Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Jimmy Savile

141 replies

wavingwhilstdrowning · 17/10/2021 11:08

AIBU to say that the BBC should not be making a film about Jimmy Savile. They should not be profiting form his victims misery. Savile attacked at least 450 victims.

Once again his photograph is everywhere, retraumatising his victims who have been treated horrifically by the BBC.

for full disclosure I gave evidence at Operation Yewtree.

OP posts:
campion · 17/10/2021 17:28

@wavingwhilstdrowning

I reported the abuse to West Yorkshire police on 3 occasions
The West Yorkshire Police were in it up to their necks imo, so they were hardly likely to take it seriously. He had his regular Friday 'Breakfast Club' meetings with them at his flat fgs. Very cosy and he had them in the palm of his hand but they were either too stupid to see past it or didn't care.

I'm surprised, to put it mildly, that there hasn't been more criticism of them or disciplinary action. I hope that this film may shine a bit more light on them at least.

I'm sorry you were ignored OP. I lived in the same part of Leeds as him and saw him around a fair bit.Horrible man.

colouringindoors · 17/10/2021 16:59

Completely agree OP. I think it's utterly disgusting the BBC have the gall to do this. And then undoubtably sell it and make money out of it.

Absolutely shameful and my heart aches for his victims.

iklboo · 17/10/2021 16:56

I saw the film; it did not glamourise that horrible man and it demonstrated exactly how a certain type of serial abuser purposely blindsides other adults, targets vulnerable people and organises opportunities to commit his crimes.

No you didn't because it's not been made yet.

shrugshrug · 17/10/2021 16:01

Saville visited Ireland, leading charity walks for the Central Remedial Clinic which is and was an organisation dedicated to the health, wellbeing and achievements of people with physical disabilities and he was feted in Ireland for "his altruism" by the great and good.
He would have had access to vulnerable children and adults at the time.
I don't know if there was ever any investigation into his activities in Ireland.
I don't know if he abused vulnerable children and adults in Ireland.
I really do hope that he was investigated and anyone, if affected, got the support they needed.
But somehow I doubt it.
At least in the UK it was investigated. Sad

thisplaceisapigsty · 17/10/2021 15:38

@wavingwhilstdrowning I totally support what you say. It's not suitable for a drama and it's not for any good reason. I hate this sort of glamorisation of abuse, because it is glamorising it just by giving it time on the tv with a star cast as JS. I don't care what the BBC say about their motives, it's business and it's money and it's prurience about the crimes.

wavingwhilstdrowning · 17/10/2021 15:29

@2bazookas

I saw the film; it did not glamourise that horrible man and it demonstrated exactly how a certain type of serial abuser purposely blindsides other adults, targets vulnerable people and organises opportunities to commit his crimes.

He was not the last of his kind and the whole of society needs to be reminded of that. To understand how they operate, why they get away with it in broad daylight, and the terrible damage they do.

I don't know how you imagine the BBC  is  " profiting from his victims misery,"  or  from making the program.   Those  who took part did so voluntarily.  Nobody is forced to  watch it.</div></div>

We are discussing the drama currently in production starring Steve Coogan. No one has seen it yet. The BBC will sell this drama worldwide as SC is well known, and they will make a LOT of money.
No one is forced to watch it but all his victims are sick of being confronted with his gurning repulsive face leering out of newspapers and the TV at us. We cannot avoid that.
You post is ignorant and lacking in an empathy.

OP posts:
2bazookas · 17/10/2021 15:24

I saw the film; it did not glamourise that horrible man and it demonstrated exactly how a certain type of serial abuser purposely blindsides other adults, targets vulnerable people and organises opportunities to commit his crimes.

He was not the last of his kind and the whole of society needs to be reminded of that. To understand how they operate, why they get away with it in broad daylight, and the terrible damage they do.

I don't know how you imagine the BBC  is  " profiting from his victims misery,"  or  from making the program.   Those  who took part did so voluntarily.  Nobody is forced to  watch it.
EboWen · 17/10/2021 15:13

Will not ever watch it. Can't believe anyone would want to watch it. Not a fan of SC anyway.

wavingwhilstdrowning · 17/10/2021 15:07

I don't think anything has changed.

OP posts:
StellaAndCrow · 17/10/2021 15:03

And I can totally imagine him still getting away with it now, do we know that anything has changed? And him being innocent in the eyes of the law surely makes it worse.

StellaAndCrow · 17/10/2021 15:02

OP I am so sorry that this happened to you, and that your warnings weren't listened to. I too work with CSE/CSA grooming victims, and like you say the lifelong consequences can be awful. A programme sensitively focusing on grooming and how people get away with it, how people and organisations collude, that would be something, but should not include someone impersonating Savile, that's just gross.
I too found Three Girls so painful to watch, I've worked with these very vulnerable people as adults, and I too have seen them be unable to keep their own children safe and the trauma of them being taken into care.

Tal45 · 17/10/2021 14:57

I can't imagine wanting to watch it.

wavingwhilstdrowning · 17/10/2021 14:46

I reported the abuse to West Yorkshire police on 3 occasions

OP posts:
iklboo · 17/10/2021 14:30

It's a very hard no from me, and I have enjoyed some of SC's other work. This, though, is just not right.

BeMoreQueer · 17/10/2021 14:25

‘Im the eyes of the law saville was 100% innocent’

Yep, that is how far this rot goes

Hands up who here is trying to convince themselves right now that 1 shady Cooper helped him cover it all up so they don’t have to accept the police will cover for child abusers

Still… after Sarah everards killer being jokingly called ‘the rapist’ by his fellow police officers

This is not the past

wavingwhilstdrowning · 17/10/2021 14:23

@Dbank

I think YABU

I'm sure Saville was an evil bastard and probably did many more horrendous crimes that we'll never know about. I also appreciate it must be distressing for the victims to be reminded about him.

The failure to bring Saville to account shows how many people turned a blind eye, as it wasn't in their interest to "make a fuss".

We have to discuss, examine and learn from these incidents and a drama is an effective way to do this.

Keeping quiet and moving on doesn't help, and was exactly the attitude that allowed him to continue offending.

I hope we live in more enlightened times, and it would be hard to imagine him getting away with it now.

Just in case anyone has forgotten, in the eyes of the law Saville was 100% innocent.

Do you believe that this bbc drama will investigate and reveal the truth?
OP posts:
Dbank · 17/10/2021 14:21

I think YABU

I'm sure Saville was an evil bastard and probably did many more horrendous crimes that we'll never know about. I also appreciate it must be distressing for the victims to be reminded about him.

The failure to bring Saville to account shows how many people turned a blind eye, as it wasn't in their interest to "make a fuss".

We have to discuss, examine and learn from these incidents and a drama is an effective way to do this.

Keeping quiet and moving on doesn't help, and was exactly the attitude that allowed him to continue offending.

I hope we live in more enlightened times, and it would be hard to imagine him getting away with it now.

Just in case anyone has forgotten, in the eyes of the law Saville was 100% innocent.

OhWhyNot · 17/10/2021 14:20

wavingwhilstdrowning I’m sorry for you and all those harmed by him and the other vile men.

There does seem to be a backlash which I’m pleased to see

Sleepyquest · 17/10/2021 14:09

I am so sorry @wavingwhilstdrowning it must be awful for you to have it brought up again and I doubt the BBC are going to be honest and take any part of the blame for allowing him to carry out years of abuse. In fact, they will make money out of this and their own fuck ups and cover ups.

BeMoreQueer · 17/10/2021 14:01

@Elderberry84
People don’t want to believe it because if it’s not one bad apple then the whole barrel must be rotten

When you start looking at who was supporting saville you quickly realise our whole system is built to protect a few and keep the masses quiet

The police knew ffs… and helped silence the op and many others

Elderberry84 · 17/10/2021 13:54

@FrippEnos

Its already been said about the BBC and their role in promoting and hiding him.

I suspect that the "documentary" will spend a lot of time going on about how good he was at hiding in plain sight and it can't be their fault.

This is exactly how I felt about the second Louis Theroux documentary!
Elderberry84 · 17/10/2021 13:50

I remember being at a house party the day after his death was announced - another guest (young woman, which I think is depressingly relevant) was a junior producer at the BBC at the time having started as a runner several years earlier. Her exact words were "Massive paedophile, everyone knows" - in reference to her employer.

Most of us that night struggled to believe her claims as it seemed impossible that the BBC could allow him the platform he had if it really were common knowledge. I felt so sick when the official story started to break and I realised she had been telling the truth. Haven't felt the same about the BBC since. Even that Louis Theroux revisit, whilst appearing terribly earnest and guilt-ridden, seemed like nothing more than a clever smokescreen for any real reflection.

They absolutely shouldn't be the ones making this.

KittenKong · 17/10/2021 13:45

I think - I hate to see his bloody face (gave me creeps when I was a kid), but the way he was allowed to basically do whatever he wanted (despite people raising their concerns and being silenced). Friends in ‘high’ places, protected by mates (who also need checking) and the BBC. It needs to be out there in the open - all the dodgy dealings, backhanders, bullying, silencing, blind eyes... never again.

CHIRIBAYA · 17/10/2021 13:43

"I'm not interested in the story of a disgusting criminal, what I would be interested to see is something on all the bystanders, those who covered for him"

Let's not kid ourselves here that this is in the past. David Rose, who writes for the Mail On Sunday, describes himself laughingly as 'a Jimmy Saville sceptic'. As soon as any investigation is launched into organised child abuse he is in there trying to discount it. He effectively derailed an investigation into Haut de la Garenne. Years of the most horrific abuse ended up being mostly ignored since it could not be proved that any child was actually murdered there; as if anything less is irrelevant and unworthy of prosecuting. Nothing but a media circus while innocent lives (including those who spoke out against it) were effectively destroyed. So yes, I'm all for having a programme on his enablers and the power structures that facilitate them. Storyville covered this very well if anyone is interested: Dark Secrets of a Trillion Dollar Island.

wavingwhilstdrowning · 17/10/2021 13:43

@Chipsahoy

But you watched three girls? I am a victim of cse and I am horrified that any of these things are made. I am horrified that so many people enjoy any of these sorts of documentaries. It does not get the word out. It does not highlight the issues or make people aware. It is sensationalising abuse. None of it should be made or shown. And as for these women and their lives are damaged forever.. I was one of those girls and I am not damaged or ruined forever.
I couldn't agree more. You are a strong woman, a survivor. These men are damaged and ruined forever, we are as great as were always going to be.
OP posts: