“I was pulling up the poster who claimed to be "skint" on £10k a month due to private school, big houses and holidays. That is what I'm referring to as being tone deaf.”
I understand that and apologies for misinterpreting your previous post.
However, on the private school issue, it’s not as straightforward as you make out. There are areas of London where people are living in £10 million houses which are adjacent to council estates. I think K&C is one if the most unequal boroughs in the U.K, but it’s not the only one. So, correspondingly, the schools reflect this gap. ‘Comprehensives’ are not really ‘comprehensive’ as they tend to attract children from deprived backgrounds only. Those who can will pay for schools, Some of the top schools in the U.K. stand alongside some if the most problematic ones. So it’s a stark choice and those you can afford to pay will tend to do just that. If there was a good suburban comprehensive or grammar locally, they wouldn’t have bothered. Some people are simply paying school fees because they dint want their kids in a school where knife crime is rife.
Paying school fees in London is no different to paying hundreds of thousands in stamp duty to move to a house in the catchment for a good school. Its swings and roundabouts and either way, you are paying up.
The more people go private in a given area, the less is the need for the government to build new schools or extend state provision in that area. So it all becomes a self-fulfilling cycle. Where I live, if all the people who used private schools suddenly put their kids into state schools, the system would collapse overnight. Pupils can’t get state places as it is! You can only put your kids in state schools if the state schools actually have places!
In the independent schools yes, there will be very wealthy families. But equally, there will be those who struggle to pay the fees and have to make concessions elsewhere. London life is expensive. The price of housing is on a different scale. A small one bed flat will be £500k (and that would be over a shop). Salaries that provide a comfortable life in other parts of the country won’t go far in this context. It’s all relative. And it’s no use saying, “Well just move to the Outer Hebrides then,” because people work where they work and have made lives where they live. You wouldn’t tell someone struggling in Wales to move to Albania because their money would go further there! People make decisions on the context of where they live and this affects whether you ‘feel’ wealthy or not.