Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

BF's relationship with his Mom- red flag or not?

160 replies

Evangeli · 17/10/2021 12:38

Dating for three years now. Everything lovely, great company, great sex, similar tastes blah blah blah. talking about buying a house and moving in together when time is right. BUT (there's always a but, right?).
BF is an only child. Never married, no kids. He's 42, fully-functioning and capable. Are these red flags?

Mom has a key to his apartment and pops in and out - a couple of times walking in on us although I understand now she texts and that hasn't happened in the recent past.
Mom does a lot of his housework, right down changing his sheets and doing his laundry.
Mom has full knowledge son’s eating habits and sleeping schedule, not to mention arranging his car check-ups, medical and bank appointments. (I know because she'll call while I'm with him, or he'll even mention it himself, not seeing anything odd about this).

i've told him point-blank that you realise if we actually do end up living together this won't continue and he says oh yes I know.

One of our biggest fights happened when he was with his mom, mentioned he was tired, he was seeing me later that night, and she went on at him about cancelling with me since he's tired and needs an early night, to the extent that "just to get her to leave me alone" he texted me and cancelled while he was still with her. I found that very disrespectful and inappropriate. We did end up seeing each other later, and he wasn't tired at all.

I remember reading a novel by an Irishwoman- very fun read (can't remember her name) and she makes fun of the "Irish Catholic Mammy" or the ICM for short, who does her son's laundry etc- that fits BF's mom perfectly (she is of Irish descent and is catholic).

My mom (now dead) was very interfering and overbearing in her own way, but not to this level detail (honestly tho maybe she would be if I'd let her), plus we are four siblings, so very different dynamic.

What do you think?

OP posts:
Dozer · 17/10/2021 13:43

I read a bit about ‘transactional analysis’ at university. Seems like he hasn’t ‘transitioned’ to having an ‘adult to adult’ relationship with his mum. He is still interacting with her as a child. And prioritising doing what she prefers / says over his adult relationship with you. Not attractive.

I would also lose attraction to someone who didn’t do all their own domestic work.

If he’s such a ‘clean freak’ and prides himself on it, why is he not doing the work himself?!

If - and I wouldn’t - you still want to date him, don’t think it’d be sensible to even consider moving in with him until your 15 year old DC has left home. Too many red flags, so would be unfair to your DC.

Evangeli · 17/10/2021 13:41

@NoYOUbekind

Easy to be a clean freak when someone else does your cleaning!
I know right :(
OP posts:
Evangeli · 17/10/2021 13:40

@Eleganz

He's 42, fully-functioning and capable.

But he isn't though is he? His mum is coming in and being maid twice a week at least.

42!

No hope for this one, the habit will be to hard to break and you'll either have mumsy as a third wheel or you'll be stuck keeping things shipshape and Bristol fashion for him instead.

I think it's more than that, every other day maybe, depending on her own health issues.

She's in her early seventies, to pp who were asking, and I understand she has considerably "slowed down".

I have no doubt that the fact he's remained unmarried and childfree at this age is due to his mother's role in his life. Because otherwise he has a decent job and income, he doesn't look like a troll, and he's generally presentable and sweet.

OP posts:
NoYOUbekind · 17/10/2021 13:38

Easy to be a clean freak when someone else does your cleaning!

MiddlesexGirl · 17/10/2021 13:37

Trial period first?
Keep your own places so you can go back to them if it doesn't work out.

Eleganz · 17/10/2021 13:37

He's 42, fully-functioning and capable.

But he isn't though is he? His mum is coming in and being maid twice a week at least.

42!

No hope for this one, the habit will be to hard to break and you'll either have mumsy as a third wheel or you'll be stuck keeping things shipshape and Bristol fashion for him instead.

Evangeli · 17/10/2021 13:35

Another option we discuss (acknowledging our differences in lifestyle) is just trying to move in the same building or even street so we could be much closer than we are now, just not in the same space.

I think I'd like us being in the same building. It would be much more in terms of expense.

OP posts:
Nowomenaroundeh · 17/10/2021 13:33

I am surprised I didn't see a landslide yanbu honestly. This is a seriously massive red flag.

I am Irish. The Irish mammy is real. It's not every Irish mother thankfully but they do exist and you have found one here.

Are you happy to be his mistress? His someday live-in mistress? Because he's married to her, not you. His dad is probably distant because he long ago accepted his role as a sideline character.

Do not underestimate what a messy situation this will be if you decide to proceed.

First of all he needs to untangle before you proceed in any way. If you move in with him you will be expected to replace her or at least compete for the position. Imagine what that will be like? Trying to prove yourself as worthy enough to pick up after him, fawn on him, generally adore him for no appreciation as it's just his dues. And you will never do it properly. You will never get the laundry just right or make apple pie with the exact right ratios or whatever it is.

If you are staying with him, you need to stress test his ability to cut the apron strings. And you need to do it cleverly, you can't say anything that will sound even vaguely like a criticism of his mother.

Tell him you have some reservations about committing further. You are a single mother. You are resilient and independent. These are essential traits in anyone you consider as a partner. The fact he 'has his laundry done' or "doesn't manage his personal affairs himself' (don't mention her!) is concerning. See what he says. Does he see where you're coming from? Can he change? Fair enough if he can't, you just felt the need to be honest. Can he show you he can change before you discuss moving in together etc.

But do not move into this mess.

Brollywasntneededafterall · 17/10/2021 13:32

My dd actually loved her bfs dm and did manage to stop her letting herself in. Didn't last long as bf got a dpuppy and guess who came and let it out midday for a wee?
And took it for jabs...
And cleaned the floor after work..
They split up... Guess where bf went to live?

Evangeli · 17/10/2021 13:31

I've actually told him (after 2 years) he needs to not have long phone conversations with her while I'm there, and he hasn't. Now it's like "Hi mom, yes Evangeli is with me. Just picked her up. Yeah I'll talk to you later. bye". Which is better, I guess? baby steps?

OP posts:
FinallyHere · 17/10/2021 13:30

he is the "clean freak" ... he has a bachelor place where it's just him.

But... his mother is coming in each to to do his washing and cleaning. He may like things to be clean but he isn't doing anything much to make or keep it like that.

I wouldn't move in with him.

The difference between your approaches will be too big to bridge. Trying to adjust will be very, very painful for both of you.

barbrahunter · 17/10/2021 13:30

Reminds me of an ex of mine. There is nothing so guaranteed to turn one off than watching a supposed equal partner delightedly opening and consuming a packed lunch that mummy lovingly prepared for him that morning.

Evangeli · 17/10/2021 13:28

Not in the UK, small town Canada. relatively easy pandemic experience.

He has a communal laudromat at his apartment building.
During peak lockdown, his parents actually made a big song and dance about him NOT going to the communal laundry, picking up his laundry from behind the door and dropping it off again.

Yes, what he eats day to day. as in "yeah I had a muffin earlier, and maybe I'll grab a sandwich later... I got 6 hours of sleep last night which was pretty good. No I'm not feeling tired- I only woke up once but was able to fall back asleep later. Ok I'll take the car at 3 then? No you don't need to call and remind me" (she calls anyway).

OP posts:
WhitePhantom · 17/10/2021 13:28

[quote Evangeli]@Taoneusa yeah- that's what I tell myself- that's it is a good sign he's so close and has warm relations with his mom.

the laundry thing- I've actually told him it makes me uncomfortable as my underwear might be there too otherwise I don't care- he says he can't stop her she just comes in and takes it and she doesn't faint with horror if she sees a pair of panties. :)[/quote]
But whether she will "faint with horror if she sees a pair of panties." is not the point. This is not about her - this is about YOU, and something that makes YOU feel uncomfortable. He needs to respect that, and not just throw his hands in the air and say Oh dear, I can't stop her. Of course he can stop her!

I wouldn't even consider moving in with him while things are the way they are, and I'd make it very clear to him to why not. If he wants you to move in badly enough, he'll change things. I wouldn't be holding my breath though...

Restlessinthenorth · 17/10/2021 13:28

Run, run away now. I'm just disentangling myself from a relationship with a man similar to this. She has been a constant problem in our relationship, extremely manipulative and controlling. No way will this woman let go without causing you major dramas, whatever she says now.

KellyJonesLeatherTrousers · 17/10/2021 13:27

It’s good you’ve flagged it as not sustainable but I’d be clear with him that things need to change even before you live together ie starting now - if I were you I’d want to see clear evidence that he can look after himself way before I moved in!

LidlMiddleLover · 17/10/2021 13:26

Marry him and move severall continents away from mummy

Evangeli · 17/10/2021 13:24

the thing with the domestic is that we have already discussed and accepted (I guess?) that he is the "clean freak" in the relationship and I will never be as tidy and clean as him- mostly because I run a family home with kids and cat, he has a bachelor place where it's just him.

I have said many times I don't like housework anyway- he should know at this point than to expect me to "take over".

OP posts:
NerdyBird · 17/10/2021 13:23

Are you in the UK? If so, what happened in the lockdowns? There would have been periods of time where she shouldn't have been coming over and doing his washing etc.

Standrewsschool · 17/10/2021 13:22

Maybe this situation has arisen and neither has broken the habit.

However, he’s 42, and his mum sorts out his appointments, washing etc. Does he have a washing machine in his house? If so, that’s out of order. If not, time to buy one.

What do you mean that she knows about his eating habits. Ie. What he eats day to day? Who does the food shopping? One my son moved out at the age of eighteen, I used to ask what he was eating (to check he was eating okay), but three years on, it’s up to him.

If he’s a fully functional adult, no issues etc, I’d see it as a red flag, unless he can start putting in boundaries now and can prove he’s an independent man. Otherwise, as others have said, you will just fill that role, and take on all the ‘wife-work’.

Evangeli · 17/10/2021 13:21

@MamsellMarie no absolutely not! No babies in the picture. I have 2 of my own, one flown the maternal nest, as they say, and he (says he) doesn't want kids (works with special needs kids professionally, says he's sees enough of kids not to want them at home haha)

OP posts:
EspressoDoubleShot · 17/10/2021 13:19

@NoYOUbekind

The thing is, say you do get him to unmesh from her - which will take time, effort, strong boundaries and patience - then what happens next? Will you be expected to fill the gaps? 42 is old to be learning the basic skills you need to exist in the world.

In other words, if mammy stops doing his washing, he'll expect you to do it instead. This will never be an equal relationship because he has no idea what an equal relationship looks and feels like. If you want to spend the next 5 years training that in, then have at it. Personally the thought makes my fanny clam up.

Yup. And SNAP that’s the sound of fanny closing shut.
Evangeli · 17/10/2021 13:19

@MildCreamyCheddar That is awful. I hope you find a way out. Thank for sharing your experience.

@Taoneusa thank you- I am hoping it is just a "jostling for position" as you say, because other than this, I have become very attached to him, I went through our own family crisis with an aging parent last month and he was very supportive (after I directly told him he had to be, he stepped up. It didn't occur to him spontaneously- but I guess the point is he did step up once it was clearly and directly pointed out to him), he's great with my son, and I can see a future with him.
Just not with his mom :)

OP posts:
OverweightPidgeon · 17/10/2021 13:18

he says he can't stop her she just comes in and takes it

And there’s your answer- he can stop her , he just doesn’t want to .

EspressoDoubleShot · 17/10/2021 13:16

Yes so the mammy will inevitably slow down,will he spontaneously step up do his own chores or expect op to undertake domestic duties