Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Gordon Brown for PM?

308 replies

Wilkolampshade · 15/10/2021 19:22

I don't know, just watching the Blair/Brown documentary, does anyone think we could/should bring back Gordon Brown as leader of the Labour Party for a shot at P. M?
YABU... Absolutely not, what ARE you thinking?!?!
YANBU.... Why not, how much worse could it get?

OP posts:
Badbadbunny · 16/10/2021 17:07

@Tealightsandd

How does highlighting the previous governments appalling record excuse the current government?
I don't know, but Labour spent 13 years blaming everything on Thatcher.
rrhuth · 16/10/2021 16:50

I also haven't said anyone who raises questions is a xenophobe, I've said I dislike xenophobes.

rrhuth · 16/10/2021 16:45

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

I think xenophobes who can't understand the financial impact of immigration are bad at maths. If they were good at maths, they would be able to understand/accept it.

You can prioritise other things, but that fact is a fact - immigration grows the economy.

Flipflopblowout · 16/10/2021 16:35

He flogged the country's gold reserves last time what can he do to us next time?

Tealightsandd · 16/10/2021 16:22

And that is exactly what has been and continues to be the problem with discussing immigration. Wilful (or, possibly accidental) misinterpretation and resorting to slurs and insults.

It needs to change.

Tealightsandd · 16/10/2021 16:20

@BoredZelda

Any legitimate concern about immigration - or more accurately, the way it's been (mis)managed is instantly dismissed with accusations of xenophobia, etc.

This is untrue and usually spouted by people who are actually racist. I’ve seen dozens of debated, well thought out, well argued for and against immigration where nobody is called racist. The only ones I’ve seen where people bang on about being called racist is when they say things like “those immigrants come here and scrounge of benefits and steal our jobs” (as if both things can be true) then when called out whine that nobody can speak about immigration without being called racist.

How is calling for investment in infrastructure and affordable secure housing (plus protection of employment conditions and wages) to meet the needs of an expanded population 'arguing against immigration'? These things are needed for all - British born and immigrants.
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 16/10/2021 16:18

[quote rrhuth]@daimbarsatemydogsbone what is my bigoted assertion? That I don't like xenophobic people? Confused[/quote]
no, your assertions characterising anyone who raises any questions about immigration as xenophobes, and adding insults about their mathematical skills just for good (sneering) measure.

Tealightsandd · 16/10/2021 16:17

Resorting to unwarranted offensive personal insults suggests a lack of coherent argument @BoredZelda

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 16/10/2021 16:16

@BoredZelda

If Gordon was right to call the woman a bigot - why did he apologise?

Are you really asking this question. Surely it’s obvious why?

If it was obvious I wouldn't be asking.

I like Gordon Brown on the whole.

There are two possible explanations as far as I can see -

1.He realised he was wrong to dismiss her as "that bigoted woman" so he went back to apologise and have proper discussion.

2.He cynically pretended he was sorry for th sake of appearances and in the hope of rescuing some votes - even though he really believed he was right and the woman was a bigot.

I want to believe it was number one because that would make the honest decent chap I generally think he is. If it was 2, he'd go way down in my estimation.

Tealightsandd · 16/10/2021 16:15

assume you mean that immigrants want a decent quality of life, and born nationals want a decent quality of life

I think my posts make that quite clear but apologies if not. Yes absolutely.

Not just want. Deserve.

rrhuth · 16/10/2021 16:12

@daimbarsatemydogsbone what is my bigoted assertion? That I don't like xenophobic people? Confused

BoredZelda · 16/10/2021 16:11

Any legitimate concern about immigration - or more accurately, the way it's been (mis)managed is instantly dismissed with accusations of xenophobia, etc.

This is untrue and usually spouted by people who are actually racist. I’ve seen dozens of debated, well thought out, well argued for and against immigration where nobody is called racist. The only ones I’ve seen where people bang on about being called racist is when they say things like “those immigrants come here and scrounge of benefits and steal our jobs” (as if both things can be true) then when called out whine that nobody can speak about immigration without being called racist.

Watchingyou2sleezes · 16/10/2021 16:10

A very minor flesh wound compared to most of the other damage he and Blair inflicted on the country

rrhuth · 16/10/2021 16:09

@Tealightsandd

There does exist sadly a minority of racists. And that is disgusting and unacceptable. But the vast majority of people raising concerns simply want the same as newly arrived immigrants. A decent quality of life.

Immigration isn't the problem. It is how it is managed.

I assume you mean that immigrants want a decent quality of life, and born nationals want a decent quality of life, rather than born nationals are somehow being denied a decent quality of life which immigrants are being granted?

The issue we have now, which we have to confront, is that a significant number immigrants are able to command decent salaries due to being highly skilled/trained/educated in their fields. It will be decades before we could have enough e.g. doctors to not need any immigration. Mrs Duffy can moan all she likes, we either accept immigrant doctors or vacant posts. There is not a UK national pool of trained but overlooked doctors.

Immigration is not the problem, but immigration is cited as a problem. We don't really need to manage immigration so much as manage how we a) make society more fair b) educate our future workforce c) ensure workers are in decent jobs, that pay enough to live well.

We can not do without immigration now, and immigrants who come here to work are not the problem. Anyone who blames immigrants or immigration for the issues which result from underinvestment in a) education/training and b) infrastructure is wrong, IMO.

Xenophobia leads many to blame immigrants for all sorts of things they have absolutely nothing to do with. I have no time for that at all. Conflating the decline/pressure in public services with immigration is just false. They are not responsible for UK political decisions.

BoredZelda · 16/10/2021 16:08

If Gordon was right to call the woman a bigot - why did he apologise?

Are you really asking this question. Surely it’s obvious why?

TrueGrit54 · 16/10/2021 16:00

No, I don’t dislike him but selling our gold reserves was a mistake in my view, thought it then and still think it now.

Dervel · 16/10/2021 15:56

We need to reframe this whole immigration debate as critical nuance is lost when it is considered aside from socio-economic factors. It is of course empirically true that immigration has been a net benefit to the economy.

It is also remarkably easy for me to be unreservedly positive about immigration for when a minority family moves in on my road they will be from my own economic class, wealthy and most likely educated. We will likely get on.

It is sadly not so the further down the economic spectrum you go. When you jostle different ethnicities up against one another when there is precious little opportunity and social mobility possible people tend to retreat into their cultural in-groups and often conflict ensues.

There have been sociological papers done on the subject and namely to make multi-culturalism work (and I very much believe we should!) you need to tackle indigenous poverty first and not after. By divorcing the economic factors from the racial ones we have created a disenfranchised native population that we’re safely able to write off as “bigoted” (as Brown himself made the mistake of doing), and I believe in large part has resulted in the utter collapse of Labour in a lot of their heartlands, and they are being punished for it now.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 16/10/2021 15:53

[quote rrhuth]@daimbarsatemydogsbone

I couldn't care less if I offend xenophobic people. I really dislike xenophobic people, and it is not my problem if they're upset about that.[/quote]
You are making bigoted assertions - can’t you see the hypocrisy in that?

BoredZelda · 16/10/2021 15:36

Lots of people whining pensions and gold, but you have to frame his decisions in the context of what was known at the time and not what we know now.

The gold was sold because the treasury determined it to be too volatile and in fact the sharp rise in price in the weeks that followed was a direct result of it being sold and only served to prove the point. The prices fell soon after. The sale allowed the U.K. to pay off a substantial part of the national debt and invest in better performing currencies. You have to look at the longer term for those sorts of investments.

And when people talk about a pension raid, do they actually know what happened? Most people I challenge have no idea beyond the Mail’s screaming headlines. But his “raid” has put £118 billion back in to the treasury. Given people seem to think these gold standard pensions are the preserve of the wealthy, presumably they are happy that the tax relief once given has now been removed?

I always saw Brown as a relatively safe pair of hands. He was not responsible for the global crash and was not the only world leader who either didn’t see it coming or was powerless to stop it or protect against it. The seeds of the crash were well planted (and ignored) when Blair was in power. In fact, the tories deregulation of the banks was what started it.

I’m a floating voter and not wedded to any single party, but if I could bring back any leaders right now, I’d vote Brown or Major back in.

Tealightsandd · 16/10/2021 15:24

There does exist sadly a minority of racists. And that is disgusting and unacceptable. But the vast majority of people raising concerns simply want the same as newly arrived immigrants. A decent quality of life.

Immigration isn't the problem. It is how it is managed.

Tealightsandd · 16/10/2021 15:17

It's interesting to note the differing narratives about pretty much the same issues.

Any legitimate concern about immigration - or more accurately, the way it's been (mis)managed is instantly dismissed with accusations of xenophobia, etc.

Yet when priced out families and individuals from London and the south east move to the SW, East, or North, it's seen as perfectly fine to bemoan the impact on locals (presumably 'locals' are born and bred?).

Also see the hypocrisy of the Lib Dems. All very pro increased population... until it comes to their own affluent spacious backyard. They recently won a by-election on NIMBYism.

An expanded population absolutely does impact on current residents - but particularly on the poorest.

Fine if it's catered for. But it wasn't and isn't. And that lack of accomodation harms immigrants every bit as much as British born. Because, you know, they too want and deserve an affordable and decent quality of life.

Infrastructure - schools, public transport, GP surgeries and hospitals (with easy access for local people), social care - including children's services and for the disabled of all ages - mental health, criminal justice, libraries. And (vitally) protection of employment conditions and wages AND sufficient supply of affordable and secure housing.

GreenLunchBox · 16/10/2021 15:09

@NursieBernard

John Smith and Gordon Brown would have made a brilliant Prime Minister and Chancellor pairing. Gordon Brown is my top Prime Minister in recent history.
John Smith Sad
rrhuth · 16/10/2021 15:06

I'm also not prepared to endlessly debate facts with idiotic xenophobes. Economic migrants contribute more in tax than they take out.

The only people who refuse to accept that are xenophobes. Who can fuck off.

If people voted for Brexit because someone like me doesn't want to listen to xenophobic bullshit, that's their problem. The people who voted for Brexit are responsible for Brexit.

amazeandastonish · 16/10/2021 15:06

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

If Gordon was right to call the woman a bigot - why did he apologise?
To win the election
lonelyapple · 16/10/2021 15:04

Lol. You are joking right?