Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why housekeepers get paid more then cleaners?

83 replies

Starryskiesinthesky · 17/10/2021 12:45

Reading about how cleaners shouldnt expect to tidy up before cleaning it said that housekeepers get paid more. I was just wondering why you would be paid for more tidying than cleaning? To me it seems easier so wondered if there is more to it? Thanks.

OP posts:
Triffid1 · 18/10/2021 10:57

@SelfEmployedCleaner you sound a LOT like our old cleaner who I always felt was somewhere between a housekeeper and a cleaner. She was very proactive on the cleaning, doing extra bits of deep cleaning weekly and a few extras (eg she'd spot that the door stop was torn and fix it or she'd turn up with a new product she'd found to solve a specific problem in our house - we'd pay for it, obviously) but we didn't use her as a housekeeper. Partly because we didn't really have the money to pay for any additional hours and partly because her English wasn't great so she'd have struggled with interacting with other service providers etc. Having said that, if she hadn't left the country pre-Brexit, I think now I'd be negotiating with her for a more housekeeper type role to include some light childcare (the kids ADORED her and currently both DH and I are often working early evenings which is a nightmare for the evening routine with the children), dog walking (our dog and her were best friends) and a few things like putting away shopping etc because frankly DH and I are struggling and she knew us extremely well.

But even just as a cleaner we did pay her quite well - £14 per hour, 4 weeks paid leave a year, a christmas bonus and sick pay. As well as an extra fiver per week as we lived further out than her other clients so she needed an extension for her travel card to come to us. It does sound like you're in her sweet spot so could definitely advertise as more than a cleaner and charge top rates.

Watchingyou2sleezes · 18/10/2021 09:21

Mine is like my house p.a.
Dealing with a lot of day to day stuff, overseeing other regular workers.Does a fair bit of laundry/ironing, kids bedrooms- been great for keeping them how I want them because they daren't mess her around. Some cooking. General errand running.Knows exactly how I like things to be and I can't remember ever having to 'remind' her how I want things done. I like to do the food shop myself and change the bedding in my own room.
Frees me up to do more worth while things and removes a massive amount of stress from the household. I pay her to reflect that

Guetzlibache · 18/10/2021 08:20

@SmileyClare.I was a cleaner too(luckily retired now)and completely agree with you.It's a hard slog though isnt itSmile

BigPyjamas · 17/10/2021 21:11

@ssd

It sounds fancier than it is. We both work full time in pretty full-on jobs and our housekeeper also does childcare (she's a nanny housekeeper but this bit didn't seem relevant in the chat)

Cleaner comes as the house would be feral without her. She does 4hr a week. House is old and rambling, she doesn't clean all of it but does the main bits.

Appreciate we are incredibly lucky and try to be really good employers.

ssd · 17/10/2021 20:51

@BigPyjamas

We pay our housekeeper £14/hr and our cleaner 12.50/hr.

Housekeeper does more complex household tasks such as cooking, meal prep, ironing, laundry, trades, shopping. She doesn't clean but I might ask her to Hoover or clean the kitchen floor.

I'm fascinated. And nosey!! What kind of life do you have that you need both of these?

Please ignore me if you'd rather not say.

TractorAndHeadphones · 17/10/2021 20:35

[quote TheFlyHalfsMum]**@SelfEmployedCleaner

I need you in my life! And you say you have free slots and are based in the NW?![/quote]
Also @SelfEmployedCleaner are you based in Manchester?

TheFlyHalfsMum · 17/10/2021 20:34

@SelfEmployedCleaner

I need you in my life! And you say you have free slots and are based in the NW?!

BigPyjamas · 17/10/2021 20:31

We pay our housekeeper £14/hr and our cleaner 12.50/hr.

Housekeeper does more complex household tasks such as cooking, meal prep, ironing, laundry, trades, shopping. She doesn't clean but I might ask her to Hoover or clean the kitchen floor.

traumatisednoodle · 17/10/2021 20:22

We pay our housekeeper £14/hour with 6 weeks paid holiday, she also got Furlough in the lock downs.

TractorAndHeadphones · 17/10/2021 20:20

[quote SelfEmployedCleaner]Have a look at this set of adverts for Housekeepers. Grin

A good selection of people who know a HK's worth and those who want to pay minimum wage for someone to manage their home!

uk.indeed.com/Private-Housekeeper-jobs?advn=3151555674175321&vjk=c9ad651a4cc90ab9[/quote]
God the £9 an hour ones are terrible - why would anybody choose that when they could work for an agency who pays at least that.
But then again in some places the only other work available is on farms... being a housekeeper looks better by comparison.

Doodar · 17/10/2021 20:08

we have our cleaner 3 days a week 8-1 she has her own routine of bed changing and deep cleans, fridge, oven etc. She would also mind the kids while I went too the gym or did a quick shop when they were younger. She also puts food deliveries away.

She knows where everything goes, put all washed and ironed clothes away and will tidy clothes drawers.
we pay her £16/ hour
in normal times we're away every school holiday, nearly 3 months in total and we pay her while we're away.
she keeps saying she's getting too old to cope with the house now, god knows what we'll do when she leaves.

SelfEmployedCleaner · 17/10/2021 19:29

As for the "Urgent full time housekeeper required offering £10 an hour, ours has retired!" I don't blame her for retiring, the poor woman's been rinsed by that family.

I know. Sad And she probably thought minimum wage was all a 'cleaning' job was worth because that's the going rate (just above minimum wage!) if you're employed by most hotels or local authorities etc.

Hopefully those people will become very aware that they aren't offering a good rate.

SelfEmployedCleaner · 17/10/2021 19:25

Yes, that one sounds particularly bad!

I always imagine myself as Mrs Hughes swanning about but also doing the work of the maids!!! That's the advantage of working in period properties, you get to pretend a bit for a few hours.

I did look into going into decluttering a while ago, it's around £20-£25 an hour. There's a professional body you can join for something like £100 a year. At the time I was debating whether or not to have a complete change and give up cleaning, but I really love organising so I might look again. It would fit well with housekeeping.

Rosesareyellow · 17/10/2021 19:18

I think a housekeeper does more than clean - you would usually have one if you had a massive house and they might even be in charge of other cleaners. If you had someone like a plumber or decorator come round in the day you could leave your housekeeper in charge of guiding them, they might even be the one to call a plumber or electrician if needed. They would also do admin, ordering cleaning equipment and things like that. A cleaner wouldn’t have the same level of responsibility.

SmileyClare · 17/10/2021 19:11

Not at all, SelfEmployedCleaner you sound great- really productive with high standards!

I must admit, some of those housekeeping roles advertised on your link sound awful.
The live in ones mean you couldn't have any life of your own?

As for the "Urgent full time housekeeper required offering £10 an hour, ours has retired!" I don't blame her for retiring, the poor woman's been rinsed by that family. Shock

SelfEmployedCleaner · 17/10/2021 19:05

@SmileyClare

I don't go into client's clothing drawers or wardrobes as it feels a bit invasive. I would if they asked, of course, and if they wanted me to Maria Kondo their homes, I'd be on YouTube straightaway and also suggesting a higher rate because whilst there are cleaners and housekeepers there are also declutterers and organisers and they command much higher rates altogether! This is giving me more ideas...

I'm such a "gold digger cleaner"! Grin

SelfEmployedCleaner · 17/10/2021 19:02

Have a look at this set of adverts for Housekeepers. Grin

A good selection of people who know a HK's worth and those who want to pay minimum wage for someone to manage their home!

uk.indeed.com/Private-Housekeeper-jobs?advn=3151555674175321&vjk=c9ad651a4cc90ab9

SmileyClare · 17/10/2021 18:35

About once a month, she will get all the clothes out of my drawers and put them back folded Marie Kondo style

Everyone has different preferences I suppose but I'd hate that. Grin

I'd feel quite violated to have my knicker drawer Marie Kondo'ed and then feel under pressure to keep that standard up so she didn't judge.

SmileyClare · 17/10/2021 17:48

It's tricky sometimes isn't it SelfEmployedCleaner to define your role as cleaner or housekeeper. It certainly sounds as though you could call yourself a housekeeper and perhaps charge more?

I've learnt over time to keep firm boundaries. On my first job years ago, I started as a cleaner but found I was gradually asked to do more and more: laundry, baby sitting while cleaning, running errands, clearing out a filthy loft with just a rickety step ladder to get up there, I was even asked to stay late to re paint their summerhouse Grin

Looking back, I was rather naively agreeing to all these extra jobs on a cleaning rate of £12 an hour and I should have said No or charged more.

Labracadabradoodle · 17/10/2021 17:47

£14ph...😂
No, cleaners and housekeepers are different.
Cleaners clean, housekeepers do that plus tons of admin.
All are worthy, in my opinion.

SelfEmployedCleaner · 17/10/2021 17:42

I also do one off spring cleans and for those I currently charge a set fee but it works out at about £15.50 an hour more or less.

SelfEmployedCleaner · 17/10/2021 17:39

@SW1amp

I'm in NW England. The funny thing is that when I started cleaning I very quickly cottoned on to the fact that in my own town and to the west and south people expected to pay less and have cleaners for maybe 2 hours a week. So I only clean near two towns about 30 minutes drive in the other direction. I also restrict my slots to a minimum of three hours. I've currently got some of those and a couple of four hour ones. I sell myself as someone who cleans old properties using natural products. I don't clean suburban modern homes - that is soul destroying for me. One of my clients lives almost 20 miles away and offered to pay mileage as well as my fee so I'm obviously tapping into a need.

I definitely think I could pick up clients who would like me to organise window cleaning and grass cutting etc, and go shopping for them.

@SmileyClare

None of my cleaning rotas take up the entire slot. At least not every week. I think on pretty much every 3 hour slot I can do something extra for 30 mins, and on the four hour ones I've done the main tasks in three hours. It does depend. My clients all live in period properties and this time of year they are full of cobwebs so that takes up time!

I also do not clean ovens! That would be £20+ an hour and it's a horrible job so I don't want it anyway.

SmileyClare · 17/10/2021 17:20

If you can put up your rates then do so, SelfEmployedCleaner Smile

However I also do more than cleaning on most jobs. I tidy, empty bins, dishwashers, do laundry, change beds, feed the dogs, take in parcels, most self employed cleaners do don't they?

The only difference being I only stay late to do extra tasks or deep cleaning if asked? The actual cleaning rota takes up my whole time slot, I don't think I've ever had a free hour at the end when I've thought "I know I'll clear out the kitchen cupboards" unless I sacrifice cleaning a bathroom or hoovering the house for example? Confused

I think most self employed cleaners are willing to do extra tasks beyond their cleaning remit if asked?

I won't clean ovens though; I recommend a professional oven cleaning company, Who charge way more than I do!

SW1amp · 17/10/2021 17:15

[quote SelfEmployedCleaner]This and the other thread have given me a lot of things to think about.

Particularly what people expect a cleaner to do compared to a housekeeper. I'm definitely going to change my offer.

Just had a look at this website about the differences.

www.greycoatlumleys.co.uk/looking-for-a-job/career-advice/housekeeper-job-description/[/quote]
Where abouts are you based?

I think there is definitely more demand in some areas than others, but the main advantage is probably not having to travel between jobs

Our old housekeeper rebranded herself gradually by only taking on new clients who would commit to a minimum of 4 hours twice a week, and sacking cleaning clients to be able to accommodate the new ones
She now only works for 2 clients and while her hourly rate isn’t much more, she doesn’t lose any time to travelling or cancellations, and is much much happier

She said the only downside is that the housekeeping clients have much bigger houses so she spends a lot of time walking up stairs so is quite tired..!

But there is no reason that you can’t advertise housekeeping services with a minimum number of hours, and see what the demand is, and cull your least favourite clients when someone hires you

2bazookas · 17/10/2021 17:08

Housekeepers do far more than cleaning. They might also shop, do laundry, iron, cook. change beds etc.