Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Jimmy Savile

141 replies

wavingwhilstdrowning · 17/10/2021 11:08

AIBU to say that the BBC should not be making a film about Jimmy Savile. They should not be profiting form his victims misery. Savile attacked at least 450 victims.

Once again his photograph is everywhere, retraumatising his victims who have been treated horrifically by the BBC.

for full disclosure I gave evidence at Operation Yewtree.

OP posts:
OhWhyNot · 18/10/2021 23:04

Philomena is told form her perspective it was her story told. The Catholic Church were not involved in the writing of the story. The Police were not involved in writing of the Steven Lawrence series

Who cares is Steve Coogan is going to play JS with sensitivity he is hardly going to claim anything else is he. I’m astounded that someone who is so outspoken and highly critical of people being silenced (Leveson enquiry) would consider this a good idea. But what a role for an actor Hmm

What a drama of a story you couldn’t make up it shocked us all. No one will be bought down with this drama, no one will be named, the BBC will probably add a little few lines at the end saying how they have learnt from mistakes and all involved will continue to pat themselves on the back for the sensitivity they showed.

wavingwhilstdrowning · 18/10/2021 22:51

Tony Wilson's friends and family hated Coogans take on him, and he refused to donate to Tony's Fundraising attempts for a last ditch cancer treatment. 24 hr party people didn't uncover anything at all, it was a simplistic and comedic take on a brutal time in Manchesters gang land history and the Hacienda and Factory's ties to it. Recent documentaries have revealed the extent of criminal activity. Once again Coogan took a serious subject and glossed over the truly important parts to create a glossy sellable product. Alan Erasmus was furious about the film, but had no say in the script and editing of his own role.

OP posts:
Floogal · 18/10/2021 21:16

@shrugshrug

Like him or loathe him I think Steve Coogan's involvement in the film Philomena, along with the sublime Judi Dench helped shine a light on the scandal that was the Mother and Baby Homes in Ireland, the treatment of the birth mothers and their babies. The refusal of the nuns and the Irish state to give information to those involved.

Perhaps the series will shine the spotlight brighter on the awfulness of Saville and the people who facilitated him ?

@shrugshrug I haven't seen Philomena or the one about Steven Lawrence. But he was good in the Christopher Jeffery miniseries. Also how portrayal of Tony Wilson in 24 hour Party People. Though primarily comedic, he portrayed more harrowing parts of the film sensetively
wavingwhilstdrowning · 18/10/2021 20:48

In West Yorks the photos have been updated daily in various papers. Huge public interest and outrage.

OP posts:
BeaucoupFish · 18/10/2021 12:43

@wavingwhilstdrowning
@ChequerBoard

spot on, people will fall for it as well.

Laiste · 18/10/2021 12:18

Here's a link showing Coogan Dressed as JS. It's in the making apparently.

I really really don't think the BBC will make a drama damning the BBC. It's track record for self reflection isn't particularly strong.

I used to like SC. Feel a bit sick at these pics of him dressed up as JS.

DoYouLikeOwls · 18/10/2021 12:09

The Alan Partridge star said the decision to portray Savile on screen was not one he “took lightly” but the series had “an intelligent script tackling sensitively an horrific story which – however harrowing – needs to be told”.

Hopefully this is the case.

Like I said before I am a fan of Steve Coogan but I was a bit shocked about them making it.

TonyThreePies · 18/10/2021 12:08

I take it the film is already in production as they have named who is in it? I'm just wondering if it's worth setting up a petition to try to get the making of it stopped. Probably not. This thread has made me beyond angry and absolutely dismayed. There is so much wrong here but for some reason - men dressing up as JS for a stag do? What the hell is wrong with them?
I'm so sorry for anyone who has been traumatised by these fucking men. Me too. By someone who knew JS.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 18/10/2021 11:56

You could argue that why make a film or series out of anything which goes against the grain

I'd suggest that depends on how it's done and who's doing it
A documentary would probably have been better, but would be unlikely to have made the BBC so much £££££, and and as so many have said the involvement of the BBC is just as filthy as their choices at the time

ChequerBoard · 18/10/2021 11:34

@wavingwhilstdrowning I totally agree. I would bet that the narrative of this drama will be something like:

Look, see all these examples of how manipulative and clever JS was at hiding his evil intentions and actions behind his good works. What could the BBC do? We were his victims too, hiding in plain sight, times were different then etc etc...

Whereas if any programme were actually to be made, it should be:

Look, see all these examples of where we the BBC and the others including West Yorkshire Police were told about this and did nothing. Look at all these trusted institutions that are culpable in the abuse of countless victims. What lessons have we learned, how can we prevent this from ever happening again. How can we possible ever be sorry enough for the harm caused to so many people, many of them in incredibly vulnerable situations where they should have been safe.

It should be a proper warts and all documentary outing those that complied and stood by, made by a reputable, impartial organisation or nothing.

KittenKong · 18/10/2021 11:17

No they really haven’t learned much. Jumped into bed not with a group that focussed on safeguarding and protection, but stonewall. Feh.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 18/10/2021 11:16

As an institution they enabled him, and have shown little contrition

And that's exactly why I wouldn't trust them with --anything at all- handling something like this appropriately

As PPs have said, JS is hardly a subject for any kind of "entertainment", but the BBC are the very last people to handle it objectively

wavingwhilstdrowning · 18/10/2021 10:48

@shrugshrug

Like him or loathe him I think Steve Coogan's involvement in the film Philomena, along with the sublime Judi Dench helped shine a light on the scandal that was the Mother and Baby Homes in Ireland, the treatment of the birth mothers and their babies. The refusal of the nuns and the Irish state to give information to those involved.

Perhaps the series will shine the spotlight brighter on the awfulness of Saville and the people who facilitated him ?

Perhaps. But it seems unlikely. Would the catholic church have made Philomena? If they had would it have shone any light? The point here is that the very organisation that gave JS the platform to abuse, and I believe to be culpable in the abuse, are making this film. The BBC has been attempting to rewrite JS as a 'psychopathic genius', which he was not. This film is most likely to be a propaganda piece, allowing SC to show his 'range' morphing from gurning clown to evil rapist with the close of a door, and the BBC to further manipulate the truth and their role in allow JS to abuse.
OP posts:
shrugshrug · 18/10/2021 10:31

Like him or loathe him I think Steve Coogan's involvement in the film Philomena, along with the sublime Judi Dench helped shine a light on the scandal that was the Mother and Baby Homes in Ireland, the treatment of the birth mothers and their babies. The refusal of the nuns and the Irish state to give information to those involved.

Perhaps the series will shine the spotlight brighter on the awfulness of Saville and the people who facilitated him ?

Pazuzu · 18/10/2021 10:01

If they're going to name names of the people at the BBC and other places who totally and utterly failed the victims of that evil man then do it.

If it's going to ignore that and somehow try and find an excuse for JS and the enablers, then hell no, don't do it. The enablers are as guilty as JS and deserve their time in the flames just as much as him.

thiscountryisdotdotdot · 18/10/2021 08:53

I think the beeb is losing its grip on reality…

wavingwhilstdrowning · 17/10/2021 20:53

I've written to the BBC. Again. I will get no where but at least I try.

I was at school with Emma Barnett (a few years above her), I wonder what she thinks about all of this....

OP posts:
Nayday · 17/10/2021 18:26

YANBU. I dislike particularly that the documentary is named for him and the focus on a famous actor playing him. It makes me feel uncomfortable that he is the focus rather than those he abused or tried to report him.

It would be a better impact to focus on what/how the abuse was enabled for so long and by so many and not allow his voice centre stage.

BeaucoupFish · 17/10/2021 18:10

@wavingwhilstdrowning
Brilliant posts thank you

The BBC are vile and it amazes me how they still exist on public funding, obviously the majority of the public just don’t care

Sundancerintherain · 17/10/2021 18:04

It's a kick in the teeth for his victims. Plenty of documentary type programs have been made about this vile creature, this will not reveal anything that us not already in the public domain.

wavingwhilstdrowning · 17/10/2021 18:04

@campion The YWPolice are responsible for PSutcliffes reign of terror, JS, many of the worst grooming scandals in the country ( there is a WYP man on remand for raping a 12 yo atm) and they hosted and visited Britian's only legalised prostitution zone in Holbeck.

My DS called Leeds "the only city in the world where you can buy a woman in the morning, and be a woman by afternoon" as they also had (maybe still have) a policy of self ID on gender that an individual can change in the council website. YW is the worst place in the UK to be a woman, I think.

OP posts:
wavingwhilstdrowning · 17/10/2021 18:00

@Floogal

Been a bit of a thing over past decade. Infamous criminals having TV dramas made about them. Keith Allen playing the Bullseye killer and Dominic West playing Fred West. Steve coogan is very talented but it is surprising the BBC of all people would make it. People do forget that Coogan actually used to do the voice of Jimmy Savile on Spitting image.
Yes, people conveniently forget that both the BBC and to a lesser degree Coogan has profited from JS on many occasions, this isn't the first incident. I watched the Fred West film and whilst horrifying, I did see there was public interest in his trusted adult and what she saw/heard/believed he had done. It was absolutely horrible, and I would be interested to hear what the families of Wests victims felt and thought about it. The woman, the trusted adult, was the centre if the story not FW who was presented as an inadequate and repulsive man.

I think JS will be presented in the "genius psychopath" guise the BBC like to sell his memory. They were too naive and innocent to recognise JS's grooming and crimes. I do not think he will be presented as weak, repulsive and obviously a pervert - all things he was - because that leaves the question to the BBC of why they employed and promoted him and SC has to answer to why he dinned out on his impressions or a pervert.

JS was a repulsive pervert and well known to be a rapist. DM knew this growing up in Manchester in the 60s. Everyone knew. They chose to allow him to rape and abuse because they didn't care about the women and JS was useful to them.

OP posts:
Floogal · 17/10/2021 17:51

Been a bit of a thing over past decade. Infamous criminals having TV dramas made about them. Keith Allen playing the Bullseye killer and Dominic West playing Fred West.
Steve coogan is very talented but it is surprising the BBC of all people would make it. People do forget that Coogan actually used to do the voice of Jimmy Savile on Spitting image.

OhWhyNot · 17/10/2021 17:48

What do we learn from a drama

That some people are not quite what they seem

There is nothing that we learn from these dramas only what the writers offer. If its true we might be surprised or shocked but it made to entertain not educate

There is no one way that abusers operate we don’t become knowledgeable about abusers or murderers only if that particular person and what the drama is informing us of