Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Switch or something else? Can talk to me about what i need to buy please?

116 replies

coodawoodashooda · 17/10/2021 12:10

It's for Christmas. We haven't got any kind of gaming equipment so far. 3 siblings aged between 6 and 10. I've been saving all year so i should (i hope) be able to affect all of what i need in order for them to enjoy it. What do i have tp buy? Where is the best place to buy it from? Are the games on the device or is that an extra expense? Do they need cases or protective covers? Im a single parent with absolutely no clue. Please help.

OP posts:
babblingbumblingbandofbaboons · 18/10/2021 22:19

Yes, giving one the main switch is fancier, but not necessarily unfair if they’re a bit older. Bear in mind that all 3 would use the main one. In all honesty though, 3 consoles is likely overkill and a bit of a waste of money until you understand if all 3 will use it. Use the extra to buy extra games and accessories rather than extra consoles and I bet they’ll love it!

coodawoodashooda · 18/10/2021 22:14

@DuvetDayIsEveryDay

List of what you need:

1 Switch (give this to the eldest)
2 Switch lites
Spare controller
Cases
Screen protectors
Games
Possible TV if want to stretch that far.

If i did this would it mean the eldest had something fancier? Would 3 lites and 1 main thing actually be more fair? (my xh does unfair gifts, its a bit sensitive)
OP posts:
jesscakess · 18/10/2021 22:06

My 10 yr old is ready to move on from a Switch now. He wants a PS4 or gaming PC as these have fuller versions of games with all the features that aren't available on the Switch. Also the switch is WiFi only, because it is supposed to be portable. If you have average to slow WiFi then it will impact some of the gaming experience, especially if they are playing online with friends. A PS4 can be wired with an Ethernet cable to give a faster internet speed. These things are most important to my DS but may not be for yours.

DuvetDayIsEveryDay · 18/10/2021 22:04

List of what you need:

1 Switch (give this to the eldest)
2 Switch lites
Spare controller
Cases
Screen protectors
Games
Possible TV if want to stretch that far.

Dancingonmoonlight · 18/10/2021 21:59

I bought a switch a couple of years ago for two DC. I didn't/don't know anything about them so bought extra controllers too.

My observations:
Bought the main switch even though was tempted by the Lite but wanted children to share and play together.
Extra controllers are not needed for two children but would be needed for three.
DC1 only played Animal Crossing and one other game in a few YEARS.
DC1 prefers to play Roblox on an old laptop.
DC2 has NEVER played on the switch. Has absolutely NO interest whatsoever. However would happily watch YouTube videos all day long if allowed.

On reflection a second cheap tv, one main switch, additional controllers and a couple of games is all you need to start off with. Your DC can go to Game and choose second hand games they think they'd like at a later time - on birthdays etc.
Also try Game for second hand consoles at a later time if you think they would prefer their own handheld devices. Get them on each of their birthdays. Game repair them before selling on. In the meantime they can share the main switch and see how they get on/if they like it at all?

Scrunchcake · 18/10/2021 21:56

Another vote for buying physical copies of games, rather than downloading them. Buy them second hand if you can, from CEX or ebay, and sell them on when they outgrow them.

The Switch Parental Control app for your phone is good - you can set age restrictions, time limits, and make sure you don't save your debit card details on the device! (or password protect it).

I would make sure you set it all up before Christmas day - faffing on with accounts etc can take a while.

babblingbumblingbandofbaboons · 18/10/2021 21:54

@Jimjamjong

I think you could get the full switch (not the lite) plus 2 extra controllers and a game each according to their interest, so a total of 3 games. Plus the extra TV.
This is a really good suggestion for a starter pack. Add in the hard case for transport and you’re complete, and still at far less cost than 3 separate consoles and sets of games. Honestly though, it will make far more sense if you go speak to someone in store, try game, explain that you’re really confused by options and that you think you need what’s been recommended here, they’ll keep you right, you’ll come out with a shopping list, and you can then organise the best deal you can Smile
Jimjamjong · 18/10/2021 21:48

I think you could get the full switch (not the lite) plus 2 extra controllers and a game each according to their interest, so a total of 3 games.
Plus the extra TV.

coodawoodashooda · 18/10/2021 21:37

@Atla

You can set it up for no online play, so they just play their own single player game.

@coodawoodashooda you know your own kids best. Does your oldest one have an opinion about what they would like?

Mine have a switch between them, but we also have a PC that they can use for gaming and things like Minecraft that can be played on tablet, so they don't have to play together/agree on a game.

For fairness on Xmas day maybe a switch lite each plus a game or two that they might like. You could always get a Switch at a later date if they want to do multiplayer?

I would never ask them. Im so tight about stuff like this. They'll never believe id buy it.
OP posts:
babblingbumblingbandofbaboons · 18/10/2021 21:34

@coodawoodashooda “ This thread makes really good sense until i need to buy the extra controllers. Surely they would all come inclusive”

When you buy a switch you get the console like the one shown in this link. The red and blue things on each side are the joycons (controllers). When you use the switch hand held these stay attached and are used as one controller. When you play multiplayer, these come off and can be used as one controller or as two single controllers.

So for all 3 of your kids to play together you need an extra set of these controllers, as you only have two with the console on its own. Does this make more sense?

safariboot · 18/10/2021 21:34

Only read OP's posts.

Switch is a good call for one console to share. There's a new "OLED Switch" with a bigger and better screen. If it'll be mostly played by itself in tabletop or handheld mode consider it, if it'll be mostly played plugged into a TV then consider the older one to save money.

"Tabletop mode": You just prop it up on the kickstand it has, take the controllers off the console, and play. So you can all sit round for multiplayer without needing to plug it into a TV. Really good for if you're travelling. Obviously a TV gives a much bigger display (and also the Switch runs in a higher graphics mode when docked).

I think other posts have covered the accessories. Second pair of Joycons for 4 player. Screen protector's a good idea; the Switch has a plastic screen which is smash-proof but scratches easily.

On games. They're not all the 40 or 50 quid price. On the eShop there's loads of cheaper ones. Eg I got Gear Club Unlimited, a decent enough racing game (not the best, but it's alright) for a few quid.

Online multiplayer requires a subscription. You don't need that for multiplayer on one console, or even on multiple consoles in the same room/house/picnic blanket.

Parental controls are kind of complicated. Make sure there's no way the kids could run up a huge bill - there are some Switch games with mobile-style money pit purchases.

That's the Switch. If you think your kids would prefer a device each, consider the 2DS/3DS range, though you'll be buying second-hand. It's a last-gen console but the games are still being sold.

MeredithGreyishblue · 18/10/2021 21:33

Minecraft is great. They don’t need to play with other kids. It's really innocuous on creative mode. It's my favourite option out of all the games mine have.

HeyGepetto · 18/10/2021 21:31

@coodawoodashooda

Is Minecraft on a switch the same Minecraft thats on an xbox?
Minecraft seems to be platform dependent, if you’re playing on iPad you can join other people playing on iPad, but not PC or Switch, I don’t know about Xbox, but it would be worth checking if it’s important for them to join their friends. I didn’t find it as easy to play on the switch personally. Have any of their friends got a switch already? I got my two one for Christmas last year and although my 7 year old plays animal crossing a lot, my 10 year old hardly plays on it at all, she plays Roblox and minecraft on her iPad instead. It might be worth trying one out if possible. I’m really put off by the price of the games.
Atla · 18/10/2021 21:31

You can set it up for no online play, so they just play their own single player game.

@coodawoodashooda you know your own kids best. Does your oldest one have an opinion about what they would like?

Mine have a switch between them, but we also have a PC that they can use for gaming and things like Minecraft that can be played on tablet, so they don't have to play together/agree on a game.

For fairness on Xmas day maybe a switch lite each plus a game or two that they might like. You could always get a Switch at a later date if they want to do multiplayer?

coodawoodashooda · 18/10/2021 21:31

@babblingbumblingbandofbaboons

There are two types of Switch - the Switch and the Switch Lite. The difference between them is that the Switch lite is hand held only, while the full Switch can be used handheld or connected to TV. I’d recommend the full Switch, especially with 3 kids.

The games don’t come with the console, they are between £30 and £50 each for most of the big titles. You can usually get a bundle when you first buy the switch, e.g the console plus a game for a small saving on buying them both separately.

The switch comes with two small controllers called Joycons (these are the brightly coloured parts on either side of the device). For some games you only need one of these to play, so you will have two controllers. I’d recommend buying another set of joycons, or a compatible controller so that all 3 of the kids can play games like MarioKart at the same time.

In terms of games, MarioKart, MarioParty, Luigis Mansion are great choices.

This thread makes really good sense until i need to buy the extra controllers. Surely they would all come inclusive?
OP posts:
HerRoyalWitchyness · 18/10/2021 21:30

I bought a switch between my youngest two last year and they love it. They have 30 minutes a day on it each or an hour if they're playing together. They love it.
I'd definitely go for one console plus accessories and extras

coodawoodashooda · 18/10/2021 21:29

@SoniaFouler

I just dont know. I can afford it. It is an absolutely massive Christmas present. Id never normally get anything as expensive as this. I need to get it right though. In my imagination i need to buy 3 things

Because you mention that you would like them to play on the TV, a switch lite can’t be an option because it doesn’t have that feature. So you can’t buy three lites anyway if playing on the TV is a must have so they’re out the question. if you’ve been budgeting for three you will probably find you can buy quite a few of the stuff on @babblingbumblingbandofbaboons list

Thank you so much everyone. I guess ill have to endure the pain of going into the shop. I absolutely hate buying stuff like this. For me it's like going to Screwfix or something.
OP posts:
babblingbumblingbandofbaboons · 18/10/2021 21:27

@coodawoodashooda

So, from another angle, if you woke up on Christmas Day what would you want to see that you and your 2 siblings got?
100% the switch on its own not 3 consoles. But this is with an adult head and the knowledge that 3 consoles won’t actually give them the things that they’re likely to enjoy most (playing together, big screen, bigger choice of games). Given their ages too, I’d think your eldest might be a bit peeved at getting the same thing as their youngest sibling, where if you wrap it as a shared present it belongs to them all and they can have games they enjoy together and games they enjoy alone.
SoniaFouler · 18/10/2021 21:25

I just dont know. I can afford it. It is an absolutely massive Christmas present. Id never normally get anything as expensive as this. I need to get it right though. In my imagination i need to buy 3 things

Because you mention that you would like them to play on the TV, a switch lite can’t be an option because it doesn’t have that feature. So you can’t buy three lites anyway if playing on the TV is a must have so they’re out the question. if you’ve been budgeting for three you will probably find you can buy quite a few of the stuff on @babblingbumblingbandofbaboons list

IlonaRN · 18/10/2021 21:24

We just bought one as a birthday present for our newly-6-year-old.
We bought the new one that came out about 10 days ago. It was super new, so no bundled games. We bought Minecraft, as he has seen that on YouTube.
He is massively into Pokémon, so his aunt bought him two Pokémon games.
His granny bought him a Sonic game and Lego City Undercover (bonus for us that the physical game has Danish language)
We got a hard case and screen protector for £18 as well.
His soon-to-be 18-yr-old cousin is dead jealous 😁

His Daddy did all the research, but it totally made sense. The new one has longer battery life etc, hence we chose that one.

coodawoodashooda · 18/10/2021 21:17

So, from another angle, if you woke up on Christmas Day what would you want to see that you and your 2 siblings got?

OP posts:
coodawoodashooda · 18/10/2021 21:16

@Atla

Minecraft is the same game just played on a different platform - they can still team up and play together with friends using a different device.
Okay. Im not keen on that. Ill surely be able to lock it?
OP posts:
Atla · 18/10/2021 21:15

Minecraft is the same game just played on a different platform - they can still team up and play together with friends using a different device.

coodawoodashooda · 18/10/2021 21:13

@Atla

The Nintendo website has a comparison tool here www.nintendo.co.uk/Hardware/Nintendo-Switch-Family/Which-Nintendo-Switch-is-right-for-you-/Which-Nintendo-Switch-is-right-for-you--1596110.html

(Sorry can't seem to do a proper link on this app!)

Be aware that multiplayer usually involves high noise levels - excited whooping, laughter and arguing, so don't know if this is a consideration for when at grandparents!

That's really kind. Thank you. Ill go and check the link. I think the grandparents will be more okay with the whooping than me!
OP posts: