Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Gordon Brown for PM?

308 replies

Wilkolampshade · 15/10/2021 19:22

I don't know, just watching the Blair/Brown documentary, does anyone think we could/should bring back Gordon Brown as leader of the Labour Party for a shot at P. M?
YABU... Absolutely not, what ARE you thinking?!?!
YANBU.... Why not, how much worse could it get?

OP posts:
rrhuth · 17/10/2021 10:49

@MarshaBradyo

Up to you biscuit

I’m happy here and I know people still find it an attractive country to come to

It isn't just about you and the few people you know. I'm not saying no one wants to come.

I'm saying we have labour shortages we can't fill. Not enough people want to come in the right roles, and we just made immigration from the EU much less easy, meaning they won't come in the same numbers. Therefore we currently have insufficient vets even though the tap is and always has been fully open.

Politics is not just about belief, it is also about reality.

TSSDNCOP · 17/10/2021 10:49

If going back in time is a thing, I think Labour needs to go and get the Milliband brother that should've got the vote in 2010.

MarshaBradyo · 17/10/2021 10:45

Up to you biscuit

I’m happy here and I know people still find it an attractive country to come to

rrhuth · 17/10/2021 10:42

There will be some who think U.K. is a terrible place as you do Biscuit

I'll talk about the UK anyway I want, it's my country and I love it.

It is a legitimate point that the transition to a points-based system will take time.

MarshaBradyo · 17/10/2021 10:36

@rrhuth

It is a tap with a system. It’s how you manage the flow

Oh, funny, I thought people would have to apply? You can't 'turn it on' if people don't want to come. The UK has to attract people.

Welcome to Britain! Pay excessive rents in a country with second-rate healthcare whilst your neighbours tell you their 'legitimate concerns' and ask you to fuck off home!

UK has quite a bit of work to do to make the transition to a points-based system.

We currently have widespread labour shortages, and thus our economy is shrinking.

There will be some who think U.K. is a terrible place as you do. Many on mn it seems.

But having lived in US Aus and U.K. (incidentally pretty lucky as they seem to be the places people try the hardest to get to) it is a very attractive country.

Would you move somewhere else, you sound a bit down about UK. You could use their points system to get in.

rrhuth · 17/10/2021 10:33

It is a tap with a system. It’s how you manage the flow

Oh, funny, I thought people would have to apply? You can't 'turn it on' if people don't want to come. The UK has to attract people.

Welcome to Britain! Pay excessive rents in a country with second-rate healthcare whilst your neighbours tell you their 'legitimate concerns' and ask you to fuck off home!

UK has quite a bit of work to do to make the transition to a points-based system.

We currently have widespread labour shortages, and thus our economy is shrinking.

JustAnotherPoster00 · 17/10/2021 10:23

Socialism is a turn off

The uk perception of socialism is quickly headed the way of the USA where anything remotely social democratic is akin to 1970s Russia invading, either way I dont have a horse in any of the races but watching the party be in thrall to the 90s policies while shedding members against a populist government who are also shedding our rights is something I consider fun, I embrace the chaos Grin

MarshaBradyo · 17/10/2021 10:22

@rrhuth

I don't think UK has the same circs as Australia, but yes, in twenty years we could have established a fully revised system with points.

Now just the small matter of bridging the critical labour shortages in the meantime...

I guess we can get used to drowning injured animals instead of humane treatment...
And nursing shortages, care home shortages, GP shortages, driver shortages - labour is not a tap you can turn on and off, people have lives.

It is a tap with a system. It’s how you manage the flow

I’m used to emigration in our family and policy in 70s drive it then too (my parents)

rrhuth · 17/10/2021 10:20

I don't think UK has the same circs as Australia, but yes, in twenty years we could have established a fully revised system with points.

Now just the small matter of bridging the critical labour shortages in the meantime...

I guess we can get used to drowning injured animals instead of humane treatment...
And nursing shortages, care home shortages, GP shortages, driver shortages - labour is not a tap you can turn on and off, people have lives.

einekleinenachtarbeit · 17/10/2021 10:15

@JustAnotherPoster00 the irony. Socialism is a turn off. Vast majority of the electorate don't give two hoots about ideological purity. Tories have pretty much thrown their rule book away and want to win elections no matter what. They are happy to adopt more left leaning policies, pretty much parked their tanks on labour's lawn. Agreed that much of the levelling up agenda is yet to be seen but it appeals to red wallers. Labour like it or not need to do the same, move away from right wing v left, socialist v capitalism, start behaving like a sensible unified moderate party.

MarshaBradyo · 17/10/2021 10:15

@rrhuth

Australia's immigration points approach is fine for them, but their treatment of refugees is a grotesque system, the off-shoring of abuse and death.

The Brexit voters may not have liked freedom of movement, but the way the implemented it was a national choice.

Now we've made another choice, which is labour shortages and a shrinking economy.

Unfortunately the UK is not as appealing to applicants as Australia, as evidenced by the fact that the UK is struggling to recruit to well-paid roles now.

I didn’t vote for it but now we have it we should use point system to our advantage as Aus does
sst1234 · 17/10/2021 10:13

@Nat6999

Labour needs Andy Burnham in as leader before the next election if they want to be in government again. Keir Starmer isn't the right man for the job.
He comes across as an all fur coat, no knickers type. He was in the cabinet before and is trying to re invent himself as the man of the people. Totally fake and disingenuous.
rrhuth · 17/10/2021 10:07

Australia's immigration points approach is fine for them, but their treatment of refugees is a grotesque system, the off-shoring of abuse and death.

The Brexit voters may not have liked freedom of movement, but the way the implemented it was a national choice.

Now we've made another choice, which is labour shortages and a shrinking economy.

Unfortunately the UK is not as appealing to applicants as Australia, as evidenced by the fact that the UK is struggling to recruit to well-paid roles now.

rrhuth · 17/10/2021 10:00

@JustAnotherPoster00 unfortunately the labour party needs to choose between those pro-Corbyn members and votes. For the good of the country I hope Starmer sorts out the party, then maybe hands it over.

MarshaBradyo · 17/10/2021 09:58

I voted remain but I am used to the points system in Aus. You do have people immigrating still of course. But they do it in a different way (to our pre Brexit anyway)

JustAnotherPoster00 · 17/10/2021 09:57

@lotsofdogshere

I believe Labour should celebrate the good things from the Blair Brown years. Starmer is leader, he was elected as the best of the leadership candidates. He’s a politician with a good career pre-politics, he has integrity and the values this country needs No point suggesting bringing Brown back. Starmer a much better future pm. Andy Burnham stood twice but sadly Corbyn won. Leave Andy with us in manchester
Starmer portrayed himself as the unity candidate between the right and left of the PLP, as soon as he was elected hes turned on the left within the party, the Labour party are hemorrhaging members and money because of it
rrhuth · 17/10/2021 09:54

You can't realistically expect people to say "OK, fine, everything is overloaded/oversubscribed but I am happy for large numbers of people still to be coming here as I know it's only overloaded because of useless politicians Confused immigrants are low users of services particularly healthcare, please explain how a nurse from overseas coming to fill a vacant post makes the NHS more overloaded Confused

rrhuth · 17/10/2021 09:52

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

What is the problem, in principle, with immigration? You've seen it laid out above in detail but chosen to ignore that. It's also a bit daft to talk about such a practical issue "in principle". In principle I am in favour of the UK offering ANY refugee or economic migrant a home - out of pure humanity since their lives are so much worse.

But we can't do that, and it's not just due to having crap governments.

You always have to deal with the practical, and sadly that includes the fact that (for whatever reason) governments and local authorities aren't prepared to make proper infratstructure investments. You can't realistically expect people to say "OK, fine, everything is overloaded/oversubscribed but I am happy for large numbers of people still to be coming here as I know it's only overloaded because of useless politicians"

As for "not liking foreign people" that's also a bit silly. As also outlined upthread, it is legitimate to have concerns where there is a significant shift in demographics which favours cultural norms where the freedom and the role of women, attitudes to LGBTQ+ people and general human rights are not respected in the way we've developed.

concerns where there is a significant shift in demographics which favours cultural norms where the freedom and the role of women, attitudes to LGBTQ+ people and general human rights are not respected in the way we've developed this clearly = not liking foreigners
lotsofdogshere · 17/10/2021 08:49

I believe Labour should celebrate the good things from the Blair Brown years. Starmer is leader, he was elected as the best of the leadership candidates. He’s a politician with a good career pre-politics, he has integrity and the values this country needs
No point suggesting bringing Brown back. Starmer a much better future pm.
Andy Burnham stood twice but sadly Corbyn won. Leave Andy with us in manchester

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 17/10/2021 08:25

What is the problem, in principle, with immigration?
You've seen it laid out above in detail but chosen to ignore that.
It's also a bit daft to talk about such a practical issue "in principle".
In principle I am in favour of the UK offering ANY refugee or economic migrant a home - out of pure humanity since their lives are so much worse.

But we can't do that, and it's not just due to having crap governments.

You always have to deal with the practical, and sadly that includes the fact that (for whatever reason) governments and local authorities aren't prepared to make proper infratstructure investments. You can't realistically expect people to say "OK, fine, everything is overloaded/oversubscribed but I am happy for large numbers of people still to be coming here as I know it's only overloaded because of useless politicians"

As for "not liking foreign people" that's also a bit silly. As also outlined upthread, it is legitimate to have concerns where there is a significant shift in demographics which favours cultural norms where the freedom and the role of women, attitudes to LGBTQ+ people and general human rights are not respected in the way we've developed.

rrhuth · 17/10/2021 07:22

@onanotherday

Time for a woman at the top for Labour..Yvette Cooper..forensic and serious.
I agree about her but wonder if the expenses thing makes it impossible.
rrhuth · 17/10/2021 07:20

[quote Snoozer11]@rrhuth having concerns about mass immigration is absolutely a legitimate view.[/quote]
Outline the concerns leaving aside all underinvestment issues and I can give you a hearing.

But usually what people are moaning about is either:

a) labour policies in the UK
b) underinvestment in public services/housing
c) not liking foreigners

None of those are actually about immigrants themselves, or immigration.

What is the problem, in principle, with immigration?

julieca · 17/10/2021 02:12

@Nat6999

Labour needs Andy Burnham in as leader before the next election if they want to be in government again. Keir Starmer isn't the right man for the job.
Sadly I dont think Andy has a chance in hell of the electorate electing hin as PM.
Snoozer11 · 17/10/2021 01:18

@rrhuth having concerns about mass immigration is absolutely a legitimate view.

Tealightsandd · 17/10/2021 00:44

Fair enough to Burnham, he isn't the only one guilty of the stoking division thing. The current government would do well to leave that behind too.

Levelling up needs to be on a national and individual basis.

A very good start would be buying and building lots of social housing.

Add in improved public services and infrastructure including public transport, and decent training and employment opportunities across the country, and (unlike in 1997) things can only get better.