Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is their any need to mention race of suspicious person? Facebook..

184 replies

tiredandfrumpy · 15/10/2021 18:33

I'm on our local community facebook group and some lady has mentioned that some black man was trying to offer her daughter sweets and was offering her back to his house.

I could understand if she had a real description but you can't just warn people of a black man? People are going to be terrified if they see a black man now.

AIBU or is that an ok way of describing someone to watch out for?

Not trying to cause a war here just curious on what people think.

OP posts:
EmeraldShamrock · 15/10/2021 22:59

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

audersandbaby · 15/10/2021 22:56

Also the “description” isn’t even remotely helpful. If a child is offered sweets in the area but by a white man, they don’t have to worry? How about ANY MAN OFFERING SWEETS = DANGER

audersandbaby · 15/10/2021 22:55

There has been so much evidence to show why what OP has describes fuels racism.

It wasn’t a description. If it were she would have said a black man, mid 40s with a beard. It was her unconscious bias that felt the need to say he was black. I bet if he were white she would have just said “a man”.

mustlovegin · 15/10/2021 22:52

I would have just gone straight to the police, or asked others on the group to check their cctv for an accurate description

But maybe she has reported it to the police already and she's trying to alert others promptly of the risk?

Do you have any daughters? Have you thought that maybe the suspect may try to lure one of your DDs? In these scenarios I would rather err on the side of caution and know sooner rather than later (even if details are scarce or perhaps understandably uncomfortable for some)

idiotfacelicker · 15/10/2021 22:52

The fact that the vast majority of this thread genuinely can't fathom the problem is the problem.

Beefmeupscotty · 15/10/2021 22:51

And this is why it is so important to call out this type of institutionalised racism. How many replies has this post got defending it? Compared to 1 or 2 rightly pointing out the problem. Black can be used as a description, but that's not the purpose in the example. As pp said "man offered my dd sweets. Description: black, male, 20-40 (if age hard to destinguish), short dark hair etc." then yes, black is part of the description.

idiotfacelicker · 15/10/2021 22:48

@Zarene

We have lots of this on NextDoor.

I’ve never, ever seen a post saying ‘White man acting suspiciously’.

Which leads me to conclude that white mens’ behaviour is less likely to be seen as suspicious, and/ or people are using ‘black’ as a warning not as a description.

So yes, I suspect the majority of people posting in this way are racist.

This says exactly what I was going to say.

YouTubeAddict · 15/10/2021 22:23

Of course it’s relevant, she’s giving a description. It seems like, these days, unless you’re describing someone as Caucasian then there’s something sinister going on 🤷‍♀️

tiredandfrumpy · 15/10/2021 22:17

@mustlovegin I probably wouldn't have gone to Facebook to warn other parents unless I had a decent description. as I said other black men pick their kids up from that school so it's pointless.

I would have just gone straight to the police, or asked others on the group to check their cctv for an accurate description.

Warning parents and kids of a black man isn't good enough.

OP posts:
mustlovegin · 15/10/2021 22:09

What would you have done OP if you had been in this mum's shoes?

Would you have ignored the danger if the attacker's skin colour was the only salient point the little girl could remember (probably because it was different to her own)?

How would you have handled this?

I understand you may be worried about your brothers visiting, but if the neighbourhood is diverse, as you say, there will be many men who will fit that description, so they should have no reason to be concerned

Every -imaginary- crime in our neighbourhood

Why are posters implying that the mum or girl are lying? Aren't we supposed to believe the victim until further investigations are carried out?

martingrowler · 15/10/2021 21:59

@VestaTilley

YABU. It’s fine as long as it’s true. It’s only racist if it’s a lie.

People need to know who to worry about in such a situation - better to be wary of the right person, than saying “all men” just to be politically correct.

So, be wary of all black men?
VestaTilley · 15/10/2021 21:52

YABU. It’s fine as long as it’s true. It’s only racist if it’s a lie.

People need to know who to worry about in such a situation - better to be wary of the right person, than saying “all men” just to be politically correct.

MissChanandlerBong81 · 15/10/2021 21:46

So is it ok to describe someone purely on their weight? Height? Hair colour? Dress sense? Speech? Age?

It might be acceptable, but it still wouldn’t be that helpful.

‘Man with brown hair’

‘Overweight person’

‘Skinny man’

‘Person in 30s’

All useless descriptions.

Similarly ‘black man’ isn’t a very helpful description. It just means a black male aged somewhere between 14 and 102. And there’s the additional issue that black men are as a group routinely stigmatised as dangerous criminals by our society and by our police force.

tiredandfrumpy · 15/10/2021 21:44

@lovescaca you wouldn't describe someone purely by their weight or hair though would you their would be other details along with that.

I'm not understanding your argument it's ridiculous?

I'm not going back and fourth with you anyway. I have seen your comments on threads over racism. Calling people sensitive.

I can see what your about already!

OP posts:
lovescaca · 15/10/2021 21:26

So is it ok to describe someone purely on their weight? Height? Hair colour? Dress sense? Speech? Age?

lovescaca · 15/10/2021 21:23

🤦🏼‍♀️🤦🏼‍♀️

SickAndTiredAgain · 15/10/2021 21:22

Which leads me to conclude that white mens’ behaviour is less likely to be seen as suspicious, and/ or people are using ‘black’ as a warning not as a description.

I’m not sure it’s necessarily always being used as a warning (I’m sure it sometimes is), but that the people using it see white as the norm and therefore not worth commenting on. I’m not saying that’s right, but it’s common, people are imagined as white unless described otherwise. You see it in books, often when characters are described physically, the only time race is mentioned is when they aren’t white.

tiredandfrumpy · 15/10/2021 21:19

@Why2why I agree with you, however it's interesting to see what other will think.

@lovescaca have you even read the thread or are you just getting yourself all worked up? And no I don't think describing someone by JUST their skin tone is acceptable or is it USEFUL.

OP posts:
Why2why · 15/10/2021 21:19

@lovescaca

Ohh ffs!. what u want her to say? Is he black? Yeah? So what is the problem. Would it be ok is she said white man? Small man? Fat man? Skinny man?
Bingo. That’s mumsnet for you.
lovescaca · 15/10/2021 21:13

Ohh ffs!. what u want her to say? Is he black? Yeah? So what is the problem. Would it be ok is she said white man? Small man? Fat man? Skinny man?

Xenia · 15/10/2021 21:07

Misschan, www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-45320189

Why2why · 15/10/2021 20:59

This made me remember Liam Neeson wanting to go out on the street and find any black man to beat up because “a black man” had assaulted his sister.

He would not have gone out look for any white man to beat up and kill if it was a “white man” who assaulted his sister.

I used to like him and from that day I listened to his interview I have never watched another movie of his.

Siameasy · 15/10/2021 20:53

I think if it had been a white man the person would’ve just written “a man…”

Black men are so demonised so I do think one ought to be mindful. By all means mention ethnicity but personally I would write: “a man offered sweets etc etc. Description: a black male aged about 40 wearing etc etc”-

I distinctly remember reading about a burglary in the local paper as a kid in the 80s “the woman woke up to find a black man in her room”. This was a common way of writing back then and I feel the effect was to imply there are men…and then there are black men ie a much more scary type of man.

Why2why · 15/10/2021 20:53

@FitAt50

Why2why · 15/10/2021 20:53

Oh please!