Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

BF's relationship with his Mom- red flag or not?

160 replies

Evangeli · 17/10/2021 12:38

Dating for three years now. Everything lovely, great company, great sex, similar tastes blah blah blah. talking about buying a house and moving in together when time is right. BUT (there's always a but, right?).
BF is an only child. Never married, no kids. He's 42, fully-functioning and capable. Are these red flags?

Mom has a key to his apartment and pops in and out - a couple of times walking in on us although I understand now she texts and that hasn't happened in the recent past.
Mom does a lot of his housework, right down changing his sheets and doing his laundry.
Mom has full knowledge son’s eating habits and sleeping schedule, not to mention arranging his car check-ups, medical and bank appointments. (I know because she'll call while I'm with him, or he'll even mention it himself, not seeing anything odd about this).

i've told him point-blank that you realise if we actually do end up living together this won't continue and he says oh yes I know.

One of our biggest fights happened when he was with his mom, mentioned he was tired, he was seeing me later that night, and she went on at him about cancelling with me since he's tired and needs an early night, to the extent that "just to get her to leave me alone" he texted me and cancelled while he was still with her. I found that very disrespectful and inappropriate. We did end up seeing each other later, and he wasn't tired at all.

I remember reading a novel by an Irishwoman- very fun read (can't remember her name) and she makes fun of the "Irish Catholic Mammy" or the ICM for short, who does her son's laundry etc- that fits BF's mom perfectly (she is of Irish descent and is catholic).

My mom (now dead) was very interfering and overbearing in her own way, but not to this level detail (honestly tho maybe she would be if I'd let her), plus we are four siblings, so very different dynamic.

What do you think?

OP posts:
Evangeli · 17/10/2021 19:35

@Monkeymilkshake

Maybe just moving in the same building would be great or carrying on as it is! I wouldnt want to move in with him the way you describe him! You’d be in the middle of him and his mum. The cons outway the pros in this case
Moving in the same building does sound ideal it's just such a double expense. And what is the justification for it? "I love you but you and your mom remind me of Norman Bates and his mom"? :)
OP posts:
Evangeli · 17/10/2021 19:33

Oh and no question of having children with this man or anyone else. Had my tubes tied after DS and unplanned pregnancies :)

OP posts:
Evangeli · 17/10/2021 19:25

"he says he can't stop her

He could if he wanted to of course he could! He could speak to her, he could even take his key off her. He's far more reluctant to "upset" her than you"

Well yes. That's what he says. He says she gets far too upset if he tries to "stop" her and it's easier just to "go along with it".

I am assuming he does actually know how to clean and launder and make car appointments, after all he is holding down a fairly taxing job in education for many years. Again, it's just "easier" to let mom do that stuff. After all, why not. And as she said to me on one of our pleasant get-togethers, she "worries about him so much, working so hard with all those children". Another piece of context is that he had a horrible illness in his teens (I don't know how to spell it- long bouts of nausea and dizziness) which almost killed him lasted for months, as well as a nasty rockclimbing accident which shattered his knee and left him with a limp, so the mom is "understandably" over-protective (?)

@MrsClatterbuck
Interesting point re future. He just saw us arrange for our elderly dad to move into full-time care after a bad fall, breaking hip and surgery not recovering leaving him fully wheelchair-bound (the crisis I mentioned earlier) - we both know personal care etc is not on the cards. Although he does glorify his auntie who took care of his grandma till her dying day.

He is "woke" and "feminist" - I've never heard him spout stuff about "women's work" etc- but I think posters above who said his words and actions seem quite different might have a point.

His last serious relationship ended when she wanted to move away to a big city and he never wants to leave here. That was several years ago- he's been without a long-term relationship for years until he met me because he says he was too busy with his education and career.

I wouldn't necessarily hold it against him that he didn't marry/doesn't have kids- plenty of women in their forties are in the same boat!

Yes I do the domestic labour -and I bloody well hate it. I have a cleaner once a week for heavy stuff, and I like cooking tho'. Kids do some chores and the amount of energy to get them to do it might as well do it myself.

OP posts:
MrsClatterbuck · 17/10/2021 19:04

One of the things that would worry me is when his mum becomes elderly and cannot do things the same including her own house. Would you be expected to step up or even have her move in with you. Not fully au fait with the Canadian health and welfare system but it would be a lot less expensive for them to move in with you or maybe want her son to move in with them to look after them. A Facebook I am in for elderly parents has a lot of dils having a venting session about their mil living with them. Seems very common for Canada and the States. Can't see your bf doing any personal care. Can you?

Monkeymilkshake · 17/10/2021 18:43

Maybe just moving in the same building would be great or carrying on as it is!
I wouldnt want to move in with him the way you describe him! You’d be in the middle of him and his mum. The cons outway the pros in this case

AnnieSnap · 17/10/2021 18:30

I would be very reluctant to move in with a man under these circumstances. There are many things to consider. It’s likely this level of babying him would continue after you are living together and it would drive me nuts. Plus he is a 42-year-old man who has never learned to take care of himself and his own home. Who do you think he will expect to take over when she can no longer do it? You of course. That would surely cause friction.

If you really want to live with him, maybe tell him that he needs to demonstrate that he can do his own washing, ironing, cleaning etc and that isn’t done by his mum before you can move in together. He can still be close to her, meet her for coffee etc, but that you want to see a more independent version of him. Otherwise, the living in separate apartments in the same building might be the best option.

Ledition · 17/10/2021 18:13

I'm well acquainted with Irish Catholic mammies and I would advise you to put this one back on the shelf, he's ruined. He's not "fully functioning" as you say as he's never had to be and at 42+ it's too late to change him.

You will never be equal domestic partners as that will forever be seen as "women's work". Do not use set any circumstance have children with this man unless you plan on being a carbon copy of his mother. You have been warned!

Graphista · 17/10/2021 18:08

In a boyfriend aged late teens/early 20's this would be slightly concerning... it would put my dd aged 20 off a chap.

In a 42 year old?! Run!

No no no no no

I recognise the archetype as a scot of Irish descent raised Catholic myself

My mum COULD have been this way with bro but he nipped it in the bud himself

At 40-odd? Nah he likes it this way and you'll be framed as unreasonable for actually expecting it to change if you live together/marry

This may well be WHY he's this age never having married or had dc!

Do you know what happened with his previous relationships?

High possibility mum "saw them off"

I agree even IF you get him to cut the umbilical cord finally, then he will be pretty useless as a partner/father cos he's never HAD to do the drudge work!

There's close...and there's enmeshed! This sounds far more like enmeshment

he says he can't stop her

He could if he wanted to of course he could! He could speak to her, he could even take his key off her. He's far more reluctant to "upset" her than you

It's irrelevant that he "knows" you're not a tidy type, he'll still expect either you take over OR accept that she will still be doing all she is now

You don't seem compatible generally I think if you moved in there'd soon be massive tensions

His dad is probably distant because he long ago accepted his role as a sideline character

I would agree, this is all VERY dysfunctional.

It borders on covert/emotional incest to be honest!

Seems like he hasn’t ‘transitioned’ to having an ‘adult to adult’ relationship with his mum

Totally agree - I've also studied TA and that totally fits

Hard rule: never ever move in with a man who is not doing his own cleaning, cooking and laundry, and to a standard you respect

That's a pretty good rule

Frankly if I knew him in real life I'd be telling him to get loads of therapy

Weonlyhavealoanofit · 17/10/2021 17:41

I have a friend who is very intimately involved in her adult son’s life. She speaks to him 4 times a day and holidays with him at every available opportunity. She supervises almost everything he does. IMO, re your ‘future MIL’ ….her son is the husband she never had…..mammy won’t give up this special relationship, her husband is the 3rd person in the marriage.

Ponoka7 · 17/10/2021 17:38

"he should know at this point than to expect me to "take over"."

He sounds like the type who needs it spelling out. Has he spent much time at your place? I doubt if he will cope with what living together would bring, in terms of noise and mess. He would definitely expect you to step up.

bluegreygreen · 17/10/2021 17:31

He's 42, fully-functioning and capable

In what way? He doesn't appear to be able to do his own housework or life admin.

Interesting that his Dad is still about but very much on the periphery. The primary relationship is between him and his mother. I think you may find, if you continue, that your role reflects his Dad's - pleasant but secondary.

Dozer · 17/10/2021 17:25

Because of your BF’s issues, that is, not living with someone per se!

Dozer · 17/10/2021 17:24

As regards domestic work and attraction, my philosophy is that I wouldn’t want to get serious with someone unwilling to do their domestic work and ‘life admin’, so why bother dating them?

Things you might out up with when dating would be much harder to ignore if living together.

Presumably as a single parent you’ve done and still do a lot of domestic work, and have taught your teen DC to do it. It seems illogical to consider living with someone much less willing and capable than you are. Even setting aside his major mummy issues!

Whatever you decide for yourself, wouldn’t put your youngest DS into a situation of living with your boyfriend. Unfair on DS.

OverweightPidgeon · 17/10/2021 17:18

GoingOutOutNEVER the trouble is , what he says and what he does are two very different things, if he didn’t like it surely he would have put a stop to it by now?

Could you just keep things as they are Op , enjoy his company when you see him and let his mum carry on mummying him ?

GoingOutOutNEVER · 17/10/2021 17:13

Ask him if he likes his mum doing all the stuff, he may find it difficult to tell her to stop. Does sound like he’s treated like a child, why is she telling him to cancel his plans with you and more importantly why is he doing it. I’d be out of that relationship, waving goodbye and telling him the reasons why .. he needs to grow up and be an adult

Evangeli · 17/10/2021 16:41

@OverweightPidgeon

It’s also not great that , although he stepped up and supported you through a difficult time , you had to tell him he should do it , he didn’t do it naturally.
I know, definitely a strike against him.
OP posts:
Evangeli · 17/10/2021 16:39

hi everybody just popped in to say hi :)

I have to say about the timeframe, a lot of that is on me. As a lone parent of two teenagers who'd been through abusive relationship, hellish divorce and then the father fucked off to another country, abandoning all fatherhood responsibility, I was massively nervous about introducing him (or any bf) to my kids. In fact I didn't do so until over a year that we had been dating. He was a well-kept secret till then. Even after that, he wasn't like around at our place all the time and we weren't doing "family" shite and all that- I'd go out with him. He'd drop by for a visit or something and that was it. Our place is my kids safe, comfortable space, and nobody ever has/had any intention to taking that away from them.

the main reason there is talk of moving to the next step is mostly because my oldest DD has moved out to uni and I feel very lonely in the evenings:)

However, now, it is clear that not much will happen in terms of "progressing" until DS15 is home. Or if/when we can buy a property big enough to accomodate the 3 of us comfortably? Not sure what that could look like.

He's always been very respectful of the boundaries with my kids, and never pushed against that.

The mom making appointments and stuff never really bothered me -until now when I wondering.

Thanks for the input.

OP posts:
OverweightPidgeon · 17/10/2021 16:30

It’s also not great that , although he stepped up and supported you through a difficult time , you had to tell him he should do it , he didn’t do it naturally.

StrongLegs · 17/10/2021 16:18

Are you thinking of having kids? If you are then having such a helpful MIL might be handy, if you can divert her caring attention onto your whole family, not just your dp.

FinallyHere · 17/10/2021 16:16

Maybe if he could demonstrate adulting by living for a year without any input from his DM? Try asking him whether he would be prepared to do without the housekeeping services from his mother, starting now.

I'd love to know his opinion on such an idea.

BananaPB · 17/10/2021 16:12

There's a programme on TLC (channel) called I Love a Mama's Boy which has different couples where the man has this dynamic with his mum. It looks like hell tbh.

C152 · 17/10/2021 16:06

Christ almighty, ditch him now! IF he manages to get his mum to take a step back once you move in together / get married, he will be expecting you to take on the role of 'mother'...and with her muttering in the background, you'll never live up to expectations.

The fact that he's an only child, never married with no kids is not in itself a red flag. It's the inappropriate relationship with his mother. She needs to let go and he needs to grow up. But it hasn't happened by the time he's in his 40s, it's never going to happen. It's not normal. Seriously, you deserve better. Let him go and find a grown up.

Herewegoagain84 · 17/10/2021 16:03

Not only will she be the third person in your relationship, if you suggest all her organisation of his life ends when you move in, he’ll just expect you to do it all instead…

LadyTiredWinterBottom2 · 17/10/2021 16:01

You know that bit in your opening post when you said he's a fully functioning adult - he quite clearly isn't.

Can you imagine having kids with this man? You will die of exhaustion while his mum fusses over him because the baby woke him in the night

Is thus a red flag? This is a terracotta army of red flags

Merlotmmm · 17/10/2021 15:54

I bet your boyfriend thinks you'll be picking up all tasks his mom currently does and that's why he knows she may not be as involved in the future.

I don't see any possibility of him being able to look after himself. Are you sure this is what you want, OP?