Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Somalian Descent

92 replies

YearsSinceISawYou · 16/10/2021 11:21

AIBU to wonder why the papers are referring to the man arrested for killing David Amess as a British Muslim of Somalian descent.

Surely, if he is British-that's all we need to know. Why do we need to know about his line of descent?

OP posts:
maddening · 17/10/2021 01:32

Buggritbuggrit - a British man of French origin is probably just a bog standard (in this country) white British man, his grandparents origin does not really add anything- unless he had attacked some French institution or French figure perhaps as then it may be an aggravating factor.

maddening · 17/10/2021 01:28

Because a "Muslim man", however wrong it is, brings a person of Asian origin to mind, therefore if he is white Muslim or in this case of Somalian origin, it helps to provide that detail.

Balonzette · 17/10/2021 01:21

What??

By that logic, did we need to know he was male? Or British?

Of course it's relevant!

znaika · 17/10/2021 01:07

That's bullshit. It would definitely be pointed out if he was E European.

Buggritbuggrit · 17/10/2021 00:49

I would like to point out that they only ever do this with POC. Nobody ever gets described as ‘of French descent’ because their grandparents were from Provence.

Guetzlibache · 16/10/2021 18:42

It gives the right wing press some racist fodder.

PearlclutchersInc · 16/10/2021 14:52

Positively, they are descriptors which give the reader an instant mental picture.

Negatively (and depending on the paper) they're goady gits.

fanjosaysi · 16/10/2021 14:52

Exactly- his ideology was reported, but not his appearance, heritage or religion. Which is what I was saying.

Standing with Britain first is a pretty good indicator he's white though. I'm sure at least some news outlets would have reported on his race anyway just to clarify.

But it's not like it was hidden, like just 'man, age'. We knew what side he was on and therefore his ethnicity.

worriedatthemoment · 16/10/2021 14:50

@Fyngal123 well they do as they often refer to mo farah's heritage

Seeingadistance · 16/10/2021 14:43

The man who murdered Jo Cox was born in Scotland, and that was reported early on, when his identity was known.

Missgemini · 16/10/2021 14:39

@GCAcademic oh, believe me, I was not saying that it was true or not true!
The Daily Mail has a whole gossip section that I'm pretty sure does not vet every bit of gossip published there.
The point is that not even a single magazine mentioned the Prince William gossip, whereas well known newspapers in the US published it at the time. I don't expect the BBC news to have a headline on it, but come on.. even OK magazine didn't feel the need to mention it?

Warsawa31 · 16/10/2021 14:25

Shying away from truth doesn't help anyone.

The Pedophile grooming gangs were mostly people of south Asian descent - does that mean it applies to everyone ? No. But was it important to know so that patterns could be looked into ? Yes.

GCAcademic · 16/10/2021 14:22

@Missgemini

Lots of people demanding that the press be free to report everything etc etc.

2 years ago, I was on holiday in the US. The media over there was reporting big news that Prince William had cheated on Kate.
Called my husband in the UK to say: "omg, have you heard the news..." He hadn't heard!
Most people in the UK haven't heard as the media chose not to or where silenced!
As a PP has said, they just wanted to make it clear that he's black and Muslim. The end!

The media in the US (and Australia) make up all kinds of crazy stories about the British royal family. Some of the headlines you see are hilarious ("Kate at War with the Queen! Packs up and Leaves!"). Just because it's published there, doesn't make it true.
Missgemini · 16/10/2021 13:58

Lots of people demanding that the press be free to report everything etc etc.

2 years ago, I was on holiday in the US. The media over there was reporting big news that Prince William had cheated on Kate.
Called my husband in the UK to say: "omg, have you heard the news..." He hadn't heard!
Most people in the UK haven't heard as the media chose not to or where silenced!
As a PP has said, they just wanted to make it clear that he's black and Muslim. The end!

Newrumpus · 16/10/2021 13:26

Totally unreasonable to focus on this. Why on Earth should it not be reported? That this line of thinking has emerged is worrying.

Bananarice · 16/10/2021 13:25

It is an efficient way of saying he is both black and Muslim, just like pp said.

Theythinkitsalloveritisnow · 16/10/2021 13:22

@MakingM2 at least theoretically the media don't have rules set for them by government about withholding facts when they are considered to be uncomfortable/ inappropriate for us plebs to hear. I am perfectly well aware they often self censor ( about different things depending on their particular biases)

Marguerite2000 · 16/10/2021 13:14

Why refer to a man, OP? Surely he should be just be called a person. Why do we need to know he's male?
A person has been arrested. There you go, as little information as possible.

MakingM2 · 16/10/2021 13:08

@Theythinkitsalloveritisnow

I really don't want to live in a country where the powers that be decide what details of news people can hear and that there are things better kept quiet. I want access to a free press and to read facts, even if some may be uncomfortable for some to hear.
Good luck with that. A “free press” has never actually existed. Anywhere. Ever.
CuteGirlsWatchMeEatEther · 16/10/2021 13:07

@Ponoka7

On a different note, if African countries could get sporting teams together, we'd barely get a look in. Look at the top 'French/British/Spanish/German' sportspeople.
What’s that got to do with anything?
MakingM2 · 16/10/2021 13:05

Might I suggest that this might be their way of saying he is both black and Muslim as they are both common characteristics of the Somali community without saying he is black and Muslim. They’re not really fooling anyone, are they?

Theythinkitsalloveritisnow · 16/10/2021 13:03

I really don't want to live in a country where the powers that be decide what details of news people can hear and that there are things better kept quiet. I want access to a free press and to read facts, even if some may be uncomfortable for some to hear.

DysmalRadius · 16/10/2021 12:53

[quote mygenericusername]@DysmalRadius. are you kidding? It was immediately jumped on that he was a right wing extremists with links to Britain first that shouted Britain first as he killed poor Joe. It was later reported that he said this is for England/Britain.[/quote]
Exactly- his ideology was reported, but not his appearance, heritage or religion. Which is what I was saying.

PineappleWilson · 16/10/2021 12:50

From what I heard on the radio this morning, there had been speculation as to who the person involved was. It's a way of ruling out the other person suspected.

mygenericusername · 16/10/2021 12:49

@DysmalRadius. are you kidding? It was immediately jumped on that he was a right wing extremists with links to Britain first that shouted Britain first as he killed poor Joe. It was later reported that he said this is for England/Britain.