Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to invite 'best friends' to 3 year olds birthday?

81 replies

nurserypolitics · 18/10/2021 16:01

DD is about to turn 3. She has two 'best friends' who she's known since she was a baby and has been in nursery with, and had weekend play dates with, since then. Let's call them Ann and George. Recently they have all also been playing with another little girl, Julian. DD is the last to turn 3, the 'parties' we've been having so far have essentially been play dates with cake, and have featured all of the above. So lovely small groups of 3 or 4 kids, nice and relaxed.

Unfortunately, Ann, who she is closest to, it moving very far away soon, before her birthday. DD is devastated by this, and doesn't really understand why Ann won't be at her party. We've already said we'll also invite another friend who she plays with on our road. She has, in the l week or so, started talking about inviting two other little girls in nursery as well, Peppa and Suzy, to her party. The problem is, I really don't think she actually plays much with Peppa and Suzy at all, and actually I think reading between the lines they may be a bit mean to her and she may be inviting the 'cool kids'.

I know Peppa's mother through NCT, and I know Peppa had a party with some of her closest nursery friends a while ago and DD wasn't invited (absolutely no issue with that btw, and reflects what little I know about friendship groups). During covid her 'group' was split by age, and Peppa and Suzy were in the slightly older group, and now they've merged again I get the impression there's a bit of the 'we're older and cooler' vibe going on, and sometimes they say they won't play with her. There are loads of other kids she DOES talk about playing with in the day, who if I were going to invite extra children from nursery I would say 'oh could you pass on a message to Billy's mother' or similar, based on who she regularly says she's playing with. So this has totally thrown me as she quite often says things like Peppa and Suzy wouldn't play with her, or said she wasn't allowed in their house, or she's a 'little' girl and they're big girls. And they're the ones she's adamant she wants, not the other friends I know she does play with.

I have Peppa's mother's details, I could v easily ask her, and probably get details for Suzy's parents too, but basically DD has had a rough time recently and with Ann not being there I don't think a 'big' (7 kids, plus baby siblings) party is a good idea and its likely to end in a meltdown. And I know they're changeable but I'm not sure she actually is playing with Suzy and Peppa all that much. But she's said it almost every day for two weeks. We've been trying to down play birthday chat but they're all basically friends from NCT originally who ended up in the same nursery so the birthdays and parties roll on one after the other.

I am aware I'm massively overthinking this, but if I hold my ground, stick to original invitees will she just go along with that? Or would two extra little girls be a good distraction from Ann not being there and it might be a way to get them all to play better together? Advise from more experienced parents would be great, I keep going around in circles.

OP posts:
MoiraNotRuby · 18/10/2021 17:03

I love a toddler party and they are some of my DC happiest memories. My advice is hire a hall, pick a theme and invite the whole lot. With parents staying. I know everyone else will say it doesn't matter. But to me it did. No friendship issues with 30 kids invited.

2pm. Party starts. Colouring/v simple craft. Music in background. Cups of tea for parents. Bouncy castle if you are having one. Balloons and large toys if not.

2.30pm. 30 mins of party games. Finish with lazy lions. When child is tapped they can wake up and go and sit at the party food table. One by one is a bit calmer than a stampede.

3.00pm food. Savoury first. After 20 minutes or so, bring out biscuits.

3.30pm sing happy birthday and blow out candles.

Then disco time (ie same as first half hour more or less) whilst cake is cut and put in bags.

3.55pm time to give out the party bags and say thanks for coming.

4pm DONE. Clear up, go home, eat leftovers.

My DC are teens now but I do miss the parties! Have fun OP.

Tilltheend99 · 18/10/2021 17:00

Can you really tell who are the cool kids out of toddlers in a nursery. I think you are overly involved and concerned in something that is not as important as you think.

Yes she was friends with Anna a week or so ago and now she is friends with girls from nursery. It all changes very quickly at that age and she won’t even remember who came by next birthday.

If on the other hand the real issue is you are better friends with the parents of certain girls and would enjoy some adult discussion at the party then just invite Anna as well.

esloquehay · 18/10/2021 17:00

Fucking hell, OP, you've put far too much thought into this and embellished somewhat. They're toddlers/preschoolers, not Mean Girls 3 wannabes.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 18/10/2021 16:58

Just ask nursery who she plays with the most rather than trying to second guess her.

I dont think 3 year olds have any concept of coolness or trying to get in with a cool crowd though I think they are generally a bit in awe of older kids (though if you're all nct friends the age difference should be negligible)

MadeItOut21 · 18/10/2021 16:57

Errmm she's 3! She doesn't need a party with her friends, just some cake and family. Why start with the bday party stress so early? You have many, many bday parties to organise when she's old enough to remember them

BananaPB · 18/10/2021 16:55

Massively overthinking.

My kids are teens but when they were 3, happily playing alongside another 3 year old and not getting into squabbles with grabbing etc was seen as the sign as friendly behaviour (ie not being antisocial)

Keep the invite list as it is and relax. If your dd becomes closer to the older girls then you can invite them round some time but tell your daughter that invites have been sent so the guest list is final or "maybe next year"

morechocolateneededtoday · 18/10/2021 16:55

She'e 3 not 13.

They don't do 'we're cooler' at that age. Generally those that are older bond better because they are more mature, nothing to do with being cool. DD was advanced in language so she has always bonded with older children. Even now, she has countless friends in years older than her at school. DS not quite the same and bonds better with those his age or younger

For 3rd birthday, DD got a party with NCT friends because those are the parents I knew and easiest to invite. She had been nursery for just 3 months and I hadn't got to know parents yet. She had a brilliant time and so did we

DinaofCloud9 · 18/10/2021 16:54

Toddlers are not cool. Dear me.

Burnerphone21 · 18/10/2021 16:54

Ask the nn for guidance they will tell you

BakedTattie · 18/10/2021 16:53

Eh?

NoKnit · 18/10/2021 16:52

Can't she just pick 3 friends?

If she picks Ann just have her party early before Ann moves. Your daughter is 3 will never know her birthday party was before her birthday or even care.

Fairy cakes, crisps and tea for the mothers. Blow up a few balloons and let them trash your house, every 3 year olds dream. What more do you want to do?

Overthinking way too much and she won't even remember it

doodleygirl · 18/10/2021 16:48

Massive over thinking. Maybe you need to find a hobby to use up your thinking energy Grin

AnEpisodeOfEastenders · 18/10/2021 16:45

No wonder kids these days are so messed up!

ittakes2 · 18/10/2021 16:36

I am guessing she is your first. She is 2 turning 3. She won't even remember this party in the scheme of things - how much could you remember when you were 2/3? Choose whatever option is easiest for you.

Lindy2 · 18/10/2021 16:29

I think you're making it a lot more complicated than it needs to be. I couldn't even follow who was friends with who - but it has been a long day 😂

3 year olds are generally best friends with whomever they're playing with at that exact point in time.

Decide how many people you want there and invite accordingly.

Although it's sad a good friend is moving away at 3 years old she really isn't going to dwell on it. Children are very adaptable and at that age live very much in the moment.

Toottooot · 18/10/2021 16:23

Is a 3 year old even capable of thinking and acting the way you are describing? Nah I don’t think so.

Getyourownback · 18/10/2021 16:21

@highstreetdiestreet

Either my 3 year old is hugely behind, or OP is overthinking A LOT
I thought this. My one doesn’t care about anything like this, let alone have formed deep enough friendships to feel ‘devastated’ they can’t come to a party, or have the awareness and understanding of the concept of someone moving away.
gogohm · 18/10/2021 16:16

She's 3, you are seriously over thinking this! No kid thinks they are the cool ones at 3, she will have forgotten her friend who moved away in days, and she will enjoy her party regardless

AliceinBorderland · 18/10/2021 16:15

I had a tea party at home with just my parents and siblings. I only remember from photos.

Dear me so much drama. It's a 3 year olds party.

CarbonMonoxideParty · 18/10/2021 16:11

Shame you didn't call Ann child 'Candy', for theoretical purposes

Anonymous48 · 18/10/2021 16:10

I think you're way overthinking this!

Crabbitcrab · 18/10/2021 16:10

They are all toddlers invite whoever you want

ANameChangeAgain · 18/10/2021 16:10

Mine would have noticed at 3 if her bf wasn't there. Talk to nursery staff about who she plays with the most, but would just invite everyone.

Twickerhun · 18/10/2021 16:09

‘We’re older and cooler’ AT 3?!

Op chill a bit

Rosebel · 18/10/2021 16:08

Don't invite Suzy and Peppa. They're surely more likely to be mean to her without her best friend there.

Swipe left for the next trending thread