Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this uniform policy is wrong

162 replies

rosesinmygarden · 17/10/2021 18:05

My daughter does an extra curricular activity which is linked to scouting/guiding.

The activity involves performing, for which she has to wear a specific uniform.

The uniform specifies exact items which are all boys'/men's clothes. Think men's dress trousers and a men's shirt.

There is no alternative uniform for female members.

The uniform is uncomfortable and fits my daughter badly no matter what size we buy. I've asked several times if she can wear women's versions of each item and have been told that if she does, she will be excluded from performances. They insist the uniform is unisex. It is not. The items are sold by the uniform company as boys/mens items.

AIBU to think this is quite wrong and that the male members would never be expected to wear women's clothes? Let alone be excluded if they refused!

My daughter wants to do the activity and I really don't want to be 'that' parent, but it makes me quite uncomfortable and I'm shocked that the people in charge of the activity think it is acceptable. There is a man in charge overall but his wife is also heavily involved in the running.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
rosesinmygarden · 18/10/2021 11:17

@WeAreTheHeroes

Yes, I can understand that, especially as it's rarely worn. But investing (and we all pay subs which presumably paid for them to buy the boys uniform which fits the boys) would mean being more inclusive for years to come.

I'd be willing to help the band pay for it if it fitted her, and subsequent, girl members and allowed them to take part without feeling embarrassed.

OP posts:
WeAreTheHeroes · 18/10/2021 11:09

My thoughts on this are that they don't want the cost of buying new jackets for the girls if they own this formal uniform.

rosesinmygarden · 18/10/2021 10:33

@WeAreTheHeroes

If you really don't want to make a stand then get them altered. He cannot tell you you cannot alter an item to get it to fit. Why are you even asking? Would you ask if the trousers were too long and needed taking up? Whats he going to say, your trousers look suspiciously like they fit you today?

I completely agree with the pp who said this.

What's the ultra formal band uniform then? Is it jackets which they've only got in boys'/mens' sizes and fits?

Basically yes, and in a pale colour which will show off the ill fit even more than the normal black.
OP posts:
rosesinmygarden · 18/10/2021 10:31

@PeeAche if I was willing to withdraw her then I would definitely go to local media and press.

As she wants to stay, I think this would be unwise.

I will see what the DC has to say on the issue. At least I will have tried. I wish I knew the other parents well enough to coordinate a stand but I rarely see them.

OP posts:
WeAreTheHeroes · 18/10/2021 10:31

If you really don't want to make a stand then get them altered. He cannot tell you you cannot alter an item to get it to fit. Why are you even asking? Would you ask if the trousers were too long and needed taking up? Whats he going to say, your trousers look suspiciously like they fit you today?

I completely agree with the pp who said this.

What's the ultra formal band uniform then? Is it jackets which they've only got in boys'/mens' sizes and fits?

PeeAche · 18/10/2021 10:27

@rosesinmygarden

I have emailed the district commissioner. I have asked them to keep it anonymous and not share my name or the age of my daughter.

I spoke to my daughter again this morning and she is refusing to attend a particular event as it is one where they have to wear an 'ultra formal' uniform supplied by the band. Her words were 'They won't have anything to fit me and I will look fat and have to stand up all day'. The more I thought about her words the angrier I got. So I have emailed to ask what the policy is and how best to work with the leader on this.

We shall see if the DC is a dickhead too!

This is such a shame. And I totally get it. I can remember being 12 or 13 and "realising" I couldn't wear my dungarees anymore because they made me look "fat".

Boxy clothes on curves are awful and if you feel awful you really don't want to March around performing.

In the end, this man will win and your daughter will withdraw. So will any other young ladies faced with the same dilemma. He doesn't want blossoming female bodies in his tidy man-sized line up.

I wonder if your local paper might be interested in this...?

Fizbosshoes · 18/10/2021 10:22

Also I can't understand why more than 30% of voters think its acceptable for the choice to be for girls to wear ill fitting and uncomfortable or pay a fortune for alterations when an appropriate uniform is available!!Confused

WaltzingBetty · 18/10/2021 10:21

[quote rosesinmygarden]@WaltzingBetty. Yes I have made them aware of how uncomfortable the girls feel. So have other parents. The leaders are not all male but the female leaders it appears either don't mind the uniform or are not in a position to challenge the policy. I've mentioned this several times in the thread but I appreciate it is now quite long and would take a while to check this.

I have directly asked which girls items I should buy so that my daughter can be comfortable but smart and have been told that the items on the list (which are men's/boys' items) are the only ones acceptable for performances.

I do think the main leader is oblivious and too important to be bothered by trivial things like girls feeling comfortable at a performance. It simply doesn't feature on his radar.

I would have pulled my daughter out a while ago, but she really does get so much out of doing the activity and has worked so hard to get to the point where she is good enough to be allowed to perform. It took approx. 18 months of practices to be allowed to even attend church parade with the band and she has now been invited to perform at some really prestigious events. She would hate to leave her friends and to give up an activity which she enjoys and is such a great outlet.

My dilemma is that I feel the uniform policy and the leaders' attitudes towards it are very wrong but to make a fuss means drawing attention to my daughter in a negative way. To not make a fuss, teaches her that when men are in charge you can't complain about issues that make you unhappy.[/quote]
I've read the thread and saw that some of the leaders are female but it seems clear from your posts that you feel they may be disempowered and this issue is something being driven primarily by the male leaders.

My question then is what is his response when you have this conversation - how has he reacted to you pointing out that his policy is making girls uncomfortable and disenfranchised and is discriminatory ?

I'm struggling to see how he can reasonably defend forcing girls to perform in Ill-fitting men's uniform that is uncomfortable for them and increases the likelihood of them not participating at all. If he doesn't think there is a difference in body shapes then why not have all of the members in the 'female' uniform?

Fizbosshoes · 18/10/2021 10:20

Why should the solution be for girls to have to pay out more than their uniform than the boys?

I also think this is a poor solution - for a uniform that is a) not cheap in the first place and b) available in a suitable fit anyway!

As an aside I take exception with my DC school on uniform. Boys uniform is charcoal trousers. I buy DS slim fit ones from M and S (£15 for 2 pairs)
Girls uniform is the school skirt, in one style, which has to be bought from the school supplier @ £26/each or "girls trousers" which are hideous also have to be purchased from the school shop and are from £23 per pair
DS has 4 pairs of trousers for less than the cost of DDs 2 skirts.

rosesinmygarden · 18/10/2021 10:14

@ittakes2 sadly not, or this would obviously not be such an issue.

OP posts:
BigFatLiar · 18/10/2021 10:12

Point out to him that if the girls are wearing properly fitting uniforms then his band will look so much smarter and be more appreciated. If the girls look scruffy in ill fitting clothes it will reflect badly on him.

Cryalot2 · 18/10/2021 10:11

Michellesams
Loved your trip down memory lane. Which one are you? Lovely GB photos. Both my sils and niece were all leaders.

TracyLords · 18/10/2021 10:05

Good. I’d still speak to him in person and tell him exactly what I think.
But, hopefully going through the DC will fix it

ittakes2 · 18/10/2021 10:04

If the trousers are from a school uniform supplier - do they not have those elastic with buttons on the waist band so the waist can be adjusted?

rosesinmygarden · 18/10/2021 10:00

I have emailed the district commissioner. I have asked them to keep it anonymous and not share my name or the age of my daughter.

I spoke to my daughter again this morning and she is refusing to attend a particular event as it is one where they have to wear an 'ultra formal' uniform supplied by the band. Her words were 'They won't have anything to fit me and I will look fat and have to stand up all day'. The more I thought about her words the angrier I got. So I have emailed to ask what the policy is and how best to work with the leader on this.

We shall see if the DC is a dickhead too!

OP posts:
TracyLords · 18/10/2021 09:57

So fuck if he is annoyed!!!! Make a fucking fuss. Tell him it’s creepy and pervy to expect girls to wear the boys outfits when they clearly can’t fit into them. Report to the district commissioner. Stop being a fucking coward and stick up for your daughter. I’ve got the absolute rage reading this

CarrotSticks23 · 18/10/2021 09:56

When you say the main leader is too important, it's a local scouts marching band. He's not too important. He needs to get over himself, honestly the more I read the more I think this complete dickhead needs challenging

CarrotSticks23 · 18/10/2021 09:52

You are coming up with a lot of obstacles.

Your DD cannot wear the mens trousers. They are uncomfortable and don't fit. Just say no. No she is not wearing mens trousers because they are uncomfortable, they split all the time. all the girls need to say no. Stop asking and refuse. Is he going to exclude his entire marching band?

He's not a well meaning parent. He's being at best a dickhead, at worse there is genuine safety concern in a man who insists teenage girls wear a uniform that regularly splits. You say he's a bully. Why are you you even letting your teenage dd attend this event

If you really don't want to make a stand then get them altered. He cannot tell you you cannot alter an item to get it to fit. Why are you even asking? Would you ask if the trousers were too long and needed taking up? Whats he going to say, your trousers look suspiciously like they fit you today?

He's not going to change based on you asking him. So you either need to make a proper stand and put your foot down or take it higher. This is a children's activity where the leader regularly threatens children with exclusion if they wear correctly fitting clothes that are not at risk of splitting and behaves like a bully. That's not acceptable. There will be a higher power, contact them.

PeppermintMocha · 18/10/2021 09:34

Sounds like the safeguarding route might be the way to go then - remind this man that he is creating a situation that means the girls have to undo their trousers to sit down, and that that could look very dodgy if anyone further up took note of what he was doing - make it like you are giving him a friendly heads up that he is putting himself at risk. You shouldn't have to threaten like this, but it might be the only way.

And in the meantime, paying the extra to get the clothes tailored seems the only way, or finding girls' items that do look otherwise identical to the boys'. Unfair for the girls to have to spend so much more money, but if she is really keen to keep on with the band, you might have to.

It's a shame the girls can't all get together and refuse to wear the boys' uniforms, as the sudden loss of half the band at a performance might be enough to make him give in. Or if there is any time where she is really vital to her section/doing a solo/the only one who can come on a certain day etc, then that might be the day that he decides girls in girls' clothes can in fact perform after all.

rosesinmygarden · 18/10/2021 09:26

I guess really the answer is to put up and shut up unless my daughter wants to make a stand.

OP posts:
rosesinmygarden · 18/10/2021 09:23

@WaltzingBetty. Yes I have made them aware of how uncomfortable the girls feel. So have other parents. The leaders are not all male but the female leaders it appears either don't mind the uniform or are not in a position to challenge the policy. I've mentioned this several times in the thread but I appreciate it is now quite long and would take a while to check this.

I have directly asked which girls items I should buy so that my daughter can be comfortable but smart and have been told that the items on the list (which are men's/boys' items) are the only ones acceptable for performances.

I do think the main leader is oblivious and too important to be bothered by trivial things like girls feeling comfortable at a performance. It simply doesn't feature on his radar.

I would have pulled my daughter out a while ago, but she really does get so much out of doing the activity and has worked so hard to get to the point where she is good enough to be allowed to perform. It took approx. 18 months of practices to be allowed to even attend church parade with the band and she has now been invited to perform at some really prestigious events. She would hate to leave her friends and to give up an activity which she enjoys and is such a great outlet.

My dilemma is that I feel the uniform policy and the leaders' attitudes towards it are very wrong but to make a fuss means drawing attention to my daughter in a negative way. To not make a fuss, teaches her that when men are in charge you can't complain about issues that make you unhappy.

OP posts:
budgiegirl · 18/10/2021 09:18

It seems like you are looking for commiseration rather than a solution, but as a solution, buy the uniform too big so that it fits her chest and hips and take it to a good tailor. It will be expensive but it can be made to fit perfectly

Why should the solution be for girls to have to pay out more than their uniform than the boys? There is an alternative uniform available to the girls at the same price as the boys, but the leader is choosing not to allow them to wear it. OP, I'd definitely take this higher, if you have explained your concerns to the leader and he has refused to change the policy.

ErrolTheDragon · 18/10/2021 09:15

A blouse is a shirt, maybe the bloke needs introducing to a dictionary.

WaltzingBetty · 18/10/2021 09:07

@rosesinmygarden

Yes, you are right though - it would be a minefield!

It would make sense for it to say shirt/blouse though and Scouting UK has chosen not to do that. They have chosen the default 'male' word for the garment instead. They have also chosen to make allowances for younger members of bands, but not for different genders. That seems wrong to me and has allowed these leaders to make this uniform policy as it is.

There are around 50 members of the band and the males/female split is around 50/50. The girls range in age from 7/8 to 18 and some of the teenage girls have not returned after COVID, so this problem is probably not apparent to those with younger girls as members, or those whose teenage daughters are very slim and/or not yet developed.

Standard everyday sexism male default

Have you actually spoken to the leaders and discussed how uncomfortable and ill fitting the uniform is for teen girls @rosesinmygarden ?

That's the fist step. It wouldn't surprise me if the leaders are simply oblivious to issues like this as makes they've never faced them

knittingaddict · 18/10/2021 08:56

@rosesinmygarden

The wife, who is the 2nd in command, is a very slim lady. They have no children.

I think they are so wrapped up in the 'success' of the group that they will be unwilling to change things. Most of the girls and their parents are the type not to want to rock the boat so to speak. I think if i complain, it will become difficult for my daughter to continue attending. The leader is a bit of a bully when he wants to be.

I'm very tempted to get the uniform tailored to fit and then just deny it.

I've just checked and the latest trousers are actually 42 inch waist!!!! Shock my daughter is a ladies size 10/12 so you can imagine the extra fabric around the waist! They are also £38!

It's a shame that not all the parents of the girls would be willing to make a stand. My advice would have been for all the girls to buy the correct uniform for their shape and see what happens. If this man chucks them out I would then create a stink and contact anyone with an interest - the organisation itself, social media, the press and see what happens.

This should not be happening now.