Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you actually lose weight if you breast feed, or is it a myth?

130 replies

fussytodd · 18/10/2021 16:39

I would love to hear some experiences as I've heard mixed things.

Lots of people say you lose weight.

Others say that you actually need to eat a lot, otherwise you don't produce enough milk - so you don't actually lose weight.

Personally, I couldn't breast feed for very long, as I wasn't producing enough milk. I was also not eating huge amounts of food though. So who knows ! Any experiences appreciated. I may be onto my second one next year and would really like to try again and see if I get more milk this time.

OP posts:
sunnyhoneybumblebee · 18/10/2021 17:01

@TheKeatingFive

I didn't. I held on to 10 pounds no matter what I ate.

When I stopped BFing it melted off like magic.

Same as me xx
Abitlost2 · 18/10/2021 17:01

I bf all of my 3 dc until 18 months and I had a totally flat stomach days after giving birth. Ive always been slim but became v lean with bf and could eat as much as i wanted and put on zero pounds. I think it's actually stood to me, my youngest is 4 and im 37 and i never put on any weight since.
I think its one of the healthiest things a mother can do for their baby and their own body tbh.

Ozanj · 18/10/2021 17:00

@fussytodd

I would love to hear some experiences as I've heard mixed things.

Lots of people say you lose weight.

Others say that you actually need to eat a lot, otherwise you don't produce enough milk - so you don't actually lose weight.

Personally, I couldn't breast feed for very long, as I wasn't producing enough milk. I was also not eating huge amounts of food though. So who knows ! Any experiences appreciated. I may be onto my second one next year and would really like to try again and see if I get more milk this time.

If you’re in the UK it probably wasn’t your milk supply unless you actually got your milk tissue measured by a midwife?? It is more likely that your baby had an undiagnosed lip or tongue tie which meant they couldn’t establish the supply they needed.

To prep for the second insist on a midwife feeling for your milk tissue, and when baby is born really push hard to make sure even ‘minor’ tongue ties are corrected because when it comes to breastfeeding even minor tongue ties can ruin the early establishing period. If diagnosed and needed you can pump on a schedule until it’s fixed so you can have a reasonable milk supply at the 6 week mark.

DuggeeHugs · 18/10/2021 17:00

I didn't lose weight while breastfeeding until I stopped overeating, which makes sense. I breastfed continually for 6 years (2 DC), including tandem feeding, and losing weight was definitely down to 'eat less, exercise more'. I only slightly reduced calorie intake (1700 per day) and the weight dropped off in a way it hasn't since.

DontBuyANewMumCashmere · 18/10/2021 16:59

I had two periods of BFing and lost my baby weight very quickly after both kids. I don't know if this is genetics or lifestyle but I am generally quite active and returned to walking daily straight away, plus EBFed and didn't overeat at all.

wetpebbles · 18/10/2021 16:59

I ate biscuits whenever feeding so day and night and gained

Catsstillrock · 18/10/2021 16:58

I did. I also (needed to) eat a lot. Not junk, healthy home cooked meals with lots of good proteins and fats and all the carb I could eat. I’d have a morning snack, afternoon cake and bedtime snack too.

Sometimes I had something neutral like a oatcake on the night - I also did this in pregnancy, it helped me go back to sleep. Some pregnancy insomnia is low blood sugar.

It might depend on your metabolism. I’m naturally slim with a fast metabolism and needed to eat plenty.

I also drank lots. And carefully mixed plenty of water with isotonic drinks, especially in summer - both my babies were born during heatwave summers. I drank rehydration sachets (like you use for an upset stomach) once or twice a day when the weather was hot.

I’ve read on here that what you eat ans drink doesn’t affect milk supply but my personal experience is that’s just not true.

tiredanddangerous · 18/10/2021 16:57

I went the opposite way and put weight on. I was permanently starving and craving carbs.

FTEngineerM · 18/10/2021 16:57

@fussytodd

Did anyone have more luck feeding their second baby?

My HV always said when I'd get upset that I didn't manage to feed as much as I wanted, that with the second one I'll be able to do it.

Didn’t loose weight with DS1 because I ate everything I saw I was like a locust whilst BFing I can’t describe my appetite in any other way. 😂

Feeding DS2 now and just switched to combi feeding, he’s an absolute milk monster and I just don’t wanna do it alone. There definitely is more and a faster flow this time around though so so can confirm for me at least, it’s different this time. Milk came in sooner too. Less pain when starting out.

minipie · 18/10/2021 16:57

I lost loads of weight in the first 6 months but as per some PP it’s hard to know how much was BF and how much was due to non sleeping velcro baby meaning not much time to eat.

My weight crept up after 6 months as she was taking less milk and allowed me more time to eat.

BeQuietBrenda · 18/10/2021 16:57

So saying I had weight to lose prior to getting pregnant and then I had hyperemisis so got to the end of both pregnancies weighing less than at the beginning! The only times I've ever lost weight easily has been during pregnancy.

BiscuitLover09876 · 18/10/2021 16:57

*yes and no it should have read

MondeoFan · 18/10/2021 16:56

I lost weight but I had a bad birth and was massively stressed both times for different reasons after the birth but I'm certain breastfeeding contributed to weight loss.

BiscuitLover09876 · 18/10/2021 16:56

Yes and now. Every time you breastfeed your uterus contracts a bit more (you can feel it!) So your womb shrinks much more quickly. But it also involves a LOT of lying around and you do get hungry, so if you keep overeating then you counter the effects. Overall I'd say yes though.

LaikO · 18/10/2021 16:56

I did/am. No idea how since I eat like a horse and don't exercise, but somehow weigh less than I did pre-pregnancy!

FateHasRedesignedMost · 18/10/2021 16:56

I lost a lot and became underweight. Fed for over 2 years but even after 6 months I was far lighter than before pregnancy.

Caspianberg · 18/10/2021 16:55

As above I do think it’s also to do with baby rather than feeding per say. Ds has been a terrible napper and whined so much at home that the first year was spent with him in sling or pram and me just walking miles and miles every day so he wouldn’t scream

biggirlknickers · 18/10/2021 16:55

I had a raging appetite. Also spent more time sitting down doing the actual breastfeeding. I did not lose weight.

Second baby was way easier than the first to breastfeed but I think that’s just because I had half a clue what I was doing the second time. The first time I almost gave up every single day until week 9 when it suddenly clicked.

8dpwoah · 18/10/2021 16:55

@TheKeatingFive

I didn't. I held on to 10 pounds no matter what I ate.

When I stopped BFing it melted off like magic.

Similar here tbf. I lost quite a bit soon after birth as I think I was quite fluid-retaining, shall we say, but I reckon I was at least half a stone more than 'normal', probably more, until I went back to work when DD was 10 months old- I was still BF around that though-and consequently was BFing a lot less. Possibly eating less too as the snack opportunities weren't the same as being on leave 😂

I think it depends on your metabolism really, I'm quite trim normally but I think this was my body holding on to some reserves as a just in case?

SpangoDweller · 18/10/2021 16:54

I lost weight but like many PPs it was because I did a lot of pram/sling walks and barely ate much during the day because of feeds or naps. When DS was down to a couple of feeds a day and went to nursery, the weight piled on because I had time to snack!

BeQuietBrenda · 18/10/2021 16:54

Hmmm.... I did but I also did a lot more walking, ate healthier (but also ate a lot more than I did previously) and was on the go a lot more. So not sure I could put it down to breastfeeding.

Lemoncurd · 18/10/2021 16:54

I lost a huge amount each time, eating as much as I liked. Went into each pregnancy weighing 12-13 stone and dropped to 9 stone while feeding. The weight went back on each time I stopped feeding. Mine were exclusively breastfed, stopping at between 18 months - 2 years each time.

Caspianberg · 18/10/2021 16:53

Yes. Ds is 18 months and I have lost the 20kg gained in pregnancy plus extra I didn’t need to. The first 20kg in about 3 months. He only feeds once a day now but the first 9/10 months he fed constantly day and night.

I didn’t really eat any more as was always feeding so rushed meals to feed again, and hated feeding after just eating as baby basically sits on stomach.
Bmi now about 18/19. I assume it will regain a bit now not really feeding any more, but I dont have time to make nice food as much as I used to do.
I have never really snacked so main calories always came from meals

TurnUpTurnip · 18/10/2021 16:53

I gained, I was bigger than when I was pregnant but that’s because I was hungry all the time. But then breastfeeding didn’t make my periods stop either and they returned at 5 weeks with all 4 children despite ebf so I’m obviously unlucky

miltonj · 18/10/2021 16:52

I lost a huge amount with no effort. Have found I can basically eat what I want and still losing weight 13 months on. My supply was overwhelming for months, maybe that's correlated I don't know... would be interested to find out.

I also think though for me, it may just be to do with the new life style of being a mum, constantly on my feet and little rest, a lot busier than my pre kid lifestyle.