Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be 24 and never want to live with a man again?

164 replies

heywassuphello · 15/10/2021 19:27

Anyone else?! 😩

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 18/10/2021 07:23

@AICM

I sometimes feel that women saying they never want to live with a man again would, in some cases, want to but can't find one. They then say they don't want a man to protect themselves disappointment.
Yes, I bet you do. I've seen your posts!
logsonlogsoff · 18/10/2021 07:10

Having witnessed what a lot of my friends seem to have to put up with to have a man in their house/life, I don’t blame you!
I have a wife rather than a DH and I honestly don’t understand why they put up with half the sh&t they do!

HarebrightCedarmoon · 18/10/2021 07:06

Yes exactly. After my DF's mum died young, in her 40s, DF's dad, my grandad, met B some years later, who had also lost her DH young. She was like another grandma to me and they were together for years, but never got married or lived together. Very modern of them, I thought and a good thing too (this was the 1970s/80s).

SuperSange · 18/10/2021 06:36

My gran had been alone for about 20 years after my granda died; I remember she had a 'man Freind' who used to go to the local community centre dance club with her and he'd obviously mentioned perhaps becoming more serious. I can remember her baking and saying very sternly' he's a nice man, but I'm not having anyone getting their feet under my table'. 😂😂😂

userxx · 18/10/2021 06:30

@AICM

I sometimes feel that women saying they never want to live with a man again would, in some cases, want to but can't find one. They then say they don't want a man to protect themselves disappointment.

🤣🤣 give over.

Inthesameboatatmo · 18/10/2021 06:07

Nope never again.
I'm mid 40s and I do not want another man in my house full time ever again.

HarebrightCedarmoon · 18/10/2021 05:33

@Fleek

Aside from the mushy nonsense like being able to hang out with someone I love every day, there are real, crucial benefits to cohabitation - especially at a time where property has never been more expensive and many young people will struggle to buy a home without doing it with someone else. Plus - not having to do all the washing, cleaning, decorating, furniture building, cooking etc by yourself, surely that's a benefit?

This!

Being happily single is great and society would be enriched if more women felt confident living alone and doing their own thing. But quite often these threads fill with people saying 'I'm happy but if anything happened to my partner I'd stay single as I'd be fine like that.' And it's all this hypothetical thing from people who haven't experienced the reality of it over the longer term.

Yes, being single long term can have massive benefits. Some of the downsides I've experienced include missing someone to make you a cup of coffee after a long week when you're feeling run down, someone taking over the cooking or coming up with a new recipe you wouldn't have thought to look up. Someone to share all the little ups and downs - it gets you down after a while when you've had really great or difficult news and there is no significant other to really share your joy in a way busy friends don't have time for. I have a major life decision to make in the next year and even just having to make that alone and it not affecting a significant other (financially, emotionally) is lonely. Friends aren't really invested even if I could talk it through with them because it's not their life, a partner would be someone to mull it over with properly and be a source of support through the difficult bits of carrying it out.

So yes, I definitely wouldn't settle for a crappy partner and I really mean that, but I also believe a good relationships is preferable to being alone by far.

24 is generally too young to close yourself off to a decent relationship, but do what's right for you OP.

The point is that people have been in relationships but have seen few, or none of those benefits, but a ton of disadvantages. Most men still believe fundamentally that housework and childcare is women's work.
heywassuphello · 17/10/2021 18:22

@AICM with respect: thats bollocks

OP posts:
sandragreen · 17/10/2021 16:55

This is an interesting thread.

There are plenty of ways of cohabiting that don't involve romantic relationships, so for those who just don't like being alone, being saddled with a romantic partner isn't the only other option. I know plenty of people who live happily with parents, siblings, other family members.

DD (24) and her friends mostly live with friends. One group of three have bought a flat together and have been there for three years so far without any issues.

For me, I am in mid fifties and have lived with partners and lived alone throughout my life. I know that for me I am much happier living alone.

There's been lost of research on this - I recall seeing a Canadian report that found the rankings of happiness were as follows (assume married includes other romantic partnerships:

Happiest:
Married Men
Single Women
Married Women
Single Men

PP are not wrong when they say the institution of marriage and living in a romantic partnership suit the patriarchy.

Fleek · 17/10/2021 16:26

Aside from the mushy nonsense like being able to hang out with someone I love every day, there are real, crucial benefits to cohabitation - especially at a time where property has never been more expensive and many young people will struggle to buy a home without doing it with someone else. Plus - not having to do all the washing, cleaning, decorating, furniture building, cooking etc by yourself, surely that's a benefit?

This!

Being happily single is great and society would be enriched if more women felt confident living alone and doing their own thing. But quite often these threads fill with people saying 'I'm happy but if anything happened to my partner I'd stay single as I'd be fine like that.' And it's all this hypothetical thing from people who haven't experienced the reality of it over the longer term.

Yes, being single long term can have massive benefits. Some of the downsides I've experienced include missing someone to make you a cup of coffee after a long week when you're feeling run down, someone taking over the cooking or coming up with a new recipe you wouldn't have thought to look up. Someone to share all the little ups and downs - it gets you down after a while when you've had really great or difficult news and there is no significant other to really share your joy in a way busy friends don't have time for. I have a major life decision to make in the next year and even just having to make that alone and it not affecting a significant other (financially, emotionally) is lonely. Friends aren't really invested even if I could talk it through with them because it's not their life, a partner would be someone to mull it over with properly and be a source of support through the difficult bits of carrying it out.

So yes, I definitely wouldn't settle for a crappy partner and I really mean that, but I also believe a good relationships is preferable to being alone by far.

24 is generally too young to close yourself off to a decent relationship, but do what's right for you OP.

crochetmonkey74 · 17/10/2021 15:35

@AICM

I sometimes feel that women saying they never want to live with a man again would, in some cases, want to but can't find one. They then say they don't want a man to protect themselves disappointment.
I dont think men are hard to find 😂😂😂
scarpa · 17/10/2021 15:02

@thepeopleversuswork

YANBU.

I am nearly 50 and absolutely certain I will never live with a man again.

Cohabitation is massively over-rated. Unless you have kids with someone there is no upside and all downside.

I find it really encouraging that so many younger women are realising this too.

That's a HUGE sweeping statement! I know plenty of women are happier living alone and I think we should absolutely encourage women not to see their life goal as finding a partner and 'settling down'.

But if you're saying you can't see there are upsides to happy, mutually beneficial cohabitation with someone you have a good relationship with, you're being obtuse. Aside from the mushy nonsense like being able to hang out with someone I love every day, there are real, crucial benefits to cohabitation - especially at a time where property has never been more expensive and many young people will struggle to buy a home without doing it with someone else. Plus - not having to do all the washing, cleaning, decorating, furniture building, cooking etc by yourself, surely that's a benefit?

The only way there are no benefits to cohabitation is if you live with an arsehole who doesn't pull their weight domestically or pay their way, and/or who isn't a nice person and therefore makes life at home horrible. That's not a problem of cohabitation, it's of the people you're cohabiting with.

CatsBooksAndCoffee · 17/10/2021 13:51

@TroysMammy

A man has lived with me for 7 years. If I found myself single again I would stay single as I'm not cut out to live with someone.

I don't know what possessed me to dabble in online dating all those years ago as I was perfectly self sufficient. Perhaps my vibrator stopped working.

🤣🤣🤣👍 Thanks @TroysMammy. That gave me a good belly laugh.

OP, YANBU, you are very wise. Enjoy feeling lighter; make time to care for and pamper yourself and I hope your little ones are feeling much better soon.

deeni · 17/10/2021 12:49

Well, there's a definite "upside" when you're happy living together. Just not when you're better off living alone.

thepeopleversuswork · 17/10/2021 12:05

YANBU.

I am nearly 50 and absolutely certain I will never live with a man again.

Cohabitation is massively over-rated. Unless you have kids with someone there is no upside and all downside.

I find it really encouraging that so many younger women are realising this too.

Brainwave89 · 17/10/2021 11:59

[quote heywassuphello]@Wrenna both I think.

I came to this conclusion after my boyfriend of 6 years left me yesterday. We have a 1.5 year old and a 2 month old (who are both ill atm). Im heartbroken but I also feel feel free and a bit lighter. Like im not having to justify my decisions or put a front on for anyone. Even though it's fucking hard caring for them both on my own.

Im sure my views will change but god the prospect of being free forever seems so inviting [/quote]
I am so sorry OP Flowers. Sadly some men can be complete bastards, and I do not blame you for taking this view. My sister had the same thing probably ten years ago- a man who told her repeatedly that we did not need a piece of paper to confirm our love (or some such bollocks), buggered off with another woman who he married a few months later leaving her with a baby and a toddler. However, the story got better ... Within 12 months she had found herself a gorgeous, younger lovely man (now married) who is great with the kids. Ex's marriage failed was furious when my sis found a new partner and at one stage the police had to be called as (when drunk) he refused to hand the kids back when the new partner was there. You will not be surprised that I had quite limited sympathy.

GCAcademic · 17/10/2021 11:53

Protecting yourself from disappointment is a perfectly reasonable path to take. When you consider the number of relationships that end in divorce or separation, alongside those which continue along the spectrum of generally unfulfilling to outright abusive, the majority of relationships end in disappointment.

AICM · 17/10/2021 11:48

...from disappointment...

AICM · 17/10/2021 11:47

I sometimes feel that women saying they never want to live with a man again would, in some cases, want to but can't find one. They then say they don't want a man to protect themselves disappointment.

heywassuphello · 17/10/2021 10:21

@AICM what do you mean by that?

OP posts:
AICM · 17/10/2021 07:20

I often read comments like this on MN and often feel the ladies doth protest too much.

deeni · 17/10/2021 07:14

I can see both sides of this.

I have a very happy marriage which is decades long. We married when we were young students, and it's still the best thing I ever did, no contest.

However if something awful happened, I'd never try another relationship again. The idea of trying to connect with some stranger and then bringing him into my home or life is unthinkable now.

Monthstogo21 · 17/10/2021 06:27

I have a partner of 15 years. We have separate houses.

ShepherdMoons · 17/10/2021 05:57

I've been single for 7 years and had always been in long term relationships before that.

I love living just with my dd. No snoring (ex was a horrendous snorer), hygiene issues (ex did not shower often) and I have been able to focus on myself more.

I'm not sure I'd want to live with a man again!