Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this uniform policy is wrong

162 replies

rosesinmygarden · 17/10/2021 18:05

My daughter does an extra curricular activity which is linked to scouting/guiding.

The activity involves performing, for which she has to wear a specific uniform.

The uniform specifies exact items which are all boys'/men's clothes. Think men's dress trousers and a men's shirt.

There is no alternative uniform for female members.

The uniform is uncomfortable and fits my daughter badly no matter what size we buy. I've asked several times if she can wear women's versions of each item and have been told that if she does, she will be excluded from performances. They insist the uniform is unisex. It is not. The items are sold by the uniform company as boys/mens items.

AIBU to think this is quite wrong and that the male members would never be expected to wear women's clothes? Let alone be excluded if they refused!

My daughter wants to do the activity and I really don't want to be 'that' parent, but it makes me quite uncomfortable and I'm shocked that the people in charge of the activity think it is acceptable. There is a man in charge overall but his wife is also heavily involved in the running.

OP posts:
Wroxie · 18/10/2021 08:56

It seems like you are looking for commiseration rather than a solution, but as a solution, buy the uniform too big so that it fits her chest and hips and take it to a good tailor. It will be expensive but it can be made to fit perfectly. I did this with a suit for a male friend's wedding when I was standing up with the men as a groomsman and it it looked great (I wore it with a silk vest top underneath in the same colour as the ties the other men wore).

rosesinmygarden · 18/10/2021 08:48

The stupid thing is that they also have an 'informal' uniform of polo shirts and fleeces which are genuinely unisex. These look really nice and smart. They are comfortable for all and everyone looks the same.

It's the formal uniform which is a joke.

I think my issue with this man is that he would never in a month of Sundays expect himself or any of the boys to wear women's clothes. Ever. Because that would be very very wrong.

OP posts:
rosesinmygarden · 18/10/2021 08:45

@trollopolis, the trousers are a very slim men's fit. So, for women, they often need to be bought huge around the waist in order to fit around the hips and thighs. Because of the expense (£38 a pair and lack of sizes in 2nd hand) many of the girls end up putting up with too tight trousers which would split (in an embarrassing place) if they don't unzip before sitting on the coach to an event or bending down to pack or unpack their instrument. They have even taken to standing in front of each other for modesty.

The trouble is, guidance can be interpreted in many ways. It doesn't say the word blouse in black and white. Traditionally, a shirt is a men's clothing item and a blouse is the women's version.

OP posts:
trollopolis · 18/10/2021 08:39

Unfortunately, I think the guidance can be interpreted to support our leaders

I wouldn't have read it that way - the official shirt for girls is being denied them

12inches too wide at waist and also too tight to sit in without unzipping sounds a nightmare for trousers. I'm very surprised they haven't made a change in the basis that the first all look like a badly wrapped sack

WeAreTheHeroes · 18/10/2021 08:39

Well if they want to recruit new members and encourage inclusivity then perhaps they need to drop their unintentionally sexist approach to band uniform?

rosesinmygarden · 18/10/2021 08:38

@bestbefore thanks, I have messaged you.

@WeAreTheHeroes no I haven't spoken to anyone other than band leaders and other parents so far.

OP posts:
rosesinmygarden · 18/10/2021 08:34

Yes, you are right though - it would be a minefield!

It would make sense for it to say shirt/blouse though and Scouting UK has chosen not to do that. They have chosen the default 'male' word for the garment instead. They have also chosen to make allowances for younger members of bands, but not for different genders. That seems wrong to me and has allowed these leaders to make this uniform policy as it is.

There are around 50 members of the band and the males/female split is around 50/50. The girls range in age from 7/8 to 18 and some of the teenage girls have not returned after COVID, so this problem is probably not apparent to those with younger girls as members, or those whose teenage daughters are very slim and/or not yet developed.

OP posts:
bestbefore · 18/10/2021 08:31

@rosesinmygarden yes but the idea of going to county would be an arbitration, if you can't agree then county can. Message me if you like with what county it is because if it's the one I'm in I sort of know the cc and I know she would be very interested in this.

WeAreTheHeroes · 18/10/2021 08:29

What you've had that conversation with the county-level leadership already? Because that was what I was suggesting.

Life's too short to put up with this kind of crap and I wouldn't be making my teenage daughter wear clothes that so obviously don't fit, especially not if I've had to pay for them! Just buy the girls' version instead and ignore.

rosesinmygarden · 18/10/2021 08:26

They argue it means shirt. Unfortunately. I have already had this conversation with them. Sigh...

OP posts:
TheUnexpectedPickle · 18/10/2021 08:22

Thing is, he's got it all wrong in terms of "look". Its important that everyone matches but that doesn't mean wearing exactly the same thing- women looking uncomfortable in mens clothes doesn't look smart at all! My first thought is that the armed forces have lots of marching bands and you don't see the women looking dreadful in mens clothes- they have their own! If they can perform for the actual QUEEN in separate mens/womens uniform and look great then surely a local marching band can do the same 😬

I hate the concept of "unisex" uniform. My work uniform claims to be unisex. It isnt- its mens clothes and women have to just approximate a size. The shoulders of my shirts are halfway down my upper arm and I have to roll up the sleeve so its not below my elbow, all so I can get the shirt to do up over my boobs. Apparently whoever decided that we shouldn't have a female uniform didn't realise you can be 5'4" with size 38HH boobs. I don't look smart, I look scruffy which is how I imagine the girls in the band look!

WeAreTheHeroes · 18/10/2021 08:18

Right, well there's your starting point when you approach the county leadership, that the guidance states "shirts" all the way through with no mention of blouses for the girls who are a different shape from the boys meaning the cut of the shirts doesn't fit them. Now it may be that the county come back with they intend "shirts" to be interpreted as "shirts or blouses" and they may respond as such.

How many are in the band and how many of them are girls?

bestbefore · 18/10/2021 08:13

@rosesinmygarden

I must admit, I am surprised there is not guidance on uniform for different genders.
Minefield!!
bestbefore · 18/10/2021 08:13

OK so the official uniform, if they all wear the same top, has a blouse for women and a shirt for men - I'd argue shirt is a generic term meaning both.

shop.scouts.org.uk/uniforms/network

rosesinmygarden · 18/10/2021 08:10

I must admit, I am surprised there is not guidance on uniform for different genders.

OP posts:
rosesinmygarden · 18/10/2021 08:09

Thank you @bestbefore

Unfortunately, I think the guidance can be interpreted to support our leaders.

e.g.
^10.18. Marching bands sv
Uniform:

Members of Scout Marching Bands have two options from which the Band as a whole may choose:
youth members may wear the official uniform shirt for their Section or the approved sweatshirt (for Cub Scouts and Beaver Scouts only). Adults wear the adult official uniform shirt;

or

all members, including adults, wear the official uniform shirt i.e. the Scout, Explorer Scout or the adult official uniform shirt.^

It doesn't mention blouses, only shirts. And it talks about the band as a whole wearing the same thing.

OP posts:
bestbefore · 18/10/2021 08:04

Thanks for the update, I've been thinking about this a bit overnight. And I'm so cross for you.
There's guidance on uniform here

www.scouts.org.uk/por/10-uniform-badges-and-emblems/#10.18

10.18. Marching bands sv

rosesinmygarden · 18/10/2021 07:48

It's a Scout and Guide marching band. Obviously not one where they wear their own section tops and black skirt or trousers @Reachersloveinterest as if it was, there wouldn't be an issue.

All the girls hate the uniform but despite many polite requests, the leaders refuse to allow them to wear women's items and state that anyone not in full uniform will not be allowed to perform. I have seen them send kids home from performances for having the wrong colour socks so I can fully believe they mean this.

For those of you airily suggesting I pay for adjustments, I don't see why I should have to pay £62 for uniform and then pay even more for someone to alter it. We are currently on our 4th pair of trousers as my daughter has changed shape and size considerably since going through puberty. They are 12 inches too big around the waist. 12 inches! That is not a simple few stitches...

For the finance reasons, of course the girls aren't all going to go out and buy even more uniform which they aren't allowed to wear in order to protest. We are not made of money and this would be a completely pointless exercise.

The uniform is only worn for performances. The kids wear their own clothes for practices.

I think I will have to speak to my daughter and decide with her whether she wants me to speak to county.

I don't for one minute think the man in charge has any sexual motivations for the uniform policy. He apparently got a well meaning parent helper to pick all the items and put the uniform policy together (the trousers for example are not from scouting UK, they are from a school uniform supplier). This parent had only boys and I think simply didn't consider the girls in the band. They are now refusing to change the uniform because everyone needs to look the same. There are girls trousers available which are very similar but not the same. I personally don't think this would affect the look of the group, but the leaders disagree, or can't be bothered to discuss it as they are too busy with more important things.

OP posts:
GrandmaAli · 18/10/2021 04:38

Maybe if ALL the girls refused the shirts, and ALL turn up in similar female shirts/blouses, then this man couldn't really do anything about it!!
He needs to realise he's now in the 21st century and that young women are wearing comfortable clothing!

tillytown · 18/10/2021 04:27

Why have none of the parents reported him for ensuring the teenage girls in his care have to unzip their trousers to bend over or sit? Surely none of you really think this is innocent? It has nothing to do with looking the same and everything to do with being either a bully or sexual predator

Llareggub · 18/10/2021 00:28

I wouldn’t be leaving my child attend an activity run by someone who can be “bit of a bully” tbh.

unknownstory · 18/10/2021 00:05

@fallfallfall

Buy oversized and get the uniform tailored to fit.
Why should they pay £20-30 on top when a female version is available??
unknownstory · 18/10/2021 00:04

I'd also use it to teach my daughter to challenge these things. Question them. Fight for her right to wear the uniform designed & available for teenage girls.

unknownstory · 18/10/2021 00:02

I'd be going mental. I'd have county involved. I'd be screaming about equality. I really wouldn't care what the leaders thought at this point.
They don't have kids. Its not an issue the wife faces clearly.
But it's hideous discrimination & humiliating for the girls whose bodies are a different shape. There are separate versions for a reason

fallfallfall · 17/10/2021 22:23

Buy oversized and get the uniform tailored to fit.