Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Different to touch a mans pecs to a woman's breasts?

246 replies

imamearcat · 17/10/2021 23:56

Did anyone see the thing where a woman touched 'Gastons' chest at Disney land?

I got into a bit of an argument on Facebook about it with people saying it was the same as a man touching someone's breasts. I just don't think it's the same at all. Not saying it's right, but not the same.

AIBU?

OP posts:
SleepingStandingUp · 18/10/2021 18:37

Nonsense.
Women get grabbed all the time. Esp when working in certain types of costume/ attire.
And if a video went viral of a woman having her arse grabbed by a friendly laughing bloke there's no way he wouldn't be ripped apart as a sexual predator abusing women and if he'd do that they're what would he do given the chance. Only a small proportion of people would think it's ok to touch a woman like that vs a large proportion thinking this guy should man up, enjoy it, asking for it etc

NiceGerbil · 18/10/2021 17:42

@BillMasen

And (sorry) I do t think anyone is saying we have it worse. Absolutely we do not. Women have the impact of a sexual assault coupled with the fear and threat to their safety. We don’t (usually) have the latter. That doesn’t make the former funny or fine.
But it's the same. You just pointed out a counter example to prove that.

To what PP said happened to her.

And that's fine obv but then straight away saying it's not the same I don't get!

(Fradishes- it really hurts when they do it hard as well. Same with other stuff we're told to laugh off/ don't make a fuss. Eg hard slap or pinch to arse. I once had a man force my mouth open by shoving his finger hard into the hinges of my jaw a bit like when the vet gives a cat a tablet to keep their mouths open. Anyway he had a big old tonguey slobber in my mouth. My jaw was sore for days after that).

DillonPanthersTexas · 18/10/2021 14:55

Plenty saying men and boys have it worse

I'm pretty sure that has not been the case at all on this thread. Just lots of people recognising that non consensual touching of a man by a women in a sexual manner is wrong.

OneTC · 18/10/2021 14:31

Something can be wrong without having to draw an equivalence that minimises sex offences against women and girls.

Drawing an equivalence is only minimising it if you personally see what happened to him as being a minor infringement though surely?

BillMasen · 18/10/2021 14:07

And (sorry) I do t think anyone is saying we have it worse. Absolutely we do not. Women have the impact of a sexual assault coupled with the fear and threat to their safety. We don’t (usually) have the latter. That doesn’t make the former funny or fine.

BobMortimersPetOwl · 18/10/2021 14:06

Of course its the same, as its uninvited and unwanted touching. People should keep their hands to themselves. Granted, its probably less sexual in nature but neither should happen and neither are OK.

BillMasen · 18/10/2021 14:05

And by the way what happened to you was totally unacceptable and in no way your fault.

Just as when I had my genitals grabbed at school by a bunch of girls at 14

Or a couple of years ago while gigging.

BillMasen · 18/10/2021 14:03

@Fradishes I’m not sure people are saying it’s exactly the same. Maybe some but the majority seem to say it’s different but also unacceptable

Just like a woman having her breasts touched is different to her arm stroked. Both unacceptable if not wanted, possibly both sexual in motive but yes, different.

I don’t think the equivalency means reporting both/all types in the same way. It means seeing both as unacceptable and not “just a laugh” or “fine because he’s bigger”

VeganCheesePlease · 18/10/2021 13:58

[quote imamearcat]@ABCeasyasdohrayme because there was obviously no threat to his safety, I think. I do think it was wrong of her but i don't feel he would be threatened in the same way a woman would feel having a random guy touch her boobs. [/quote]
If a man means no threat to my safety but touches any part of me without me wanting him to, that doesn't make it OK.
Doesn't make this OK either.

Fradishes · 18/10/2021 13:57

Literally no one has said the woman’s behaviour is acceptable and there are lots of examples of women behaving in a grim and quite possibly illegal way towards men’s bodies. However, the question was is touching a woman’s breasts the same as touching a mans chest. Now lots of people are saying it is and in fact any unwanted touching on any part of the body should be treated exactly the same.

This is why I have a problem with that. Like many girls I was groped by a stranger. I was 14, walking with a friend in the middle along a busy road. A man ran up to me, grabbed my breasts hard and then ran off. I didn’t make a fuss, I was scared and didn’t want to draw any attention to myself and then I think we were just so relieved he had gone and not done anything else. This was in the80s, it didn’t occur to me to report it to the police. In any case I felt it was probably my fault anyway for having too big breasts and a slightly low cut top. So I think a lot about this incident still, still with a sense of shame. And I know now that the man who did it could well have been working up to more serious assaults, and I believe it should be a police matter. So I really would have hoped that things would be different now - after MeToo - that if anything similar happened to my daughter or her friends they would feel able to go to the police and in an ideal world the assailant would be caught and charged.

But, if we say that all inappropriate touching, on any part of the body, experienced by a man or woman in any place or context, should be treated in exactly the same way - then how could that happen? The police would simply be overwhelmed. How would they have the resources to catch such a man, if they would have to go out to a call for any unwanted physical contact, whether an over familiar stranger on a bus misguidedly touching someone’s arm, or an accidental brush up against someone in a shop or bar..there would simply be no way for them to prioritise.

So in this world it would be highly unlikely for anything to happen differently - no police, no reporting. Because it’s unacceptable to say that a man grabbing a woman’s sexual anatomy can actually be different to other forms of unwanted physical contact.

Porcupineintherough · 18/10/2021 13:56

@user1473878824

It’s unwanted contact with a sexual meaning. So yes, it’s the same. You don’t touch anyone like that without consent.
^^This. I dont think it is ok to touch another person like that even if they dont feel unsafe, feeling uncomfortable is enough.
BillMasen · 18/10/2021 13:56

@NiceGerbil I don’t think anyone is minimising offences against women and girls. This is a thread about unwanted sexual contact by a woman on a man. Most have said it’s not acceptable and a few of us have mentioned our experiences.

NiceGerbil · 18/10/2021 13:52

For girls, school uniform is a magnet for creeps.

I raised the issue of men touching boys/ men sexually but only one reply. That's a worry as is incredibly rarely even mentioned.

NiceGerbil · 18/10/2021 13:50

@ANameChangeAgain

He was at work and she had no right to touch him. If he patted her backside, which is probably the closest equivalent, then all hell would have broken loose.
Nonsense.

Women get grabbed all the time. Esp when working in certain types of costume/ attire.

NiceGerbil · 18/10/2021 13:49

This woman is totally out of order.

The idea that it's not seen as funny by esp men in the most common places it happens pubs clubs when women are felt up is very strange. And the idea that everyone goes omg etc is strange as well.

Women and girls are expected not to make a fuss/ laugh it off. IME.

And the dynamic is different. Rather than helping men - even though the vast majority on this thread have said they see what she did as totally out of order.

It seems to feel more like minimising sexual harrassment/assault against women and girls.

Plenty saying men and boys have it worse. And those saying hold on dynamics etc are being told they are apologists for sexual harrassment/assault.

Something can be wrong without having to draw an equivalence that minimises sex offences against women and girls.

ANameChangeAgain · 18/10/2021 13:48

He was at work and she had no right to touch him. If he patted her backside, which is probably the closest equivalent, then all hell would have broken loose.

NiceGerbil · 18/10/2021 13:41

I can't understand this determination to draw equivalence.

NiceGerbil · 18/10/2021 13:40

Sometimes it is and sometimes it isn't.

Surely that's obvious?

NiceGerbil · 18/10/2021 13:39

Groping isn't threatening in and of itself?

That's not true at all.

FaceForRadio1973 · 18/10/2021 13:29

There's a common theme on here about women's breasts being more sexualised then men's. That's no doubt true, certainly by men.

However, I would have to wonder how many women would want to touch a man's chest unless they find it sexually alluring in some way?

ConstanceGracy · 18/10/2021 13:26

.. and either way it’s not on.
She’s an idiot.

ConstanceGracy · 18/10/2021 13:23

Yabvu.
She should not have touched him anywhere and I’m glad he told her to get lost, it’s a family park not a bar

Simonjt · 18/10/2021 13:14

@CounsellorTroi

I find it bizarre that people are going on about him being bigger and stronger. He was working. His size and strength were irrelevant. He couldn’t just walk away.
I wonder what size someone has to be for sexual assault to become okay.
WhoWearsShortShorts · 18/10/2021 12:59

The apologists aren't going to like this but it doesnt actually matter how big and strong he is - in that situation the woman is in the position of power as she is the customer. What if his employers minimised his experience to the extent some of you lot are? He could lose his job if he doesn't handle it properly.

CuckooCall · 18/10/2021 12:53

@DillonPanthersTexas

Also perpetuates the notion that there is no such thing as unwanted sexual attention from women as far as men are concerned, that they are always “up for it”.

Spot on.

Men from a young age are conditioned to laugh it off or not complain out of fear or derision from both their peer group and the woman doing the groping.

Attitudes are changing (as evidenced by the comments on this thread) but there is still very much a view amongst a sizable minority of women that unwanted sexual touching of men is not as serious an issue or should be taken as a compliment or a joke. Anecdotally, pretty much all my male friends have been grabbed in nightclubs or bars at some point and most of the time it is just met with a shrug because what can you do? Nobody is going to take a complaint seriously. On the rare occasions that I have verbally responded with a weary ‘fck off’ when a woman has grabbed my cock as she walked past me in a club I have been accosted by her mates for having ‘a problem’ or my personal favourite ‘are you fcking gay’.

In my early 20s I used to work in a certain south coast bar popular with hen and stag dos and it would seem that for hen do’s grabbing or kissing blokes without consent was part of the standard ‘dare’ rituals that such occasions promote. The male bar staff were always getting propositioned to snog the bride, getting ‘felt up’ for a laugh or being asked to handover their pants as part of some game challenge, refusal to comply was often met with abuse. Unsurprisingly the women staff were subject to unwanted touching too but security would remove the individuals or groups responsible without question, the men just had to ‘deal with it’.

When I played rugby it was not uncommon for some women to enter the men’s changing rooms from the bar area post game and ogle at the blokes in the showers or try and rip the towels off players, they were quickly shown the door but such actions were dismissed as ‘funny’ and there were zero consequences. I knew quite a few team mates who were very self conscious and pissed off over these changing room invasions.

I get there is a whole raft of different power dynamics at play with regards to the very real consequences of actual physical harm depending on whether it is a women or a man dealing with unwanted sexual attention. Sadly there are too many men out there who will respond with violence towards a woman who has the audacity to object to being sexually harassed. Equally there seems to be a complete dismissal by some that women to men sexual harassment is even a thing and I have certainly seen on these forums in the past the mocking ‘what about the poor menz’ comments when anyone dares raises the subject.

Great post and sums up the issue perfectly.
Swipe left for the next trending thread