Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is their any need to mention race of suspicious person? Facebook..

184 replies

tiredandfrumpy · 15/10/2021 18:33

I'm on our local community facebook group and some lady has mentioned that some black man was trying to offer her daughter sweets and was offering her back to his house.

I could understand if she had a real description but you can't just warn people of a black man? People are going to be terrified if they see a black man now.

AIBU or is that an ok way of describing someone to watch out for?

Not trying to cause a war here just curious on what people think.

OP posts:
Coffeetwosugars · 15/10/2021 19:52

I think if its a genuine desciption of someone who has done something wrong then its fine. Sadly lots of these facebook posts are borderline racist false statements. I have had lots of heated arguments with friends who regularly share 'stories' of eastern european or asian gangs' going around trying to kidnap young girls. Or 'black men' knocking on doors pretending to sell things but robbing pensioners.

This is a lot more common than people realise..

muddyford · 15/10/2021 19:50

Asian as a descriptor is useless. Are we talking Japanese or South Indian? Worse than useless.

DandyHighwayWoman · 15/10/2021 19:48

@tiredandfrumpy

I'm on our local community facebook group and some lady has mentioned that some black man was trying to offer her daughter sweets and was offering her back to his house.

I could understand if she had a real description but you can't just warn people of a black man? People are going to be terrified if they see a black man now.

AIBU or is that an ok way of describing someone to watch out for?

Not trying to cause a war here just curious on what people think.

I think the description is fine. However you suggesting ’People are going to be terrified if they see a black man now.’ is not fine and ridiculous Hmm
muddyford · 15/10/2021 19:46

If the incident had happened in the West Indies and it was a white man offering sweets, do you think a prime differentiating feature from the vast majority, skin colour, wouldn't be mentioned? YABU

Thatsplentyjack · 15/10/2021 19:44

I see where you're coming from but I suppose it depends where you live if it would be helpful or not. A area where predominantly white people live, then it would be helpful. Predominantly black people, not as helpful. Also, if you flipped this and you lived in an area where mostly black people lived (although I don't suppose there are many of them in the UK considering the percentage of black people in the uk) and a whitean was going round offering kids sweets and asking them yo come with him, then I'm sure the post would mention his skin colour.
Colour of skin is a distinguishing feature, same as hair colour, height weight, eye colour.

Porcupineintherough · 15/10/2021 19:39

We get this all the time on our local Facebook group. The individuals involved dont even have to do anything, just be seen in the neighbourhood looking "Eastern European" (white but with a swarthy skin/dark hair) or "foreign " (anything but white).

Naunet · 15/10/2021 19:32

I do understand your point OP, and your perspective, but I think an extension of that argument is that if she’d just said a man offered her daughter sweets, men could start saying ‘oh great, so kids will be scared of all men now?’. So we have less information of the suspect, and wider fear, and I don’t see how that would help? Ultimately, I do think children’s safety is the most important factor here, it has to be.

PicsInRed · 15/10/2021 19:30

Sadly lots of these facebook posts are borderline racist false statements.

It's this, and when the stories are made up it's just out and out racism for clicks, comments and likes - and to spread their racism in the community.

Ibelieveinghosts · 15/10/2021 19:25

Well the vast majority of men in this country are white (about 86%). I think about 3% of the population are black. It is therefore by definition a distinguishing feature from the majority in this context as it would massively reduce the number of suspects so worth mentioning.

frumpety · 15/10/2021 19:24

I presume she is going on the description given by the child ?

FitAt50 · 15/10/2021 19:23

I think if its a genuine desciption of someone who has done something wrong then its fine. Sadly lots of these facebook posts are borderline racist false statements. I have had lots of heated arguments with friends who regularly share 'stories' of eastern european or asian gangs' going around trying to kidnap young girls. Or 'black men' knocking on doors pretending to sell things but robbing pensioners.

PurpleFlower1983 · 15/10/2021 19:20

YABU, I might describe someone as a white male in his 30s wearing a… etc. It’s no different.

youboozeyoulose · 15/10/2021 19:20

I think not being able to tell someone's age if they are of a different race to you is because of the "other race" effect. Someone explained this to me years ago. Afterwards I noticed I was far more likely to be asked for ID when buying wine from a non-white shop assistant.
www.theguardian.com/science/neurophilosophy/2011/aug/15/people-other-races-look-alike

Peanutsandchilli · 15/10/2021 19:19

A white man would probably have been described as Caucasian. I don't see anything wrong with describing the man as black, if that's a fact. Yes, it means kids are going to be wary of black men, but if it stops someone being attacked or whatever, then surely it's a good thing?

Eilatan2018 · 15/10/2021 19:18

@Zarene

We have lots of this on NextDoor.

I’ve never, ever seen a post saying ‘White man acting suspiciously’.

Which leads me to conclude that white mens’ behaviour is less likely to be seen as suspicious, and/ or people are using ‘black’ as a warning not as a description.

So yes, I suspect the majority of people posting in this way are racist.

This is utterly ridiculous! If a white man was offering sweets to a child it would also be dodgy! The child just described what they saw.. it isn’t racist to specify what colour the man was, it’s surely good to make other people wary just in case?
Wegobshite · 15/10/2021 19:16

My husband is white
He’s 6ft 3 and big
If I describe him it’s always the really tall big white guy

My brother is mixed race but he has very stunning green eyes he’s also very tall and similar build to my husband
If I were to describe him I would say the the tall mixed race guy with green eyes
You just tend to pick the most identifiable features in a person I

Vallmo47 · 15/10/2021 19:03

I can see your point of view OP but if he’d been a white man and that was the sole description used I would equally react and think “well that helps, not”. It would have been more useful if she’d said a middle aged, medium build black man but there you go…
I find estimating age so difficult and dark skinned people seem to age soooo much better. I’m usually 20 years off target 😂

youboozeyoulose · 15/10/2021 19:02

I don't see the problem with the description if that's all the info you have but wouldn't be surprised if it was made up.

tiredandfrumpy · 15/10/2021 19:02

It's not that I am not concerned about the kids as I am my children go to another school nearby.

I don't know it's just not very nice to read all these people saying warn your kids.

What are they going to say watch out for that black man when you are walking home from school.

OP posts:
Zarene · 15/10/2021 19:01

We have lots of this on NextDoor.

I’ve never, ever seen a post saying ‘White man acting suspiciously’.

Which leads me to conclude that white mens’ behaviour is less likely to be seen as suspicious, and/ or people are using ‘black’ as a warning not as a description.

So yes, I suspect the majority of people posting in this way are racist.

PicsInRed · 15/10/2021 19:00

Really, that happened and no police were involved? Luring a child to his house with sweets, let's make a Facebook post? Doubtful, eh.

romdowa · 15/10/2021 18:59

I don't see the problem. If you report something to the police they expect you to mention if the person was black , white or Asian etc. To be fair her child probably wasn't able to give a full description on age , height , build etc. So his skin colour was all she could mention to set the man apart from all men.

Cofifeefee · 15/10/2021 18:54

Are all these kids going to be cautious off every black man now? maybe I'm just sensitive as I am black and my brothers come to visit me now and again

What do you mean by cautious? Presumably your brothers won't be offering children sweets and inviting them around so there won't be anything to be cautious about.

I never said it was racist, how would she have described him if it was a white man?

"A white man offered my daughter sweets"?

It sounds like she wasn't with her daughter so didn't see the man so is probably going off her child's description. Depending on the age of the child, she may not have been able to give a more accurate description.

Eilatan2018 · 15/10/2021 18:53

You clearly think it’s racist because you are black and think it’s offensive. It doesn’t matter what race he is but if he’s doing something concerning, it’s best for children to be cautious of who to be wary of if they’re acting strangely. If it was a tall man, a fat woman or an old man for example, would you think it was size-ist, fattist or ageist to describe them in that way too?

Cofifeefee · 15/10/2021 18:50

So if she had described him as a man with blonde hair, would you be offended on behalf of all men with blonde hair?

I think it's ridiculous that you are more worried about how a potential predator will feel about being described by his race than for the safety of children in your community.