Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lying to someone on their deathbed?

205 replies

Nc4post99 · 18/10/2021 11:11

What’s everyone’s take on lying to someone on their death bed? As a general principle and then in this specific incident listed below.

My personal view is it’s wrong, but what about the pretence to make the dying person happy? I still feel this is wrong and shows a lack of respect for the dying person and there are many other ways to leave a loved one with fond memories than a lie.

Person in question lies to a family member on their death bed about gaining a snr military position straight out the gate, bought from eBay the kit to sell the lie. Person In question did not know the family member would die, it v much came out of the blue. Now the family member has passed, the person in question is maintaining the lie and wearing the uniform etc.

Person in question has a history of being a pathological liar and weaving these sort of intricate tales to vulnerable elderly family members and financially gaining due how how ‘proud’ they were of him. I’m talking in the £000s, cars bought etc not a £5/£10 here and there.

OP posts:
RudestLittleMadam · 18/10/2021 12:36

Depends on the lie. Lying to anyone to swindle them is always wrong. Swindling someone who is vulnerable and/or dying is particularly low.

White lies to comfort someone who is dying/close to it I don’t think is wrong. I used to lie to my nan all the time towards the end of her life that she would see my grandad soon/he had popped out and would be back later. (He’d died few years before) She had very advanced dementia and by that time didn’t remember stuff from one minute to the next. It seemed preferable to keep reminding her that the love of her life had died, it seemed too cruel. No regrets for me.

Mamamamasaurus · 18/10/2021 12:35

The dying part is a red herring (I'm not making light of it, just that it's slightly 'irrelevant' on this scenario)

They lied. They've bought 'kit' to perpetrate and backup the lie. It's a lie, straightforward.

There's a huge difference between telling someone in their final hours / days that everything is fine (insert white lie) etc but it's another thing completely to make up something so elaborate if they didn't know the person was going to pass away. What would have happened had they not passed, I assume they would've kept up the pretence?

Nc4post99 · 18/10/2021 12:32

@Laiste

He's maintaining the lie with his WIFE?????!
Well she’s either in on it, or she’s being duped too…. I don’t know her well enough either way. Meant to put soon to be wife. Apologies, they aren’t married yet.
OP posts:
Nc4post99 · 18/10/2021 12:31

What’s everyone’s thoughts on the nature of this specific lie, ie fabricating a snr military rank (tbh alarm bells sounded for me when I heard this as the lie was the person was the rank of lieutenant as an entry level role with no military experience at all and with less than 6 weeks training, hadnt had the welcoming ceremony yet had been issued with the full uniform, that he was wearing, the uniform also looked old) to some one on their death bed? Even if the lie wasn’t being maintained now? I still think this kind of lie is disgraceful, especially because it had been attempted by the individual before

OP posts:
Laiste · 18/10/2021 12:30

He's maintaining the lie with his WIFE?????!

Laiste · 18/10/2021 12:29

As you say ''white'' lies - fine.

But this is on a different scale! Is this deceptive person a close relative OP? Are you going to challenge them?

LadyCatStark · 18/10/2021 12:25

It’s despicable to take the glory of being in the armed forces without the risk. I’d assume he must have serious mental health problems to maintain this lie.

AdmiralCain · 18/10/2021 12:24

@Nc4post99 Thank you, you phrased that a million times better than I could have done.

PumpkinPie2016 · 18/10/2021 12:20

The specific situation you describe is absolutely wrong on every level. More because the person is continuing the lie, impersonating senior military personnel and potentially committing a crime than lying itself.

Telling a dying person an innocent white lie to avoid distress is a different matter. When my Nan was dying (in her last two weeks) she told me that she felt that I was going to have another baby and it was going to be a girl (I have a son already whom she adored). I have absolutely no idea where she got that from as we had spoken many times about the fact that I wasn't having more and she had always supported that.

However, I just nodded along with her because I didn't have the heart to tell her it wasn't happening given that her time was almost at an end. I wonder in part if she was remembering when my grandad died. He died young and at the time, my mum was in the early stages of pregnancy with my younger sister. I look very much like my mum and was a similar age to what she would have been so maybe it was that.

Either way, no harm done, although there is still no baby, girl or otherwise!

Nc4post99 · 18/10/2021 12:15

@AdmiralCain

On My Dad's deathbed I told him every and I mean EVERY little shitty I'd ever done, every secret, every immoral thing. I cried my eyes out, I wasn't after forgiveness and I wasn't trying to disappoint him by making out he'd done a bad job and raised me wrong. I just couldn't let him go, he was my best friend and I had to tell him the truth as that's how he raised me. It takes a special kind of scum to lie to someone on their deathbed.
That’s like me @AdmiralCain. I thought too much of the deceased to ever lie to them. I’d have rather theyd be proud of me for who I was, than for a work of fiction.

The maintenance of the lie concerns me, but this person despite their problematic and actually v violent past behaviour is still viewed favourably in the family, so I’m not sure talking to anyone will do any good. It’s the potential for legal consequences, the person in questions wife (whom he is maintaining the lie with also), their family and elder members of their family and additional further more vulnerable members of his family

OP posts:
Bagelsandbrie · 18/10/2021 12:11

Yeah that’s weird and wrong.

My now ex fil shook hands with the brother he hated in front of his dying mum to show them they’d made up (they hadn’t spoken in years). They left the room and never spoke again - but their Mum died happy! I think that sort of thing is okay.

Nc4post99 · 18/10/2021 12:10

Again distinction between white lies to protect someone from something really devastating, esp when things like dementia come into play. That’s unequivocally the right thing to do.

To me this specific situation is different than saying ‘i got the job’ to someone on their deathbed rather than saying you haven’t heard back or didnt get it you know, whilst i wouldn’t do it myself, i probably wouldn’t bring it up but I’d never feel it was morally wrong. This person has never been in the military at all, they had actually pretended to join before when they lived in their parental home, took money from parents for uniform and training (but actually went on holiday) then the lie came out but the parents forgave, as the person in question was 19/20 at the time

OP posts:
ZealAndArdour · 18/10/2021 12:04

My younger sibling died about 6 months before my grandma did. She’d lost her husband the previous year and hadn’t coped very well.

We never told her about my brother, we didn’t think she’d be able to cope with the news of her grandson dying so it was easier for her (but certainly not us) to keep up the pretence that he was still away at university. She had Alzheimer’s.

Every family must do what is right for them and the person concerned and to hell with blanket applications of morals/what is seen as right.

Fallagain · 18/10/2021 12:02

There is a difference between telling a person on their death bed that you have been promoted and another thing entirely maintaining the lie.

suspiria777 · 18/10/2021 11:59

When my grandma was dying (it was a "short illness"), I had recently submitted my PhD and was waiting for my viva -- but the rest of my family started calling me "doctor" and told my grandmother that I'd passed AND had a book contract already. This was about a two weeks before she died.

It was easier to go along with it than correct her or try to explain how I had completed the PhD but didn't have it yet, or how I had essentially written a book but didn't actually have a contract with a UP -- I was the first person in my family to even finish secondary school, so the differences between A levels and degrees and a PhD and how books get published in academia were beyond their experience.

Still haven't got around to submitting my book proposal, even several years later...

Nc4post99 · 18/10/2021 11:59

Few PPs have made the distinction between a soft white lie, ie not mentioning a pet has died, that’s a good point. It’s even something I did with my late grandma, I didn’t say my dog had died as I didn’t want to upset her given her circumstances. I was more thinking larger lies, but you’re spot on in those instances little white lies to not worry someone at a time like that is clearly the better thing to do.

With regards to how I know it was bought online on eBay, it’s because that probably one of the only ways you could get a military uniform without being part of the military, although I suppose you could get them from shop, but internet seems the most likely for ease.

The deathbed thing is an issue for me, because of the nature of the lie and how elaborate it is, bringing props etc. To me it shows a total disrespect and disregard for the dying individual who was a very honest person and would be ‘proud’ no matter what. I’m also concerned if this was a ‘play’ that the individual had started before the deceased’s health started to decline.

I’ve googled it and I’m not sure stolen valour is a crime In the Uk, definitely is in the US.

OP posts:
UnsolicitedDickPic · 18/10/2021 11:53

Depending on what the lie was, I can sympathise entirely with someone lying to a person on their deathbed. But this situation isn't a white lie: it's fraud, and honestly pretty disgusting.

AdmiralCain · 18/10/2021 11:52

On My Dad's deathbed I told him every and I mean EVERY little shitty I'd ever done, every secret, every immoral thing. I cried my eyes out, I wasn't after forgiveness and I wasn't trying to disappoint him by making out he'd done a bad job and raised me wrong. I just couldn't let him go, he was my best friend and I had to tell him the truth as that's how he raised me. It takes a special kind of scum to lie to someone on their deathbed.

Steppenwolfshit · 18/10/2021 11:48

It's "Stolen Valour" -- it is abhorent and
disrespectful to the real military members
and higher ranks.

It's illegal.

It's criminal fraud; and it's disgusting.

AdobeWanKenobi · 18/10/2021 11:47

My take would be to drop these guys a message personally...

thewaltercumpershunterclub.wordpress.com

SickAndTiredAgain · 18/10/2021 11:39

The specific situation you’ve described sounds bizarre and beyond any kind of “normal” lie you might tell.
So leaving that aside, I disagree strongly with your view that it is always wrong to lie. I would be totally fine keeping bad news from them, and lying that I/a particular situation was ok if I/it wasn’t. My aim would be to provide comfort and minimise distress. If someone is going to die within a day or two, what use is bad news.

M0rT · 18/10/2021 11:35

As pp say, lying to give peace and claim all is well so the dying person isn't worrying about a loved one is fine.
Your person is just a scam artist.

SoniaFouler · 18/10/2021 11:35

I don’t get it. How do you know he bought the kit from Ebay but nobody else does?

ineedsun · 18/10/2021 11:33

Seems to me like the deathbed lie is not the primary issue here, it’s all the other stuff which is odd.

10yearwarranty · 18/10/2021 11:32

Impersonating most uniformed officers can be an actual offence, depending on what the person doing the impersonation does while in the uniform.