Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that self isolation within a household isn't that effective

61 replies

IDontGetOutMuch · 18/10/2021 16:31

Would love to hear stories of self isolation within a family actually working. We are all covid positive at the moment, but all bar one of us tested negative on LFT one day, then all bar one positive on PCR the next. So, although the positive LFT immediately self isolated and we all had PCR the next morning, and then the one negative PCR then isolated, don't think it will have helped much because a bit too late, if that makes any sense.

Anyone have an opinion? Is it worth it to have people self isolating within a household, in their bedroom? Or is it just trying to hold back the tide?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Oblomov21 · 19/10/2021 14:06

Probably now I wouldn't bother insisting vigorously that ds's teens stayed apart from us. I know not why none of us have had it.

worriedatthemoment · 19/10/2021 12:26

I think for us we are doing the isolating as with the new rules of us going to work and out etc it feels like more risk we get it and pass on in the 48 hrs before symptoms or if no symptoms, LFT don't always pick up as far as I know , although in my sons case no symptoms they did which means we kept him home.
Also a lot easier with a 16 year old ,I don't think we could of done it with him 2/3 years ago and if he was unhappy or really ill and needed other care then we would of course just stop
As it happens he is enjoying texting me like room service , can I have a snack , drink etc but is getting bored but only as in he is an outdoorsy /sporty type
So I have bought him so new weights for him to use in bedroom as I know lack of exercise is getting to him more and we have a postage stamp size back garden

siestalady · 19/10/2021 12:15

I know of two families:

  • One where the DD got it, they didnt isolate her from the rest of the family - no one else in the household got it (including her unvaccinated younger sibling)
  • One where the eldest DD got it, the family immediately quarantined her off into her room with meals being delivered outside her room, but then they all got it anyway

Its just random. Personally, I cant imagine forcing my (admittedly primary aged) kids to spend 10 days away from the rest of the family, but each to their own. I just dont think there is a hard and fast rule to catching it/avoiding it when its in your house.

Polkadotties · 19/10/2021 12:05

The viral load is highest when someone doesn’t have symptoms. That is how viruses spread, no point in being spreadable when people are confined to their sick bed. And this is also why T&T ask for your contacts for the 48 hours up to the onset of symptoms.

Pinkyxx · 19/10/2021 08:28

Worked for us. DD had it last year, there had been a literal epidemic in her class so I kept her home, a day later she started to get a runny nose
so stayed in her room mostly (her choice). I thought she being dramatic but the next day the cough started and a day later she tested positive. From that point, she stayed in her room with ''room service'' None of the other 4 members of our household got it, including me (which I still can't believe as I was around her mask less before she tested positive).

horseymum · 19/10/2021 08:15

My dd and DC isolated from rest of house. They were either in their rooms or outside ( summer so much easier) We ate meals all outside with them 2 metres away. None of the rest of us caught it. May have been good luck, who knows. I know it isn't possible for everyone and much harder now you can't be outside as much. We have a big but not huge house but two bathrooms so that helped. What did make the difference was we knew DC had been exposed early ( and in fairly close and constant contact) he kept away from us before he was positive. This was partly due to tiredness and being a teenage boy who stays in his room quite a bit anyway! Most people probably won't know until the PCR is positive which is too late. You can't really blame yourself if it gets passed on in the home .

GiveMeNovocain · 19/10/2021 07:48

Catching a virus is not a failing. They're designed to spread.

Bunnycat101 · 19/10/2021 07:37

Depends on your set-up. When our household had it we had a 3yo and a 1yo. We’d all been in close contact and exposed anyway. There was no point. Day 1 I tested positive and the next day my husband and eldest did. Little one never showed any symptoms.

icedancerlenny · 19/10/2021 06:34

I don’t really understand why some get it and some don’t. I was positive and my daughter negative. She slept with me the first night before I realised what was wrong. I sneezed & coughed all over us both in the car for the PCR. I did then stay in my room for a week as I was too poorly to leave but she did come in and out. She had negative lateral flows every day & 2 negative PCRs.

My friend’s family had it at the same time. 2 did; 2 didn’t.

onelittlefrog · 19/10/2021 06:29

It is worth it - it reduces the likelihood of transmission and reduces the viral load if it is passed on. It might be unavoidable to have a bit of contact living in the same house, but the less contact you have, the better.

In my family house, 3 people have had it at different times. They each isolated when they had it.

So, we have had 3 incidences of Covid brought in from outside, and each one was contained to one member of the houshold who stayed in their room.

The fourth person hasn't picked it up on any of those occasions.

Kb2942 · 19/10/2021 06:20

I don't think isolating would help for the majority of us who don't live in massive houses. We only have one toilet too in this house. My kids have sen. It would be impossible. I don't think I would even bother.

Someone I know got covid, her kids in the same house did not catch it from here even though she was quite poorly with it. But they did catch it 6 weeks down the line from school! It's an odd virus!

FindingMeno · 19/10/2021 05:05

I think once you test positive it's too late to fret about isolating because you've probably been contagious for a couple of days.
Obviously trying not to cough or sneeze on each other is a good plan though

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 19/10/2021 04:06

3 of us got it separately. Never isolated from each other though

fiveleftfeet · 19/10/2021 02:32

It's not about whether you get it or not, it's also about the viral load. The greater your exposure, the worse you'll get it, potentially.

RiojaRose · 19/10/2021 02:17

It was effective for us. Smallish house, one bathroom, daughter isolated in her room after positive test, no one else got it.

TheUnbearable · 19/10/2021 01:40

I isolated in a room and had food and drink dropped at the door. At the end of the day I popped in to kitchen put everything directly in to dishwasher.

Milothegreat · 19/10/2021 00:50

Currently locked away in my room as daughter needs to go out to work and I don’t want her to get it too.

GreenLunchBox · 19/10/2021 00:45

@KylieKoKo

Even with having meals put outside their door presumably either the sick person has to come out of their room to wash their dishes or someone else has to wash them so risk catching covid.
I could be wrong but the main transmission risk with covid is that it is airborne. So I don't think that handling someone's crockery (as long as you don't touch your face before washing your hands) would give you covid.
beautifullymad · 19/10/2021 00:37

We are a family of six and our youngest suspected covid and isolated in his room immediately.
He then tested positive with both LF and PCR. We share a bathroom so I was doubtful we would be spared. But with his quick action and wearing a mask to and from the bathroom, and me cleaning it after use, no one else in the household caught covid. Minor miracle considering how contagious we are told it is.
Everyone else was tested twice with pcr and daily LF as we were carrying on as normal.

worriedatthemoment · 19/10/2021 00:03

Ds2 isolating now , tested on lft thursday and had pcr thurs too , he stayed in his room since then
We are sharing bathroom but ds16 is wiping ta , door handle and flush with wipe after using ,
Me, dh, ds1 has pcr yesterday ( sun) all negative , so will have to see if stays that way
Ds2 is ok isolating in his room and is enjoying room service, he isn't really ill so doing college work in day , asked for his weights to be put in room and is ok getting on with it
We don't want to catch ideally as me and ds1 start new jobs next week and dh has several hospital appts
Plus now we are allowed out to work etc feels worse maybe mixing and potentially getting it and passing on
Ds2 has no classic covid symptoms and we would of missed it if LFT hadn't shown positive

hobag82 · 18/10/2021 23:35

My son 22 got it and we live in a small 2 bed terrace with one downstairs bathroom. Neither me or my husband caught it. My son had only had one vaccine when he caught it whereas both my husband and I had both.
He did wear his mask around the house when he left his room but we didn't ask him to as we just assumed it was only a matter of time before we got it but PCR's said otherwise!

MarshaBradyo · 18/10/2021 23:34

We didn’t do any isolation in the house and it didn’t spread

IDontGetOutMuch · 18/10/2021 23:34

I think it depends a bit on whether the positive person is caught early on. My two daughters were LFT negative the same day I tested positive with minimal symptoms. I isolated as soon as I tested but only one person negative in PCR the next morning. That person had been with the still apparently negative rest of the house and firstly there had been spreading already, and he tested positive on LFT a few days later. We are a household of regular LFTs too.

OP posts:
Polkadotties · 18/10/2021 23:32

Dp got it. Apart from sleeping in separate bedrooms our normal routing was the same, only one bathroom etc. I didn’t catch it.

cheeseismydownfall · 18/10/2021 23:29

DC1 is on day 8 today. DH is on day 4. Both have had very mild symptoms and we are just carrying on as normal with no attempt to isolate from me, DC2 or DC3. None of us have any underlying conditions, and it feels inevitable that we will catch it eventually and so it might as well be now. We are doing LFTs daily so we will know if we have it asymptomatically. So far the rest of us are negative.

I completely understand why some families would make a different decision, especially with young children (and the risk of both parents being ill at the same time) or if someone is CV.