Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

CF territory and how to solve

89 replies

PurpleLlama · 15/10/2021 23:06

NC as potentially outing...

Due to an initial risk of weather damage/damp, which has now cascaded into a house move to downsize and that won't need work on it, I am currently heavily involved in the sale of my grandparent's house/certain items of belongings to try and raise some money for care/downsize.

My DNan had an obsession with sewing. There is no other word for it. The studio (repurposed large shed) was weather damaged and damp was eking its way in, so DM and I took the initiative to box bits up/sort through/sell what we can as Nan has a long term condition that is deteriorating and will need care.. and is no longer able to sew.

One of my childhood friends (20+ years) has a mum (I'll call her Betty) who is heavily into sewing, so after mum and I took our pickings for projects, we thought Betty would love a root through/first dibs/a chance to have some bits cheaper than retail. DNan wasn't a cheapskate so a lot of high quality bits in her possession.

At some point there was a misunderstanding that if they helped us with selling/developing DNan's house she could have the sewing bits for free.
This was never mentioned, and a total wtaf moment for DM and me as it was so out of the blue and neither of us know where it came from.

Anyway, DM was clear on that to Betty, and we had no intention of developing ourselves, so was a moot point.

However, this was back in June/July sort of time, and so far there has been no money forthcoming.

It is sickening the amount of money's worth she has had from us (approximately £500 just in one type of thread, excluding the crates of fabric, other threads, equipment etc). Obviously we are not after retail prices, far from it, but even £1 an item would go a long way in helping us pay for DNan's care needs, and Betty would be getting a bloody bargain and she damn well knows it. They arent short of a penny or two, with 7 bedrooms, a swimming pool, tennis court and horses.

I am highly cautious about confronting her for the money, as I don't want it to have a knock on effect on my friendship with Betty's daughter, although deep down I don't think it will as she said her mum would pay...

AIBU in wanting to (diplomatically) say "oi bitch gimme money"?

Any suggestions on how to word it? I was thinking along the lines of giving her bank details in case my DM had "forgotten" and see what she replies...

OP posts:
tofuschnitzel · 16/10/2021 12:54

@Franklyfrost

It doesn’t sound like the sewing stuff would be worth anything, maybe a tenner at best. How many hours help did you get? Just let go of the sewing stuff. You could ask for it back but then you’d have to find another way of getting rid of it.
Saying it is worth a tenner is nonsense. Depending on the brands, the items are likely to sell on eBay or Etsy. Lots of people sell second-hand thread in bundles, and they can go for a fair amount depending on the brand and the shades. And that's without taking crates of fat quarters in to consideration. Again, it is highly likely to sell for more than a tenner for the lot of it.
DeepaBeesKit · 16/10/2021 12:43

You may be over valuing stuff. This sort of thing sells second hand for a fraction of retail, unless there are good quality high spec machines etc, recent models. Thread & fabric go for pennies second hand. You can't be sure of dye lots etc on yarns etc.

Alieninmybody · 16/10/2021 12:34

I thought to OP said only one of the items was worth £500 retail and that the friend had many many more items than just that?

TopBlogger · 16/10/2021 12:29

It wouldn't even enter my head to charge an old family friend for unused crafting materials. I would be grateful that it had been taken off my hands and someone was getting the use of it

But you aren't the OP and the OP needs the money for her DNan's care Hmm

diddl · 16/10/2021 11:06

Perhaps look at it as her helping you clear stuff out?

You & your mum had already taken what you wanted & there is still more that you can bundle & sell.

Hope478 · 16/10/2021 10:50

@TwinklyBranch

It wouldn't even enter my head to charge an old family friend for unused crafting materials. I would be grateful that it had been taken off my hands and someone was getting the use of it.
This. A friend of 20 years.
Franklyfrost · 16/10/2021 10:50

It doesn’t sound like the sewing stuff would be worth anything, maybe a tenner at best. How many hours help did you get? Just let go of the sewing stuff. You could ask for it back but then you’d have to find another way of getting rid of it.

HowardNoir · 16/10/2021 10:42

I don't have any sound advice but is there anything else you could offer her and say "Have a look through and we can sort out a price for this and the sewing items" It does seem rude that Betty knows she misunderstood the original offer but still hasn't paid up.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 16/10/2021 10:28

If it's £500 retail, I guess it's worth around £100 now? If that's all I and Betty is helping in any way, I think you should let it go. It's a lesson in being clearer in saying "We're going to sell this for £100, just giving you first dibs but if you don't want no worries, we'll stick it on ebay". You really do need to be that clear about selling things. £100 is pocket money compared to the price you'll get for the house so I would really not sweat this too much.

PurpleLlama · 16/10/2021 10:24

Posted too soon

I hold my hands up - yes, we should have made expectations clearer from the start

no, we dont want or expect retail back.

I suppose it it was me in that position, knowing the value, then I would offer something for it.
Not even a value per item, but just.. something.

The house sale itself isn't being the main provider of care money - DNan is moving into a more suitable home, so while there will be some money freed up, it isn't going to be lots as PP seem to think. We're trying to support her in maintaining her independence while she can, which is what she wants to do.

Anyway, thank you to all who have posted - it is not as black and white as I was thinking and I appreciate all the posts.

I will be sitting and mulling it over before deciding anything, and will have another read through of the thread first.

OP posts:
Chamomileteaplease · 16/10/2021 10:23

While Natalia's text is almost perfect IMO, it still means that you will have to have the chat about how much she is going to give you, when you are there in person picking up the leftovers.

If she replies to the text saying yes great, I would follow up with a question about how much she would like to keep and how much she is going to pay you (to then pass on to your Nan).

Then it's all sorted before you see her face to face Smile.

PurpleLlama · 16/10/2021 10:20

People seem to be focussing on the £500 I mentioned for thread - that in itself was retail value, and was not what we would have expected back from anyone for it, whether sold online, craft sale, or from Betty.
I put it there as an example of value, but clearly I have got the wrong wnd of the stick on it; it was stored safely in a "really useful box" and all bar one or 2 of them still had their plastic wrap on, so had never been used.

Again, I had no idea it was easy to pick up crates worth of fat quarters etc from charity shops or places for next to nothing - lesson learnt on that as well.

As for petrol and clearing the house, Betty didn't help on that side at all. She came over once, and then my DM was in charge of swapping crates/items etc. (Yes, I'm going off half information on that side of things).
There were no dump runs, no assistance in house clearance on that side of things.

And no, Betty/family didn't help sell the house at all. Her partner gave us an option as he is a builder and into the housing market and development etc but we declined that side of it all - we never wanted to develop and sell on... mostly as we don't have the money for it/respect the neighbours/need the money for care costs rather than investing it all in a project that'll span a couple of years

To the PP asking if I would bundle bits to sell... yes, I would. We are talking about many hundreds of fat quarters of materials, that are complementary with each other, and would work well bundled.
We still have plenty left, and won't be disposing of it, so undoubtedly will be bundling at some point, yes.

OP posts:
Lalliella · 16/10/2021 10:11

@NataliaSerene do you work for the diplomatic services? You ought to! Your suggestions are perfect.

callmeadoctor · 16/10/2021 10:02

In all niceness, its really not worth the bother.

callmeadoctor · 16/10/2021 10:01

Sorry I realise that it was one item that was £500, so whatever money you are expecting.

Howshouldibehave · 16/10/2021 10:00

It is sickening the amount of money's worth she has had from us

Sickening?

Perhaps you should have been clear about what you wanted to happen. It sounds like she helped you out by taking loads of stuff out of the house so it was clear for photographers but weeks later you want some money!!

What did you actually say to her?

callmeadoctor · 16/10/2021 09:59

If you are selling a house for her then the £500 you are expecting is nothing in comparison. The woman did you a favour. Are you really going to bundle bits up and sell on ebay? Really?

pinkyredrose · 16/10/2021 09:47

Did you ask her if she'd like to have some sewing bits or did you ask her if she'd like to buy some bits?

Geamhradh · 16/10/2021 09:46

Is anyone else imagining Betty's AIBU?

"I helped the relatives of my dear friend to clear some stuff out of the house, and they asked if I wanted any of the old sewing materials. I took it off their hands and now, 6 months later, the CF wants paying for it. They did tell me it was worth a bit when they offered it to me, but I never thought that was what they thought I'd be paying them!"

areyouinsane · 16/10/2021 09:42

‘At some point there was a misunderstanding that if they helped us with selling/developing DNan's house ..’

Could the sewing items be seen as payment for this help?? What did they do for you? And was this selling/developing something you’d normally pay for? If so you might be being reasonable…

TwinklyBranch · 16/10/2021 09:28

It wouldn't even enter my head to charge an old family friend for unused crafting materials. I would be grateful that it had been taken off my hands and someone was getting the use of it.

Hopeisallineed · 16/10/2021 09:25

I sew for a living and £500 in one type of thread? Really? How did you get that second hand thread valued? I pick up second hand thread for pennies, I truly doubt your wild estimation unless you have a whole shops worth of thread. Nothing is worth much once it’s been owned and left in a damp shed, especially if it’s textiles. You should have put a value on it immediately as I definitely wouldn’t have taken it off your hands for that amount especially as it’s so easy to pick up from charity shops for next to nothing.

Angrynellie · 16/10/2021 09:19

As someone who has just done a house clearance for a parent, I honestly think she’s probably done you a favour.
Crates of hobby type stuff sounds horrendous to deal with and you will get virtually nothing for it, and it’s a massive hassle to find a market for it, then sort, picture, try to sell, post or deliver etc etc, for very little reward. I’d let it go.

Loudestcat14 · 16/10/2021 09:02

It doesn't sound like you were at all clear that you expected money in return for the items you invited Betty to help herself to. It sounds more as though it was told to her as "we're clearing out Nan's things, come and see if there's anything you want", without any specific mention of "oh, and you have to pay us for any item you take".

I think the ship's sailed because you weren't clear enough and you need to let it go now.

BunnytheFriendlyDragon · 16/10/2021 08:52

Only if she knows you want her to pay would I text

But even then I'm wondering how much she helped you

You say she has money. Do you need the money?