Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Leave DS behind when we go on holiday?

395 replies

Kermitsolvestheclimate · 18/10/2021 18:34

We're due to go away tomorrow (in UK). DS (age 14.5) won't pack his bag or do anything to get ready to leave early in the morning despite various encouragements and warnings from us. He has just gone out for the rest of this eve (to a class he attends). He has form and caused a lot of trouble on our last holiday as he wouldn't pack to leave and we had a strict deadline to be out of the accommodation. His lack of co-operation was very stressful and I ended up clearing his room, packing his bags for him on top of everything else I was doing like clearing the kitchen, packing the car etc. he just sat there doing sweet FA. AIBU to just think sod him, we'll go without him in the morning and leave him home alone rather than have all the angst again. I refuse to accept he needs his mother to pack a bag for a few days away whilst he sits playing on his phone. I know he does want to come on the holiday and when he snaps out of his stupid mood will be upset if we leave him behind. (For context he has ASD but is 'high functioning' and is perfectly able to pack an overnight bag) .

OP posts:
Thereluctantgrownup · 19/10/2021 21:31

Hello, social care professional here 🙋‍♀️ Whilst you, OP, are correct that there are no legal guidelines as to leaving a child home alone, there are very clear recommendations that children under the age of 16 should not be left alone overnight. Children under the age of 16 are rarely emotionally mature enough to deal with long periods alone or emergencies. Given your child has ASD, it would be highly inappropriate to leave him alone for 5 days. You say you have relatives who live 20 minutes away... a lot can go wrong in the 20 minutes it would take to get to him if needed.

Perhaps if you are really struggling with his behaviour try contacting your son's paediatrician, early help team or social care service to ask for help in managing this. Its very possible that your child actually does not understand how to pack a bag, or is finding the whole situation overwhelming. If you have been nagging at him, raising your voice or demonstrating your frustration this is likely to have further impacted on his motivation/ability to get his things ready 🤷🏻‍♀️

earthyfire · 19/10/2021 21:11

I have a 14 year old, I would never leave him, I wouldn't want to anyway. I pack my children's clothes when we go away, and they pack a bag of things to keep them entertained. Why sweat the small stuff.

Timetoretiretospain · 19/10/2021 20:49

@clockover

I don't think OP is 'up to speed' - the suggestion that he is perfectly capable of packing his bag suggests OP is lacking basic understanding of how autistic people 'lose' function at crucial times. I'm not denying the frustration at all, but ultimately it's one of those things you learn to deal with and prepare for over time.
Exactly this
RedLightGreenL1ght · 19/10/2021 20:39

No parent out there simply packs for their kids these days? Even though they're practically middle aged at 14 on here ...

My DS is nearly 15. If we are going on holiday I simply pack his clothes. With teens you need to pick your battles and I wouldn't be making the ' pack your suitcase on your own' thing the hill I chose to die on. Especially not with a child who has additional needs

FuckYouCorona · 19/10/2021 20:39

What a horrendous thread. The OP reminds me of my parents who thought it was appropriate to punish the ASD out of the child. They can't switch it off to suit the occasion. The OP seriously needs to educate herself on ASD. All my DC are ASD. We didn't go on holiday because it didn't suit their needs. Shocked at the ignorance & selfishness on this, but mostly from the OP, who should know better. I honestly hope this is a troll post. Sad

momtoboys · 19/10/2021 20:35

@Tigerwhocameforsupper

I would take him, but don’t pack the bag.

If he arrives there with no stuff then more fool him.

He will pack. He wouldn’t ensure his phone charger was in there unless he did!

I'm with Tiger
Amitskitshaw · 19/10/2021 20:34

The task of packing might feel too big. Can you make a list to give him? Break it down. Pack with him. He might be feeling overwhelmed.

clockover · 19/10/2021 20:34

I don't think OP is 'up to speed' - the suggestion that he is perfectly capable of packing his bag suggests OP is lacking basic understanding of how autistic people 'lose' function at crucial times. I'm not denying the frustration at all, but ultimately it's one of those things you learn to deal with and prepare for over time.

campion · 19/10/2021 20:29

@niugboo

You’re unreasonable on every level and your post indicates a complete lack of understanding of autism and the impact.

Poor lad.

I suspect OP is very familiar with autism and its impact on her son, on her other children, on her relationship, and, oh yes, on herself. She lives it every day so its quite likely she's up to speed, don't you think?

BTW the holiday started today so she either went or she didn't. DS was definitely going. Poor lad.

Timetoretiretospain · 19/10/2021 20:18

@niugboo

You’re unreasonable on every level and your post indicates a complete lack of understanding of autism and the impact.

Poor lad.

Yep
niugboo · 19/10/2021 20:15

You’re unreasonable on every level and your post indicates a complete lack of understanding of autism and the impact.

Poor lad.

Thevoiceofreason2021 · 19/10/2021 20:10

Pack a tiny rucksack with absolute essentials….. no chargers etc. Tell him when he gets in you’ve packed, your f he wants anything else he’ll need to pack himself

Wally1983 · 19/10/2021 20:04

Of late I know of a 15yo that was left home alone for 12 days out of 21 as his mum & her husband went away..typical teen had said “I don’t want to go” and they said fine and left him at home. They’re not saying that now after he stole the car, smashed it, stole money, drugs, drink etc too.
The only reason she isn’t being charged with neglect is she was actually home the night he stole said car….then they discovered he’d driven it for a week.
Think very carefully about leaving him home alone!

StargazerAli · 19/10/2021 20:02

He is still very young to leave and if it was my decision, the worry about him being on his own at home would ruin my holiday. Best to have him miserable with you than suffer any unexpected consequences.

TertiusLydgate · 19/10/2021 20:00

Blimey, who is the child here?

I assume you're joking about leaving a 14-year-old. Just pack for the poor kid ffs.

MrsLargeEmbodied · 19/10/2021 19:52

so frustrating op
my relative was the same
asd or not i think his reaction is very very common

mylifestory · 19/10/2021 19:48

pack his stuff, leave vital things he needs at home like chargers. if he ask say they are already packed bt of course u have hidden them at home. He wont do it again ....

TravelLost · 19/10/2021 19:40

@Peanutsandchilli

I hope to goodness that you've taken him with you.

My daughter is 17 and 'high functioning'. In reality, she can do fuck all for herself and would need me to pack for her. She'd then sit in our accommodation for the next few days and not go out at all. I'd never leave her though. She'd never cope.

The last post of the op days they are all going. Bar her who will stay at home.

Reading the OP’s posts would have put your mind at rest.

Chouetted · 19/10/2021 19:39

The fact that he actually wants to go on the holiday reads to me as a strong suggestion that it's more likely to be an executive function issue than a strop.

Although he may well be also having a strop over his own inability to pack - I would have at his age. Teenagers are complicated.

Peanutsandchilli · 19/10/2021 19:37

I hope to goodness that you've taken him with you.

My daughter is 17 and 'high functioning'. In reality, she can do fuck all for herself and would need me to pack for her. She'd then sit in our accommodation for the next few days and not go out at all. I'd never leave her though. She'd never cope.

TravelLost · 19/10/2021 19:29

I also love how do many posters are coming to tell the op that it’s because he isn’t managing transition etc… with no input from the op to base those assertions on.

But would be horrified at any generalisation about their own autistic dc because they are all different.

And all seem to forget that we are talking about a teenager too. Autistic but still a teenager with all their flaws.

I’m really wondering how anyone can determine of the child in question is struggling due to the autism or is just having a teenage strop (or a nice mix of both!)

Wonderfulstuff · 19/10/2021 19:28

@Jontomsam

I’m astonished at the ignorance of ASC awareness on this thread. I despair for my ASC child I really do. 😢
I totally agree. I made a throw away comment about my DH and holidays further upthread as it's something we joke (maybe sometimes through gritted teeth!) about. But really everything here is a reminder as to why my neuro-diverse DH struggles so much in 'normal' society.

The lack of understanding and tolerance is really sad. And some of the advice is terrible e.g. advice to punish the child by removing his phone... for my DH his phone is his anchor - it reminds him of tasks, it tells the time, combined with earphones it blocks out auditory distractions. Without it, his already poor executive functions dissipate even further causing his a great deal of personal distress and self loathing.

Timetoretiretospain · 19/10/2021 19:27

[quote linsey2581]@Timetoretiretospain I’ve just read some of OPs replies to my daughter who is 17 and our sons young carer and she is shocked by her suggestions[/quote]
It’s just awful

TravelLost · 19/10/2021 19:24

I think the child is long gone on hols as they were due to leave this am. Plus the father prepared the bag anyway

Not sure why do many posters are up in arms at the idea that the child would be left alone as it’s clear it’s not happening Confused

Basilandparsleyandmint · 19/10/2021 19:24

For heaven’s sake woman pack his bags yourself - he is 14! He doesn’t get a choice and you are his parent. Get a grip ! He is a child and you cannot leave him just because he is being difficult.