Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Somalian Descent

92 replies

YearsSinceISawYou · 16/10/2021 11:21

AIBU to wonder why the papers are referring to the man arrested for killing David Amess as a British Muslim of Somalian descent.

Surely, if he is British-that's all we need to know. Why do we need to know about his line of descent?

OP posts:
DysmalRadius · 16/10/2021 12:45

I just read a few reports of Jo Cox's murder - initial reports just referred to the arrest of 'a man'. There didn't seem to be much mention of his appearance and although later reports mention his far-right ideology, his heritage and religious beliefs don't seem to have been mentioned. Perhaps there was more at the time, but I don't remember it being, despite that also being a terrorist attack.

Mummyoflittledragon · 16/10/2021 12:44

Because the murder has been confirmed as a terrorist attack.

Rubyupbeat · 16/10/2021 12:41

Ffs...let's be honest here, somalians, generally, are hated by other Africans, and vice versa.
I worked within a somalian community, there would be violent fights between themselves and other Africans, mainly so between the women, to the point they had a separate nursery.
This reporting would probably lessen offence between the communities. I don't know, anyway his identity will be revealed soon.
I feel so bad for the family of the victim, he was meant to be a lovely man and well loved in leigh on sea and southend area.

Missgemini · 16/10/2021 12:41

OP, I understand your question completely.
The guy is British and has been arrested. It's not like he's still out on the streets and we need to watch out for him.

The answer to your question is that the media needs to make it clear that he's not 'one of us', even though he clearly is!
Had he been Mo Farah winning golds for Britain, then he'd just be British!
Now watch as attacks on immigrants will shoot up, even though this one crazy guy may have been British born and raised!

EvilRingahBitch · 16/10/2021 12:39

There was instant online speculation linking this attack to the UK's refugee policy and assuming that this man was an illegal immigrant/asylum seeker/refugee - presumably based on eye witness descriptions of his appearance.

The most convincing way to clear this speculation up is to state that he was a UK national of Somali descent.

0blio · 16/10/2021 12:39

He is British end of. He was probably born and raised here a product of this soil doesn’t know what Somalia looks like.

Not necessarily, he could just as easily have a completely different background and culture to most of us - that's what is relevant.

JanglyBeads · 16/10/2021 12:39

twitter.com/sarahbealewales/status/1449280302187257856?s=21
Mo Farah is also of Somali descent….

Rosesareyellow · 16/10/2021 12:38

I imagine it might mean that he has British citizenship but hasn’t lived in Britain for that long? If his parents were Somalian but he had been brought up here I doubt it would be worth the mention. I think terrorists who originally and fairly recently come from different countries but have British citizenship may be ‘British’ on paper but don’t feel a strong affiliation with Britain. So I think it is relevant. It’s basically saying they are technically British but not really…

mygenericusername · 16/10/2021 12:32

@Coogee. It may be a man v woman thing. Who knows. I guess when you’ve been bunched in with all Asians for the past 20 years, been stared at on planes and in crowded spaces with constant suspicion because of something that was carried out by people not only of a different religion but nationality it makes you a bit paranoid.

It was never stressed enough where the attackers came from. People from civilised countries have been victimised for years as a result.

OhWhyNot · 16/10/2021 12:30

It’s believed to be terrorist link

Coogee sometimes people do get stopped regularly and we don’t know why. But let’s not pretend that it happens as much to white people as it does to people of colour. Your husbands case is unusual sadly for many black and Asian men it’s a common occurrence

CatsArePeople · 16/10/2021 12:29

oh please. of course we need to know. actually paints to clearer picture what and why.

lazylinguist · 16/10/2021 12:27

Because someone's background is (usually) relevant to their motive

^This. Plus it's pretty normal for the media to include all kinds of details about suspects or anyone in a news story. Whereabouts they live, age, if they are married, have kids etc, even when those things aren't relevant to the crime/story. I mean... were you under the impression it usually just says 'person' and leaves it at that?

DevonTF · 16/10/2021 12:23

Because we live in a free democratic society and expect the news to report the actual news. And not decide which parts we can know.

Coogee · 16/10/2021 12:15

To this day my Indian BIL gets stopped at the airport gate more than my white sister.

My white British husband gets stopped at airport gates all over the world about nine out of every ten times he flies. I’ve been stopped about once in my whole life. It’s a running joke.

Peaflock · 16/10/2021 12:14

Because he is of Somalian descent?

Fyngal123 · 16/10/2021 12:11

Because that’s British press for you. Only claiming the individual as British if it’s positive news. He is British end of. He was probably born and raised here a product of this soil doesn’t know what Somalia looks like. If he had represented Great Britain in Olympics and won they don’t specify his descent. Never heard them referring to most athletes descent when talking about their wins only when it’s related to an offense.

mygenericusername · 16/10/2021 12:04

@Jinkiesfredlll

I’m the ignorant one? That’s the most hilarious thing I’ve heard all day.

The 9/11 were Saudi and UAE Nationals. I never said anything about Indians being Hindus or Muslims. I said my Indian brother in law still gets stopped as an Indian. Not all Asians look the same believe it or not.

Really take a good look at your own prejudice beliefs.

puddlebubble · 16/10/2021 12:02

ffs. If a bomb went off in Canary Wharf tomorrow, and it was a white male, it would be his background included, is he Irish, Russian, mental health issues, known to police, there is a similar thread on here at the moment, these are descriptors that are absolutely KEY.

GCAcademic · 16/10/2021 12:01

[quote Jinkiesfredlll]@mygenericusername .... Indian isn't a religion... you can be both Indian and Muslim. Muslim is for the followers of Islam. Your post just seems a bit ignorant using the terms so interchangabley ?[/quote]
Er, she didn't use the terms interchangeably. Go back and read what she wrote.

SaskiaRembrandt · 16/10/2021 11:59

@Ponoka7

On a different note, if African countries could get sporting teams together, we'd barely get a look in. Look at the top 'French/British/Spanish/German' sportspeople.
African countries already have sports teams.
Jinkiesfredlll · 16/10/2021 11:56

@mygenericusername .... Indian isn't a religion... you can be both Indian and Muslim. Muslim is for the followers of Islam. Your post just seems a bit ignorant using the terms so interchangabley ?

silentpool · 16/10/2021 11:52

If they were saying of African appearance, well then I'd prefer they were specific. Africa is a big place with lots of different cultures in it. I'm an African and I have white skin. So you see how it could get confusing.

lollipoprainbow · 16/10/2021 11:51

Does it matter ?? A poor man has been stabbed to death.

GoWalkabout · 16/10/2021 11:47

I think the reporting of crime does somewhat need to be clear about incidences and patterns of crime in different communities within a multicultural society. For instance, the grooming and sexual abuse of mainly white British girls by mainly Asian men in Rotherham, that over 1,200 women (of all nationalities) were reportedly sexually assaulted during the 2015–16 public New Year's Eve's celebrations in Germany, in most cases by men of non-European origin, or that over 75% of the names on a list of drink driving arrests in my local area were Eastern European names. I think if it can't be talked about it can't be tackled. In those first two cases journalists were reluctant to report the facts and it obscured what happened. Today people will be wondering and worrying about the motives, and need to understand why and how this happened. Extremism and terrorism within certain groups (far right, white supremacist, Islamic) is something we all need protection from, and to do that need to be able to discuss it.

mygenericusername · 16/10/2021 11:45

@MissAmbrosia

Because it’s been happening since 9/11. It’s human nature unfortunately.

To this day my Indian BIL gets stopped at the airport gate more than my white sister. He’s a 40 year old GP for Christ sake and Hindu not Muslim yet he is still packaged up and victimised with the extremists based on his look.

We need to be honest about where the terror cells are coming from. It’s not racism. It’s realism.

This man was british. His heritage is Somalian. Somalia is a dangerous, violent country with extremist views. There is absolutely nothing wrong with knowing that.