Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think children did not used to get support for traumatic events?

110 replies

julieca · 17/10/2021 01:57

This is just something I was talking about with DP. Looking back there were some difficult times. A boy in my class in secondary died of cancer. DP saw a friends brother die in front of him of a sudden asthma attack when he was 8 years old. A close friends father died when she was 15 of a sudden heart attack.
Although parents tried to support us, there was no formal support at all. No school counselling, no group support exercises, nothing. I don't know if this is the best approach or not, but surely these days the school especially would be offering support?

OP posts:
Glassofshloer · 17/10/2021 07:44

Sad and tragic as it is I’m not sure why you would need counselling because a fellow pupil passed away? I could see why it might be needed if you actively watched somebody die though.

Mumoblue · 17/10/2021 07:43

It’s absolutely not true that people in the past didn’t have mental health problems- they just weren’t allowed to talk about them, it was all hushed up. I’ve met a fair amount of older people who clearly want to talk about the traumatic things that happened to them, but have no outlet or understanding of how to do that constructively.

Even the attitude of “Well I never received help for my traumatic experiences, so why should young people?” doesn’t exactly scream “emotionally healthy and stable”.

The understanding of mental health continues to evolve and if kids these days are getting more support then I’m glad.

ImNotWhoYouThinkIam · 17/10/2021 07:42

@Mnusernc

Could I ask, those of you who experienced these events when young. What would have helped? My young daughter is going through similar and the school has been abysmal. Have asked them to do more and am open and supportive at home but just wondering if you had any advice? Thank you
I think for me, i just needed someone who would listen. Someone who could talk through the stages of grief with me. I convinced myself that my friend hadn't really died. That it was some kind of... I don't know what. I had this mad idea that he'd run away from home and was hiding in a shack some where and that he'd come back one day. I didn't know that denial was a normal way of processing grief. It was very much swept under the carpet in a "well you knew him but you weren't best friends" kind of way. Grief should never be minimised like that.
Dontknowwhatsnext · 17/10/2021 07:37

I think sometimes people think the support always must be external and professional.

Often kids can process what's happened if they feel they have a safe and consistent outlet for it. Meaning their parents or main carer/s.

Lots of parents jump straight to 'something bad has happened that vaguely impacts my child. The school/NHS must provide the safe space for them.

Obviously, sometimes, professional outside support is needed. But it shouldn't always be the first stop.

My best friends dad died when she was 15, what she needed was her mum to be present and support her through her grief. Not the professional grief support she was given, that didn't do much. But, her mum has always been incredibly selfish and continued to be the same way. She still is.

My friend has had quite a bit of professional help. But its never replaced the fact that her mother wasn't there for her.

CreepyPasta · 17/10/2021 07:36

I agree OP.

I was in the care system as a child (80’s and 90’s) due to neglect and abuse. No support at all. It wasn’t recognised at school either and I was classed as a ‘problem child’. Ended up using alcohol and drugs to cope. It didn’t seem to be acknowledged by anyone that my behaviour was linked to what was happening. I felt a lot of guilt and shame.

It’s only in the past few years that I’ve been lucky enough to be able to afford private therapy and work through my past.

rrhuth · 17/10/2021 07:35

@Mnusernc

Could I ask, those of you who experienced these events when young. What would have helped? My young daughter is going through similar and the school has been abysmal. Have asked them to do more and am open and supportive at home but just wondering if you had any advice? Thank you
If you can pay, get private support for her and you. They teach you how to help.

Also routines and being reassuringly predictable.

LetHimHaveIt · 17/10/2021 07:34

Meh. In the late 90s, a boy arrived at my mum's school. He was thought to be about 12, but no-one (including himself) was certain: he'd been five or thereabouts when he witnessed the execution of all his male family members in Srebrenica, and was found lying amongst the bodies. He received the square root of fuck all counselling - which was something of a surprise considering the lavish amounts available to a boy in his class the following year, who'd apparently been traumatised by seeing his moronic low-rent gangster father arrested in front of him, for his role in the Millennium Dome raid.

Mondaynightnamechange · 17/10/2021 07:33

I think there was much more of a ‘get in with it attitude’

I absolutely agree there should be support for anyone that goes through traumatic life events.

However I think there is a flip side to this also, everything these days seems to be a ‘big deal’ for example my children and friend’s children are the age that they have just started or will be starting secondary school and we all agree that when we went there was no fuss made (90s) you just did it we didn’t even visit before hand.

I know people suffer with crippling anxiety but I think the natural feeling of being nervous has been blown out of all proportion.

Mnusernc · 17/10/2021 07:30

Could I ask, those of you who experienced these events when young. What would have helped?
My young daughter is going through similar and the school has been abysmal. Have asked them to do more and am open and supportive at home but just wondering if you had any advice? Thank you

ronkey · 17/10/2021 07:18

And I agree that support isn't always necessarily there for kids or adults as in @DeepaBeesKit examples.

ronkey · 17/10/2021 07:16

we didn’t have the tsunami of mental health problems we have now

Is that true? MH is more open & talked about but J would argue it always existed but was repressed.

DeepaBeesKit · 17/10/2021 07:15

You would be surprised at how little is available to support people who lose a baby, whether miscarriage or stillborn. For a miscarriage, even if you end up hemorrhaging in hospital as I did, no one will check so much as check you for hours. I bled all over my clothes because i was put in an empty ward and left there for an hour with no sanitary pad and i couldnt get to the bathroom. I'd arrived by ambulance and DH was at home with our eldest.
A friend had a stillborn and got some immediate bereavement support in hospital for a couple of days then nothing once she got home.
Another friend lost one of a twin pregnancy close to term and the medical staff were really brusque about it, expected her to be happy one had survived and forget the other.

ronkey · 17/10/2021 07:15

We are a nation that stoically embraces echo trauma, and we wonder why our kids are fucked up

It's not healthy

LadyTiredWinterBottom2 · 17/10/2021 07:12

The way children are viewed has changed rapidly and dramatically in recent years. Even in the 80s people would say 'children should be seen and not heard'. Now they are recognised as a vulnerable group. There is legislation just to protect them and recognise their small people rights. They are actually seen as people. So yanbu. I expect previously people would say little Jonny was too young to understand or whatever. Or simply not know what to say, so ended up saying nothing.

ronkey · 17/10/2021 07:08

I think support is a good thing & don't favour the brushing under the rug approach. Some older family members have had quite severe mental health problems & dependencies because of trauma from the past that wasn't dealt with & thats impacted their own dc.

PurrBox · 17/10/2021 07:06

When I was 7, my teacher died in a car crash. My parents got a phone call and I will never forget the horror and grief I felt. The school did all sorts of 'support' activities, involving talking in groups and having children talk about how they felt or do small activities which were supposed to somehow help. The horror of those discussions turned me into a wreck, sobbing, and absolutely unable to function. My parents had to come pick me up from school and ended up having to keep me home from school until the discussions stopped, because I could not bear them. I remember thinking 'none of this brings back a person I loved who is dead; there is no point to it; people seem not to actually care; I can't even mention this person without being wracked by sobs; please don't make me share in this group who seem to be almost enjoying this'.

I think that group activities can be very deeply distressing at the wrong moment or for the wrong young child.

My parents were very sensitive to my pain, acknowledged and respected and didn't trivialise it.

JustGiveMeGin · 17/10/2021 07:06

I agree with @Fairyliz. SOME people will need support, many many people prefer to deal with things themselves.
I was at school in the 90's and by todays standards things were brutal. Bullying was a part of daily life, a few students committed suicide, lots and lots of underage sex and drug taking etc.
My mother had an accident when I was 14 (very low survival rate but she did pull through) followed by my father's heart attack not long after. I was studying for my GCSE's at the time and heavily involved in the family business whilst they recovered. I don't recall any acknowledgement from school about what was happening in my personal life and I wouldn't have wanted any!
Not every child is traumatised by life and I do think too many parents of my generation have no idea how to instill any kind of mental resilience in their children (good example above where the teachers daughter died and parents were asking about support for their own children)
Children are far stronger mentally than a lot of parents give them credit for, I personally think in a lot of cases a loving supportive family will get them through a lot of lifes trauma. Maybe if some parents could just jump off the mental health bandwagon the children that actually need the support would be able to access it quickly enough for it to do them some good.

rrhuth · 17/10/2021 06:59

This is the reality of mental health support for young people - it is largely a mirage

mobile.twitter.com/Samfr/status/1448720072390942721

rrhuth · 17/10/2021 06:50

we didn’t have the tsunami of mental health problems we have now

Suppressed mental health problems still exist. How many people coped by hitting their wife? Or their kids? Or drinking too much?

In order to help a child deal with emotions, you have to be able to manage your own. This is really hard, but each generation is getting better at talking I think.

I agree it can be taken too far, but my kids come and say 'I'm sad' and I can listen.

I would like to point out though that mental health services for children are almost non-existent, they are so grotesquely underfunded. Even if your child expresses suicidal thoughts, the wait is really long - multiple years at times.

HereWeGoAgains · 17/10/2021 06:44

My Dad died when I was a child, there was no support, no counselling. For me, or my Mum. This was in the 80s.

I’ve never had any form of counselling over it. We were just expected to get on with it by everybody.

Fairyliz · 17/10/2021 06:33

It’s a tricky one.
DH’s best friend died in front of him on the football pitch when DH was 10 and no one ever mentioned this boy again. This was in the 1960’s.
It seems very harsh and yet we didn’t have the tsunami of mental health problems we have now. So perhaps ‘not talking’ works for some people?

Pixxie7 · 17/10/2021 06:27

I personally think it is going OTT now each child is different and requires different interventions which the parents best placed to decide if and what their child needs. Is it any wonder mental health services is on its knees with every time something happens we immediately look for something to be wrong.

Meatshake · 17/10/2021 06:24

I was sexually abused by my grandad and then had a really traumatic court case where I was a
witness he was found not guilty. My parents turned down SS offer of counselling because we didn't need it, then refused to speak of the whole thing ever again.

When I was 13 a boy I was friends with killed himself. No support, business as usual the next day.

When I was 14 I took an overdose, went to hospital, luckily I was ok and off I went back to school the next day. Not sure if school ever even got told.

When I was 16 I told my mum I was depressed. I took myself off to the doctors who prescribed me 25mg of sertraline and told there was a long wait for therapy so he wasn't going to refer me.

I think most of that would be handled very differently these days, the 90s were a trip.

Our grandparents were emotional wrecks and parents are traumatised. Our great grandparents were traumatised from war. You can trace my grandfather's peadophilia back to my great grandads wartime trauma, my father in turn was emotionally neglected.. This is the legacy toolkit I was given to parent my own children.

We are a nation that stoically embraces echo trauma, and we wonder why our kids are fucked up and cling to the easy validation of social media likes.

Dontknowwhatsnext · 17/10/2021 06:24

Things are moving on.

My nanas son died at 3 months old, in the 50s. They were offered any support. My mum (was about 4 at the time) still remembers being woken by her mother's screams while her dad came into her bedroom and told her not to come out and slammed the door. Her and her siblings were offered no support.

Around the same time My dad's school friend died. They weren't even informed in school. They knee because it was a fairly small village, so found out from their parents.

In the 90s, while at school, my brothers friend committed suicide. We were told in assembly. We were advised there would be people available to speak to. I have no idea what that looked like. Our parents weren't informed, I told mum when I went home. She knew the boys mother and didn't know.

About 10 years ago my dd (she was about 7) class mate died of cancer. They had trained counsellors available. Dd was upset but I wouldn't call it traumatised.

My ds is autistic and we opted to keep him home during lockdowns as the change in routine at school was upsetting him. A constant reminder of what was happening. The school were fantastic at providing practical support while I home schooled and worked full time. And when we went back they were great at supporting us on return. Not professional counselling needed. But they really pulled out all the stops to get home back in and in a settled way.

I do think having appropriate support is far better than what we had. I do also think it can be taken too far. Mainly, fueled by parents who think their kids recieving any bad news will leaving lasting damaging. Such as the example given above, where a teachers child died and parents want support for their kids.

We will all hear of people we know having bad things happen, treating it as though everytime a child hears these things they need masses counselling and support, as a given.

I also think these parents don't really have a clue how sparse these services can be.

Maskless · 17/10/2021 06:00

Just over 100 years ago, 700,000 British families were told by telegram that their son or father who had gone to fight in the war had been killed.

Those families of course included - typically - 3-4-5 even 8 children who had lost a father or sibling, often their beloved big brother who may have been as young as 17-18.

None of these millions of children, who must have numbered well over 2 million, were given any counselling, and nor were their mother or grannies, neighbours or best friends, nor were the sweethearts and fiancees of the dead youths.

In many cases no body was repatriated so no proper funeral, either.

(And a million young women had no man to marry because of the imbalance in the sexes.)