Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder how school residential dorms are organised

42 replies

TheLasrStraw · 17/10/2021 16:50

Secondary school DD won't be in the same dorm as her friends due to numbers not allowing it.

DD is the one that has been left out and the school haven refused to fix it by say letting one friend go in a dorm with her and swapping someone out.

It's so unfair. How come 4 girls can be with 3 friends and my DD gets to be with zero friends?

What to do?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SheWoreYellow · 18/10/2021 14:40

@TheLasrStraw

You are all much more relaxed than me.

So, no -one would raise it with the school? Anyone?

I would, one very polite, quick email asking if they were aware they’d been placed with no friends.
Kite22 · 17/10/2021 21:03

@TheLasrStraw

You are all much more relaxed than me.

So, no -one would raise it with the school? Anyone?

No
MissCruellaDeVil · 17/10/2021 20:55

@YourFinestPantaloons
No not at all, sorry that was poorly worded, I meant a dorm where they are all friends.

icedcoffees · 17/10/2021 20:17

@TheLasrStraw

You are all much more relaxed than me.

So, no -one would raise it with the school? Anyone?

No.

Read a PP"s post - it's impossible to split a group of five into dorms of four without someone from either that friendship group or another friendship group ending up alone.

icedcoffees · 17/10/2021 20:16

@JagerPlease

There is no way of splitting a group of 5 friends into rooms of 4 without someone being alone without their friends, either 1 of the 5 (as has happened) or another child made to go in with the 3, if they were split 3 and 2.

I wouldn't be raising something with the school if I was effectively suggesting someone else's child should be swapped instead of mine

Exactly. You can't arrange it so nobody misses out.
clockover · 17/10/2021 20:10

Mixing not missing ^ Blush

clockover · 17/10/2021 20:09

@TheLasrStraw

You are all much more relaxed than me.

So, no -one would raise it with the school? Anyone?

It's a residential trip with school, not a holiday. It's fine for them to be missing with people they wouldn't ordinarily spend time with, I mean it's part of the point.

DeepaBeesKit · 17/10/2021 20:06

And please please don't be possessive about friendship groups. It sends a signal to kids that friendships are very fixed which is unhealthy and massively exclusionary. You often see girl groups especially where the friendship is only really based on "having always been friends", often the dynamic is awful and they no longer have much in common or actually are truly good friends to each other.

DeepaBeesKit · 17/10/2021 20:04

There is no way of splitting a group of 5 friends into rooms of 4 without someone being alone without their friends, either 1 of the 5 (as has happened) or another child made to go in with the 3, if they were split 3 and 2.

It's this. The teacher probably put your DD in with others because they were most likely to be sociable with/gain something from friendship with a different bunch anyway - see it as a compliment.

JagerPlease · 17/10/2021 19:49

There is no way of splitting a group of 5 friends into rooms of 4 without someone being alone without their friends, either 1 of the 5 (as has happened) or another child made to go in with the 3, if they were split 3 and 2.

I wouldn't be raising something with the school if I was effectively suggesting someone else's child should be swapped instead of mine

ItsAllGoingToBeFine · 17/10/2021 19:48

The school may have done it deliberately...

YourFinestPantaloons · 17/10/2021 19:47

@TheLasrStraw

You are all much more relaxed than me.

So, no -one would raise it with the school? Anyone?

No

It's a chance to make new friends and get out of her comfort zone.

You need to channel Elsa and let it go. And by 'it' I mean micromanaging your DD's life

Cantstopthewaves · 17/10/2021 19:47

I'd not raise it with the school.
I may secretly feel a bit sad on my dd's behalf but I'd also look to it as an opportunity for DD to expand her friendships.
This is a good opportunity.

TheLasrStraw · 17/10/2021 19:40

You are all much more relaxed than me.

So, no -one would raise it with the school? Anyone?

OP posts:
YourFinestPantaloons · 17/10/2021 19:09

I think what you need to remember OP is that whilst I'm sure they have a lovely friendship, these close knit groups often result in pushing others out, albeit unconsciously. They're in Y7 meaning there'll be people just started struggling to make friendships and hoping for an 'in' on a residential but unable to get one because of the insular groups

YourFinestPantaloons · 17/10/2021 19:07

@MissCruellaDeVil you are mixing sexes in the dorms??!

MissCruellaDeVil · 17/10/2021 19:07

@prawncrackergirl
Were the same. our parents would cause chaos if they knew all their little darlings weren't with their friends 100% of the time.

MissCruellaDeVil · 17/10/2021 19:05

I'm planning one and organising it so that friends aren't all together, there are a few exceptions, but all girls in one dorm etc would be hell; they wouldn't sleep!

arethereanyleftatall · 17/10/2021 17:43

'That's good news darling - great chance to make some new friends. The more friends you have, the better.'

budgiegirl · 17/10/2021 17:42

@TheLasrStraw

Her primary school guaranteed one friend, but secondary doesn't.

If it's ok for that to happen to my DD, why not swap someone out so it happens to someone else and so give my DD one friend?

Wow, so it's ok to happen to someone else, as long as it's not your child?

I get it's disappointing for your daughter, and it is quite tough on her to feel left out, but I'm sure she'll be fine.
Unless there's a particular reason that your daughter can't share with the children she's been allocated (such as a bullying issue), then I don't think there's much to be done. After all, if you swap one child out of the dorm to be with your daughter, then the child going in won't be with her friends either. So it's just transferred the problem to another child - I can't see the teachers agreeing to that.

YourFinestPantaloons · 17/10/2021 17:39

I organise residential for secondary aged children.

I also don't tell them who they're bunking with until the day because you can guarantee some nut case parent will be on at me. Why on Earth did they tell you?

How do I organise them? Well considering the time, money, risk assessing (oh the ruddy risk assessments!) and the hours of effort that has to go into these things - quite often all done in my own time - I put people together who are likely to cause less disruption in their groups.

That's not to say your DD is a troublemaker but if there's a group of 7 rather giddy/silly friend (common in Y7) I won't put them all together. Especially not in a dorm. Teachers spend hours pacing the corridors instead of sleeping because of noisy/silly groups of kids who won't sleep. I also have been known to put people in with others to make them grow and perhaps socialise outside their bubble. I'll never group people with those they've ever had issues with.

But being with others outside her group will, at the very worst, mean nothing changes for her friendship-wise but at the best, means she makes friends. Not a bad thing OP.

WhatAShilohPitt · 17/10/2021 17:38

I don’t think YABU that unreasonable, actually. I don’t really understand their reasoning of ‘numbers don’t allow it.’ Fair enough that they can’t fit all 5 in a room but it seems a bit off to let 4 girls stay together and 1 be entirely with girls she doesn’t know. Don’t see the issue with allowing 2 rooms with 2 friends & 2 ‘non-friends’ and I’d think that was better for getting them all to mix.

That said, she has the chance to make three new friends which is great!

superram · 17/10/2021 17:32

I understand you are upset. As far as possible I try to get students to sort themselves out. In this situation I would say they have to be a 3 and a 2 or I will room them and they may all be alone. I wouldn’t do the swapping out though. Please don’t say anything though.

saraclara · 17/10/2021 17:31

@TheLasrStraw

Her primary school guaranteed one friend, but secondary doesn't.

If it's ok for that to happen to my DD, why not swap someone out so it happens to someone else and so give my DD one friend?

So you're happy for it to happen to someone else? As long as it's not your daughter?

Let's stand by then, for another of these OPs from that girl's mother.

prawncrackergirl · 17/10/2021 17:31

Oh, @TheLasrStraw, your last message really made me eyeroll.

Just pull her out of the trip, if that's your feeling. It will save the school staff (who will be running themselves ragged preparing, planning, risk-assessing and getting ready for working 24 hours a day for however long the trip is) a MASSIVE headache not to deal with you.