Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think children did not used to get support for traumatic events?

110 replies

julieca · 17/10/2021 01:57

This is just something I was talking about with DP. Looking back there were some difficult times. A boy in my class in secondary died of cancer. DP saw a friends brother die in front of him of a sudden asthma attack when he was 8 years old. A close friends father died when she was 15 of a sudden heart attack.
Although parents tried to support us, there was no formal support at all. No school counselling, no group support exercises, nothing. I don't know if this is the best approach or not, but surely these days the school especially would be offering support?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheRealBettySpaghetti · 17/10/2021 14:01

I was told as a child 'children are resilient'. You were just expected to get on with it. Bullying was apparently 'part of childhood'. The fact is I was a pariah at school but it meant nothing to anyone when I tired to tell them. I still live with the damage that did.

I remember being bullied in class and the teacher just watched me walk out of that class in tears but had absolutely no emotion about it and didn't intervene to stop it. I had liked him before, afterwards I hated him. Weak man

julieca · 17/10/2021 12:55

I agree that counselling is not always needed.
But I do think for example that a teacher could have spoken to us as a group when my classmate died and said if anyone wants to talk to a teacher, we are here. Instead, there was nothing. My classmates told me he had died.

OP posts:
ufucoffee · 17/10/2021 11:35

When I was at school something that would be considered very very traumatic happened that we witnessed. I was 11. It was on the news and In all the papers. We didn't get offered counselling or anything like that. It happened on a Friday and we went back to school as normal on Monday. I can't say that I felt any need for counselling though tbh.

namechangeoctober2021 · 17/10/2021 10:46

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

GloriaPunniford · 17/10/2021 10:38

My dad died in the early 80’s when I was 7. I had no counselling or support. He’d been sick for a month, died on a Tuesday, I found out on the Friday because I’d been away with relatives. I was back at school on Monday.

Six weeks later it was Fathers Day and I had to make a card in school. I was told to make it for a granddad or uncle. No sympathy for the fact my dad had died a few weeks before.

Auntycorruption · 17/10/2021 10:28

I agree there is no one size fits all approach. My past has various trauma of the scale which would definitely be highlighted by schools now. No one ever mentioned anything out of the ordinary to me about it, life just carried on.

I have grown up to be a rational and well balanced person with no MH issues. I often wonder why that is, why am I spared the additional trauma of dealing with anxiety/depression/other MH disorder as a consequence. I think I'm well equipped to help my children deal with difficult situations and I honestly think the cycle is well and truley broken in my family. But why, I don't know.

SammyScrounge · 17/10/2021 10:22

@Fairyliz

It’s a tricky one. DH’s best friend died in front of him on the football pitch when DH was 10 and no one ever mentioned this boy again. This was in the 1960’s. It seems very harsh and yet we didn’t have the tsunami of mental health problems we have now. So perhaps ‘not talking’ works for some people?
The Israelis have support services for Holocaust survivors and their descendants too. During an anniversary of events in the war, people were discovered who had never spoken of the war and were better adjusted than those who underwent counselling. One elderly grandfather was known to be a happy optimistic person. Even his family didn't know of his past. Maybe it's just a reminder that there is no universal approach to those who have suffered trauma.
beautifullymad · 17/10/2021 09:51

Mental health support today is appalling for children and even worse for adults. It's an eroded service that has no hope of ever offering what is needed.

Back in the 1970's and 1980's there was nothing. I know several adults (children back then then) who carry around damage from this time due to bereavement and other horrible life events.
I think sadly it's just life. Today nothing much has changed in the delivery of care, maybe some lip service and a nod in the right direction. But no actually help or provision delivery for traumatised children.

MimosaFields · 17/10/2021 09:38

I was born in 1970 and I agree with you. I only recently found out a girl in my primary school was sexually assaulted in the staircase going up to her flat. She was telling us how she had zero support and it was all kept hush, like it was her fault. She was 9 at the time. As for the other girls, I remember being told never to share a lift with a man, but no more than that.

Others at school lost parents or siblings, but it was all taken as very matter of fact.

MH support is not great now, but it used to be much worse

Nayday · 17/10/2021 09:38

My mum, in her 70's now, recently told me that as a young child of around 6 her beloved and favourite aunt just disappeared (close working class/factory type community). Noone explained anything to my mum at all.

My mum looked and asked for her every day, where was she? Eventually another relative took pity on mum and took her to the graveyard - her aunt had died.

Just a completely different world of understanding. Do I think that level of 'getting on with it' healthy? No. My mum was lovely and practical but emotionally distant, no emotions were tolerated or entertained really, this extended to other matters, even bodily functions. To the level of not even (as a nurse) being able to talk to me about periods as a kid - towels just appeared in my room. Was a very unnecessarily frightening and confusing time. But how could my mum change after a life time of hiding uncomfortable truths/repressing difficult emotions? She couldn't. I'm grateful that there's so much more insight available nowadays so that these patterns can be changed.

acoldwintersday · 17/10/2021 09:35

Praying for all those affected xx

DemelzaRobins · 17/10/2021 09:35

One of my school friends was killed in a car crash during our A level exams. My friend was driving with several others from school (they were in another car which didn't crash) and they were with him when he died. This was around 5pm. They sat an A level exam the next morning at 9am.

I can't believe that now looking back. A large group of us had an exam a few days later on life after death. We expected the school would flag up the circumstances to the exam board but they never did. We had a bit of emotional support from teachers in terms of a memorial assembly and to come and talk to them if we were struggling. No counsellors or anything like that.

This was 14 years ago.

DicklessWonder · 17/10/2021 09:30

@HeyFloof

We lost our baby last year late, under traumatic circumstances. In the fog of grief and horror I was absolutely aware that I needed to be present, capable, loving and constant for my almost 4 year old.

I have had bereavement training/experience before so knew (sort of) how to explain what was happening to him so that he could process it in a safe and age appropriate way.

As the year has gone on, he has discussed his baby sibling at least once a week, brings him up as part of his family tree at school and is confident in explaining to other people that "it's sad that our baby went to heaven but he was born too early and was too poorly to stay." He knows his heart stopped beating, that it was nothing to do with "falling asleep" and that dying is something that usually happens when you are old and have lived a happy, long life. He knows that he isn't going to die soon, but when he is an old man.

My DH's response would have been to tell him very little, probably nothing and just say that there was no baby any more. He isn't good at dealing with any kind of grief himself, so I can't imagine he'd have been any good at explaining this particular death to DS without causing confusion or upset. Dh worries that DS will be "the weird kid who talks about his dead brother" if we discuss it at home and he's comfortable talking about it. I could see that doing more emotional damage than dealing with it openly because then it becomes mysterious, the unknown and potentially scary.

Thank you on behalf of your son.

I’ve had so much pain from your DH’s approach being taken. Yours is much healthier.

I’m so sorry for your loss. Flowers

PuertoPollensa · 17/10/2021 09:26

When I was 12 a boy in town died by suicide. I didn't know him but my friends and cousins did. I was in the group that heard about his death from the boy who found him (not from an adult). We went to his funeral. I wrote a story about it in school. The only comment made was that I hadn't put a title on the story.

Same school, a girl in my class killed a man she worked for at the age of about 15. (It was she who did it, but she was coerced by a third party.) This was NEVER spoken about, by my parents, by the school. Nobody. She never came back to school. I don't know what happened to her. (There was a court case and I believe she was found guilty, but as she had been coerced, I don't know what her sentence was, if any.)

These events took place 25-30 years ago.

Zero mental health support.

butterflyze · 17/10/2021 09:26

I got counselling in the 1970's when my dad died. It didn't do much good though.

HouseOfFire · 17/10/2021 09:25

We didn't have autism or adhd back then either, we just had the naughty kid.

Things are not the same

TimeIhadaNameChange · 17/10/2021 09:22

My dad died when I was 6. Mid 80s. Like others, I was left to get on with it. I asked my mother about it 10 years ago and she just said no one though children needed counselling at the time.

It's totally fucked me up. Damaged the family (none of us have dealt with it). I've never had a 'proper' relationship and this is at the heart of it. I've also be suicidal in the past. I can't help but think that intervention at n early age might have mitigated at least some of the above.

CounsellorTroi · 17/10/2021 09:21

I often think of the evacuee children during WW2. Must have been traumatic, but they didn’t get much support.

RampantIvy · 17/10/2021 09:16

A boy at DD's school was murdered by hs father 7 years ago. It was massive news at the time. The school did loads to support the other pupils. The safeguarding governor (an ex nurse with bags of empathy) went in to be available for any pupil who wanted to talk about it.

maxineputyourredshoeson · 17/10/2021 09:13

I’ve shared a lot of my childhood on here before. It was horrific and my brain has wiped lots of it.

My DM has BPD (back then it was manic depression) which was not helped by the fact she was literally given to the next door neighbour at 6 days old. She had many, many suicide attempts - serious attempts that often resulted in ICU stays.

At the age of 2/3 I found her hanging from the bannister of our house, over the years I have found her unconscious from overdoses, I have seen her attempt to chop her hand off with a meat cleaver. My dad left after my mum had an affair when I was 9.

In 1995 my brother was killed in a car crash, my DM’s MH took a serious turn for the worse. Her own GP actually stopped her getting sectioned more than once - stating ‘well she is grieving for her child’.

All through my childhood, my brothers death and subsequent court cases I had no help at all. Not one single person thought that this child who had witnessed things that no person should ever see, who was 15yrs old and grieving her 14yr old brother, who was supposed to be sitting her GCSE’s. Who felt abandoned by her dad - even though I saw him every other weekend (I also blamed him for not helping me) might need help.

At 25 I had a breakdown, I was given antidepressants and 6 sessions of counselling. I some how muddled through, met DH at 29 had DD1 at 31.

I had PND with DD1, again antidepressants. After DD2 was born I was sterilised then diagnosed with Adenomyosis had a hysterectomy at 33 unfortunately there were severe complications that left me with chronic pain and disabled.

My MH spiralled after this - I attempted suicide twice and hated myself because I didn’t want to turn into my mother, luckily to this day DD’s don’t know about this. I’ve been diagnosed with a whole host of MH issues, I have received so many hours of different therapies, had god knows how many prescriptions for antidepressants.

I’m the most stable I have been for many, many years but it’s a bloody fight within myself every single day. And I can only hope that I can continue to live like this.

Now, would help back then of helped, yes it would, would it have changed anything who knows. But I hand on heart will never be able to understand how the whole host of people that I came into contact with, including my dad, grandparents, aunts, uncles, teachers etc could stand by knowing everything I had witnessed without thinking I might need some help of any description.

NoBetterthanSheShouldBe · 17/10/2021 09:13

In the 90s and 00s my younger DC lost their DF as a baby, first primary school teacher to cancer during the first year of school, and a good school friend to cancer in junior school.

The last loss was talked about in assembly but no support was offered that I’m aware of.

MangoSeason · 17/10/2021 09:11

When I was at high school in the early 1990’s a classmate died in an accident Sunday afternoon. All of our year of 86 students was called to an assembly and told. On hearing the news, 85 heads swivelled to look at the dead boy’s best friend, who was hearing the news for the first time. These boys were inseparable. The teachers knew this and it has always angered me that they didn’t pull him aside at the start and tell him privately.

NightIbble · 17/10/2021 09:07

A school friend of mine died just after our GCSE's in the 90's the school had a book of condolence and a little ceremony where they planted a tree. Which helped me and if you wanted to talk to someone you could. It happened the same day Princess Diana died and I remember being irritatied that people were so sad about the death of a person they had never met.

FanGirlX · 17/10/2021 09:06

@KloppsTeeth

When my Dad died in 1994, I had just turned 17 and my brother was 15. We had absolutely no support or help whatsoever. Nothing was offered. School did nothing to help either of us. My mum had no support. It was very traumatic for us, yet there was no counselling or anything. Mental health knowledge has improved but is woefully underfunded and so things access to services probably is very poor, but there is the internet to look up support for that there wasn’t much info online back then either.
Mine died in 1986. Same. Nothing. He died on a Saturday and we were sent to school as normal on Monday. It just wasn't mentioned.
Elephantsparade · 17/10/2021 09:04

Reading a lot of these, the thing missing isnt so much counselling but sitting with the child and explaining things in terms they understand, acknowledging their feelings about it and then showing a bit of ongoing compassion and awareness.
Thats not to say that counselling isnt needed for some people.