Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

IABU to think there's no way he'd have pulled this if I'd been a man?

142 replies

thepeopleversuswork · 18/10/2021 11:32

There's a guy fixing my boiler atm. I've had no heating or hot water for four days and my child has been ill. So understandably I haven't been overly preoccupied with some (non perishable - old wrapping paper and bin liners type thing) rubbish at the bottom of a storage cupboard which adjoins the place where the boiler is stored which is hardly used. And which in no way impairs his ability to do his job.

But the guy has seen fit to tell me its "pretty disgusting" and I should prioritise cleaning it.

He also twice interrupted me when I was obviously trying to get my child out of the door to school to tell me off for not having moved some bikes from the hallway which he'd only asked me to do five minutes earlier (and which he was perfectly capable of doing himself).

He's also walked into background on a Teams call and started asking me something when I'd told him I was about to join a work call and needed not to be disturbed.

I'm stuck with him now as he needs to finish the boiler but I'm seething and also feel like there's no way on earth he'd have done this if I were a man living on my own. Has anyone else ever successfully dealt with this sort of low level misogynistic shit from people doing jobs in your home without a row?

OP posts:
Zugs · 19/10/2021 02:24

When i had my boiler replaced , i was asked to ensure everything was clear in advance so that the engineer could work. There's gas, water and electricity in one space, the last thing needed is stuff in the way. You do sound like you've not prepared or factored in your time to ensure he has what he needs. When i have a workman in i always expect some time to be devoted to that task and always offer tea/coffee on the way in - just courtesy imo. Never had a problem in 25 years. Treat people the way you would like to be treated, he's not dirt under your feet ("he interrupted me when i was taking kids to school"). He just wants to do the job and get paid. It sounds like you are the nightmare who has not prepared and then wasted his time....surprise surprise he's not the most charming with you. When you go on your Teams call does you client tell you to hang on while they do the school run despite having arranged the call at that time?

BTW - its not a gender thing. People i'm nice to are generally nice back, people who waste my time make me grumpy too. You may think you are the queen of sheba....you're not. Next time try to prepare, allow time to ensure the workman has what he needs and maybe offer tea - you might find a very different interaction.

NotMyCat · 19/10/2021 00:39

@KayKayWat

To be fair, mechanics might take women more seriously if most could do the simplest automotive task like change a tyre. Most of my mates can't even check the oil or top up the coolant.
Don't Grin I work in a dealership and had to ring another part of the building to ask a service advisor if they could top up some screen wash for a customer as they didn't know how In the background is the service manager "is that notmycat? Is it for her car?" I nearly flattened him later as he said "I'm only joking! I know you know how!"

Our dealership is female heavy and any of the men speaking to a woman like they were a child/idiot wouldn't be lasting long

KayKayWat · 18/10/2021 22:47

To be fair, mechanics might take women more seriously if most could do the simplest automotive task like change a tyre. Most of my mates can't even check the oil or top up the coolant.

AnneElliott · 18/10/2021 22:20

I feel your pain op. I think there's a lot of workmen who say stuff like this to women when they wouldn't to a man.

We had a bloke come to fix the boiler a few years ago. The boiler is in the loft (stupid place but it was there when we bought the house). The man that turned up was too fat to get into the loft and they had to send someone else the following day. But this was made out to be my fault somehowHmm.

JumperooSue · 18/10/2021 22:11

My partner dropped my car to the garage for a brake pad change, the plan was I dropped his car there the next morning whilst picking up mine, as his needed a service. My car is the nicer of the two currently, his the run around. I’m women so therefore by default it couldn’t possibly be that I currently have the better car of the two.

Long story short, when I arrived the next morning the car that they had called to say was ready actually wasn’t. When I said they’d called to say it was ready the mechanic almost bent down and lent in towards me like people do to children, hands on his knees and said ‘well my lovely, this is a special car that needs special break pads and they haven’t arrived yet’. I asked him if it also has four wheels and goes vroom vroom🙃

Would he ever had spoke to my partner like that?Of course not!

echt · 18/10/2021 21:59

I literally have never once had a man (and they are almost always men) do work on my home without patronising me about something. And they usually overcharge as well. It's trivial but I'm so tired of it. If you're a woman and live alone you're a sitting target. I'm not even talking about the real cowboys, just the low level shit

I always make bookings in my late DH's name, even manufacture phone calls and leave clothes of his around precisely because I don't want to be ripped off as a woman. No-one's ever been rude, though I like to think it's because they nice, but it may be DH's "presence".

A male neighbour remarked on the sexism his wife encountered in these situations and agreed the sad necessity of my subterfuge. I'm in Australia.

ALongHardWinter · 18/10/2021 21:48

Christ almighty,sounds like the one who was at my house a few weeks back to do my annual boiler service. He needed to access the gas meter in the hall cupboard,and started whingeing about 'all the rubblish in the way'. There was a few rolls of wrapping paper,and an ironing board,none of which were remotely in his way! There was exactly the same stuff there,in the same position,as the year before,when a different engineer did the annual service,and strangely,he didn't have any trouble accessing the meter!

Marvellousmadness · 18/10/2021 21:45

Yabu. Your job to make sure he can access the boiler without a hassle. And its not up to him to move bikes. And really? He is not allowed to ask you anything because you were due for a work call?

And calling it misogyny straight away grinds my gears.. the man might have just been irritated as he deals with customers non compliance everyday doesn't make him a woman hater.

JesusIsAnyNameFree · 18/10/2021 21:39

suspect the people arguing with you are or have some connection to tradesmen

No, I just happen to realise that the boiler man has another house or 5 to get to before he's done with work and I have no right no delay him or fuck over other people who also have lives where they also need to have meetings, pick up their kids or go see their mum and bring her shopping over.

I have an incredibly stressful job. I would jump with joy if I had only 5 hours of meetings. I still realise that I am not above the plumber.

Where are you people getting your tradesmen anyway, the 1950's? All of mine have been a fucking delight, except for the one who pretty much said he wanted to shag me, in not so many words.

symi · 18/10/2021 20:41

I think you’re turning this into something it’s not, kurtney.

I’ve had one fantastic (older) Polish man who fitted the windows. He’s a delight to have in the house - professional and polite. I also once had a young (British) electrician who will definitely go very far as he has a great attitude.

I had the plumber from hell once. Absolute tosser. We have him the contract to do the re-plumbing of a whole renovation. £30k job. He came - put in half a boiler and some pipes. Texting me hourly to show me what he’d done Confused. Basically, he was manic on drugs, as it later turned out. This went on for three days. All the floorboards up so the builders were moaning. One fell through a ceiling! Then - he disappeared for two weeks. Radio silence. After that, he was promising to come every day - “Absolutely... I’m on my way,” But he never showed. In the end, it turned out he’d got a girl pregnant and was “depressed” because she wouldn’t get an abortion of “it.” His mum had called the girl and told her “You’re getting nothing from my boy,” He actually said, “She saw me coming didn’t she - self-employed plumber - kerching,” Hmm He said he was so low he couldn’t get out of bed. He said she would get nothing from him and he wanted nothing to do with “it” ((the baby). He told me this as if I’m meant to feel sorry for him - poor thing - and welcome him back to finish the job after months. He couldn’t believe I hadn’t stalled the whole project to wait for him or that he wouldn’t be paid. No idea. He kept saying, ‘but I was always coming.’ This mentality is everything that is wrong with this country.

KayKayWat · 18/10/2021 20:25

I often think it must be tiresome being spoken down to as a tradesman when you outearn most office workers tbh.

kurtney · 18/10/2021 20:10

@ScienceSensibility I don't think it's me who's had a nerve touched, but do go on with your very condescending manner.

I don't know where you're all finding these misogynistic stereotypical tradesmen, unless it's the 1950's. I've had several trades people in my house over the last decade and they've been nothing but unfailingly polite and respectful of my home. It's so exceedingly unlucky that so many of you keep getting the same sort of bloke to do your jobs, I'd almost suspect that the problem is not them, but you and the way that you treat them.

Of course OP's plumber shouldn't have told her to 'chop, chop' after she hadn't prepared for his visit and his asking her to remove the obstacles in the way of him doing his job, before she fucked off out of the house for 15 minutes. He should have tugged his forelock and begged her most 'umble pardon and apologies for troubling her at all.

symi · 18/10/2021 20:07

A lot of tradesmen wouldn’t last 5 minutes if they worked within an organisation. This is why a lot of them are solo, frankly. I had another one who put some shelves up and drilled through a water pipe. About 2 weeks later the wall was saturated. I called him. He said, “Oh what a shame. I would have loved to help out but I stopped my insurance last month and I can’t give you any money as I don’t have any.” Confused.

These people think there one rule for them and another for everyone else. This one thought that because he didn’t have insurance, paying to repair the damage he had caused was somehow rendered optional. Like a child - this is the mentality.

ScienceSensibility · 18/10/2021 19:58

@kurtney

I suspect the people arguing with you are or have some connection to tradesmen

Or perhaps some of the people realise tradesmen are actually human and not servants for the middle classes to treat like they're Lady of the Manor. Maybe next time, you can tell them to face the wall and never address you when they're in your presence, so you can pretend they don't exist and fairies come in at night to do all the manual labour that's beneath your very important office work.

That’s a bit of a leap! Touched a nerve?

This is nothing to do with class. They are invited into a home to carry out a piece of work. They are ONLY in that home by dint of their trade and the work required by the householder. It doesn’t give them the right to be rude, abusive or misogynistic to the occupants.

As a management consultant, I am invited into a workplace to carry out a piece of work. I do not make rude or personal comments about the client or the workplace. I don’t walk into their board room and plonk my radio on the table at high volume. I don’t hint to other colleagues that they should make me a drink. I don’t comment on what colleagues are wearing. Do you see the parallel? I do hope so.

In context, he who pays the piper calls the tune. That is true of many so called ‘middle-class’ (your words) occupations.

And we haven’t even started on the over-charging or con tricks so prevalent in the building trade.

It’s a complete nightmare OP. Here’s hoping your boiler is fixed and he is gone! I certainly wouldn’t use him again or offer a reference.

knittingaddict · 18/10/2021 19:45

I had a builder complaining that I hadn't cleaned the top of our kitchen wall cabinets. The building work was to include extending the kitchen, during which the ancient kitchen units were being removed and replaced with new. No idea why he thought I should have scrubbed the unseen part of the cupboards first. Idiot.

notacooldad · 18/10/2021 19:44

He sounds like a bully and he definitely wouldn’t have spoken to a man like that, particularly interrupting your Teams meeting
So if op is on really important meetings for up to 5 hrs how is he supposed to get a signature or let her know he is finished?
Bonkers!

Embroidery · 18/10/2021 19:35

practice

Embroidery · 18/10/2021 19:33

Every single time I get a tradesman in they are rude, sexist and patronising. It actually has put me off men.
They are also all conmen. Most of their cons are seen as standard practise.

I've learnt to be quite stern with them recently, but now they just hate me, and say how they dont allow their wives to do that...etc

My recent worktop fitter said his wife wanted the same worktop as he was fitting in my house, but he wouldnt let her!
And thats just the start of it!

FangsForTheMemory · 18/10/2021 19:15

I can sympathise. I've had all kinds of tradesmen doing work on my different homes and while many are great, a lot of them are just arseholes. I end up wondering what their home lives are like. I actually told one recently 'It's my house and I decide what happens here!' because he was whingeing about a minor inconvenience.

Skysblue · 18/10/2021 19:15

He sounds like a bully and he definitely wouldn’t have spoken to a man like that, particularly interrupting your Teams meeting. A journalist actually wrote an article about just this (tradesmen demanding her attention during her work).

That said, you should have made sure the area was clear. Their insurance doesn’t cover them moving householders stuff as you could put a broken bike there, ask him to move it then claim he broke it and demand his insurance cover it…

kurtney · 18/10/2021 19:11

I suspect the people arguing with you are or have some connection to tradesmen

Or perhaps some of the people realise tradesmen are actually human and not servants for the middle classes to treat like they're Lady of the Manor. Maybe next time, you can tell them to face the wall and never address you when they're in your presence, so you can pretend they don't exist and fairies come in at night to do all the manual labour that's beneath your very important office work.

ScienceSensibility · 18/10/2021 19:02

OP, you are definitely NOT being unreasonable.

I suspect the people arguing with you are or have some connection to tradesmen.

I loathe having tradesmen in the house. Especially if DH is not around at the time. I will give them all the time in the world at the quotation stage, firming up the brief and giving them the information they need.

Once they arrive, I expect them to just do the job they are being paid for. That’s it. No loud music, no demands for drinks dressed up as jokes, no telling me how badly previous people have done the job etc etc.
It’s tedious and I’ve heard it all before.

I’m polite, but then I make it clear I am going into my office to work and he should get on with his work.

I find the older, more experienced tradesmen are much more aware of how to conduct themselves in someone’s home. The younger jack-the-lads, not so much.

I am always on the look out for female tradespeople. There’s a massive business opportunity there for someone.

Last time we moved house, we got all the work we wanted doing before we actually moved in. Doesn’t help if you have a boiler emergency like you, OP, but I feel for you.

Anyone telling me to ‘chop chop’ in my own home would quickly find themselves on the other side of the front door. How dare he?

Chimley · 18/10/2021 19:00

I had my entire downstairs remodeled over 5 weeks and literally not once did they say 'chop chop', tell me anything in my house was disgusting or walk in on a Teams call. If my builders/workmen can manage it for 25 days, this gas man can manage it for 1!! YANBU.

mothermothermother · 18/10/2021 18:36

Received quite a lot of infuriating and patronising comments from tradesmen, yep, and usually I don’t let it mess up my day, but sometimes you seem to get one after the other and you can’t help wondering how much easier life would be if you only had a penis when needing something fixed…Angry

JesusIsAnyNameFree · 18/10/2021 18:14

@thepeopleversuswork

You’ve arranged for someone to do work in your home, knowing that you’ve got important calls and can’t be disturbed. That’s poor diarising on your part

I have important calls and can't be disturbed for about five out of every eight hours a day. They are a given of the way I work and I don't get any control over this. And you can't "diarise" a boiler breaking down. It needs fixing it needs fixing. I don't get to take a day off work to deal with this.

5 hours huh? Some have it easy.

Your work is not more important than his. You've hired someone to fix something in your house. Irrelevant if it broke down or not, you still need to be available to assist him with things. Get over yourself.

Swipe left for the next trending thread