundred shares and thousands of comments calling him all sorts. As soon as he realised he did what someone said on here and wrote his own post, also added pic of fat dog to prove his point 🙄

WizardHowl · 18/10/2021 22:25

How awful for you OP!

I’d be asking/expecting the town page admins to post a retraction and acknowledgment that it was untrue, and that they’ll be reviewing their policies on posting ‘gotcha’ images, as PP have said. I’d then be tempted to follow up myself by commenting on the retraction post along the lines of what @melj1213 suggested regarding identifying the poster.

2Two · 18/10/2021 22:24

You might be able to find a lawyer willing to take this on on a no-win n-fee basis, but it may depend on whether the prospective defendant has the means to pay hefty damages - they would have to be hefty to make the lawyer's percentage worth having. But you'll need a screenshot.

DivorceAdvicePlease123 · 18/10/2021 22:23

@warmeduppizza

Police won’t do anything. Someone accused me on social media of being a paedophile, nearly costing me my job. Police said they could only take action if I was ‘vulnerable’ Confused
Fucking hell fire! 😳
ShirleyPhallus · 18/10/2021 22:22

@MsLizard

I'd post on the local group stating that you're aware that a libellous and completely untrue post was made about you and has since been deleted.

Calmly state that the guard checked and confirmed that you were fine, and you suggest that people in future don't post incorrect and damaging information when they have no idea what they're talking about.

I’d do this too
PfizerMinnelli · 18/10/2021 22:22

An abysmal situation, OP. This is precisely why images of supposed criminals and criminal activity are not allowed on well run FB groups.

You said you have screenshots of the original post? If I were you, I'd let admin of the group see them when you message to ask for a retraction by them.

These screenshots should also let you see the identity of the profile that made the post. If you can't see them, or the post, you may well have been blocked by them. See if any one else can see them. If they can, that will mean you're blocked. If no one can see them they may well have suspended their account when they'd realised what they'd done. Did you comment on their post, or anyone stick up for you?

Lastly, you can request CCTV footage of yourself, which may show others around. If you wanted to go down this route. See www.gov.uk/request-cctv-footage-of-yourself

sadeyedladyofthelowlandsea · 18/10/2021 22:22

I would 100% contact the admins of the page/group and tell them exactly what's happened as you did in your first post here, and ask them to post something along the lines of 'Following a recent post by a member which clearly made a false accusation against another person, as well as clearly identifying who the entirely innocent party was, we will be tightening up our rules over posts. This was a wholly malicious accusation, and has caused significant distress to the accused, who is now taking further advice on how to proceed. As admins, we apologise unreservedly for allowing this post, which was wholly without foundation.'

The admins really should have better moderation over what is posted, there's no excuse for allowing something like that to be posted publicly. I would be absolutely furious if I were you.

NaturalStudy · 18/10/2021 22:19

Contacting the police and civil action are a waste of time.

As irritating as it is most people who read the post will have forgotten about it by now, making a song and dance about it on the Facebook page or elsewhere will just remind them.

purpleme12 · 18/10/2021 22:17

@warmeduppizza

Police won’t do anything. Someone accused me on social media of being a paedophile, nearly costing me my job. Police said they could only take action if I was ‘vulnerable’ Confused
Wow that's awful
melj1213 · 18/10/2021 22:15

Christ, I work in a supermarket and if someone posted on FB every time one of our door alarms went off then there would be nothing else on my newsfeed! Door alarms can go off for any number of reasons other than theft - the staff genuinely missing a security tag on an item so it didn't get removed, a damaged tag that didn't deactivate properly, a tag that has been reactivated and so goes off, a glitch in the security gate that made it go off randomly etc etc - and I cannot understand why anyone would go out of their way to post a random security alert they happened to see in a shopping centre.

Since it was posted to a public group I would make your own post with the basic facts of what happened - the alarm went off as you left the store, you chatted with security and let them check your bags and they confirmed you had done nothing wrong and you went on your way - and that you have been made aware that someone has taken your picture during the incident and posted libellous rubbish on that group. I would ask for the members help to identify the person who made the post as you are considering taking legal action against them for their blatant lies and for the upset caused. In addition you would like to take the opportunity to remind people that just because someone posts something to a FB group and makes a claim (such as that they are posting photos of a thief) does not make it true and you hope people aren't quite so quick to judge others without the full story in future.

Whether or not you actually plan to take legal action is entirely up to you, but if you make a post where it looks like you are appealing for information to support legal action then youre more likely to get more attention/positive feedback than if you just go and post "I didn't do anything, this person is a liar!" as that can just come across as defensive and disingenuous, even if it is true.