Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is their any need to mention race of suspicious person? Facebook..

184 replies

tiredandfrumpy · 15/10/2021 18:33

I'm on our local community facebook group and some lady has mentioned that some black man was trying to offer her daughter sweets and was offering her back to his house.

I could understand if she had a real description but you can't just warn people of a black man? People are going to be terrified if they see a black man now.

AIBU or is that an ok way of describing someone to watch out for?

Not trying to cause a war here just curious on what people think.

OP posts:
martingrowler · 15/10/2021 20:50

Due to the fact I can't imagine her saying "a white man was offering my daughter sweets" it's racist.

Had she said "a man was offering my daughter sweets. He was black and wearing a grey tracksuit" that would not be racist.

HarrisMcCoo · 15/10/2021 20:48

No different from saying white man or Asian man. It's purely descriptive.

FitAt50 · 15/10/2021 20:48

@Why2why

I think there is a black Mumsnetter section where you might find it much more useful to discuss your concerns.
Whats wrong with discussing her concerns here?
Why2why · 15/10/2021 20:45

I think there is a black Mumsnetter section where you might find it much more useful to discuss your concerns.

Why2why · 15/10/2021 20:44

OP, why bother? Mumsnet will pretend that there is no problem with demonising black men, who are already stereotyped as dangerous just by their mere existence.

If the description was “a white man” it would be equally useless except society does not socialise people into being suspicious of white men as a default.

In any case, you are wasting your time here trying to get Mumsnetters to understand the racial issues that this silly description can cause black men. Clearly they assume that society treats or regard black men as they treat white men.

So many black men have been arrested because they fit the description of being black. Few if any Mumsnetter on this thread would care to have an ounce of awareness of the injustice that takes place even today because of such ridiculous general description.

Mumsnet is not a place to discuss issues facing black people.

MissChanandlerBong81 · 15/10/2021 20:43

Every -imaginary- crime in our neighbourhood is committed by a man who “looked Eastern European”. These crappy posts are just racist dog whistles and I ignore them and think people that share them online are morons at best bigots at worst.

Yes we get loads of these posts. We also had a great one a couple of months back warning everyone to be vigilant because Peruvians are being flown over to burgle our houses and then flown back out again. And the poster finished the post by saying that at least Brexit should improve the problem.

Anyway, I get it OP and don’t think you’re being over sensitive - it’s the fact that ‘black’ is the only descriptor used. Not even ‘tall black man’ or ‘black man in a green top.’ And frankly that makes me think the story is highly unlikely to be true and is just an attempt at a racist dog whistle.

Eilatan2018 · 15/10/2021 20:36

@PoetryLaser

If she said "a tall black man wearing a blue hoody and distinctive yellow trousers", that would've been fine; it's a description of the man . But to use his skin colour/race as his only defining feature, it's not.
Why? If it differentiates him from the majority?!
tiredandfrumpy · 15/10/2021 20:35

@Hobbes8 hahahahaha oh gosh poor man!

Ah my FIL still calls black people coloured I've gave up correcting him some things you can't change.

OP posts:
Scarcity20 · 15/10/2021 20:35

Definitely a valid part of a discription. But obviously depends on the area how helpful it might be, around our way pretty helpful, as not that many.

Hobbes8 · 15/10/2021 20:23

We had similar in our local Facebook page. An “Asian man” was seen going up and down people’s driveways.

Turns out he was delivering newspapers.

bubbletrumps · 15/10/2021 20:22

Our village Facebook group is worse. The suspicious man was described as being 'coloured' 😱

Dancingbugbadge · 15/10/2021 20:19

I don’t think it’s racist. I see lots of posts about a “white males” being mentioned. It’s just a description surely… I don’t see how the jump would be made to being scared of all black men, just as I would not be scared of all white men.

Twillow · 15/10/2021 20:18

Yes it's racist. Perhaps not intentionally but institutionally.
We've had this kind of story on facebook - Asian men in van etc. Police issued a statement that it was just a rumour, no evidence at all, after loads of children started reporting to their parents the 'suspicious' actions of every perfectly innocuous van driver of that race they saw.

C8H10N4O2 · 15/10/2021 20:17

So if she had described him as a man with blonde hair, would you be offended on behalf of all men with blonde hair?

tiredandfrumpy · 15/10/2021 20:10

@PoetryLaser yes this.

The thing is their are many black men that are picking their kids up around that time so to me is seems ridiculous to even post unless you have a decent description.

Kids can't be looking out for every black men they see.

OP posts:
RudestLittleMadam · 15/10/2021 20:09

It’s when the description says the suspicious person/people were “Romanian” or looked Romanian/sounded Romanian. Like, how can you tell unless they were speaking that language and you happen to speak it too? A person speaking English in a heavy accent could come from any number of places. I think most of these warnings are horse shit and often seem to be started by people with an agenda.

I see your point OP. “A black man” doesn’t narrow it down much for me (or many other people). I’d want to know an accent, height, build, type of car or whatever…

I see what you

Marelle · 15/10/2021 20:02

Black men are about 1.5% of the population so the description narrows it down significantly. Describing someone as a white man isn’t as helpful because they’re about 44% of the population. In addition it’s possible to describe white men in more detail with hair and eye colour, whereas most black men have brown hair and eyes so mentioning their hair and eye colour isn’t very helpful in distinguishing them.

PoetryLaser · 15/10/2021 20:01

If she said "a tall black man wearing a blue hoody and distinctive yellow trousers", that would've been fine; it's a description of the man .
But to use his skin colour/race as his only defining feature, it's not.

FreedomFaith · 15/10/2021 20:00

I don't see the problem. It narrows down the list of possibilities.

If your children would automatically be scared of every black man after this, you are raising them very wrong. Consider that the majority of men who committed crimes against children in Britain were/are white. Are your children afraid of all white men? I doubt it. Hmm

GoodbyePorpoiseSpit · 15/10/2021 20:00

Every -imaginary- crime in our neighbourhood is committed by a man who “looked Eastern European”. These crappy posts are just racist dog whistles and I ignore them and think people that share them online are morons at best bigots at worst.

Rainbowheart1 · 15/10/2021 19:58

I’ve seen posts before about “white men” so I don’t think it’s any different to that.

SandrasAnnoyingFriend · 15/10/2021 19:58

Do you also have an issue with them saying it was a man? Because that's similarly broad and unhelpful.
Are you worried people will be scared of all men?

tiredandfrumpy · 15/10/2021 19:56

Yes but we live in a very diverse area so I don't see how the description of a black man is very helpful.

If it was predominantly white then yes I could 100% understand.

OP posts:
MrzClaus · 15/10/2021 19:55

I think it's mentioned because it is a major identifying factor.

If the sweets were offered to a child, I doubt the child would know specifics such as height / build etc! It might be the only thing they were able to notice / remember.

If I read that post, id be wary of any black man I saw offering sweets to a child - not just any black man I went past.

Nootall · 15/10/2021 19:54

I wouldn't mention that a man was white, because where I live 95% of men are white. I would mention if he was black, as no-one would expect that. If I lived in an area where a high percentage of men are not white, I'd probably mention that the man was white.