Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that self isolation within a household isn't that effective

61 replies

IDontGetOutMuch · 18/10/2021 16:31

Would love to hear stories of self isolation within a family actually working. We are all covid positive at the moment, but all bar one of us tested negative on LFT one day, then all bar one positive on PCR the next. So, although the positive LFT immediately self isolated and we all had PCR the next morning, and then the one negative PCR then isolated, don't think it will have helped much because a bit too late, if that makes any sense.

Anyone have an opinion? Is it worth it to have people self isolating within a household, in their bedroom? Or is it just trying to hold back the tide?

OP posts:
EdgeOfTheSky · 18/10/2021 23:23

The rest of our household didn’t catch it when one member of the family had COVID but stayed in their room except for toilet visits.

Bananarice · 18/10/2021 23:19

It can be effective. Dsis didn't get in January when most people got it in the house.

My other dsis brought her food and she had the upstairs toilet to herself. She had brain surgery in November, so everyone was extra cautious around her. Luckily, she still hasn't got covid.

BluebellsGreenbells · 18/10/2021 23:15

It takes one unlucky timed visit and boom. Catching covid or your household catching it is not a bloody failure. There’s no winners

It’s not luck though is it? I work in a school full of unvaccinated kids and it’s exploding - it was only a matter of time before I caught it! I know exactly which child coughed in my face and I’ve been on the sofa since them away from my own children.

I’m glad it’s me first because I’ll be able to look after them if they catch it.

I haven’t left the room and they are looking after me. It’s called isolation

What’s wrong here is the governments lack of foresight into parents unable to isolate from ill children and still able to send siblings to school or work themselves.

That’s the spread. And it’s the governments fault.

scrivette · 18/10/2021 23:11

DS and DD had it at separate times and no one else in the family had it.

We didn't isolate from each other as the DC are too young and the 3 year old often slept in the same bed as me and I didn't catch it.

Buttons294749 · 18/10/2021 23:11

Worked for us!

whitehorsesdonotlie · 18/10/2021 23:07

Ds (14) tested positive: none of the rest of us caught Covid. But we distanced properly, wore masks, opened windows etc.

emetophobe12 · 18/10/2021 23:06

When I was pregnant, DH got covid and isolated in the spare room for the whole 10 days. He literally never left the room other than to use the toilet or to shower and he always made sure that I was downstairs or out. I was making him food and drinks and bringing it up to him (leaving it outside the door) (this was all his choice btw - I'm not some weird wife who locks my husband up 😂)
I never got it.
I'm reallly surprised I never got it though because he didn't isolate from me until his results came back and confirmed positive (which was 2 days after his symptoms started - we were convinced it wasn't covid because he only had a bit of a runny nose and felt achey).

So if we go off NHS test and trace rules with the contact tracing 48 hours prior to symptoms starting.. I was with him for a whole 4 days of the most infectious period (2 days before and 2 days after symptom start date). We share a bed, kiss goodnight every night, cuddle in bed.. couldn't have got any closer

I did an antibody test too to double check I just wasn't asymptomatic and I was negative for antibodies 🤷🏽‍♀️

FrangipaniBlue · 18/10/2021 22:55

It's been 7 days since DS 13 tested positive and so far neither DH or i have caught it.

He has stayed in his room mostly although has ventured downstairs to the living room and kitchen while I was in my office working.

We also all share only one bathroom.

notHarris · 18/10/2021 22:42

My dsis isolated in her house from her dp and adult ds.
Dp got it but was asymptomatic, adult ds didn't get it.
Was that a success story or just chance??
I live alone with primary age children, no way am I isolating from them, we'd all just have to muddle through.

Teenagers2grownups0 · 18/10/2021 22:37

We did it. DS1 (adult) got it and isolated in his room and used the main bathroom while the rest of us used our ensuite. We took food to his door and spoke to him through an open door briefly when he was in bed. None of the rest of us caught it.

Not saying we won’t catch it, feels almost inevitable now. More of a ‘when not if’ unfortunately.

ChampionOfTheSun · 18/10/2021 22:31

Neither DH nor my (at the time 18mo) DD (who I BF throughout) caught covid when I had it. DH kept away from me but obviously didn't keep away from DD who obviously came to me often. We didn't share towels, were very careful about hand washing, wiping down touch points etc.

Maybe83 · 18/10/2021 22:29

My dd got it. She did self isolate. We brought her food and she used the main bath room. We all wore masks when opening her door. She wore one any time she left her room.

I disinfected door handles and light switches. Dh our younger child and I didn't catch it.

YodaiamsaidI · 18/10/2021 22:26

My then 14 dd isolated in her room last year and me and other DC never caught it.

IDontGetOutMuch · 18/10/2021 22:24

@Yellow85 I think that's it in a nutshell really. Obviously, you can try not to have contact within a house, but unless it's palatial or has a separate annexe or en suites, it does seem to be a bit luck based.

OP posts:
Yellow85 · 18/10/2021 17:19

@IDontGetOutMuch

I am smarting a bit from a friend telling me how marvellously they are all doing isolating and how they have thus managed to have only one case in their house. I'm oversensitive, and still a bit ill, but it took me right back to baby days when people took complete credit for baby's superior sleep/eating etc. I'm not sure what more we could have done. We did best possible isolation from me getting LFT test, but given that next day there were majority positive PCR, it seems it was too late.
Look if I’ve learned anything from this whole bloody pandemic, it’s that it doesn’t matter how intricately you follow the rules and how amazing you are at distancing and washing down your shopping. It takes one unlucky timed visit and boom. Catching covid or your household catching it is not a bloody failure. There’s no winners.
MrsAvocet · 18/10/2021 17:04

When my teenage DS tested positive he tried pretty hard to keep isolated - ate his meals in his room etc - but in a few days DH was positive. I guess DS may have infected him even before he knew he had it. Once 2 of them were positive we gave up on the internal isolation idea. I figured out I probably already had caught it, and 36 hours later I was proved right!

iloverunningslow · 18/10/2021 17:00

My parents and brother managed it. My brother knew he was likely to get covid due to his job so he started isolating from them before he got it. They used separate bathrooms. My mum prepared all his meals and drinks so he didn't use the kitchen. She left meals and collected dishes from outside his closed bedroom door and all communication was by text message.
Thankfully my brother is self contained and resilient. My mum used to be an intensive care nurse so she is very experienced in correct hand washing and other infection control measures.

Oblomov21 · 18/10/2021 17:00

We haven't had it at all. None of us. Barely anyone we know has, and no one badly. But I would NOT now make teen ds's stay in their room all the time. I just can't see that it's that effective, having read bits.

Orangebug · 18/10/2021 16:59

My teen DS was isolating last week. He spent a lot of time in his bedroom, but as he is a teen this was not a hardship for him. He came downstairs for meals (but sat on the other side of the room to the rest of us). He used the family bathroom. None of us caught it from him. DH and I are double vaccinated, but DD didn't get it either.

DoormatBob · 18/10/2021 16:58

As a family we aren't particularly covid opinionated, it just seemed the right thing to do. The risk of doing nothing is we both get it and try to look after a 3 year old who also then can't leave the house. Rely on family to drop shopping off etc.

We were fortunate with family support. It would be very hard to keep a 3yo away from her mum for 10 days in the same house.

FrankButchersDickieBow · 18/10/2021 16:56

My husband and daughter had it, so I felt it was inevitable that I would get it. Shared a bed with both of them at different times and didn't catch it. In fact, I took part on a study where as long as I got a negative LTF ever day, I was allowed to got the shops etc.

TerrifiedandWorried · 18/10/2021 16:54

I isolated away from my family for 5 days, none of them got it. Stayed in my room, husband slept in sofa.

BUT I provably had it for 5 days before my positive test (lots of close contact with family) so was there any point?

DoormatBob · 18/10/2021 16:52

We did it when DW got it. She got the bedroom, I had DDs room and DD(3) did a 10-day 'sleepover' with nanna and grandad.

I left meals at the door. DW wore a mask to use bathroom and sprayed disinfectant on any surfaces on way back. Plates etc were left outside and I washed them immediately.

It was the tidiest the house has ever been and DD had a great time too!

InTheLabyrinth · 18/10/2021 16:49

Back in the days when a case in the house meant everyone had to stay in, we didnt isolate my 12 yr old further. I even ended up sharing a bed with him on his worst nights. None of the rest of the house got it.
With the lower isolation requirements, I dont know what we'd do.

IDontGetOutMuch · 18/10/2021 16:48

@KylieKoKo

I can't see how you can unless you have a huge house and all go separate wings. I also can't imagine isolating away from dp if he was sick and am horrified by some people's accounts on primary school aged children being alone in their bedroom for 2 weeks.
This is my worry-all these kids essentially in their rooms for ten days or more?
OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread