Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

3 year old peeing in a potty in the corner of a museum

361 replies

Griddlesizzle · 16/10/2021 18:41

As it says in the title. Mother just whips the potty out and the child pees away, without the mum even asking anyone if there was a loo nearby. As a side point, the loo was less than 10m away…

Ai by - it’s pretty vile
Aibu - what else are you gonna do?

OP posts:
Glassofshloer · 16/10/2021 19:40

@highstreetdiestreet you don’t know it was discreet and you don’t know there would’ve been an accident otherwise. Stop making out like people who don’t want to see other people (toddlers or otherwise) pissing and crapping in public is pearl-clutchy. It isn’t.

If he isn’t reliably dry they should carry nappies for days out.

highstreetdiestreet · 16/10/2021 19:39

@Kanaloa

No it isn’t acceptable to me. I would say if mine couldn’t wait to walk to a nearby bathroom then they’re not potty trained. If they literally need to be whipped onto the potty the second they need to go then they aren’t toilet trained at all.

My son wasn’t toilet trained properly until age four, and one of the things that could send him into meltdown was if someone turned the dryer on or flushed another toilet while he was on the toilet. I still never thought of just letting him use a potty in public - where does it end? Can he have a poo and wipe his bum in a potty in the corner of the national gallery?

4?

RIDICULOUS .etc

MrsKeats · 16/10/2021 19:39

How was it discreet if the op saw it?
That's the opposite of discreet.

gardeninggirl68 · 16/10/2021 19:39

would think the staff would not allow it

can you imagine if every entitled parent decided it was the way forward

PissedOff2020 · 16/10/2021 19:39

No that’s pretty disgusting.

As a mother who has toilet trained 3 boys I’ve never had a situation when they could not make the loo. Never carried a potty around, just a toddler toilet seat but that stopped after the first few weeks.

Kanaloa · 16/10/2021 19:38

No it isn’t acceptable to me. I would say if mine couldn’t wait to walk to a nearby bathroom then they’re not potty trained. If they literally need to be whipped onto the potty the second they need to go then they aren’t toilet trained at all.

My son wasn’t toilet trained properly until age four, and one of the things that could send him into meltdown was if someone turned the dryer on or flushed another toilet while he was on the toilet. I still never thought of just letting him use a potty in public - where does it end? Can he have a poo and wipe his bum in a potty in the corner of the national gallery?

Holly60 · 16/10/2021 19:38

@KingsleyShacklebolt

Horrendous and completely inappropriate.

No excuse.

I’ve just read a post about anti-Vaxxers targeting teens getting their Covid jabs. That is horrendous and completely inappropriate.

A toddler having a wee-wee in a potty... Not so much.

highstreetdiestreet · 16/10/2021 19:37

So many presumably grown women over reacting like children on this thread. 'Grim' 'disgusting' 'horrified' 'gross' etc.

All for a tiny child discreetly using a potty rather than having an accident.

(I'm not convinced this thread isn't fodder for some odd people to get their kicks)

Clocktopus · 16/10/2021 19:37

Sorry, no, it isn't. Toileting your child in the open is degrading, and I'm saying that as a severely disabled person.

Two of my DC are disabled and we have radar keys, if your DC has additional needs then you can take them into the accessible toilets where you will have control over when/if the hand drier is operated.

SylvanasWindrunner · 16/10/2021 19:37

My DD would become very distressed at me trying to put a nappy on her to pee into. It would cause far more of a scene.

DD is 2.5 and uses a potty because she just doesn't want to use the big toilet yet. She has no accidents at home and hasn't had any while out and about, takes herself to her potty, pulls her pants down, etc. But we take a travel potty out and about with us to use in the loos as she prefers that to a big toilet at the moment and she doesn't feel very secure on proper toilets yet as she's v small.

In a dire emergency, I would use the travel potty in a quiet corner, using my body to block everything from view, if the alternative was her wetting herself in a public place. And yes, I would be stressed about it and hate doing it, but honestly I care more about my daughter not wetting herself and getting soaked in urine than a random who couldn't really see anything anyway being offended. Our potty clips shut and has a seal so no carrying an open potty full of wee around for anyone to see.

Like I said, we've been out and about and it hasn't happened and I hope it never will as we are careful to make sure she goes frequently and doesn't drink too much and she's good at telling us when she needs to go, but toddlers can be unpredictable, they are still learning, and accidents do happen! So I would probably just think 'There but for the grace of god' and be glad it wasn't happening to us that day tbh.

LookingGlassMilk · 16/10/2021 19:37

Sorry, no, it isn't

Sorry yes it is. It is absolutely ableist to suggest that children with autism shouldn't be taken out in public.

DeepaBeesKit · 16/10/2021 19:37

Toileting your child in the open is degrading, and I'm saying that as a severely disabled person.

Clearly there are no men on this thread because they wee against trees, down alleyways and at street urinals late at night and dont seem to find it degrading. I see parents taking kids for wees behind the bushes in our local park a lot, the council closed the only public toilet near there years ago.

Innocenta · 16/10/2021 19:36

@Thelivesofothers Why do only your and your child's needs matter in this situation? What about everyone else who is affected?

Clocktopus · 16/10/2021 19:35

And it's not teaching them to wet themselves.

Neither is using an emergency nappy once in a blue moon.

Clymene · 16/10/2021 19:35

It's disgusting. There is no excuse.

Clocktopus · 16/10/2021 19:34

I didn’t even try until DS was three and he was perfect within a week (we just stayed at home)

This is pretty much what I did, age difference aside. I waited for signs of readiness then picked a long weekend to stay at home and do it, started on the Friday and by the Monday they were reliable enough to take out and about. As a PP said, you ask them when passing a loo if they need to go.

Innocenta · 16/10/2021 19:34

@LookingGlassMilk

Don't take the child into public places if they can't badly a hand dryer

This is a horrible ableist comment. Should children with autism never be brought into public places?

My eldest has autism and was absolutely terrified of hand driers. Our solution was to use a portable potty. We tried our best to find a quiet empty corridor somewhere. He loved fire extinguishers so we usually found a spot beside them.

I didn't have to do this with my other two children. They didn't have the same problems. It's not that they were parented so much better -they didn't have the same sensory issues.

Sorry, no, it isn't. Toileting your child in the open is degrading, and I'm saying that as a severely disabled person.
Thelivesofothers · 16/10/2021 19:34

Did this years ago and I'm not sorry.

You can't ever know other people's lives, so some of the global condemnation on this thread feels a little misplaced.

Let me give you some details: by the time this happened I was over a year into toilet training a child with undiagnosed (later diagnosed) special needs. It was a huge victory when he could tell me he needed to go, so I had to respond immediately because that was the timeframe he operated in. I was horribly socially isolated, and meeting a friend for the first time in many months.

What would you have me do, let him piss all over the floor in the national gallery? Piss himself even though he'd told me he needed? Magically transport myself up a flight of stairs and through three galleries with a double pram to the accessible toilets? Cage me up at home with the rest of the parents of "unmentionables"? Not let me leave the house? Deprive him of the opportunity to toilet in a socially acceptable way by keeping him in nappies until someone else deemed it appropriate? Suddenly wish away his "differences"?

Judge less, lest ye be judged. If you're a perfect parent to a perfect child, knock yourself out, but maybe think of the lives of others before you decide how outranged you're going to get about something so utterly minor.

P.s. he's 16 now and fully toilet trained, able to take himself off to the loo and I know how very very fortunate I am that that's the case.

CoastalWave · 16/10/2021 19:33

Grim. They're doing it for attention.

If they actually bothered to potty train PROPERLY (ie take the week off work and nail it at home first, then short trips not a bloody trek round a museum) there would be no need to do this.

Mummyoflittledragon · 16/10/2021 19:33

@Curtaintwitching

She was not harassed and I know the age of the child because we were out with them. Relatives of my DH
Are you the op? Name change fail?
highstreetdiestreet · 16/10/2021 19:33

@Clocktopus

Yeah, that doesn't sound discreet at all actually

Quiet corner, my body blocking DC from view, slide whole nappy into back of pants (no pulling down the pants), pull front half of nappy up from the front (again no need to pull down or remove pants), fasten, done.

Much more discreet than allowing a child to pull their pants down and wee on a potty.

If the child is in a corner and blocked by my body, then using a potette is literally no different.

And it's not teaching them to wet themselves.

DeepaBeesKit · 16/10/2021 19:33

I didn’t even try until DS was three and he was perfect within a week (we just stayed at home) Not a single accident because he was ready.

I did both mine at 2 and had maybe half a dozen accidents. That's probably 4 nappies a day per child, 2 kids, 365 days in a year....close to 3000 nappies saved from landfill/150 nappy cycles in the washing machine. These are the different choices we all need to make for the environment.

highstreetdiestreet · 16/10/2021 19:32

@Clocktopus

You've never heard of a potette then.

No, because there's no need for a potty outside of the house (and realistically no need for one inside the house either but that's personal choice).

It's a matter of opinion.

There's absolutely no need to judge how parents decide to potty train their young children.

LookingGlassMilk · 16/10/2021 19:32

Don't take the child into public places if they can't badly a hand dryer

This is a horrible ableist comment. Should children with autism never be brought into public places?

My eldest has autism and was absolutely terrified of hand driers. Our solution was to use a portable potty. We tried our best to find a quiet empty corridor somewhere. He loved fire extinguishers so we usually found a spot beside them.

I didn't have to do this with my other two children. They didn't have the same problems. It's not that they were parented so much better -they didn't have the same sensory issues.

Clocktopus · 16/10/2021 19:31

Clocktopus my DD age 2 is tiny and the family small toilet seats dont fit our loo. We need a potty because she isn't big enough to safely use an adult toilet.

That's fine, it's your choice. I meant it's not compulsory/essential to have a potty.

Swipe left for the next trending thread