Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think children did not used to get support for traumatic events?

110 replies

julieca · 17/10/2021 01:57

This is just something I was talking about with DP. Looking back there were some difficult times. A boy in my class in secondary died of cancer. DP saw a friends brother die in front of him of a sudden asthma attack when he was 8 years old. A close friends father died when she was 15 of a sudden heart attack.
Although parents tried to support us, there was no formal support at all. No school counselling, no group support exercises, nothing. I don't know if this is the best approach or not, but surely these days the school especially would be offering support?

OP posts:
Ann5324 · 17/10/2021 05:38

@labazslovesliving so sorry to hear that

Ann5324 · 17/10/2021 05:31

@DDUW

“ A girl I went to school with was routinely punished for being upset after her mother had died. I remember a class trip to the churchyard to look at gravestones. The girl broke down in tears and the teacher shouted at her for making a fuss. We were about 9 and we all took our lead from the teacher. We all thought there must have been something mentally wrong with her for being upset about it.”

That’s really upset me. I hope that little girl got the help she needed when she grew up. That teacher sounds awful

Oldtiredfedup · 17/10/2021 04:16

There’s no support now for many.

Domestic abuse and everything that goes with it what did we get???

A group for my autistic son that he absoloutly hated because it was around the corner from the house we had been forced to leave abd the social worker didn’t get autism (no surprises there, they never do) Nothing for me except for a family support worker coming around once a week telling me I needed to get my youngest into nursery and not to bother getting a carers assessment because the council had no money anyway so I’d be turned down even though my son was in receipt of DLA.

6 sessions of CBT

Begged for therap - none, for any of us

CAHNS told us to fuck off

GP wasn’t interested…

What support???????

Simonjt · 17/10/2021 04:14

@Magicalwoodlands

I read an interview with a child psychologist where he stated that children who had undergone trauma needed, not more affection, but routines adhering to.

How true that is I’m not totally sure - he is the expert I suppose.

It is very much not true.
CiaoForDiNiaoSaur · 17/10/2021 04:08

Yes I know they will point them in the right direction. I haven't said they won't. Confused
My point was that teachers aren't counsellors. Although I obviously didn't make it clear that they can be first port of call as it were.

That's what's changed since I was a teen. My teachers knew I'd been bereaved. I was expected to be at school, on time and just get on with it. I was really struggling but no one told me where I could get support.

Evesgarden · 17/10/2021 04:03

@CiaoForDiNiaoSaur but they can help point them in the right direction. if a child discloses something to a teacher the teacher then has to disclose that to the safe guarding lead who will decide what to do with it. There will be a clear pathway for the Childs needs. A teacher will absolutely not be too busy to do this.

No teacher I know would walk away from a child that has disclosed deep grief or other safeguarding issues. They may not be able to deal with them directly but they will trigger the support that they may need. Whether they get that support further down the line is an other issue.

For what its worth I think there should be qualified councillors in every secondary school, in which that is their sole role.

HPandTheNeverEndingBedtime · 17/10/2021 03:58

I was at secondary school in the 2000's a boy in my year dies if a heart attack and we were told in assembly and there was a quiet place with someone to talk to for anyone upset for that week. We had something similar in place a few years ago when a student died too alongside all of the normal counselling going on.

I think in the past trauma and death was more normal and more accepted. Less H&S guidelines and more people working in the military means more accidents and death. Health services weren't as good and people had bigger families in poorer conditions which meant more death and DV was probably seen as normal and if something is normal I suppose there's no point in having counselling as nothings wrong by yesteryear standards.

ClaryFairchild · 17/10/2021 03:57

I think it has come a long way, which is great. How good it is is sadly dependent on the actual school. We went through and incredibly prolonged difficult period of time.

At the primary schools they were amazing. Head teacher took time to chat to my DSs not about what was going on necessarily, but just so that he knew they were there and cared - that helped him a huge amount. They checked in with me at all times to see if there was anything. Else they could or should do and I felt listened to and supported the whole time.

In high school DS didn't want the teachers to know what was going on so was given a card from support services that he could show to the teachers if he needed to leave the class without having to explain why he was leaving, or the teacher even commenting on it. He never used it, but knowing that he could helped him a LOT.

They also had available a unit where he could choose to do all his lessons with the support teacher's assistance if he couldn't face actually going into class, to keep him in school. None of the other parents even knew it existed but it was there, and used l, heavily on occasions, by children who needed it.

Compare that with someone I know from my childhood who had a suicide jumper from a multi story car park land a couple of meters in front of him, and covering him with blood etc, in the 80s. He used his school blazer to cover the body up until ambulance and police arrived. Apart from taking his name nothing was ever done re support for him. Not even to just talk it through with him to help him process it.

But... I think we can go too far sometimes. A teacher at infant school had lost her adult daughter in a hit and run. The parents were frantic as to how they could help their children cope with this. She was not someone they had ever met. A small school so they did know the teacher well. I remember telling my 6 year old DS about it. He had a really sad face and said "oh that's so sad. Poor Mrs x". Then turned around and asked if he could go and play such and such a game. As parents we were feeling OUR distress at the thought of losing a child. They children themselves weren't suffering a loss and apart from needing to be aware of why their teacher wasn't there, really it was too distant to them to have much of an impact.

junebirthdaygirl · 17/10/2021 03:46

When l was 15 a boy in my class died in an accident and l was completely shocked as up to then had thought that only old people died. I couldn't sleep and was quite bereft. We had no school help. Nowadays psychologists would be called in but at the end of the day nothing they could say could make it go away but having it acknowledged does seem to help.
When my dh was 14 a boy died in the actual school and one of the teachers laughed at him for crying. It was a boarding school and his parents weren't contacted or told. It definitely is a different situation now .

labazslovesliving · 17/10/2021 03:34

sadly I have PTSD from events in my childhood including being sexually abused my best friend dying of leukaemia when I was 6 when that prognosis was more or less a death sentence due to lack of treatment then several family deaths etc. I went to a child guidance clinic who were not very helpful their treatment was at the age of 7 putting me on valium which was then classed as the wonder drug of the time, from then on I was in and out of the mental health system, long boring story but I have ended up with PTSD as mentioned BPD anxiety and depression, most of my adult life has been connected with mental health services which have deteriorated rapidly though in some way the way they would section at the drop of a hat does not seem to have changed. it may help talking things through as they happen but often that does not eliminate the effects some people will carry things through their whole life though the effect it has in the future depends not just on counselling but personality etc

CiaoForDiNiaoSaur · 17/10/2021 03:33

[quote Evesgarden]@CiaoForDiNiaoSaur I've worked with children in the past and I know other teachers. Teachers will listen if a child discloses anything. Any one that has done child safeguarding will absolutely down tools and listen.[/quote]
Yes I'm aware they will listen. But my point was that often children need actual qualified people to help. Teachers aren't those people. Not really. Not for real deep emotional support. They are teachers. We shouldn't be expecting them to be grief counsellors as well. (Although some of them are bloody fantastic).

LobsterNapkin · 17/10/2021 03:33

I don't really see the issue with 14 year olds babysitting, it's kind of the ideal age I'd have said? But that's an aside.

I agree less of this used to happen through school. But I'm not sure that schools are particularly good at this sort of thing tbh, even now. What a lot of kids need in these situations is love and stability, and while schools can try and offer stability, you can't get love from a therapist. Schools aren't even all that good at being a friend to children and teachers can be discouraged from developing that kind of close relationship with kids.

There's also some truth to the idea that a fair bit of the time, the only real way to deal with difficult life problems is to carry on.

CiaoForDiNiaoSaur · 17/10/2021 03:31

[quote Dddccc]@ciaoForDiNiaoSaur you would be surprised how many teachers deal with this kind of stuff daily I reported stuff to them they listened and took the time to help direct me and got me better help but it was the first step of many most kids dont need a trained psychiatric help they just need someone to confide in and talk to and be believed or have something explained to them also these days deaths of a pupil the head normally gets a few teacher to have a open door policy who you can go to also,[/quote]
I'm aware how many teachers are dealing with it. I'm also aware that they often don't have the training or time to be doing so but manage because they care.
In my experience the teachers who are asked to have the "open door policy" are the ones who have had extra training. My mums best friend, who was a teacher, had training in how to support children who had suffered some kind of loss. But she was the only one in the school who had.

Of course a teacher can be an appropriate person to help a child, but not always. My experience as a teen who needed support was that there wasn't any. And if there was no one signposted me to it. (Friend mentioned above hadn't done the training at that point. I've found out recently I'm one of the reasons she chose to do it)

Evesgarden · 17/10/2021 03:27

@CiaoForDiNiaoSaur I've worked with children in the past and I know other teachers. Teachers will listen if a child discloses anything. Any one that has done child safeguarding will absolutely down tools and listen.

starrynight21 · 17/10/2021 03:26

Whisky in babies bottle to help them sleep - even further back

Yes, my DM was born in the 30's and when my baby was waking at night she recommended "Some brandy in his bottle" to settle him. That was apparently standard when she was a young mother.

Evesgarden · 17/10/2021 03:22

It was a different time back then. Bloody hell my parents used to smoke in the car when I was kid, it illegal now. I was baby sitting half the streets kids at 14 so their parents could go to the pub. Whisky in babies bottle to help them sleep - even further back Shock

We can't compare todays standards by those that were held 40/50 years ago. Children were often an afterthought coming from the era of children should be seen and not heard. Its only really in the last 15 -years or so children have become more centred and their mental health looked at to prevent long term damage - which is mostly due to academics publishing studies in this era.

My cousin lost her mum suddenly at 13 ( 30 years ago) she was offered no support off the school/GP/any one but she was allowed to walk around the school field with a friend during lesson time if she was feeling sad.. I dont think the school at that time thought it was their problem to deal with. Their concern was that she was in school and safe.

There still in a long long way to go for even the child protection services. I read a really interesting article that there was hundreds of teenage school kids that were by themselves living in shared accommodation (with alcoholics and drug takers ) and these children were having to get themselves to school ect..

Typically children dont get treated very well.

Dddccc · 17/10/2021 03:19

@ciaoForDiNiaoSaur you would be surprised how many teachers deal with this kind of stuff daily I reported stuff to them they listened and took the time to help direct me and got me better help but it was the first step of many most kids dont need a trained psychiatric help they just need someone to confide in and talk to and be believed or have something explained to them also these days deaths of a pupil the head normally gets a few teacher to have a open door policy who you can go to also,

user1481840227 · 17/10/2021 03:19

@Dddccc

Why should it be schools that pay for this though also these days you can just talk to a teacher if needed I had counselling in the 90s social services set it up and they would for any kid that needed it if people asked
It shouldn't be the schools who pay for it, the support should be provided through the schools though.

Kids might not realise they need counselling or support and kids who don't get support at home are unlikely to think that they can ask a teacher for support.

CiaoForDiNiaoSaur · 17/10/2021 03:10

@Dddccc

Why should it be schools that pay for this though also these days you can just talk to a teacher if needed I had counselling in the 90s social services set it up and they would for any kid that needed it if people asked
You can't "just talk to a teacher". They are already insanely busy, and most aren't trained to deal with trauma.
DDUW · 17/10/2021 03:06

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Dddccc · 17/10/2021 02:58

Why should it be schools that pay for this though also these days you can just talk to a teacher if needed I had counselling in the 90s social services set it up and they would for any kid that needed it if people asked

starrynight21 · 17/10/2021 02:56

Yep, that's right, there was no official support at all. My ( adopted) sister witnessed her father die from an asthma attack and she was just expected to get on with it. One of my friends from school was killed in a terrible car accident when we were about 12 - we all went to the funeral but nobody asked how we were coping or anything.

KloppsTeeth · 17/10/2021 02:48

When my Dad died in 1994, I had just turned 17 and my brother was 15. We had absolutely no support or help whatsoever. Nothing was offered. School did nothing to help either of us. My mum had no support. It was very traumatic for us, yet there was no counselling or anything.
Mental health knowledge has improved but is woefully underfunded and so things access to services probably is very poor, but there is the internet to look up support for that there wasn’t much info online back then either.

user1481840227 · 17/10/2021 02:47

When I was primary school a child in the class above me died very suddenly.
I remember going to the funeral but there was definitely no support offered through the school. My parents didn't even speak to me about it after or see how I was. It was my first funeral and it was very upsetting, I still remember the wails from the childs mother and how she collapsed and had to be held up.

My parents were cold and emotionless anyway but unfortunately there are still parents like that so I do think schools should be obligated to provide support in those instances. That was mid 90s so yes it was a long time ago but times don't seem like they were that different either!

I have avoided all funerals since apart from one where a friend specifically asked me to go with her.

over2021 · 17/10/2021 02:40

I think community spirit used to be much more of a thing though. People would have had support from neighbours, the local church, the local family GP and life was generally more basic- you couldn't psychoanalyse everything on Google/YouTube.