But, everything you’ve described is something that can be done by a lot of people given a bit of time and on the job training. It doesn’t require many rare attributes or skills.
Doesn't the fact that the care sector has SUCH a high turnover of staff tell you that this isn't the case?
On paper, it may be that lots of people can do the job, but the reality is that they can't.
I'm a dog walker and it's a job that often comes up on those threads where people are asking how to earn extra cash, as people assume it's just sticking a lead on a dog and walking round the park.
But a good dog walker walks in all weathers - rain, snow, hail, heat. They know when the weather makes it too dangerous. They know what to do if a dog gets injured or stung by a wasp and needs vet care. They're insured in case your dog gets hurt or lost or escapes it's collar. They have qualifications, know about first-aid and know how to control large groups of dogs off-lead at once.
On paper, lots of people can do it, but I've seen SO many people start it and drop out once the temperature drops, or when mud season kicks in, or when they've walked for 15 days in a row in the pissing down rain etc.
A good "unskilled" worker is worth their weight in gold. It's quite insulting to tell them they're easily replaced and that "anyone could do their job".
I also know 100% that I could not be a carer. On paper, I could do it, but I couldn't clean up bodily fluids or deal with a grown adult having a meltdown. I'm just not emotionally capable of that.