Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Jimmy Savile

141 replies

wavingwhilstdrowning · 17/10/2021 11:08

AIBU to say that the BBC should not be making a film about Jimmy Savile. They should not be profiting form his victims misery. Savile attacked at least 450 victims.

Once again his photograph is everywhere, retraumatising his victims who have been treated horrifically by the BBC.

for full disclosure I gave evidence at Operation Yewtree.

OP posts:
wavingwhilstdrowning · 17/10/2021 13:41

SC was employed as a JS impersonator. He played JS on Spitting Image.
spittingimage.fandom.com/wiki/Steve_Coogan

The defence of this program I have heard in RL is that SC was great in Philomenia. Good for him. Apparently Dame Judi found his impression of JS hilarious: www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2021/10/16/revealed-steve-coogans-far-from-sensitive-jimmy-savile-gags/

OP posts:
SpindelWhorl · 17/10/2021 13:39

@Wisteriac43

I'm not interested in the story of a disgusting criminal, what I would be interested to see is something on all the bystanders, those who covered for him. I still don't think we know 'who knew what'. I doubt that will get made though...
Oh hell yes to this.
x2boys · 17/10/2021 13:36

@DoYouLikeOwls

Steve Coogan isn't just a comedian/impersonator. He was really good in Philomenia and Steven. I have enjoyed his other serious roles as well. As a fan I won't enjoy him playing JS though.

Js made me feel sick when I was child and I didn't get why anyone would want to meet him. This was before any thing came out.

I used to love Jim, ll fixit as a child, the BBC made him out to be a lovable eccentric, everybody's favourite,"Uncle" with the jewelry, and the cigar and his "now then, now then" catch phrase, etc, really creepy of the BBC to do that looking back.
Chipsahoy · 17/10/2021 13:33

But you watched three girls? I am a victim of cse and I am horrified that any of these things are made. I am horrified that so many people enjoy any of these sorts of documentaries.
It does not get the word out. It does not highlight the issues or make people aware. It is sensationalising abuse. None of it should be made or shown.
And as for these women and their lives are damaged forever.. I was one of those girls and I am not damaged or ruined forever.

DoYouLikeOwls · 17/10/2021 13:30

Steve Coogan isn't just a comedian/impersonator. He was really good in Philomenia and Steven. I have enjoyed his other serious roles as well. As a fan I won't enjoy him playing JS though.

Js made me feel sick when I was child and I didn't get why anyone would want to meet him. This was before any thing came out.

wavingwhilstdrowning · 17/10/2021 13:15

Some of Savile's victims have had their stories told. Louis Theroux tired to make an apology and involve victims in a documentary.
ITV also hosts victims with respect on their magazine shows, especially if there is another show about him on: www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10068253/Jimmy-Savile-victim-says-told-away-BBC-Pops-crew.html
The BBC silences the victims to tell the story they want to tell.

OP posts:
CoffeeRunner · 17/10/2021 13:12

@Porcupineintherough

But do his victims want their stories told and their voices heard on national tv? That's a genuine question btw, I just cant imagine I would in their position.
There are thought to be around 450 victims. If only a very small minority wanted to speak then you could still make a series along those lines. There are probably others who may want to speak out & make things publicly known without appearing on camera at all.
wavingwhilstdrowning · 17/10/2021 13:08

@Saucery

Wonder who they’ll get to play Jerry Sadowitz? After all, he was one of the ones who spoke up at the time. Strangely, never got BBC gigs after that……. All the people who tried to say something, what a kick in the teeth for them. I’m sorry they ignored you, OP. I’m sorry they ignored everyone who tried to make it known.
Jerry Sadowitz, Johnny Lydon and Irvine Welsh all spoke openly and repeatedly about JS abuse of children.

They managed to get away with it because 1) they are male 2) they are 'anarchists' 3) they are hard as fuck! It did have a very negative effect on Lydon's career thou.

OP posts:
TheQueef · 17/10/2021 13:05

Really important distinction Chequers if ever a subject should be above artistic licence it's CSA and the BBC have dirty hands in this scandal they absolutely should not be allowed to control the narrative of this story.

wavingwhilstdrowning · 17/10/2021 13:05

@BoredZelda

He's repeatedly done impressions of JS. He's an impersonator.

Loads of people did that. They aren’t doing them now though so I’m not sure your point is relevant here.

I think it is an important story to tell, as long as it focuses on what went wrong.

Last night I saw a group of men on a stag night, 3 were dressed as Savile. Many men find it hilarious to impersonate Savile. Every time I see 'him' I am traumatized.

Coogan is an impersonator first and comedian first and foremost. It is not likely to be a victim centred story focused on how JS was allowed to get away with his crimes is it?

OP posts:
wavingwhilstdrowning · 17/10/2021 13:01

@TheQueef

BBC wants to make money so it makes a DRAMA about the scandal. You'd be forgiven for expecting our public broadcaster not to capitalise on it's own failures, it is morally bankrupt. A documentary would be inappropriate from the BBC but at least we may discover facts. A drama serves no purpose other than financial, the BBC created victims and now they are selling them. (Before anyone bleats JS was the abuser, BBC had abuse complaints from Totp and Jimmy was looking old and creepy presenting Totp so the BBC solution was to create a dedicated kids programme for him)
Thank you for this TheQueef The BBC protected JS and were repeatedly informed of his offending. They were complicit in allowing JS to threaten his victims and silence them. I met JS in 1992. The nation as a whol wants this to be ancient history - a crime of the 60's when everyone was high and no one knew right from wrong, an era when many men abused children without any concern of prosecution. But this was something that he did his whole life, he engineered his entire career around this abuse. And the BBC not only allowed it, but protected him when victims complained. As did the Police.
OP posts:
ChequerBoard · 17/10/2021 13:00

@BoredZelda

He's repeatedly done impressions of JS. He's an impersonator.

Loads of people did that. They aren’t doing them now though so I’m not sure your point is relevant here.

I think it is an important story to tell, as long as it focuses on what went wrong.

It's a drama, not a documentary. Any drama that is 'based on a true story' takes liberties with the truth, usually adding scenes and sometimes creating merged characters based on multiple real people to amp up the drama and enable story-telling in a way that real-life just doesn't happen.

Anyone looking to give a frank and honest account of Saville's crimes and how they were obscured by so many organisations and people wouldn't be making a drama with a star cast list.

Saucery · 17/10/2021 12:58

Wonder who they’ll get to play Jerry Sadowitz? After all, he was one of the ones who spoke up at the time. Strangely, never got BBC gigs after that…….
All the people who tried to say something, what a kick in the teeth for them. I’m sorry they ignored you, OP. I’m sorry they ignored everyone who tried to make it known.

FrippEnos · 17/10/2021 12:54

Its already been said about the BBC and their role in promoting and hiding him.

I suspect that the "documentary" will spend a lot of time going on about how good he was at hiding in plain sight and it can't be their fault.

BoredZelda · 17/10/2021 12:53

He's repeatedly done impressions of JS. He's an impersonator.

Loads of people did that. They aren’t doing them now though so I’m not sure your point is relevant here.

I think it is an important story to tell, as long as it focuses on what went wrong.

Stath · 17/10/2021 12:36

@TheQueef

BBC wants to make money so it makes a DRAMA about the scandal. You'd be forgiven for expecting our public broadcaster not to capitalise on it's own failures, it is morally bankrupt. A documentary would be inappropriate from the BBC but at least we may discover facts. A drama serves no purpose other than financial, the BBC created victims and now they are selling them. (Before anyone bleats JS was the abuser, BBC had abuse complaints from Totp and Jimmy was looking old and creepy presenting Totp so the BBC solution was to create a dedicated kids programme for him)
EXACTLY @TheQueef.

‘The BBC created victims and they are selling them’ sums it up perfectly.

It’s like a plantation owner making profitable entertainment featuring a particularly nasty overseer they employed a few years after abolition Angry

GemGEmGemster · 17/10/2021 12:36

I have a family member who was murdered. Professor David Wilson did a programme called ‘Britains Most Evil Killers’ or some shit like that, which featured my relatives killer. I wrote to David Wilson and asked him not to use my relatives case as it was so upsetting for us and he had the absolute barefaced fucking cheek to tell reply saying - and this is a direct quote - ‘ I note your concerns about programmes such as this inevitably re-igniting public interest about tragic events and how you and your family have avoided publicity. However, I also shared with you how some victim families will actually contact me wanting publicity – for diverse reasons – and that they will take an opposite view’
ie I should be grateful that he was taking an interest!!
Titillating the masses. Pathetic. There are actual humans behind these crimes and the TV companies couldn’t care less.

ChequerBoard · 17/10/2021 12:36

I agree with you OP, this is disrespectful, thoughtless and self-serving of the BBC. To try to turn this into a ratings-winning drama is frankly unbelievable.

Only someone as narcissistic as Steve Coogan would take on that role. Vile, just vile.

I hope no-one watches. I'm not usually in favour of boycotting things but for this I could make an exception.

wavingwhilstdrowning · 17/10/2021 12:28

@toocold54

The BBC and his friends were at fault too for turning a blind eye so I think they are trying to show ‘look how serious we take it and how sorry we are’.

I get that it can be distressing for the victims but I do think it’s important that things like this aren’t just forgotten about and that any mistakes are highlighted and make sure they don’t happen again.

It also encourages other victims of his or other celebrities to come forward.
Many times one person comes forward and then other people come forward afterwards.

If someone finds it distressing they don’t have to watch it but if someone is going through it now and watching this makes them come forward then I think it is a good thing.

That's true but this week I've seen photos of coogan mugging as savile and it's fucking disgusting. It really is. The BBC knew. I told them. Repeatedly. I also told West Yorkshire Police who colluded to silence me.
OP posts:
toocold54 · 17/10/2021 12:26

The BBC and his friends were at fault too for turning a blind eye so I think they are trying to show ‘look how serious we take it and how sorry we are’.

I get that it can be distressing for the victims but I do think it’s important that things like this aren’t just forgotten about and that any mistakes are highlighted and make sure they don’t happen again.

It also encourages other victims of his or other celebrities to come forward.
Many times one person comes forward and then other people come forward afterwards.

If someone finds it distressing they don’t have to watch it but if someone is going through it now and watching this makes them come forward then I think it is a good thing.

HumphreyCobblers · 17/10/2021 12:26

I just think how dare the BBC do this? It is not on. A DRAMA ffs. Totally tone deaf and disrespectful.

BeMoreQueer · 17/10/2021 12:22

And yes… giving him a children’s show when there were already allegations wasn’t a bloody accident

x2boys · 17/10/2021 12:22

@OhWhyNot

I agree it wasn’t just the BBC

But the BBC kept his career going this allowed him to use his position of being a national treasure to gain such power

Oh I'm definitely not not defending the BBC, its just the whole cover up from various organisations, that it allowed him to continue to abuse
BeMoreQueer · 17/10/2021 12:20

British bullshit corporation trying to control the narrative

I haven’t paid license fees or engaged with the bbc in my entire adult life but it’s hasn’t made them go away

The most regular reason i argue with my mum is she believed the bbc is gospel… I think she’s right in that they are both lies told to control people and thats where we reach irreconcilable differences.

The fact they think they can pull this off while ex execs who facilitated his abuse live off generous bbc pensions just goes to show how little the institute has changed

TheQueef · 17/10/2021 12:19

BBC wants to make money so it makes a DRAMA about the scandal.
You'd be forgiven for expecting our public broadcaster not to capitalise on it's own failures, it is morally bankrupt.
A documentary would be inappropriate from the BBC but at least we may discover facts.
A drama serves no purpose other than financial, the BBC created victims and now they are selling them.
(Before anyone bleats JS was the abuser, BBC had abuse complaints from Totp and Jimmy was looking old and creepy presenting Totp so the BBC solution was to create a dedicated kids programme for him)