Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Gordon Brown for PM?

308 replies

Wilkolampshade · 15/10/2021 19:22

I don't know, just watching the Blair/Brown documentary, does anyone think we could/should bring back Gordon Brown as leader of the Labour Party for a shot at P. M?
YABU... Absolutely not, what ARE you thinking?!?!
YANBU.... Why not, how much worse could it get?

OP posts:
Badbadbunny · 17/10/2021 16:52

@Tealightsandd

Brown had good ideas but his implementation was shockingly bad. He had no foresight at all about the entirely foreseeable "unforeseen" consequences. Typical brainy person, he had the intelligence but failed miserably on the practical side.

He didn't need foresight for right to buy. The misery and suffering already caused by it was happening in front of him. Why didn't he end it?

In fact he did the opposite. He made the housing crisis worse...

... Through his social cleansing aka housing benefit cuts. He claimed it would compel landlords lower rents. It didn't take an intellectual to know that already (even before the cuts) landlords were turning away lower income tenants. Which they could afford to do - because of increasing demand for housing (due in no small part to the failures of governments including his and Blair's to build more social housing).

I agree. Same with taxes. He cut the tax for limited companies and was then surprised when the likes of window cleaners and dog walkers converted themselves into limited companies to save tax. It was blindingly obvious that would happen, but Brown and his sidekick Dawn Primarolo didn't think people would do that just to save tax (She said that in the Commons!). As I say, no practical common sense.
Zilla1 · 17/10/2021 16:00

@Tealightsandd I recall Alan Johnson was well thought of by many, including the Civil Servants in his Department. Not sure he wanted the top job or was willing to be ruthless.

I never understood the presumption that criticism of Ed Milliband for daring to stand against his brother and it being dressed as betrayal. The notion that it was the elder's right seemed odd at the time.

Tealightsandd · 17/10/2021 15:22

@TSSDNCOP

If going back in time is a thing, I think Labour needs to go and get the Milliband brother that should've got the vote in 2010.
Should've been Johnson (Alan).

Burnham, actually think he might have potential - for the future if, and only if, Starmer doesn't work out after being given a fair chance. They could work well together really, if they were both willing, as part of a more unified team Labour. He'd need to reassess some of his policies particularly the stoke division tactic (and acknowledge past mistakes from his time in cabinet), but we all learn from mistakes.

Tealightsandd · 17/10/2021 15:10

We have rising unemployment - million+, and it's set to increase.

We also recently welcomed 20,000 refugees from Afghanistan.

Some of the unemployed and refugees will be unable to work for various reasons - but many can and want to.

Our unemployed and our refugees are not useless or incapable.

They simply need a chance.

Train them up, pay enough, ensure decent non exploitative conditions of employment.

Of course the key is to also tackle the public health housing and homelessness emergency. We need to buy and build lots of social housing.

Good training and employment opportunities and affordable secure homes, and we're on our way to a better future.

Tealightsandd · 17/10/2021 15:04

Now just the small matter of bridging the critical labour shortages in the meantime...

Very immediate short-term aside, we need to get on with doing what should've been done 30 years ago (and certainly as soon as the Brexit vote result was known).

Set-up training and apprenticeship opportunities.

Many many roles can be learnt on the job. It always used to be so. Employers need to start investing long-term in their employees again. Juniors training on the job, working their way up.

We need to start valuing the so-called low skilled essential jobs again.

Employers need to offer decent working conditions and wages above poverty pay.

And - crucially - boost the economy and construction industry with a massive social housing build (because employers can only afford to pay so high and will never be able to keep up with spiralling private housing prices).

Tealightsandd · 17/10/2021 14:55

Brown had good ideas but his implementation was shockingly bad. He had no foresight at all about the entirely foreseeable "unforeseen" consequences. Typical brainy person, he had the intelligence but failed miserably on the practical side.

He didn't need foresight for right to buy. The misery and suffering already caused by it was happening in front of him. Why didn't he end it?

In fact he did the opposite. He made the housing crisis worse...

... Through his social cleansing aka housing benefit cuts. He claimed it would compel landlords lower rents. It didn't take an intellectual to know that already (even before the cuts) landlords were turning away lower income tenants. Which they could afford to do - because of increasing demand for housing (due in no small part to the failures of governments including his and Blair's to build more social housing).

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 17/10/2021 13:32

@rrhuth

Our benefits systems are almost uniquely not generally related to contributions all benefits entitlement is national policy choice

EU migrants were not entitled to benefits in the way you are claiming.

Once again you seem to have created something in your mind - pray tell me what way I "was claiming" anything exactly? You can't because I didn't.
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 17/10/2021 13:28

I'm all ears about these demographic shifts Hmm
No you aren't - you've already dismissed the idea.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 17/10/2021 13:26

@BoredZelda

So in your version 3, Gordon still believes she was a "bigoted woman", but pretends otherwise and issues a fake apology, is that right?

@daimbarsatemydogsbone yes, just like anyone else in a high profile position would do when faced with the pressure from PR. He wasn’t the first, and won’t be the last. If he had refused, the story would have gone on and on for weeks. I don’t blame him one bit for that, the media made way, way more of it than it was. The woman was a bigot, she wasn’t looking for a serious debate, she just didn’t like them immigrants.

I am not sure how you can contend she was a bigot from that limited exchange; but both you and Gordon seem to have reached that conclusion on very limited evidence. That you fully accept and defend Gordon (in your judgement) telling a bare-faced lie and issuing a fake apology doesn't make you someone occupying the moral high ground in any way - in fact that's part of the problem when no-one has any principles they will stand by - that's not morality it's just lies.
Badbadbunny · 17/10/2021 13:03

@jewel1968

Wasn't Brown the mastermind behind working tax credit. I always wondered why not just increase minimum wage? Problem with benefits/credits is they can be removed or reduced. Very hard to lower a minimum wage.
It was a good idea in theory, but the detail and implementation was appallingly bad.
jewel1968 · 17/10/2021 12:52

Wasn't Brown the mastermind behind working tax credit. I always wondered why not just increase minimum wage? Problem with benefits/credits is they can be removed or reduced. Very hard to lower a minimum wage.

MarshaBradyo · 17/10/2021 12:50

I have wondered about where’d we’d be if other Milliband was chosen

Maybe no Brexit.. not sure

einekleinenachtarbeit · 17/10/2021 12:50

Why do people say no labour (or Tory) voters in this house ? Do people never change their opinions ? Are their opinions set in stone ? Quite worrying really and means that even absolutely governments are always safe because people are just lazy thinkers.

BoredZelda · 17/10/2021 12:48

If going back in time is a thing, I think Labour needs to go and get the Milliband brother that should've got the vote in 2010.

I was totally against it at the time, but with hindsight, it would have been a good move.

BoredZelda · 17/10/2021 12:45

So in your version 3, Gordon still believes she was a "bigoted woman", but pretends otherwise and issues a fake apology, is that right?

@daimbarsatemydogsbone yes, just like anyone else in a high profile position would do when faced with the pressure from PR. He wasn’t the first, and won’t be the last. If he had refused, the story would have gone on and on for weeks. I don’t blame him one bit for that, the media made way, way more of it than it was. The woman was a bigot, she wasn’t looking for a serious debate, she just didn’t like them immigrants.

Badbadbunny · 17/10/2021 12:43

@DeclineandFall

No Labour voters in this house but Gordon Brown was what you need as a PM- hard working, decent, intelligent, honest. He mitigated the worst of the economic collapse in 2008. Compared to the two self serving schisters Cameron and Osborne that rocked up after him he was a titan of politics. The current government is hardly what you call a government.
Brown had good ideas but his implementation was shockingly bad. He had no foresight at all about the entirely foreseeable "unforeseen" consequences. Typical brainy person, he had the intelligence but failed miserably on the practical side.
DeclineandFall · 17/10/2021 11:25

No Labour voters in this house but Gordon Brown was what you need as a PM- hard working, decent, intelligent, honest. He mitigated the worst of the economic collapse in 2008.

Compared to the two self serving schisters Cameron and Osborne that rocked up after him he was a titan of politics. The current government is hardly what you call a government.

MarshaBradyo · 17/10/2021 11:13

have to believe

Leave? I’m yet to hear a single positive statement about U.K., it gets wearing after a while, what do you mean Aus spectrum?

rrhuth · 17/10/2021 11:10

Our benefits systems are almost uniquely not generally related to contributions all benefits entitlement is national policy choice

EU migrants were not entitled to benefits in the way you are claiming.

rrhuth · 17/10/2021 11:08

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

concerns where there is a significant shift in demographics which favours cultural norms where the freedom and the role of women, attitudes to LGBTQ+ people and general human rights are not respected in the way we've developed

this clearly = not liking foreigners

No it isn't, and just repeating the mantra "you're a xenophobe" doesn't make me one. Being concerned about demographic shifts is legitimate. I see you have no answer to this except to throw casual accusations of "ism".

I'm all ears about these demographic shifts Hmm
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 17/10/2021 11:07

The Brexit voters may not have liked freedom of movement, but the way the implemented it was a national choice.

This again. This is always trotted out about the way we implemented FOM - but as usual it conveniently ignores the reality of the UK -
We typically and habitually are not used to being required to register locally in the way that much of the EU does - we don't have the infrastructure for that. Our benefits systems are almost uniquely not generally related to contributions. Changing those things and the attendant enforcement would have cost many billions and so were never going to be possible.

rrhuth · 17/10/2021 11:03

@MarshaBradyo

Yet your narrative is so depressing and down. Can the left say anything good about the U.K. I wonder? A real vote killer that inability. I’ll leave you to it.
Oh, I see, we just have to believe, as real politics is too complicated to think about?

I'm not left btw. Presumably I am on Australia's spectrum!

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 17/10/2021 11:02

immigrants are low users of services particularly healthcare, please explain how a nurse from overseas coming to fill a vacant post makes the NHS more overloaded
Please explain where I made that claim - clue I didn't.

You seem to be stuck in a binary thought pattern and you cannot get out of it - anyone who questions any aspect of immigration is just a xenophobe - that's not correct however much you may like the idea as it allows you to write people off casually.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 17/10/2021 10:58

concerns where there is a significant shift in demographics which favours cultural norms where the freedom and the role of women, attitudes to LGBTQ+ people and general human rights are not respected in the way we've developed

this clearly = not liking foreigners

No it isn't, and just repeating the mantra "you're a xenophobe" doesn't make me one. Being concerned about demographic shifts is legitimate. I see you have no answer to this except to throw casual accusations of "ism".

MarshaBradyo · 17/10/2021 10:51

Yet your narrative is so depressing and down. Can the left say anything good about the U.K. I wonder? A real vote killer that inability. I’ll leave you to it.