Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this uniform policy is wrong

162 replies

rosesinmygarden · 17/10/2021 18:05

My daughter does an extra curricular activity which is linked to scouting/guiding.

The activity involves performing, for which she has to wear a specific uniform.

The uniform specifies exact items which are all boys'/men's clothes. Think men's dress trousers and a men's shirt.

There is no alternative uniform for female members.

The uniform is uncomfortable and fits my daughter badly no matter what size we buy. I've asked several times if she can wear women's versions of each item and have been told that if she does, she will be excluded from performances. They insist the uniform is unisex. It is not. The items are sold by the uniform company as boys/mens items.

AIBU to think this is quite wrong and that the male members would never be expected to wear women's clothes? Let alone be excluded if they refused!

My daughter wants to do the activity and I really don't want to be 'that' parent, but it makes me quite uncomfortable and I'm shocked that the people in charge of the activity think it is acceptable. There is a man in charge overall but his wife is also heavily involved in the running.

OP posts:
User478 · 17/10/2021 19:26

Oh, definitely include this bit. It is absolutely a safeguarding concern that girls are required to undo their trousers to take part in the activity!

(And absolutely ridiculous when a suitable, official, uniform is available)

budgiegirl · 17/10/2021 19:23

*The blouse buttons up differently and has a different collar and cuffs. Not very different from a distance but obvious in a uniform check.

The trousers are my biggest bug bear. Many of the girls cannot sit or bend down while wearing them without undoing the button and zip*

Definitely take it higher - I can't believe the leaders think this is ok in this day and age.

User478 · 17/10/2021 19:22

Nearly all "joint" activities are managed by scouts rather than guides.

The scouts "rules" about uniform are here: www.scouts.org.uk/por/10-uniform-badges-and-emblems/#10.8

I would phrase an email using the information from cultural requirements and safety considerations as her emotional well-being is just as important as whether they are getting soaked at a remembrance parade or whatever.

If it's band (I'm guessing spitfires?) They are usually managed at a county level, they should have told you who to contact but if not you should be able to contact the county commissioner by googling them or asking who is the leaders line manager. (hampshirescouts.org.uk/contact-us/ -if it is spitfires). If no luck at a county level contact HQ www.scouts.org.uk/contact-us

girlmom21 · 17/10/2021 19:18

@ErrolTheDragon it does fit.
She admits in the OP it fits. It's just not flattering.

rosesinmygarden · 17/10/2021 19:17

@user1471530109

OP, how would they know if she wears the 'girls' form of the shirt? Especially if it is tucked into trousers? Our sea scouts don't wear the shirts at all. They wear their own groups Polo shirts under the jumpers which is why I was confused. The trousers have all been hand me downs. My DD is only 12 so I may have more of an issue with this in the next couple of years. There are more girls than boys in our group.

If it is an off branch of scouts, it is still 'scouts'. So I would write to their county 'leader'. There is one as far as I know in each area.

The blouse buttons up differently and has a different collar and cuffs. Not very different from a distance but obvious in a uniform check.

The trousers are my biggest bug bear. Many of the girls cannot sit or bend down while wearing them without undoing the button and zip.

OP posts:
user1471530109 · 17/10/2021 19:12

OP, how would they know if she wears the 'girls' form of the shirt? Especially if it is tucked into trousers?
Our sea scouts don't wear the shirts at all. They wear their own groups Polo shirts under the jumpers which is why I was confused. The trousers have all been hand me downs. My DD is only 12 so I may have more of an issue with this in the next couple of years. There are more girls than boys in our group.

If it is an off branch of scouts, it is still 'scouts'. So I would write to their county 'leader'. There is one as far as I know in each area.

ErrolTheDragon · 17/10/2021 19:11

[quote girlmom21]@ErrolTheDragon it does fit [/quote]
Huh? The whole point of this thread is that it doesn't.Confused
Maybe you're fairly tall and slim hipped so men's or 'unisex' stuff fits you, but it absolutely doesn't fit many women and girls.

bordersroaming · 17/10/2021 19:09

@Clymene

That's dreadful. And against the Equality Act. He is discriminating against girls by insisting they wear clothing that is ill fitting. The boys are allowed to wear clothes that fit them.
Just what I wanted to say

You could also give them a copy of invisible women by criado Perez

PeppermintMocha · 17/10/2021 19:04

how competitive is it to get into the activity? Is she easily replaced?

I'm wondering what would happen if you call their bluff - buy her the girls' items, and see if a) they notice, and b) actually refuse to let her perform, as presumably that has repercussions for the group

How obvious would it be really if they boys' items were tailored to fit? I can't see how it would look much less uniform, just to have a few darts here and there - no less uniform that the mix of heights and body shapes anyway!

Clymene · 17/10/2021 19:04

That's dreadful. And against the Equality Act. He is discriminating against girls by insisting they wear clothing that is ill fitting. The boys are allowed to wear clothes that fit them.

titchy · 17/10/2021 19:00

I'm assuming it's a Scout/Guide marching band? In which case it will be Scout affiliated so you should raise your concern with the District, or even Regional Commissioner.

RoseAndRose · 17/10/2021 18:57

They would NEVER insist that the boys buy and wear the girls' version of the items

Though that is exactly what I would like to suggest - the sexes take it in turns to have uniform that fits, rather than it always being one which is not comfortable

NotSoNewAndShiny · 17/10/2021 18:57

What about the wife? You said she also runs this group with him - does she also prefer uniform over fit/comfort? Have you talked to/written to her? Perhaps they could have a conversation about it and change the rules a bit to suit some of the children. It would still be uniform, just better fit for them.

If there's nothing else you can do and no one else to report to, then it's either continue or stop attending, unfortunately.

rrhuth · 17/10/2021 18:57

@rosesinmygarden

It isn't a national activity. It is a local off shoot. There isn't a group in each town, county etc. It's a bit niche and a group of kids with a very specific performing skill.

We pay for the uniform ourselves unfortunately and it's not cheap. No alterations allowed.

It sounds really awful actually.

Can your DD not find a different group without the weird leader?

rosesinmygarden · 17/10/2021 18:56

This is the shirt. Girl's version (which is banned) is right next to it.

She's not an air or sea scout btw. They just use the same uniform.

AIBU to think this uniform policy is wrong
OP posts:
budgiegirl · 17/10/2021 18:56

*Yes, there are girl's/women's versions of each item available for sale from scouting UK. She is not allowed to wear them. If she does, she will be excluded from performances.

They would NEVER insist that the boys buy and wear the girls' version of the items*

That's terrible. As they must be affiliated with the Scouts, then I would definitely take this higher - contact Scout HQ if need be. Scouts/Guides are all about inclusion, and if your daughter is going to be excluded because the leaders are insisting she wears the boys version of the uniform, then that is surely going against the inclusion policy.

LaurieFairyCake · 17/10/2021 18:55

What I would do is complain to the greater organisation above them

It sounds like one rogue mysoginistic arsehole

girlmom21 · 17/10/2021 18:55

@ErrolTheDragon it does fit

LaurieFairyCake · 17/10/2021 18:54

Get them altered/tailored

Tell them they haven't been altered when they ask

rosesinmygarden · 17/10/2021 18:49

@Clymene

Are some posters honestly trying to say that teenage boys and girls bodies are essentially a similar shape? Confused surely no one is that thick.

OP - is there uniform for women? I mean is it made? I would get that. And if your group leader complains then I would go higher up the food chain

Yes, there are girl's/women's versions of each item available for sale from scouting UK. She is not allowed to wear them. If she does, she will be excluded from performances.

They would NEVER insist that the boys buy and wear the girls' version of the items.

OP posts:
ErrolTheDragon · 17/10/2021 18:46

@girlmom21

Even if it's a group that's unisex a universal uniform will fit everyone. The intention isn't for it to be flattering - it's for everyone to dress the same.
Of course it doesn't fit everyone. Hmm the OP has clearly explained it fits the boys but doesn't fit many of the girls)
rosesinmygarden · 17/10/2021 18:42

It isn't a national activity. It is a local off shoot. There isn't a group in each town, county etc. It's a bit niche and a group of kids with a very specific performing skill.

We pay for the uniform ourselves unfortunately and it's not cheap. No alterations allowed.

OP posts:
girlmom21 · 17/10/2021 18:41

Even if it's a group that's unisex a universal uniform will fit everyone. The intention isn't for it to be flattering - it's for everyone to dress the same.

Clymene · 17/10/2021 18:38

Are some posters honestly trying to say that teenage boys and girls bodies are essentially a similar shape? Confused surely no one is that thick.

OP - is there uniform for women? I mean is it made? I would get that. And if your group leader complains then I would go higher up the food chain

ftw163532 · 17/10/2021 18:34

Damn it, that was meant to be in response to posters saying men's clothes fit them fine.