Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not want my brothers very nice new girlfriend to meet my newborn?

182 replies

ArranMumma · 17/10/2021 18:16

My brother has been in a relationship with his new girlfriend for probably about 4 months now. I’ve met her a handful of times and she seems very nice. I’m quite a shy person and I’ve really struggled with anxiety during my pregnancy (whole host of reasons.. broke up with my baby’s dad, ended up back at my parents and unsure of where I could live, being in a shit financial situation as I got pregnant as a uni student, blah blah blah). Because I’ve been so sad, stressed and anxious, I haven’t been particularly friendly or made much effort to get to know her. Ive not been rude but I also just felt unable to pretend to be chirpy and happy when half the time I felt like I wanted to crawl under a rock and never been seen by anyone ever again. So anyway, I’m doing better now and starting to feel more myself but I’m well aware that I haven’t made the best impression to her, and that no doubt she thinks I’m a boring, moody cow.

My baby is due next month and of course my brother wants to come and visit. I feel a bit awkward around his new girlfriend, because I am shy and also because I know I’ve not made a good impression, and because of this I’d rather he just come by himself to see the baby - at first anyway! Of course not forever.

If I asked him not to bring her, I think he would be a bit confused and offended as she hasn’t actually done anything wrong. Although I’d prefer her not to be there, so I can just relax, I also don’t just want to be a dick. I have a feeling that I am being unreasonable to be fair, and am probably just causing a weird atmosphere for no reason ...

What do you guys think? Ask him to come by himself at first or stop being selfish and just let her come with?

OP posts:
Pinkhedgehog · 18/10/2021 06:52

@lilcolibri

aww OP.

You sound a lot like me with the anxiety, based on that you asking your brother to come alone sounds like it could trigger more anxiety for you later on -- because then you'll be fretting about this and any falling out with your brother and his gf.

So based on that I'd invite them both, swallow the anixety as best you can if only so you're not extra stressed about when her first visit actually is.

Exactly.

Avoiding things when you're anxious just makes the anxiety worse. Just look up the anxiety cycle.

Especially if your brother IS offended. It'll make it harder when she finally does come round and you'll feel more anxious about it.

Whatever people on here say, it will come across as strange not to allow someone to pop by for a short time a few days after having your baby.

Just limit the time they're there and say you might need a bit of help with making the tea and clearing up etc. and it'll be over before you know it.

YourFinestPantaloons · 17/10/2021 22:18

The days and weeks immediately following giving birth is not the time to "being open to building a relationship" with people who you may well never cross paths with again

Derbee · 17/10/2021 22:05

This anti “be nice” thing is getting out of hand. Be selfish, self centred, don’t worry about anyone who you might hurt or upset, because nobody matters, and social niceties aren’t important, and fuck the patriarchy. It’s all a bit silly. You can be polite, and open to building a relationship with your brothers girlfriend without it meaning that you’re a pushover or visiting after a baby is some circus show.

Everyone should just chill out a bit, and stop making a massive deal out of things that don’t need to be a big deal

MrsMiddleMother · 17/10/2021 21:34

Of course you're not being unreasonable, it's entirely up to YOU who meets your newborn baby and why.

LadyCleathStuart · 17/10/2021 21:20

BIL brought his girlfriend of all of 5 mins who I had met very briefly only a week before, to visit my newborn DS in the hospital about 2 hours after I had my cesarean so I was lying there with numb legs, huge maternity pad stuffed under me and with catheter still in - the works.

It would have been horribly awkward if there wasn't a snuggly newborn taking all of the attention off of me.

I agree with the pp's who say use the new baby to cover any awkwardness and also as a good excuse to cut short any visit.

amazeandastonish · 17/10/2021 21:17

Hi OP, your brother's girlfriend could become a good friend which is what you may need. You need family around you and you don't want to upset your brother. You've had a bit of a shit time of it and I think your anxiety is affecting your perception of things. Have you spoken to your doctor or HV about how you are feeling and gotten some support there?

Mellowyellow222 · 17/10/2021 21:05

When my Best friend had her baby her brother was dating a girl she didn’t get on with.

The girlfriend made a huge point of visiting in the hospital calling herself auntie x and was in the first family
Pictures with the new baby.

They broke up two months later.

Brother is now raging that he let her take over so much.

People date, she might not be around in a few months. Tell your brother you are exhausted, keep visits short. But be hie at - it’s fine if you want some time with just your brother and not ‘visiting’ with a girl you don’t really know. But have a short visit with her.

TonTonMacoute · 17/10/2021 20:54

Explain your feelings to your brother and discuss with him how best to handle this, rather than a bunch of strangers on an Internet forum..

There is no right or wrong answer - he knows you and his GF best. Ask for his help and understanding, I'm sure he will want to do what's best for everyone and will know what to do.

YourFinestPantaloons · 17/10/2021 20:54

@Thepennysjustdropped

Re the being shy, you may feel differently after the baby is born. It's such a big thing in your life and feels like such an achievement that everything else seems to lose its importance, and you may find you really don't mind. I would meet them both for a quick cuppa and then say you're feeling tired.
Yes but it doesn't happen overnight. I've definitely grown in confidence since having kids, I used to be very shy but it was a slow process, not a flick of a switch.
Thepennysjustdropped · 17/10/2021 20:52

Re the being shy, you may feel differently after the baby is born. It's such a big thing in your life and feels like such an achievement that everything else seems to lose its importance, and you may find you really don't mind. I would meet them both for a quick cuppa and then say you're feeling tired.

NewlyGranny · 17/10/2021 20:47

OP's DB and his GF do not understand from experience that giving birth is a bit like being hit by a truck.

If anyone - anyone! - tries to muscle in, just ask them how they'd feel about visitors trooping in if they'd just been run over. 🤷🏼‍♀️

Boundaries!

Temple29 · 17/10/2021 20:43

I would tell your brother that you only want family members/close friends to visit you and baby in the first few weeks because it’s a vulnerable time etc. And suggest he bring his girlfriend along when you’ve had time to get settled.

My brother called me when I was on the way home from the hospital after having DS1 saying he would be at my house with his girlfriend when I arrived home. I said absolutely not (after 8 days in hospital) because I was in no fit state to make small talk with someone I don’t know very well.

YourFinestPantaloons · 17/10/2021 20:43

The OP would be a cow for not inviting a practical stranger to meet her newborn?

What?

Wonder if she'd have got different responses of it was her sister's boyfriend rather than her brother's girlfriend?

Would that make her a cow not wanting a strange man in her home postpartum?

SpuduIika · 17/10/2021 20:43

Look, you ultimately get to decide on who comes into your home and gets to interact with you and your baby.

What is your fear, though? What are you afraid will happen if she visits?

Lalliella · 17/10/2021 20:41

@DockOTheBay

If you're worried that she doesn't like you because of the way you have acted when you've met before, why would you want to further alienate her? She probably doesn't think you're a cow, its easy to overthinkk these things, but she probably will if you do this.
^^ this
Yummymummy2020 · 17/10/2021 20:41

I agree with the wait and see how you go approach. Personally I had my first while living at home and went mad over all the visitors. Lovely people want to come over and meet the baby but it was during Covid and my mum was appearing with her friends into my bedroom every hands turn while I was trying to rest and feed the baby 😂 I think it’s perfectly fine to want some peace with the baby especially if you are feeling anxious. If you need space it’s perfectly normal and reasonable to say that!

Cheeseontoastwithchopsauce · 17/10/2021 20:39

If your brother knows that you've had a shit time of it lately then just maybe drop him a text to say what you've told us, if she's got any compassion she'll understand if you're a bit quiet etc. I think you're overthinking it a little bit tbh. Let her visit with him and if you get a bit overwhelmed just excuse yourself with the baby and go and have a breather.
Or maybe meet both of them a couple of weeks after for a walk in the park/coffee with the baby
It can all get a bit overwhelming with visitors, I had no problem excusing myself with by newborn if I felt it was getting too much, and a couple of times it did.
You never know, she might become a lovely SIL

Cherrysoup · 17/10/2021 20:34

Well, different scenario entirely if you’re in your own place. You get to dictate who comes into your home. Just tell him he can visit (specify for how long, I think people can be clueless how knackering it is to host with a newborn) but you’re not happy to meet new people just now.

Pebbledashery · 17/10/2021 20:33

See, I'm on the fence here. Op may not have been the most welcoming to her brothers gf, however after giving birth, you're just going to want to be comfortable and be yourself, if you're not necessarily that close to your siblings partner then she may feel ill at ease. You shouldn't be made to feel that way. You could just say to your brother if he'd rather wait till you're feeling up to inviting his gf too then that's ok. I knew when I had my DD we had v few visitors the first few weeks. I certainly wouldn't have felt comfortable with someone I wasn't close with accompanying a family member.

NigellaSeed · 17/10/2021 20:25

I can see I'm going to get flamed for the greasy/stinky comments.

I don't like being unwashed and vulnerable in front of randoms who I don't owe anything to. No mum medal for me

saleorbouy · 17/10/2021 20:24

You need to accept that he is with her. You might enjoy her company and not allowing her to visit might get your relationship off on a wrong footing and that might be detrimental in the future.
It's time to draw a line in the sand and try to.move on from your anxiety. Having a baby is not easy and you will need adult company to keep you sane over the coming months.

louderthan · 17/10/2021 20:19

You're assuming that she will want to come. I have no interest in babies and would not be offended at all: in fact I'd be actively looking for an excuse not to visit!
I don't think you're being unreasonable at all but I suspect I am in the minority!

NewlyGranny · 17/10/2021 20:19

This isn't about your DB or hid GF, it's about you and what you feel comfortable with! You aren't under any obligation to be a people pleaser at any time, nor promote your DB's happiness at this high stress point in your life.

Tell him and everyone that you are likely to feel shattered and overwhelmed for a bit, and specify one visitor at a time from a date you will announce. Tell them you'll keep everyone in the loop and say when you're ready to socialise more, which should stop them asking. Nobody kind or thoughtful will push your boundaries. Your newborn is not a rare zoo animal for gawking at or cooing over.

AutumnLeafy · 17/10/2021 20:17

I think wait and see how you feel when baby is here but it doesn't have to be a big deal if you just want your brother to come alone. Couples don't have to do everything together and you can invite her round when you're up to it.

Allmyarseandpeggymartin · 17/10/2021 20:17

@YourFinestPantaloons Not one person has mentioned having to play hostess we are trying to give op the benefit of our different perspectives and experiences.

I had lots of visitors and didn’t make a single cup of coffee. Fuck that.