Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If one person in the house is on a particular diet, should everyone else be on it too?

134 replies

Margotshypotheticaldog · 17/10/2021 18:37

It's for health reasons, this person is overweight and sedentary. They currently do none of the cooking or shopping. They can't have takeaways, sweets, chocolates etc. We're not a very sweet tooth house but do get takeaway occasionally. Dinners cooked 6 days a week from scratch reasonably healthy, meat, fish veg etc. If this person now wants to go on a specialist diet, should they source and cook for themselves or do I have to do it basically?? (I'm refusing. That's the Aibu)

OP posts:
Margotshypotheticaldog · 17/10/2021 18:55

I do always cook from scratch, it's not very exotic or exciting but healthy enough imo. I have no problem keeping treats out of the house, in fact I rarely buy them it's usually him. The kids and I are already v active. He's the only one who needs to make lifestyle change as far as I'm concerned.

It took me Years to get my power back in this relationship. He has always expected a service wife and in recent years I have successfully changed the dynamics. But I'm hyper hyper alert to falling back into old habits.

OP posts:
Notimeforaname · 17/10/2021 18:55

My father has never cooked a meal for his wife or children EVER in his life.

If my mum isnt here he will make fried/boiled eggs and toast. Or get a takeaway on his way home from work of she is not there to cook his dinner.

He has NEVER gone food shopping ever .
Except for picking up a litre of milk In the corner shop very occasionally if mum forgot.

He now has extremely high cholesterol and my mother who is in her 60s has spent the last week meal planning, researching foods and wondering if 'he'll eat this or not'' and generally treating him like the child he is. The man can do nothing for himself at 63 and needs her to keep him healthy. More fool her.

You need to not become my mother.

Make him shop and do his own meal plans.

LesterKnopf · 17/10/2021 18:54

Can you say you would be happy to make some changes (decide beforehand what seems doable) if he does the same? For example, he starts walking to places short distances away like he would normally drive to? Or he goes out for a 20 minute walk each evening while you cook his new recipes? He may be unreasonable and expect you to make all the changes while he does nothing but at least you have offered a good deal before refusing completely.

Banani · 17/10/2021 18:54

There’s a middle ground, no not everyone has to bend and eat the ‘specialist diet’, but some compromises and meals that can be adapted should be possible. And being mindful of what you’re eating around the person dieting is helpful, although of course there’s no obligation.
The split of housework and cooking is another matter though and not acceptable.

WormYourHonour · 17/10/2021 18:53

Quite apart from why you're with this fucking idiot, the whole diet thing is nonsense.

Grown adults can choose what they eat and when. If he wants to Diet, he can diet, you're a grown adult and need no permission to eat whatever you want.

Don't stay with him for much longer though, leave him to eat what he wants.

TheLastLonelyBakedBeanInTheTin · 17/10/2021 18:53

A celiac child or anyone with a serious allergy? Yes. An adult who wants to lose a few lbs? No.

Seasidemumma77 · 17/10/2021 18:53

In my house I always cater for food allergies, and try to remember any particular favourite/loathed foods/dishes. On the whole we eat balanced/nutritious food within my budget. This year I had one ds on a high protein diet (weight lifting) and another ds getting ready to join the army. Both ds financially contributed for the additional costs, helped with the shopping, and also cooked some of the evening meals. Myself and other dc happily ate the food they prepared, and now sharing responsibility for shopping and cooking has become the norm in my house.

FleasInMyKnees · 17/10/2021 18:53

How old are the dc. Does he care that he is shortening his life and that the kids would love him to be healthy and join in with family activities. .

legalseagull · 17/10/2021 18:52

I'd go so far as to stop buying sweets and chocolate but I won't stop meals. My DH says every week that he wants to buy healthy food and criticises what I buy in the food shop. "Why have you bought a pie?!" I've bought what he wanted before but he keeps buying sweets and booze through the week! He makes no effort to think of healthy meals or to stick to a diet so fuck it. If he looked after himself for a while I'd be more inclined to jump on the band wagon with him. Myself and the kids are a healthy weight

clockover · 17/10/2021 18:51

Whoever does the cooking on any particular night cooks whatever anyone is having. We don't always eat the same meals. It has never been an issue.

NormanStangerson · 17/10/2021 18:51

He sounds like a fat, lazy twat. And you sound deeply unhappy. You know what you have to do.

CiaoForDiNiaoSaur · 17/10/2021 18:51

Depends. Would the diet change still make "family friendly" meals that everyone will eat? Will the new regime be a lot more work?
The fact you do all the cooking is the problem imo. You both work full time, you should share the household load.

We have various dietary requirements in our house. I try and make everyone the same meal, or at least a variation of.
But I'm the only adult so most of the cooking falls to me. (Teen dc so they can cook)

MatildaIThink · 17/10/2021 18:50

No, one householders "diet" should not force the others to change, unless we are taking severe allergies.

NotSoNewAndShiny · 17/10/2021 18:50

Second time today the OP posts more information while I'm typing and I see it after I've posted. I should type quicker I think.Grin

Dixiechickonhols · 17/10/2021 18:49

Depends how specialist. If it’s just slimming world or cc then there’s no harm in rest of you eating same dinner. Slimming foodie and pinch of nom books have lots of nice family friendly meals around 500 cals.
It is hard if you are dieting and everyone else having a takeaway. Is compromise you get a healthier option or they cook that night. Some great fakeaway options.
If you can’t be bothered cooking from scratch daily and usually have convenience food/ready meals suggest they cook or batch cook to replace that.
If it’s for health you’ll all benefit if they are healthier eg able to go on family walks etc.
sweets/choc - keep your stash separate and I’d try not to eat in front of them. I used to go for an evening walk when they were snacking.

Margotshypotheticaldog · 17/10/2021 18:47

Oh and I wanted to cut back on my drinking a few years ago and asked him not to bring booze into the house. He said no, he likes a beer at the weekend to relax.

OP posts:
FleasInMyKnees · 17/10/2021 18:47

If you cook healthy meals already then theres no need to change anything. Dont buy him alcohol or treats. Does he get a meal at work. He is an adult and needs to take responsibility for his own health. I am sure his doctor has said the same.

NotSoNewAndShiny · 17/10/2021 18:47

Should everyone in the house go on a diet as well or stop eating what they like? No.

Should everyone in the house be mindful of eating 'tempting' food around this person, assuming they care about this person and want to help him/her however they can? Yes.

Should this person sort out his/her meals since it's different from the regular meals, assuming this person is a fully capable adult? Yes.

If someone else does the food shopping, could s/he buy food ingredients for the person on a diet, since s/he's out shopping anyway? Yes, if they want to be helpful.

CherieBabySpliffUp · 17/10/2021 18:46

Short answer...if they are an adult then they can cook for themselves.
Long answer... it depends. Have you normally done all the cooking? How out there is this new regime? Would it benefit your health to incorporate some of it into your diet?

Margotshypotheticaldog · 17/10/2021 18:45

Alot of crossed posts there. Do I like or love him? That's another days work.
Will look into possible saucepan allergy, as that would also explain inability to load or empty the dishwasher....

OP posts:
Northofsomewhere · 17/10/2021 18:45

I'd probably try and find a way to make it work for everyone if possible. For example if they're wanting a reduced calorie diet I'd try and create the same meal for everyone but with subtle changes to the lower calorie one like less of certain items (lower carb but more fiber etc). They might find it less tasty if they miss out on a sauce or something (that is essentially nutritionally null but adds calories) but it's the effort to try and offer a similar meal that's important. If they were starting to be picky or complain by offering wasn't good enough they'd very quickly be told to cook for themselves though.

CovidCorvid · 17/10/2021 18:44

Nobody should be doing all the cooking regardless of any restrictions.

Whether the non diet person would/should/could cook as per the restrictions on the days they cook would depend how much the other person found the food to be. But people don’t have to eat the same.

So for instance I will sometimes cook vegetarian food for everyone even though I’m not vegetarian. But sometimes I cook something different. People don’t have to eat the same. Dh is vegetarian and to be honest I leave him to fend for himself most of the time…..he doesn’t like my cooking even when it’s vegi and he eats about 9pm where I eat about 5pm!

Margotshypotheticaldog · 17/10/2021 18:43

It's oh. We have a strained relationship. He has high blood pressure as a result of poor lifestyle. The kids and I are active and none of us have high blood pressure. He expects a particular level of service that I am increasingly unwilling to provide. He almost never cooks or shops, but has been googling healthy menus and suggestions for me to cook. We both work full time. I have a meal plan system that works for me and the kids for the week and I don't want to change it. I think he just needs to get more exercise and drink less. The food I cook is fine, he needs to make lifestyle changes.

OP posts:
PeachesPumpkin · 17/10/2021 18:43

Generally if you like/love this person I would say yes to support them.
Of course if you don’t like them, then you won’t want to.
It’s really impossible to say 100% though, as I don’t know the details of the diet or the person - is it your housemate or partner? If partner then yes, if housemate then no.

CloseYourEyesAndSee · 17/10/2021 18:42

Presumably your husband is overweight and has no willpower so expects you all to live without treats in the house because he can't control himself?

Swipe left for the next trending thread